
Stockholm Syndrome Christianity—Why Christian Leaders Are Failing — and What We Can Do About It, by John G. West ★★★★★
Stockholm Syndrome Christianity (SSC) addresses the issue as to why so many churches, church leaders, and church members are failing to maintain true Biblical teachings. John West is currently the vice president of the Discovery Institute in Seattle, WA. John writes in a very personal style, as though he was in a conversation with you. The book is about the 10th-grade level, so nearly any high schooler or college student should have no problem reading the book. It is not a book on the order of tackling Immanuel Kant’s Kritik der reinen Vernunft. The style of this (SSC) text is indeed similar to a previously published (and must-read book) Darwin Day in America (DDA). DDA addresses how society and its particular structures (like politics, law, education, medicine, etc) have failed us. This book (SSC) is complementary to DDA in addressing how and why the church, its leaders, and its members have failed its higher Biblical calling. The book is an encyclopedic tour de force of examples of how Christian leaders and Christian schools have failed their members.
John West draws heavily throughout the book on the writings and life of Francis Schaeffer, which also touches near and dear to my heart. I attended indubitably the most liberal college in America, Portland State University. In Paul Johnson’s words, it was a veritable hothouse of extremism (see full quote below). This was in the mid-1970s when Schaeffer was well known and debated even on far-left liberal campuses, and my liberal secular professors were quite familiar with him. In my many liberal arts papers I would often quote in my arguments words from Schaeffer. I got “A’s” on my papers back then, something that would never happen in today’s University world. Schaeffer kept me grounded in the Christian faith in the cesspool of anti-Christianity. And this is perhaps why I strongly connect with the current author. Back to the book…
SSC is written in three parts, the symptoms, the causes, and the cures for SSC. A short introduction to the book details John West’s personal account of how he saw SSC force itself onto the campus of the school where he was a professor, Seattle Pacific University. It sets the stage for why this book was written.
The symptoms section is the longest, taking up over half the book. Chapter 1 is a lament as to how traditionally orthodox churches have discarded the whole counsel of God, mostly by making irrelevant the entirety of the Old Testament, save for fuzzy, feel-good chapters like Psalm 23. Many pericopes and narratives of the Old Testament were considered outdated or worse, not true. Chapter 2 extends this wholesale trashing of the OT with the trashing of the creation narratives. The “pious” alternative to discarding Genesis 1-3 is theistic evolution (TE). TE, when formally examined, is much less of a science than is purportedly the case with intelligent design, yet snobs itself off as the intellectual stance of the elite Christian. It’s not just bad science, it’s dung science (I won’t use the more offensive word), since it lends an air of holiness to atheistic thinking, and is syncretism on par with merging Christianity with Hinduism or Satanism. Chapter 3 discusses Christians caving in on issues of sexuality. Whether it be the heterosexual promiscuity or the gay agenda, Christians have been given a counterfeit gold piece when they are told that the loving action is to love the person with the action, rather than (the Schaefferian approach) to love the person but hate the action. In the long run, it is most loving to condemn sexual perversion, yet to do that in a manner that shows genuine empathy towards the person. Chapter 4 addresses the issue of race and ethnicity in the church. To me, this seems like a simple problem to solve, yet, the modern Christian cure has become worse than the original disease. Scripture is quite plain that there is no racial division in God’s kingdom. Yet, church leaders somehow find it holier to accentuate the differences rather than the unity among various races. Chapter 5 speaks of Christians standing up for their Christian liberties; examples include the manner in which churches responded to the Covid “crisis”, or to bakers refusing to produce a gay-lesbian-themed cake when asked. West goes into detail about how Christians have insidiously lost their religious freedoms through the anti-Christian biases of the government, the courts, and the public square. Chapter 6 references the many churches and individuals who have hopped on the greased slippery slide to hell, one example being Francis Schaeffer’s son Frank who started as a militant evangelistic Christian and ended up as a functional atheist. Thankfully, West gives the story of Günter Bechly and Eta Linneman who both started at the bottom of the slippery slide and returned to the orthodox faith. The tacit lesson is that there is always hope!!!!
Section 2 addresses the causes of SSC. Chapter 7 speaks of listening to the wrong voices. Whether it be corrupt (or deluded) national media, social media, web search engines, entertainment media, or authorities (scientists, university professors, etc), you will probably need to use extreme discretion. I’ll quote an example of the use of entertainment media that is badly used. I remember being on a medical mission with my wife to a Muslim country in Africa. We had a chance to watch a movie that just came out regarding the Crusades. The movie was “The Kingdom of Heaven”, and while correctly identifying graft and corruption in the Crusaders, it painted a totally righteous image of Saladin and the Muslim invaders. The grotesque twisting of history was desperately unnerving to me, and yet sopped up by the missionaries as a warning about how evil Christians really are. They were duped!!!!! Chapter 8 discusses the desperate desire to please people, and those people are often the wrong people. Generally, you want to make your boss, your priest or minister, your advisor, or your friends happy. Sadly, this leads to a series of compromises in one’s beliefs that ultimately lead to a non-Christian Weltanschauung. Two words suffice: STRENG VERBOTEN!!!!! Chapter 9 discusses tolerating the wrong rulers. Whether it be a wrong person(s) on the board of directors of a college, or elders in a church, or government officials, a bad apple or two on a board will eventually rot out the entire system. West’s warning is most appropriately heeded, as he speaks from numerous real-life experiences both in the ecclesiastical as well as the educational system.
Finally, section 3 addresses solutions and cures. In the last three chapters of the book, Dr. West gives very sagacious, wise, perspicacious, and sound advice for students, academics, clergy, laity, and just plain old farts like myself as to how to respond. Maintaining the intent and desire to let Scripture control your hour-by-hour thinking, your Weltanschauung, and your meditative life, living true to that Scripture, and being willing to sacrifice everything including one’s life are relevant. The call to engage the culture and fight the evil… no, Satanic, secular beast that confronts us, are words we approve of but always find a challenge to do. May we pray for ourselves and our culture that we could be the olive branches that bring sanity to devils that seek not only our minds but also our souls.
So far, amazon.com has one written review, and the complaint was that West should have moved beyond social issues and just addressed Christianity. But, he totally misses West’s point! It is impossible to divorce the social from spiritual aspects of the Christian life. The reviewer’s mindset is exactly why we are in the morass we are in.
I need to mention two individuals that West brought up throughout this book as examples of SSC. They are Francis Collins and Tim Keller. I met Francis Collins once, as he was the keynote speaker at the Society of Surgical Oncology annual meeting (for which I’m now an emeritus member), which occurred somewhere around the year 2002. During his speech, he emphatically claimed that progress was going so well in cancer research that by the year 2012, we would no longer be seeing anybody dying of breast cancer. Yet, in 2022, 42,211 women in the USA died of breast cancer. The incidence of death from breast cancer has dropped somewhat, but mostly owing to earlier detection, and not from “miracle” cures. The form of dishonesty displayed by Collins breeds huge donations for research but also breeds false hopes and severe disappointments, including lawsuits against treating physicians; “If we are winning the war on cancer, then why am I dying of the disease” is asked by many patients. Collins’ less-than impeccable reputation has generated wanton ruin through his leadership at the NIH and with his involvement with groups such as the Christian Medical and Dental Associations, who held him in great acclaim. Tim Keller has also been mentioned frequently. A pastor of a past church of mine held Tim Keller in the highest esteem as a model of how Christianity should be presented and Sunday worship executed. It was Christianity lite, a Christianity stripped of everything except for empty grace grace grace. I regarded Keller as a heretic many moons ago, even before other groups began to become very uncomfortable with Keller’s stances on theological and public issues. I’m glad that West was able to provide greater substance to that. Keller’s defection was a great loss. He is now dead and cannot correct his sins, which, if he had corrected them, could have made a serious impact on global Christianity. Keller will now accompany Harry Emerson Fosdick, another New York liberal Presbyterian preacher of a century ago, into the waste bin of history, an insignificant failure who did more harm than good to the whole of Christianity.
A slight bit of humor must be added to West’s book. The patron saint of Stockholm Syndrome Christians is none other than St. Peter himself. Like SSCs today, Peter in a moment of pride and self-preservation denied the real Christ at a critical moment. Unlike SSCs today, St. Peter soon saw the error of his ways and wept bitter tears, never to ever deny his Lord and Savior again. It is not ok to have screwed up, but it is redeemable; St. Peter showed us how to do that. Soli Deo Gloria!
SUMMARY: If you are a conservative Christian with a belief in scripture being the infallible word of God, don’t even ask the question! Buy this book from Amazon and read it! It is not a Streams in the Desert devotional book. You won’t feel warm and fuzzy. The book will convict you, direct you, inspire you, inform you, and motivate you to stand firm; it will open your eyes all the wider to see the wolf in the sheep’s flock, the devil in the pulpit or pews; it will put your fight to where the battle is being fought. Mainstream conservative Christianity needs a reboot and reset and this book will do it. God bless you and God bless John West for his labors in writing this book.
Universities are the most overrated institutions of our age. Of all the calamities which have befallen the 20th century, apart from the two world wars, the expansion of higher education, in the 1950s and 1960s, was the most enduring. It is a myth that universities are nurseries of reason. They are hothouses for every kind of extremism, irrationality, intolerance and prejudice, where intellectual and social snobbery is almost purposefully instilled and where dons attempt to pass on to their students their own sins of pride. The wonder is that so many people emerge from these dens still employable, though a significant minority, as we have learned to our cost, go forth well equipped for a lifetime of public mischief-making.
Paul Johnson, To Hell with Picasso, 07SEPT1991
Thanks Ken for the visit and encouragement and the Stockholm Syndrome. I’m not through the whole book because it is too important for just skimming. Your review as usual is par excellanti! My first real date with Linda was a debate at the Univ. of Chicago the day that Kennedy was assassinated. Schaeffer vs. a humanist professor of Anatomy. It was a no contest winning debate!!!! for Schaeffer. Looking at similar material is the follow book I recommend to you.
Redeeming the Life of the Mind
Essays in Honor of Vern Poythress
Edited by
John M. Frame, Wayne Grudem, and John J. Hughes
FOREWORD BY J. I. PACKER
Redeeming the Life of the Mind: Essays in Honor of Vern Poythress
Copyright © 2017 by John M. Frame, Wayne Grudem, and John J. Hughes
Published by Crossway
1300 Crescent Street
Wheaton, Illinois 60187
John M. Frame, Wayne Grudem, and John J. Hughes, eds., Redeeming the Life of the Mind: Essays in Honor of Vern Poythress (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2017), 3–4.
It is an excellent description of how we are now in this mess of having TRUE TRUTH SUBVERTED.
BLESSINGS KEN TO YOU AND YOUR FAMILY. JOY, Don and Linda
Francis Collins also became the poster-boy for the American Scientific Affiliation, a “fellowship of Christians in science” in which I once was a Fellow and Newsletter Editor. I began to become uneasy about ASA – couldn’t identify cognitively what it was – in the mid to late 1990s. Perhaps it was the adoration of Collins. When he became head of the NIH, Anthony Fauci’s boss and hence responsible for what that chaff which the wind drives away (but has yet to do so) had done, yet sided with him in his mischief, I could then identify what had befallen the ASA. Additionally, when the ASA journal became a propaganda outlet of the Fauci-Big Pharma-Globalist mRNA drug attack on the world by promoting the mRNA drugs and denouncing those who raised rather scientific arguments in opposition, I am glad that I washed my hands of ASA over a quarter-century ago. The old ASAers I knew were of a different mind than what has become of ASA today. ASA delenda est!