
Religion and the Rise of Western Culture, by Christopher Dawson, ★★★★★
This delightful little book was given to me by a friend A.D. Waterman in our discussion of the progression of thought in the middle ages. It was a delight to read and most informative. I had already read much about the middle ages, but this book provides new insights into the dynamics of the Christian religious influence to the middle ages. Dawson writes well, and it was hard to put this book down. It was one of the better books I’ve read on the middle ages.
Dawson covers how the Christian religion and the Catholic Church were influential at the development of modern society, including the city, the schools, the trades, the church, law, government; all were influenced by the rise of Christianity. The book hits hard on the struggle with alien invaders in the early parts of the middle ages, from the Muslims, from Scandinavia, and from the far east. Certainly, these raids were ultimately a blessing in disguise, as many of these invaders became Christian and helped influence the development of a Christian west. He refers often to St. Thomas, which I can only presume he means Thomas Aquinas, definitely one of the great minds of the middle ages.
There is really only one deficit that I see in this text, and that is of his avoidance of discussion regarding the problems in the Catholic church, namely, the corrupt popes at three or four major times, and the Avignon papacy, with as many as 3 or 4 folk all claiming to be popes. This affected how the middle ages eventually resulted in the Reformation, a corrective measure for the decadent church, and which the Romanists fought against the corrective action of the Reformers for the church to their own loss.
Scandal can be found in virtually every denomination and church that I know of. It is the acknowledgment that we are mere sinful mortals before a holy God. This book paints beautifully the church, our church, my church, the bride of Christ, through the thick and thin of the most fascinating period in its history. It is impossible not to love the church and realize that western civilization would have looked much different without it. The monastery’s influence especially is most informative, and perhaps suggestive of something good that perhaps we have all lost with the development of modern times.
So, I highly recommend this text. As I said, it is well written and easy to read in just a few sit-down sessions.
St. Thomas – the Thomas I am cognizant of is the apostle to the Malabar Coast of India in the first century.
The problem in understanding the Middle Ages is that it is generally not appreciated how skewed a view of ancient history, including the Bible, resulted from the rediscovery and recovery of the Greek and Roman writings, which became the foundation for the construction of Western historiography. What a mistake, yet it has yet to be corrected, especially since the rise, beginning in the 1840s, of ancient Near East archaeology.
Na und? Did you wish to make a point? You must be referring specifically to Ray Capt, and not the overwhelming output of Near East archeological evidence.
My overall point is that you should be more discerning about the authors of the books you read. This is papal revisionist (false in critical places) history, as though there were no other Christians around than those in the Catholic Church, and shows the arrogance of the Roman religion.
Despite what Vatican records clearly show, the Vatican claim is that Augustine brought Christianity to the British Isles in ca 600 AD. The Celtic Christians of Joseph of Arimathea’s Culdee church found him arrogant despite their history as the first nation to have become Christian, in the 30s AD. Augustine was about 6 centuries late!
Does this author even mention the Culdee church? Or the Celtic church of Ireland? They persisted against Roman incursion in the Isles until the end of the Middle Ages. It is not to be hinted at by the post-medieval papacy but it is important to church history. It is an elephant in the RCC sanctuary!
Dane should read some of your Protestant books. Or better yet, start with Isabel Hill Elder’s book, Celt, Druid, and Culdee:
http://www.goldenageproject.org.uk/images/Celt%2BDruid-Elder.pdf
I just finished re-reading my paper copy, only to realize how much I had missed first time through. Ken, you read free books; this one is free for the downloading!