History

NPNF Series 1 Volume 9


Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers Series 1, Volume 9, edited by Philip Schaff

This volume is the start of 6 volumes containing translations from (mostly) the Greek of the writings and sermons of John Chrysostom. The remaining 5 volumes contain expository sermons, with Chrysostom preaching through selected books of Scripture. This 9th volume (of the entire Nicene Post-Nicene Fathers Series 1) includes writings about being a church pastor (On the Priesthood), ascetic writings, letters that Chrysostom wrote while in Armenia (in exile), and then a set of 21 sermons preached in Antioch during a time of great trouble in the city.

On the Priesthood is a mixed bag of items addressed to a friend named Basil, with Chrysostom first describing his youth and young adulthood. He discusses some pastoral issues, such as occasionally using deception in order to provoke the good (completely contrary to the opinion stated by Augustine), and then engages in a running dialogue between himself and Basil (not Basil the Great – Cappadocian father). In this dialogue, Chrysostom is defending an action he took which generated much anger from Basil. Basil and John (Chrysostom) were very close friends. When John heard that both he and Basil were going to be put up for the presbytery (made pastors in the church), John realized that very awkward family circumstances and promises he made to his mother would not permit this. If you are put up for the pastorship (priesthood), you do NOT have the right to object. So, using minor deception, John Chrysostom was able to connive the church leadership to recruit Basil yet hid himself and thus avoiding the appointment. Following “On the Priesthood”, there follows a set of sermons about sundry topics and various letters to close friends.

The next section includes letters that Chrysostom wrote while in exile. These were addressed to Olympias, a wealthy matron and supporter of John, and still living in Constantinople, and then to Innocent, bishop of Rome, regarding his unfair treatment at the hands of the Emperor in Constantinople.

The final section contains 21 homilies preached in Antioch soon after he had become a Presbyter. It was a time of great turmoil in Antioch. The emperor in Constantinople raised taxes on the citizens of Antioch, and riots broke out. The emperor then threatened to completely wipe out the city. Chrysostom wrote letters to the emperor appealing his decision, and the bishop of Antioch (Flavian) traveled to Constantinople in an attempt to stay the emperor’s hand. During the weeks before news that the emperor was going to relent of his decision, John preached these sermons encouraging the folk to seek God and trust in Him for survival. These sermons are all very touching, and display the oratorial skills of Chrysostom to a great degree. They are the first sermons from history that I consider to be accessible to folk living today, and could have been preached from any contemporary pulpit.

The final 21 homilies are very practical in their nature. The topics are very specific, addressing forgiving your neighbor, walking rightly in all things, not depending on the liturgical activities of the church and the eucharist to allow for licentious living or thinking, not making oaths, showing respect for government and church leaders, not putting fasting (it was the lenten season) above good behavior and disciplined thinking as most important, and general correct behavior as a Christian towards one’s brothers and toward non-Christians. Chrysostom was highly pragmatic in his preaching, and yet very fluent in style.

There are many quotable quotes in Chrysostom’s sermons. One loves to quote more contemporary saints like JC Ryle or Charles Spurgeon, yet Chrysostom offers sermons filled with statements worth re-quoting. He truly manifested oratory skills of the highest degree and worth reading.

Mein Kampf

Mein Kampf, by Adolf Hitler ★

Mein Kampf is actually two books, published in 1925 and then 1926, written by Adolf Hitler to reflect his thinking. In truth, he did NOT write the book, since much of the two books were actually written by Rudolf Hess at Hitler’s dictation. Thus, the book reads more like a rambling discourse rather than a serious publication. Unfortunately, many current radicals have used this text as a guide for forming their own world protests. Because it mostly reflects the ideological thinking of Mr. Hitler, it might have been better titled “Mein Kopf” (Mein Kampf means my struggles or my battles, and Mein Kopf means my head). Michael Ford does a superlative translation, not censoring any part of the text, and frequently offering explanations when Hitler is speaking of particular people or particular German phrases that might not have been understood by non-German speakers.

But, why should one read such a terrible book like Mein Kampf? People often view Hitler as the personification of evil, and to a large extent they are correct, save that they are forgetting the other great evils that were contemporary with Hitler, specifically Stalin, Mao Ze Tung, and Winston Churchill. History is replete with many examples of evil which have led to massive casualties. This book is frequently quoted by the modern press and both by liberals and conservatives, yet I doubt that few have actually read the book through and through in order to grasp the nature of the grievances that Hitler was wailing against. Top of the list was the very evil and unfair treaty of Versailles, though, it must be remembered that Germany, just a year before, made an equally terrible treaty with Russia, the Brest-Litovsk treaty. One would have thought that the “Christian” countries of France, Great Britain, and the United States would have done better, but clearly, they did not. Hitler was equally grieved not only that German government tolerated the treaty, but that, the government was not as sincere as they should have been in fighting the war (World War One).

The book rambles and bounces around. It begins by Hitler giving the story of his youth, going to study art in Vienna, and ultimately settling in Munich. The development of the National Socialists, which became the NSDAP (Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei , the National Socialist German Worker’s Party), which eventually evolved into the Nazi party, is mentioned sporadically, but most heavily in the later second volume of the book. The beer hall putsch in 1923 and his imprisonment for a while is never mentioned. Hitler dwells heavily on his enthusiastic involvement in the war (WWI), and disappointment that others were not quite so enthused with the war.

There are a variety of themes that Hitler frequently resurrects in his ramblings.

  1. Antisemitism. Hitler admits that his family were not antisemitic, perhaps because they were cognitive that they were actually partially Jewish, with the name of Schickelgruber. Hitler’s anti-semitism develops while he was struggling to live in Vienna, but he never gives the reason for his change of mind. His hatred for the Jew becomes quite pathological, and everything eventually becomes the fault of the Jew in Hitler’s mind. This theme continues nearly constantly throughout the book. As a subset of this, racism is constantly brought up in this book. Clearly, there were inferior races (the Jews, the Negro, etc) and the Aryan superiority as a race, with the German Folk as at the top of that superiority hierarchy.
  2. Nationalism. This is an adjunct theme to his antisemitism. In Hitler’s eyes, the “pure” German race was being polluted by other races, including not only the Jews, but also the Negroes, as well as from Slavic and Russian inbreeding. Hitler raved that Germans must take pride in their country. I can’t fault him for that; the current absence of national pride is now destroying Germany.
  3. Government. In Vienna, Hitler frequently sat in on the parliamentary proceedings and saw how inefficient and even ineffective they were at governing a people. He constantly wails against a democratic society, as the hoi polloi were stupid and incompetent at making grander political decisions. In addition, committees and parliaments rarely ever “got the job done” in an efficient style. Thus, he felt strongly that government must be ruled from top down rather than bottom up, which would be more in line with a monarchy, or in ecclesiastical circles, with an Episcopalian form of polity.
  4. Propaganda. Hitler noted how effectively the British used propaganda, laced with extreme lies about the German people, to spirit the nations against Germany during WWI, and even to demoralize the German people. Hitler realized the value of propaganda, taking most his guidance with how Great Britain used propaganda and lies against Germany. Propaganda was not an invention of Hitler, though he saw its importance in the rise of his Nazi movement.
  5. Religion. Hitler frequently quotes Scripture, and mentions his Christian heritage. Hitler saw that the church would be useful for his agenda, and thus wished to not generate the displeasure of either the Roman Catholics or the Protestants. Hitler realized that the Ultramontane movement in the Roman church meant that some Papists held to the Pope as a higher authority on earth than the leader of the state, which he had to contend with. Though some writers contend that Hitler was a closet Satanist, there is no evidence from these writings that suggest Satanist inclinations.
  6. Pacifism. Hitler absolutely detested pacifist, and pacifistic thinking. Hitler never lays out an agenda for conquering the world, as is often suggested by contemporary media and theater. That was absolutely not his interest. Yet, his rants against pacifists should have alerted Neville Chamberlain that “peace in our time” was not even a remote consideration of Hitler. (Churchill reacted in an opposite fashion, equally wrong at trying to “contain” Hitler—see the book Churchill, Hitler, and the Unnecessary War, by Patrick Buchanan). Hitler considered war to be constant and continuous.
  7. Weltanschauungen. Hitler constantly speaks of his Weltanschauung, or worldview. But he never lays out in methodological detail of that worldview. I presume that the contents of this book reflect his worldview, which, in my estimation, is rather shallow.

The closing chapters of the book detail Hitler forming a structure for the Nazi party. He describes a top down party, not controlled by committees, and expecting the party leaders to be brave in making and acting on decisions. Hitler spends much time then ruminating his final thoughts, including how to reform the trade unions by removing the Marxist influence to those unions, how to establish the various states of Germany under a single control structure, Germany’s alliances with other countries, what to do with Russia and the Slavic countries, and the necessity of restoring a strong defense structure to Germany. His bitterness about the Versailles treaty is impossible to miss. He has a grudge against France since they not only confiscated German lands (Alsace-Lorraine) but were then occupying the Ruhr valley. Hitler had no grudges against either Great Britain or Italy, and desired a closer alliance with those countries. He continually places the ultimate blame for Germany’s then current condition on the Jews.

What did Hitler not talk about? 1. He had no desire for world domination. Hollywood loves to create fictitious scenes of Hitler winning WWII and going on to conquer the entire world. That was never in his plan. Ever. 2. Extermination of the Jews. Hitler wished to remove the Jews from Germany, just as England did, Italy did, and Spain did. He never ever speaks of the ideal of exterminating the Jew. 3. Hitler discussed the need for more space for Germany, but much of that was the desire to restore the lands in the east and west which were taken from Germany in the treaty of Versailles. I probably also had in mind incorporating Germans living in the east (Poland, Czechoslovakia, Ukraine, etc.) as well as Austria into a greater German state. Hitler detested Russia, but never mentioned a desire to see the death of Russia. The Molotov-Ribbentrop pact more than confirms that Mein Kampf was not a blueprint for Hitler’s plan to dominate the world, as so many so-called pundits purport.

Why read the book? It’s not for everyone. Mein Kampf gives the reader a window into the mind of Hitler, but it also gives the reader a mind into how a national injustice might lead to resentment and the desire for retribution. It suggests also that US involvement in both WWI and WWII only made matters worse for everybody. It makes me imagine a world if the USA would have never gotten embroiled in Europe’s problems of the 20th century. Mein Kampf makes it very clear that without WWI and the bitterly unfair treaty of Versailles, there never would have been a Hitler, an extermination of the Jews in Europe, and mass devastation in Europe and abroad. I don’t believe the human race, without Christ, will ever learn from these mistakes of the past. So, I can only presume that at some point in time, civilization will see yet more wars and destruction on a global basis.

Jerome

Jerome, by JND Kelly ★★★★★

This is the second biography of JND Kelly that I have read a second time through. It is fascinating, compelling, and constantly holds your attention. Many times, truth is more captivating than fiction. Jerome was born in the small town of Stridon, located roughly in what is now Bosnia. His family were wealthy Christians. He excelled in school, and so was sent to Rome to study under the great scholars and the capitol of the empire. There he learned to master the Latin language, excelling in all of the classical authors (such as Cicero, Virgil, etc.) of the Roman empire. It is here that he was baptized, and, to the disapproval of his parents, began to seek an ascetic life style. It was here that he also developed a strong love for books which would last him his whole life. 

We do not know exactly when and why Jerome eventually left Rome, but his first stop was across the Alps in Trier, accompanied by his dear friend Bonosus. While in Trier, Jerome began to add many volumes to his library of books; most of this was performed by personally transcribing a copy of the text at hand. Again, why Jerome decided to leave Trier is unknown to us. He next journeyed back home to Stridon, only to spend much of his time in the larger town of Aquileia which was close by. Jerome, with his close friends going in other directions, decided to move to Antioch. It was the year 372 when he was 40 years old. How he was able to take along his now massive library of books is a mystery to us, but Jerome was not about to abandon his library. It was in Antioch that Jerome began a more extensive study of the Greek language. He also became quite familiar with doctrinal controversies that were raging in the church in Antioch. A nightmarish dream came to him, persuading him to abandon all and depart to the desert where ascetic monks were residing. This he did for 3 years, living in a cave. Contrary to the other monks in his vicinity, he brought along an entourage of copyists to help him reproduce many books. He also had a Jewish man begin to instruct him in the Hebrew language, from which he became moderately adept. Eventually, his fellow monks regarded him as an intruder, as he was of Latin origin rather than Greek, forcing him to leave back to Antioch. Jerome had no kind words regarding the pseudo-holiness of his ascetic companion monks.

Jerome then spent several years in Antioch and writing various letters and documents, while being caught up in the theological arguments which were splitting the church in Antioch. He took off to Constantinople, but was not involved in the 2nd ecumenical council, though he was affected by it. He developed a relationship with Gregory of Nazianzus, who was able to adroitly lead Jerome into a rational argument for the orthodox faith. It was here that Jerome engaged in a new form of literary activity, that of translation. At roughly age 51, Jerome was invited to travel with Paulinus, one of the bishops of Antioch, to Rome.

Rome created new opportunities for Jerome. He had already corresponded frequently with Pope Damasus, and now ended up serving as one of his assistants. Jerome did his first version of the translation of the four gospels into Latin, using in part a much older but oftentimes poor translation from the Greek. For this, he caught heavy criticism, almost similar to criticisms for new English translations that deviate from the King James Version, considered by some to be the ultimate authority in Scripture. Jerome also developed a strong relationship with a few of the ascetic leaning women in Rome. Though he remained clean of any wrongful activity, the rumor mills ran heavy, eventually forced him out of Rome after the death of Pope Damasus. Jerome’s main cause for the Christian populace to turn against him was his vehement advocacy for a stringent, extreme form of asceticism, coupled with his pompous and acerbic spirit. He left Rome with a small entourage of friends and supporters, sailing to Syria and then Antioch, with the intention of going to Jerusalem. Jerome spent a year traversing the holy land, observing many of the sites of events of the old and new testament, and even going to Egypt to tour sites and visit monasteries in that land.

Eventually, he settled down to his cave in Bethlehem close to the historic site of the birth of Jesus. Except for brief moments, this is where Jerome would spend the rest of his life. He wasn’t a lazy man, and the output of these years were most astounding. He completed the translation of the Old Testament, sometimes under heavy criticism for going against the Septuagint. The Septuagint was a translation of the Old Testament (excluding the Apocrypha) into Greek, performed in Alexandria before the birth of Christ by 70 Hebrew scholars. Some Christians at the time regarded this translation as being divinely inspired. Jerome wrote massive commentaries on much of the Old and New Testament, regarded by scholars well into the middle ages as the definitive commentary of Scripture. He was embroiled by numerous theological controversies which demanded much time on his part. He also was very active in the education of young children, having a soft heart for them. He spent much time grieving as he watched old friends pass away. The most heartbreaking was when the Hun Alaric invaded Rome. Though Jerome referred to Rome as the whore Babylon and the pit of iniquity, he still had many friends who perished in the invasion. Later, his own cave was invaded just a few years before his death, with much of his library burned and destroyed. 

Jerome’s last two battles were against Origenism and Pelagianism. Origen’s writings were now deemed heretical. Sadly, Jerome’s best friend Rufus and him split over this issue, causing the most unpleasant (and definitely non-Christian) exchanges between the two of them. Worst of all, they were probably mostly in agreement, realizing that most of the writings of Origen were very insightful, and the heretical statements were when Origen was simply speculating on challenging problems, such as the issue of the origin of the soul. The bishop of Alexandria, even a more malignant fellow, Theophilus, prominent in the story of Chrysostom and more eager for political power than in behaving in a Christ-like fashion. Jerome labeled Origen a heretic, yet relied heavily upon Origen’s Hexapla, a side by side issue is six Hebrew and Greek versions of the Old Testament. Jerome also relied very heavily on Origen’s commentaries on Scripture, sometimes quoting Origen word for word. This is at best wanton hypocrisy, since Jerome was the first to accuse anybody a heretic if they claimed any value came from a heretic like Origen. The second issue, Pelagianism, presented a problem in Jerusalem, as Pelagius, in fleeing from Rome for the accusation of heresy, sought the protection of the church in Jerusalem. This occurred before the voluminous authoritative works of Augustine against Pelagianism, yet Jerome remained in total agreement with Augustine, which helped cement their distant friendship in opposing Pelagius’s writings. Needless to say, both the battles regarding Origen and Pelagius were fierce, even becoming physical.

Jerome died in 410 A.D., 10 years before his younger bishop friend Augustine. Jerome left a legacy of two sorts. First, he accomplished the translation of the Scripture into Latin, known now as the Vulgate, and still used by the church of Rome. While doing this, he also established a new theory of Biblical translation. Today, you will find three types of bible translation. The first is just a free flow interpretation, in essence, a running commentary of Scripture. The second is a “thought-for-thought” translation, also known as the dynamic equivalent type of translation. Jerome occasionally had to resort to dynamic equivalent translation with problem passages. The third, introduced by Jerome, was an attempt to be mostly word-for-word, essentially a literal translation of Scripture. This is the philosophy used by the translators of the King James Version, Martin Luther, and eventually the English Standard Version translation, which we use in church.  Jerome produced a massive number of commentaries, covering many of the books of the Bible. His style was fairly new, in that most commentaries to date were mostly allegorical interpretations. Jerome chose to avoid allegorical interpretations as much as possible. 

Jerome left a legacy as a brilliant man, superb scholar, literary genius, and theologian par excellence. Yet, he also left a legacy as an arrogant, ruthless, very often hypocritical, mean spirited person, sowing discord and strife wherever he settled. How do we reconcile this? Thankfully, we don’t have to. We will most certainly see Jerome in glory as his better self!

This book is first class at describing not only the life of Jerome, but also painting a picture of what life was like in the ancient times. My only sadness with the book is that the author demonstrates through subtle comments that he has fallen entirely prey to the siren call of higher academic textual criticism which started at the Tübingen school in Germany in the mid-19th century. Textual criticism as it is manifested in academic circles is a very sophisticated and scholarly way to argue for the sacredness of unbelief and must be rejected at all cost.

Golden Mouth

Golden Mouth: The Story of John Chrysostom: Ascetic, Preacher, Bishop, by J.N.D. Kelly ★★★★★

This is now my second reading of Golden Mouth, suggesting that it is a better than normal book, worth reading twice. John was surnamed Chrysostom, as Chrysostom in Greek means Golden Mouth, and John was most acclaimed as one of the greatest preachers of all time. In this biography, the author provides not only a discussion of the life of John Chrysostom, but also paints a larger picture of what was occurring throughout eastern Christendom. The many available histories of Chrysostom sometimes conflict with each other, and Kelly discusses what he thinks is the best alternative interpretation of his history. 

Chrysostom was born in Antioch, which is now located in Turkey, and often mentioned in the book of Acts. He was born roughly in the year 349, making him junior to the three Cappadocian fathers. His parents were devout Christians, and so John was raised with a vigorous Christian mindset. He attended the public schools, and his teacher of rhetoric was a pagan, who had commented that John would have been his replacement in the school save that the Christians stole him away. Because John manifested very early in life a particularly excellent talent in speaking, he first strove to be a lawyer. Swayed more by religious affections, Chrysostom became an assistant to the bishop of Antioch, and then was ordained as an official reader in the church. 

An increased desire for a holy life led Chrysostom to depart into a mountain close to Antioch where monks would go to live lives of solitude and prayer. Monks attempted to live with as little sleep as possible, and would always attempt to be standing erect 24 hours/day; after all, one would never lay down in the presence of a King, and we are always in the presence of the king of the universe! Meals were a scant meal a day, mostly of bread and water. During this time, John managed to memorize the entirety of the Old and New Testament. He was able to keep up the rigorous monastic asceticism for approximately four years, but became seriously ill, causing him to retreat back to Antioch. While there, the bishop of Antioch ordained John to be a presbyter (priest), so he was able to start preaching. Many of his sermons were preserved by stenographers, and demonstrated progressive improvement in his speaking style. Sermons in this age were performed with the preacher sitting, while the congregation remained standing.

Antioch underwent a serious crisis at this time. The emperor raised the taxes on the city, and riots broke out with difficult quelling the unruly mob. The emperor Theodosius was livid, and threatened to wipe the city off the map, saved only by the aggressive oratory skills of Chrysostom to persuade the emperor to forgive the city of their misdeeds. Chrysostom became known throughout the empire as one of the most impressive preachers alive. After years of preaching in Antioch, and unknown to him, he was called to be bishop of Constantinople, which was the capital of the eastern half of the Roman empire. So, off he went to Constantinople, where he would serve the remainder of his life, outside of his exiles. 

Chrysostom was a stern disciplinarian. He eschewed the lavish life style of the clergy in Constantinople, and fired many bishops and presbyters and deacons who were slothful or otherwise undisciplined, or if not heretical. In other words, he cleaned up the church. By doing this, he formed many enemies. His greatest supporters were his congregation, who defended him up to his death. Even in church, John would sternly disapprove of applauding the sermon, but stated so well as to lead to even more clapping! Even in the presence of the eastern emperor and his wife, Chrysostom would maintain a very careful discipline, not engaging in the fancy meals and gala that would accompany royalty. The emperor Arcadias and his wife Eudoxia were at first very supportive of John, until John preached a sermon a bit challenging to the female sex, leading to Eudoxia’s strong and persisting disfavor. (Perhaps John Knox should have learned from Chrysostom!) Chrysostom’s battles were plentiful during his stay in Constantinople, and over time, his enemies multiplied. 

The event of the Long Brothers is worthy to be repeated. The Long Brothers were a group of ascetic monks in the Egyptian desert who had some sympathies with the (orthodox) teachings of Origen. Theophilos, the bishop of Alexandria, declared Origen a heretic, and thus also deemed the Long Brothers to be heretics (which they were not). Through forceful means, Theophilos forced them out of Egypt, and so they went to Constantinople for safety. Theophilos then declared Chrysostom a heretic for harboring “Origenistic” heretics. Theophilos was ordered by the emperor to report to Constantinople  in order to make a ruling on his charge that Chrysostom was harboring a heretic. Theophilos played the game as guilefully as possible, delaying his departure from Alexandria as long as possible, and the journeying by a land route rather than sailing directly to Constantinople. Along the way, he solicited the help of as many anti-Chrysostom bishops as possible, those who were fired by Chrysostom. With a large following, Theophilus held a rigged synod called synod of the Oak, which Chrysostom refused to attend, noting that Theophilus had assembled an overwhelming majority of anti-Chrysostom bishops. Chrysostom was sent into exile, but almost immediately recalled when the people of Constantinople rioted at the loss of their favorite bishop. An earthquake also happened, causing the emperor and his wife to fear that this was a message from God.

Soon afterwards, the emperor’s wife Eudoxia had a statue of herself constructed in the city, which John promptly condemned as pagan and idolatrous. Again, John was again placed into exile. His site of exile was in Cucusos in Cappadocia. This was essentially a house arrest, allowing John to engage in extensive letter writing appealing his case, especially to Pope Innocent, who agreed with Chrysostom. Three years passed, and Chrysostom was finally deposed to a remote area around the Black Sea. On the journey, in a severely weakened state, he died. His final words were “Glory be to God for all things”. Several decades after his death, his body was finally returned to Constantinople in great honor.

We have much to learn from John Chrysostom and his life. First, we learn how a consecrated, pure, devout life can sometimes not produce a happy and contented outcome. We learn that even in the face of bitter opposition, remaining steadfast in the faith and speaking the truth will lead to the best outcome, but only if eternity is kept in mind. Second, we learn how the church, even in its earliest, purest form, had petty jealousies and power struggles, all of which somebody like John Chrysostom had to fight and eventually succumb to. We are all, from top to bottom, as Martin Luther said, simultaneously saints and sinners, and often our greatest enemies are found within the church itself.

The Reformation as Renewal

The Reformation as Renewal: Retrieving the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, by Matthew Barrett ★★★★★

Matthew Barrett presents here a tour de force, a magnum opus, a major work of nearly 900 pages, densely written and thoroughly referenced, defending the notion that the Reformation was a return of the church to its original doctrinal stances, rather than a departure from the “mother” church. In the years after the Reformation, there are those scholars, such as John Henry Newman of the Oxford movement and many in our lifetime who separated from mainstream Protestantism, laying the claim that they are being led back to the true church. Barrett shows how these folk, and the Roman church at large, are contradicting their own history, and that the Papist church that they are returning to are in fact the heretics who have departed from the Christian faith.

Barrett explores the notion of when the Papist church truly went wrong. All the Reformers, from Zwingli, to Luther, to Calvin, quote heavily from the early church fathers as well as Augustine. There are doctrines in the early church to which all the Reformers felt needed improvement, but would not identify those doctrines as sufficient to label the early church as having bad doctrine. Rejecting Biblicism (which includes haughty disregard of the history of doctrine, irresponsible proof-texting and univocal predication), the author begins by exploring movements within early church monasticism. Though monasticism was rejected by all of the Reformers, the basic crisis within the Reformed movement was not ceremonial and liturgical practice, but rather, the doctrinal under-girding of the church. Many of the monastics had correct doctrine, and little dispute was found even with Francis of Assisi. Bernard of Clairvaux, or the early Dominicans. The Scholastics were heavily examined, and the early Scholastics like Anselm, Bonaventure, Peter Lombard, Thomas Aquinas and others gave no need for a Reformation. True, doctrines of transubstantiation, Mariolatry, Penance and Papal supremacy were objected to, but did not carry the force of necessitating a split from Rome. Barrett spends nearly 80 pages exploring the thinking of Thomas Aquinas. A few doctrines just mentioned find their acceptance by Aquinas, yet, Aquinas remained within the realm of acceptability, especially in the area of the doctrines of grace, which we would later call “Calvinism”, i.e, predestination, sola gratia, and sola Christus. Aquinas for the first time extensively brings Aristotle into use, though he uses the thinking of both Plato and Aristotle in his examination of Christian theology. As Barrett shows, Aquinas also criticizes areas where he thinks both Aristotle and Plato went wrong, but accepts their writings when working out the legitimacy of using logic in reading Scripture, and using the four-fold method of interpreting Scripture (literal, allegorical, moral, and analogical). Thus, it would be irresponsible to deem Luther or Calvin as being anti-Aquinas. Neither did Aquinas separate faith from reason (as accused of by the late Francis Schaeffer), a separation that occurred with later Scholastics. Indeed, Barrett shows with lucidity a major rift in thinking from the time of Aquinas to that of the later Scholastics, so that he divides the Scholastics into via antiqua and via moderna.

Scholastics of the via moderna included John Duns Scotus, William of Ockham, and Gabriel Biel. The late Scholastics misinterpret Aquinas in a number of ways. As Barrett points out, Biel, for instance, grievously distorts Aquinas’ thinking on free will (Luther here would have never disagreed with Aquinas), on the need for predisposing grace and the effects of sin on man (i.e., a Pelagian anthropology), on the teaching of merit, and the teaching on infused grace. Thus, in critical issues, the Reformers had no problem with Aquinas but serious problems with the via moderna, which unfortunately, formed the theology of the late medieval church and to which the Reformers found serious objection. Barrett goes on to show how Bucer, Luther, Calvin, and Vermigli all were quite Thomistic in much of their thinking. So, what went wrong? The via antiqua were essentially realists in their thinking, and via moderna nominalists. Barrett spends much time pointing out how the nominalism of the via moderna was at fault for the destruction of Augustinian (and Thomistic) soteriology. Thus, doctrines which the Reformers rejected, related to doctrines of merit, of prayer to the saints, of purgatory, etc., etc. were all fashioned within the Papist church after the time of Aquinas. The rise of humanism lent strength to Reformers gaining wisdom in their defense of the original faith. Humanism in the 16th century was NOT the humanism that we now think of. Humanism only later became a mentality that man is the measure of all things, which is a thinking of the enlightenment. Rather, it was a call to ad fontes, return to the sources. In the schools and universities, this meant learning Hebrew and Greek (any worthy scholar already was quite fluent in Latin). Scriptures were being re-read, and objection to the translation of the Patristics, and especially Jerome’s Vulgate translation of Scripture, were noted.

At this point, I’ve reviewed a little more than ⅓ of the book, leaving out many critical details, with the hope that those curious or objecting to my summary, would pick up the book itself and read it. Much that has been written so far had a very distinct philosophical bent to it. Barrett has built the fundamental basis for the Reformation, and now turns to a more historical account of the Reformation, and how the transition in Scholastic thinking, and thus the doctrines of the Roman church, deviated from what the Christian church had always thought. Starting with Hus, and moving on to Tyndale, and then the magisterial Reformers, the objections were never so much over liturgical practice or minor issues of doctrine. Indeed, the entire thesis of this book is that the Reformers sought to save the original theology of the church, and not the newer inventions of the via moderna. Thus, every Reformer, especially Luther and Calvin, were steeped in the writings of the Patristics and Augustine. The objection that they were creating novel thinking in the church was countered that they were indeed returning to the faith of the true Catholic church.

Barrett spends a large amount of time exploring the earlier pre-Reformation Luther, with the events and thinking that led him to such a strong reaction against the church. His intention was always to correct the errors of the church, and yet any effort of the Reformers to point out questionable theology always led to hardening of the intention of the Papists. The story of Luther is lucidly told by Barrett. He then moves on to the Swiss Reformation, notably Zwingli, but also Bullinger and other leaders in the Swiss movement, and their influence on Luther, and later on Calvin. The French phase of the Reformation was dominated first by Bucer, and then by Farel and Calvin, Calvin falling out at the most articulate and also the most brilliant among the Reformers, who ultimately became centered in Geneva. Finally, the history of the English church with Cranmer, and later Scottish church with Knox, are well laid out. Interestingly, Barrett paints Knox as a rather irascible curmudgeon, whose temper was inherited in a greatly blunted form by the founders of the Presbyterian church of Scotland. Even Calvin had problems with the temperament, though not with the theology, of Knox.

The last chapter discusses the counter-Reformation of the Papists, and especially the proceedings of the council of Trent. This council was off and on again, and frequently thwarted by wars occurring between the Holy Roman emperor (Charles, and later Phillip II), the French monarch, and the Papacy itself. Reformers were asked to show up, which they refused to do, since they would never have a vote in the outcome of the council, and they were never assured safe passage, keeping Hus foremost in mind. The Roman church showed no desire to seriously rethink their prevailing theology, or to consider it an aberration from what the church has always stood for, from Aquinas and before him. This gives Protestants the ability to say with utmost confidence that they represent the true church, and that Rome is the apostate church. The Reformers had every right to identify the Pope as the anti-Christ.

One last aside. The theme of this book is to clearly argue that the Protestants are the true Catholic church, and NOT the Papists of Rome. There were other movements in the church who identified the Roman church as hopelessly lost from the very beginning. These include many of the Anabaptists, who claimed that the church went wrong from the very beginning. Certainly, there remain many heretical movements even to this day that make that claim, including the Mormon Church, the Jehovah’s Witness church, and numerous other authors, such as Wilkinson. The Reformers made it abundantly clear that this was an abomination to their thinking, and that they stood by the church through the centuries. I just happen to feel most strongly that the Reformers were indeed correct, and that they returned the church to its orthodox past.

This book is excellent in both its content and style. Barrett writes most clearly, and it was a joy to follow through his arguments for the church, and his skillful recounting of Reformation church history. This is one of the better books that I’ve read in the last few years, and challenged my thinking, while enhancing my knowledge base of Reformation history, even though I’ve read a number of accounts already of the story of the Reformation. Thus, it is highly recommended by me. At 900 pages, many of which are quite technical or philosophical, the student who chooses to tackle this book will be surely most illumined and blest.

A History of the English People

Version 1.0.0

A History of the English People, by Paul Johnson ★★★★

This book was originally published as The Offshore Islanders, which is probably a more suitable title for this volume. The book does cover English history from prehistoric times to the present, but is not a history book per se. Rather, it is a commentary on the English people. This does not diminish its value, and I felt that it was an excellent survey of English events and Johnson’s commentary on those events. The greatest problem with this book is that you will not be taught English history; one needs to know English history in order to make any sense of this book. Many events are treated very superficially, such as the rise of King Arthur, the writing of the Magna Carta, the war of the Roses, the ascendancy of Henry VIII, the period of Oliver Cromwell, the changes in England made by William and Mary (who are scarcely mentioned at all), Queen Victoria, Winston Churchill, and many other pertinent people and events that made British history to be was it is. Paul Johnson excels in being able to speak truthfully about matters, and is not shy to hide the serious failings and weaknesses of the British people, specifically their hypocrisy throughout their history, as well as their hubris, but also their fortitude, love for the rule of law, and repulsion of violence when possible. Controversial areas, such as who it was who caused the gunpowder plot, are avoided by Johnson.

Paul Johnson, who grew up with Jesuit tutelage, was quick to note how English Christianity received it’s first form by it’s first notable Christian, Pelagius, and though considered a heretic on the continent, helped to form the substance of Englands’ religious community, a community from its very inception as being independent of the continent, and especially that of Rome. This religious independence also mirrored the English independence from the continent in political matters, choosing rather to not specifically identify as “European”. The rise of the British king, the dealings with Scotland, Wales, and Ireland are all mentioned with commentary. Johnson spends much time emphasizing how the British church break from the Papacy was really an event in motion at least 100 years before Henry VIII. Johnson emphasizes repeatedly the nature of the interaction between the King and Parliament and that a British constitution was never as relevant as what one would find in the USA, the King and Parliament taking the place of any formal document.

In the period of the return of Charles II, Johnson notes how England codified it’s sense of self importance, and that feeling in England lasted until the 20th century, was a sense that the British were the chosen people of God, and thus ordained by God to bring light and life to the endarkened people of everywhere else on earth. Johnson convincingly shows how this British mentality shaped internal as well foreign policy.

Johnson hits on many topics of interest. He has always been intrigued by the British educational system, viewing it mostly in a very disparaging light. His sense was that science and engineering was always a weakness in English schools, even though there have been a few brilliant scientists to come out of the Islands. In particular, he recalls Joseph Priestley, who essentially invented modern chemistry, yet was run out of the country (and ended up in the USA) for his unusual beliefs. The last chapter of this book covers the 20th century up to 1975 (the date the book was published), discussing WWI at length, mostly for commentary on how and why Great Britain, who usually avoided continental politics, got involved in the Great War (WWI). There is almost no mention of WWII. Discussion on the political management of the trade unions and civil unrest were given discussion.

A lengthy epilogue is found at the end of the book. In this section, Johnson discusses how throughout history, England was repeatedly bedeviled with “bad luck” and hopelessness, and yet always managed to pull out. He views with optimism the British people reforming themselves, and coming to a renewed presence in the world scene. It is perhaps a good thing that Mr. Johnson did not survive to the present, where a renewed sense of gloom seems to dominate the British scene, and the possibility that immigration and loss of faith in God in Great Britain could perhaps lead to the ultimate demise of that country. Only time will tell.

This was a delightful book to read offering me abundant new perspectives on the English people. I highly recommend the text, though with the understanding that the book title does not describe the book contents. I read this in paperback form, the binding was falling apart; it was an old book given to me by David Davis.

Early Las Vegas

Version 1.0.0

Images of America: Early Las Vegas, by Linda Karen Miller ★★★

This is a nice picture book showing images of early Las Vegas, with brief commentary at the beginning of each chapter. It starts with a brief note of Nevada becoming a state, and Las Vegas as one of the routes of the Old Spanish Trail. Early settled white history includes first a group of Mormons setting up a colony now preserved as the Old Mormon Fort State Park. The Mormons left, but then miners, farmers and opportunists came to town to establish a presence. Because the town had many springs, it became identified as the ideal spot for the railway from Los Angeles to Salt Lake City to traverse. Namesake settlers such as Gass, the Stewarts, Griffith, etc are also mentioned. Las Vegas transformed from just another small town in Nevada to the burgeoning metropolis that it is, with the construction of Hoover Dam.

The book is brief, I was able to read all 125 pages in under 2 hours, but was taken up by the well reproduced photos. It is a nice book to have in your library if you have an interest in the brief history and meteoric rise of the Las Vegas valley.

The Story of Creeds and Confessions

The Story of Creeds and Confessions: Tracing the Development of the Christian Faith, by Donald Fairbairn and Ryan Reeves ★★★★

Fairbairn and Reeves provide a contemporary account of the creeds and confessions of the church through the centuries up to the present. Though written by two authors, the book is entirely cohesive and quite readable. Creeds would refer to those statements of belief, mostly written in the early church, which describe the essence of who God is and the nature of the Christian belief of the trinity being one God in three persons. Confessions tend to elaborate further upon Christian belief systems, mostly to distinguish among the various sects and denominations of the Christian faith, and are formed primarily following the Reformation of the church. Fairbairn and Reeves write a compelling text, most notably providing at times a different color or spin on the various controversies that tore at the Christian faith. In general, their “spin” has been even-handed, leaving the reader to be slightly uncertain as to the personal leanings of the authors.

There were only a few areas where I tended to be at odds with the authors. The first related to the Apostle’s Creed, which is described as a later creed, following that of the Nicene creed. Yet, the author(s) admit that the Apostle’s creed had a beginning in the earliest years of Christianity as a baptismal creed, but which was modified in the west, where the church was not as rocked by the Christological controversies of the eastern church. Still, its basis was an earlier creed, and it omits many essential doctrines essential to both the eastern and western church. The Apostle’s creed fails to offer a solid explanation as to the nature of Christ and deemed vital to the belief system of both the eastern and western church. Thus, it still should be considered as an earlier and more primitive creed. Secondly, much scholarship has gone into the Nestorius-Cyril antagonism and heresy battles, for which the authors did not fully account. The battle was for ego and power in the church. The authors properly note the challenge of accurately defining Greek terminology, and the words ousia, physis, hypostasis, and prosopon tended to have widely disparate meanings, and totally unintelligible to the Latin mind. Cyril’s mean, belligerent attitude did not help, and Nestorius’s followers frequent failure to represent the thinking and mind of Nestorius complicated the picture. As a result, today, the so-called Nestorian church of the middle east is everything but Nestorian, and even Nestorius regarded the doctrine named after him as heresy. Go figure.

Reformation and post-reformation development of confessional statements served to distinguish various movements as different from each other as well as the Roman church. The earlier creeds of the church were mostly assumed, and the issues centered more around ecclesiology, the sacraments, and soteriological issues. The chief players here were the Lutheran, Zwinglian, Reformed, Anabaptist, Anglican and Roman positions.

The most recent confessions of the church tended to minimize sacraments, ecclesiological polity and soteriology with an attempt, though mostly futile, to bring further unity to the church. A confession of this sort is the Barmen declaration authored primarily by Karl Barth. More recent confessions, mostly formed in southern realms, focus more intensely on social issues, such as with Liberation Theology.

I recommend this book to those interested in church history. It is well written, it doesn’t pick on any particular denomination of the church, and offers perspectives not found elsewhere. The book is heavily referenced, provides much additional references for reading materials, and most importantly, the references are found on the bottom of each page, making it easy to identify the notes without having to constantly jump to the back of the book.

Portland’s Hawthorne Boulevard

Portland’s Hawthorne Boulevard, by Rhys Scholes ★★

This book piqued my interest for a simple reason. When our family moved to Portland, Oregon in 1964, I was 10 years old, and meeting one of the most beautiful cities in America. We lived on 35th St. about ½ block south of Hawthorne Blvd. We stayed there for about 2-3 months, until our family relocated to SE 33rd and Tibbetts. This new location was close enough that I was able to maintain several paper routes located off of Hawthorne, with the paper shack being located on 30th and Hawthorne in a shed on the back side of Sylvia’s tavern parking lot, which is now Sukis. Most of my favorite memories on Hawthorne are now gone, including the Winchell’s Donut Shop on 12th and Hawthorne, the bicycle shop on 37th, and many other establishments, including the Hari Krishna house on about 31st, the Arctic Circle hamburger joint on 34th, and many of the older restaurants above 39th Avenue. Our old garage was moved from our house on Tibbetts to the corner of the Safeway parking lot to serve the Kiwanis Club as a storage spot for newspaper recycling, and of course, it is long-gone. The Fred Meyer on 39th was there, and fairly new when we moved there, as I especially remember parking on the roof. This Fred Meyer store created the type of store that others copied, including Walmart, which had both a grocery section, as well as clothing, toys and hardware.

Even though I lived in Portland for 18 years, from 1964 until 1982, returning frequently between 1992 and 2022, there was much history that I didn’t realize. I didn’t realize that Dr. Hawthorne was a physician. I didn’t realize that the noble estate seen up at the end of Hawthorne (actually at 55th St) was built by an early physician partner of Hawthorne, who also constructed the road that we now know as Hawthorne Blvd. The road allowed him to get to work at the Asylum that Hawthorne helped establish on the corner of 12th and Hawthorne. Apparently, there was a large slough from 12th Avenue down to the river that had to be filled in; there was also a large park filled with ponds, trees, and foot paths associated with the asylum. The Hawthorne bridge seems to be the first bridge built across the Willamette River, and had to be replaced with the current bridge in roughly 1912.

Businesses seem to be quite temporary in most of Portland, and especially along Hawthorne Blvd. The only stable establishments that I could identify were the Holman Funeral Home, the Safeway on 28th, the Bagdad Theater, Fred Meyers, and the Elks Club across the street from Freddie’s. Hawthorne Blvd experiences the frequent rise and fall of chick restaurants, and in a city that takes such great pride in having wonderful restaurants, I am surprised that the best of the best restaurants in Portland come and go. Thus, I’m not sure if I could identify any restaurant that might have been there as a kid, or even in the 1990s when I returned to the Northwest.

The book is mostly a photo album, and thus can be read in an evening or two. The author claims to have worked on and lived near Hawthorne Blvd for decades, though her writing style suggests an absence of intimacy for the area. Rhys does note that much of her material comes from a graduate thesis written for Portland State University in 1992 by a lady named Rachel Hardyman. Both Rhys and Rachel take care to deliver praise for the rise in communist anti-Capitalist ideology that rules strong on Hawthorne Blvd. Their reluctance to mention that the few stable businesses (that I can think of) still enduring from the last half century were Capitalistic in their economic ideology, which include the Holman Funeral Home, the Safeway on 28th, and that of Fred Meyer’s store. It does not take a rocket scientist to determine that perhaps the communist ideology is the reason for businesses failing to endure on Hawthorne, though perhaps it is that temporality that is considered a positive good to the author. Rhys would have been much wiser to simply keep politics out of the equation. If politics were an endearing question to Rhys, she might have brought up the fact that Portland city hall had a distinct notion of being seriously corrupt from early on in Portland’s history. I saw it in real life as a kid growing up in Portland. That corruption has only gotten worse, and the incompetent management of the city and state by the mayor of Portland and governor of Oregon lend testimony that wishful thinking and radical ideology cannot make a bad city good. Portland has sadly gone in the wrong direction. On moving to Portland in 1964, it was the most beautiful city in America. As kids, we would spend countless hours exploring and riding our bikes in Laurelhurst Park, riding our bicycles from southeast Portland to downtown Portland, attending Hosford School (three blocks from Hawthorne), and venturing up on special occasions to Mt Tabor for picnics, which always included a serious game of hide-and-seek. Until they closed off the upper loop on Mt Tabor to automobiles, we would take our cars up to the top of Mt Tabor, and wax them while overlooking the magnificent view of Portland. Nowadays, I visit Portland, Oregon and weep. It is nothing but a shit-hole. Please excuse the crude language, but more cultured language would not do. Why is Portland such a disaster? Its woke ideology and failure to promote higher values has led to its demise. This is not reflected in Rhys’s text, and is exactly where she misses the point.

The last chapter of this book contains the vignettes of three well known people associated with Hawthorne Blvd. The first person is “Doc” Severinson, whose dad for a short while practiced dentistry on the corner of 42nd and Hawthorne, and later moved out to a small town on the Columbia River east of Portland. The third is Linus Pauling, who grew up just east of 39th St. on Hawthorne Blvd. Though Pauling’s greatest fame was his nobel prize in chemistry, this was scarcely mentioned, while elaborating on his nobel peace prize. The second vignette was for a Commie pinko freak socialist that I never heard of, who fought to end nuclear energy in Oregon and promote communist values, while the remainder of the world (now) regrets decommissioning their nuclear power plants.

So, I enjoyed a small historical vignette of a place I used to live, but am saddened that Hawthorne Blvd is in terminal shock. If Rhys is correct that Communist woke ideology are the prevailing spirits of Hawthorne Blvd, then, the death of Hawthorne Blvd will probably be seen sooner than we’d all surmise.

Fateful Lightning

Fateful Lightning: A New History of the Civil War & Reconstruction, by Allen Guelzo ★★★★★

This is the last of my three books that I’ll be reading by Allen Guelzo on Civil War History. It gives a broad history of the civil war, starting with the Revolutionary War period and the events in our early Republic that led up to the civil war. The book does NOT provide a blow by blow account of the battles and military maneuvers of the civil war, but focuses more on the political and civil events that transpired before, during, and after the war. It is one of the more insightful texts that I’ve read on discussion of the causes for the war, what each side was fighting for, what the attitudes of politicians, soldiers and civilians were on both sides during the war, and a very brief accounting of the aftermath of the war up to the present day. In one sense, this book was awful—once you get to reading it, it’s hard to put it down. Guelzo draws you into issues that are surprisingly relevant to this day.

The first two chapters offer a prelude to the start of the civil war. Guelzo discusses how the north and south grew progressively different from each other, but especially in two particular ways. First was the issue of slavery. Racism was not an issue, because both the north and the south had no clue as to how to deal with free black folk. Both the north and the south felt strongly that the negro lacked the same intelligence as the white man, and was somehow inferior. Thus, even if the negro were to be set free, would they have the capability of performing in the civil sphere on the equal as the white man? The dilemma of slavery became an ever more contested issue in congress from the time of President Jackson through James Buchanan, and oftentimes, decisions only intensified the problem. Particularly worrisome was the expansion of slavery west of the Mississippi River and into the newly added states of Louisiana, Arkansas, Texas, and Missouri as slave states. An equal number of northern states were added, including Wisconsin, Minnesota and Iowa. But, the issue reached a head with the Kansas territory. Should it be divided in two (Kansas and Nebraska), one being a slave state and the other a free, or should the inhabitants retain the right to choose freely? Should the old compromise of the Mason-Dixon line be enforced, which would make both Kansas and Nebraska as free states? Emotions greatly intensified, with radical abolitionists in the north making demands that were politically not viable. The Dred-Scott decision, made by the supreme court led by a southern justice named Taney declared that essentially slaves were property, and that slave holders held those property rights regardless of where they were located, in the north or in the south. This ruling was tantamount to making slavery legal in all states of the union. The backlash was worse than imagined, empowering folk like John Brown to attempt to force a military solution. With the election of Abraham Lincoln as president, the south could no longer wait, and the firing on Fort Sumpter began the worst conflagration in American history.

Guelzo walks the reader through the main events of the civil war, but focuses on important details that are typically not discussed in civil war history books. What kind of weapons were used? How were regimens outfitted? How prepared were the various armies? Compared with the recent wars in Europe, the American conduct of war, on both the north and south sides, was amateurish at best. America’s last war was under President Polk in Texas and Mexico. Since then, the USA pared down the military to a minimum. Thus, both north and south needed to relearn how to conduct a war. The weapons were of inferior grade, rifles being quite inaccurate, and still requiring breech loading, meaning there was always a minute or more between shots. The first action of Lincoln was to form a naval blockade around the south, which meant that naval trade (mostly with Europe) was not stopped, but severely limited. The story of the development of the iron-clad ship is told here, making wooden battle vessels entirely obsolete soon after the war began.

Tension among the states was intense, especially in the south, which wished to retain state rights foremost, and yet those state rights were disruptive to the confederate war effort, as they were each state for themselves. Much of the challenge of confederate president Davis was to promote a stronger central government. Unfortunately, the raison d’être for the south was the promotion of state rights, and a strong central government, necessary for the conduct of a war, was counter to state wishes.

Guelzo addresses many issues that I will not attend to at length in this review. Economics and money management were hot. Both the north and the south enacted conscription, but then, who was exempt? Large plantation owners, as they were needed to maintain the plantations? But, wasn’t the war being fought for the preservation of plantations, so why shouldn’t the plantation owners share the same risks and losses for defending their way of life? Religion was a big topic. Neither the north nor the south were terribly religious, and yet both sides vehemently charged that they were the side that was most in line with the Christian faith.

The greatest dilemma for both the north and the south was the issue of what to do with the freed slave. We know that this was always on Lincoln’s mind, but since he was assassinated only a few days after the end of the war, we don’t know how things would have worked out, though I suspect it would have been much for favorable for the south if he had remained alive. Proposals were many, including sending them back to Africa, but then, they were residents of US soil for many generations, and so that didn’t make sense. Should they be sent west? Should they have equal rights with the white man? Sadly, seriously botched attempts by Andrew Johnson at reconstruction created the worst possible mess for the black man.

The north had to contend with what to do with the confederates at the end of the war, and the terms necessary to restore them to the union. Unfortunately, Andrew Johnson gave mindless pardons to many of the most hardened confederate war criminals, who then ended up back in congress. It took Grant and his presidency to make sense of this, yet was an episode in US history that never should have happened. Still, reconstruction, referring mostly to the reconstruction of state politics to allow them to return to the union, was an unstable and often violent event. Added to this were the sometimes altruistic but more often greedy carpetbaggers seeking their fortunes or fames in the south. We still live with this legacy of unresolved tensions between the various races and cultures that make up the USA, and the sheer incompetence of the government in all three branches to truly deal with the tensions that exist.

Throughout the book, Guelzo obliquely addresses the causes of the civil war. Was it slavery? Was it state rights? Was it an irreconcilable cultural divide between the north and the south, the north being primarily industrial and the south agrarian? Was it an economic issue, such as trade tariffs with foreign countries? Sadly, those trying to answer these questions often greatly confuse the issue as they wish to skirt the one and only most obvious cause, which was the issue of slavery. The Lost Cause movement tries to evoke our pity with the “if only” questions that they raise. If only the south had more finances. If only the white male population of the south was larger. If only, if only, if only. And yet, their eyes are wide shut to the issue of slavery. Union soldiers were often greeted by the most horrific spectacles of slavery and its abuse when venturing into the deep south. Stories about mistreated slaves extend not only to the large Mississippi, Alabama and Georgia plantations, but also to the home of Robert E. Lee himself, who would always lay claim that he hated slavery and wish it would go away, and yet would not free his own slaves.

Guelzo is a master at story telling, but also a master historian. He leaves scant clues as to his leanings on the issue of the civil war. Was he a northern, or was he a southern sympathizer? He both praises and rebukes both sides. He offers more insights into the troubles of the civil war than any other text I’ve read so far. Those troubles extend to the present day, and to understand them, it is worth taking a journey back with Guelzo to the way the race and slave question was originally handled. I invite you to get a copy of this book and read it. But be forewarned; it will be hard to put down.