Yellowstone

Yellowstone: TV series 2019-2024 ★★

We watched Yellowstone on the recommendation of friends. Though Woke, Yellowstone was not suffering as badly as many other contemporary tv series in the matter of wokeness. It is the story of a large cattle ranch in south central Montana, somewhat close to Yellowstone National Park. The area is actually a fiction, though the story is cohesive so long as one does not pay to close of attention to maps. Betsy and I watched this series together. Toward the middle of the last season, we couldn’t wait for the series to end. I typically don’t do film or tv series reviews, but this series begged for a review.

The strength of this series is that it maintains a somewhat unpredictable story line. This leads to the desire to continue watching the series. It’s almost like the old Batman tv series, where at the end of one episode, Batman and Robin would be in hot trouble, but Batman and Robin would always be rescued in the following episode. It also maintains a somewhat non-woke attitude. As an example, for the first season or two, the only beer drunk was Budweiser. With the development of the woke advertisements for Budweiser, the series immediately removed Budweiser, and the only beer consumed or advertised was for Coors. The other strength was the scenery, as it presented Montana (and Utah?) at its’ most beautiful.

Why did we dislike, and often, truly hate this series? Many reasons come to mind. Some of the actors were truly despicable. Beth Dutton leads the list; her behavior led one to wish and pray that she would just be knocked off. Sadly, it never happened. Jamie Dutton was so miserably weak-kneed as to be pathetic, and defying any realistic notions about his stage part, including that of being the state attorney general. Really, one couldn’t be serious. John Dutton was acted out well by Kevin Costner, but there was never developed a sense of love or desire to see him succeed in his endeavors. The point to be made is that there was not a single character in the entire series that could be viewed as a person of virtue, and certainly the presence of virtue was non-existent throughout the series. Every role seen in the movie was self-serving. Perhaps the only character that came closest to character development was that of Jimmy. Whether it be the ranchers, who were entirely self-serving, the real estate development moguls who didn’t give a rip about environmental issues, or the Indians, who were hopelessly and cluelessly bemoaning the loss the the land that they identified as theirs. Unfortunately, the tv series was, like so many woke portrayals of Indians, the most “virtuous” of the bunch, and the Indians eventually gained control of the Yellowstone ranch.

Gone are the days where movies tended toward some form of moral development. Instead, it was repeatedly stated by characters in their rapport that morality does not exist and that actions cannot be judged based on higher law. This change in Hollywood’s attitude resembles that of entertainment in ancient Rome, which progressed over the years from virtuous to decadent, reflecting the nature of Roman society. I fear that such tv series today represent a decline in civility and virtue in society, much to our loss. There was some sexuality in the series, and nearly every episode had some lewd speech. Nudity was less common, the most seen was in one of the first episodes where Beth gets totally naked and takes a bath outdoors in front of a group of cowboys. I presume that this was included to bait teenage minds into hanging through the series, hoping for more “eye candy”. Foul language was most notable, and replete and in excess throughout every episode of the series. This is not a series for young children, and perhaps also for adults!

Christianity is still fairly prevalent in Montana. Yet, only the briefest mention of Christianity is offered in this series. There were one or two times when Dutton family members mentioned that they might have gone to church once. Instead, Indian animism and spiritism were quite frequently mentioned. Kayce Dutton performs some sort of ceremony in the outdoors to make contact with “the spirits”. Kayce moves into a new house, and their first meal is proceeded by saying “grace”, but was a prayer of thanks for their forefathers, and not to God. An animistic funeral for a newborn baby was performed. The Indians frequently mention their “sacredness”. Lost is Christianity or any resemblance of a public or private morality. Assassinations, killings, and other crimes are committed without guilt and without consequences. Crimes were considered amoral so long as the state doesn’t find out and so long as it served some sort of “good”.

Toward the end of the last (5th) season, John Dutton is assassinated. Beth then becomes the prominent star in the series, seeking vengeance on Jamie Dutton for supposedly orchestrating the murder of her father. During these final episodes, one wishes that Beth would also be assassinated, as her personality is despicable, and Jamie, not for the evil he has done, but for his lackluster, anemic personality; Jamie was assassinated by Beth, who lied to the police to hide that she did the murder. As with Jamie, justice is never properly served throughout the series, and the lesson was simply that “might makes right”.

Why the series Yellowstone had such a high rating leaves me worried. Why did people like Yellowstone? It was sewage morality, the only great actors were John Dutton and Lloyd, a hired cowhand. Though Beth was touted as a great actor, I thought that she was quite lackluster, and her oral deformity (cleft lip) was particularly annoying. We were more than grateful at the end of the series to have finished it. What’s left now is two prequels, 1883 and 1923, which I’ll probably tag to the end of this review at a later date. For now, Betsy and I need a break from this series.

Version 1.0.0

1883: A Yellowstone Origin Story ★★

This series goes back to 1883 with the Duttons departing from Fort Worth Texas. The entire 1883 series is nothing but the chronicle of their wagon train journey. Their intention was to go to Oregon. Along with the Duttons were a motley gang of German immigrants seeking guidance to get to Oregon, but completely unprepared for the journey. Also were several guides, Shea and Thomas (in real life Sam Elliott and Lamonica Garrett). The entire wagon train also rounds up about 20 stray steer to take along as food, along with some wranglers to help manage the cows. They encounter multiple difficulties, including internal dissension, Indian attacks, fatal river crossings, and challenging decisions owing to health, absence of water, and absence of horses/wagons.

Eventually, most of the German travelers had died. By the time the wagon train reached Wyoming, there were only two wagons left, no cows, and Elsa dead. Indians directed the reduced Dutton family to Paradise Valley, which is where we find them in the Yellowstone series. Sam Elliott and Lamonica Garrett make it the next year to Oregon. The plight of everybody else was left in question.

Good things about the series – The filmography was stunning, with beautiful prairie scenes, and the grandeur of the mountains of Wyoming and Montana. The acting of Sam Elliott set the standard for the series—without Sam, the series would have failed. Compared to the main Yellowstone series, there was MUCH less obscenity, and only one word (the “f” word) was used occasionally. There was no formal nudity, and the sex scenes were more subdued.

Bad things about the series – Much of the series had running editorials for Elsa Dutton, and the entirety of the series was mostly focused on her love lives and foibles. Elsa was an immature 18 yo promiscuous brat, whose character greatly diminished the series. It was torture to repetitively see her, very similar to the immature torture of watching Beth in the Yellowstone series. The world view and thinking were very much 21st century and NOT thinking what one might expect in the year 1883—this was a grave mistake. Unlike Yellowstone where there were no characters that one really felt strongly towards, Shea (Sam Elliott) and James Dutton (Tim McGraw, acting as the father of the Dutton family) were the only two characters that one gained a feeling for. The character development of everybody else left me feeling indifferent as to their ultimate fate.

The high rating of this series is a mystery to me. True, there were a few suspenseful episodes but one was left knowing that the Duttons would ultimately make it to Paradise Valley, Montana. The series could have been stronger if one saw the Duttons settling in. Perhaps that is the role for the second prequel, 1923, which will be reviewed in a few weeks.

Version 1.0.0

1923: A Yellowstone Origin Story ★

This final (I hope) series of Yellowstone chronicles the years after WW1 and the encounter with mass migrations to the west. The top stars, Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren were in good form. The remainder of the acting went from good to awful. The script writer went crazy, having 3 or 4 intertwined stories, that of Harrison and Helen at home, dealing with sheep herder rustlers, that of Indians being unjustly punished in their personal life by Catholic missionaries, and that of Spencer Dutton, the heir to be, coming back from Africa at the behest of the homestead to help solve issues with sheepherders and developers.

I’m not going to tell the plot of the story, only because it is fairly slow paced. There’s lot of unnecessary abuse of the Indians, and the narrative unjustly attributes the abuse to wicked nuns as school teachers. None of it made sense, and was devoid of historicity. It is true that the Indians were abused by the white settlers, but also true of lots of unnecessary Indian raids and abuse by the Indians. Hollywood is a terrible place to learn what actually happened in the wild west. Spenser is living his post-war years in Zanzibar, but gets a letter from mom to come home and help with the farm stresses. He seeks to return, including return with a new wife that he acquired. The boat travel was highly problematic, and by the end of season one, he is left stranded in England. He does return to Montana, but only in season 2.

Problems on the farm are predictable, with people wanting to buy his land for development, sheepherders laying claim to the land for their sheep, and Indians again stressing how the land was “stolen” from them. It became wearisome. As expected, people died, blatant criminals get away with nothing at court trials, and business remains as usual from the main Yellowstone series.

We purchased a bundle that stated that it contained all of the series, but indeed, did NOT include the second season of 1923. This is an unpardonable deception. It will cost $20 to get the last two discs, something that I have zero interest in watching. So, I will let it go. I honestly do NOT recommend this series for anybody. It is the new Hollywood at its best, trying to sell fictitious, woke party lines while refusing to acknowledge the lies and deceptions that Hollywood would love to market on the general public. I don’t buy it!

Share