
Unnatural Death: Medicine’s Descent from Healing to Killing, by Richard Weikart ★★★★
This book offers a succinct review of the history of physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia. The chronology starts with ancient times, including ancient Greece and Rome, and works toward the present by discussing the Renaissance, the Enlightenment, changes in Europe and America, the Nazi killing fields, and then contemporary events within the last 70+ years that caused physicians and the public to first be repulsed by the thought of doctors assisting in death, to that of considering assisted death a morally acceptable option and even occasionally an obligation.
The last two chapters of the book enter into the moral argument against PAS/euthanasia. Dr. Weikart makes some very salient points in defense of the slippery slope argument. I appreciated the quip that there is great hypocrisy in forbidding capital punishment while strongly advocating PAS. Certainly the great problems with PAS are brought up by Dr. Weikart in that PAS becomes an obligation, as well as it distorts the role of physicians.
This book is weak only in that it is not written from the perspective of a physician, which is what I was. I specialized in Surgical Oncology in Washington State where PAS eventually became legal. (See my discussion on PAS written many moons ago here… http://feuchtblog.net/publications/physician-assisted-suicide-article/ ) . There are issues that Dr. Weikart leaves muddy.
First, the issue of withholding medical treatment is confusing. Does pro-life ethics entail forcing life out to the longest possible breath? Is there a role for simply refusing medical treatment, or suggesting that we let a disease run its course? Two sets of patients were the most challenging to deal with. The easiest were the pro-PAS patients requesting PAS should their cancer become challenging. Only once was I unable to persuade a patient otherwise. I would have LONG conversations with patient’s that asked for possible PAS if their cancer became terminal, explaining that I would never leave, discharge or refuse to help the patient, but would never ever kill them or refer them to a death doctor. I explained that I would prescribe any necessary pain med they needed, noting that the pain medicine could be taken in does that could kill them, but that I would never ever suggest that they do that. I’ve sent a lot of narcotics home with patients, and out of the hundreds of cancer patients under my care, I’ve never had a single patient actually commit suicide. The patient wants assurance that we will always care. This is a good reason why I’m so grateful to be retired. The insanity of the narcotics police will no longer allow that conversation to take place.
My worst patients ever to care for were confused pro-lifers convinced that every physician was there to kill them. There were quite a few of them. When treatments became futile, they still insisted on persisting. The notion I learned in medical school (the same place where Ken Stevens teaches) was that pneumonia was the old person’s friend; i.e, dying a natural death without theatrical interventions was ok. I guess death must now be in a sterile and unfriendly hospital.
Secondly, alternatives for PAS are never discussed. This is sad. In 1973, the church responded to the abortion issue by forming alternatives in the form of crisis pregnancy centers. I was heavily involved in that movement. But, as a cancer doctor, I always wondered why the church did NOT provide an alternative for PAS. The alternative could be a home where end-of-life patients could receive nurture, care, dignity, attention, love, and most importantly, the Gospel. It’s easy enough to talk about preventing PAS, but much harder to offer alternatives. The original hospital started in the church, and was effective only at comforting the sick until they die. It wasn’t a bad idea, until the secular state took it over.
Summary; this book is an excellent review of how we got to where we are in the PAS/euthanasia issue. Though much of it was a review for me, I appreciated how well Weikart was able to make a story of the transition of medicine from a comfort giving, then life giving, and finally death giving transition. I saw it in real life in Washington, where in a matter of only 2-3 years, very conservative physicians abandoned their principles and caved in to the death movement. I suspect that the only solution now will be to do as Hippocrates had to do, and simply start a separatist ethical community of physicians. I just can’t dream of any other alternatives.