Cranmer’s Church

Cranmer’s Church: Then and Today, by Chuck Collins ★★★

This is a wonderful book, well written, that talks about the Anglican church from its inception at the time of Henry VIII. The book has short, and easy to read chapters. It gives a good summary of the history of the Anglican church, as well as its theology. Apparently, the Anglican Church is not a confessional church, and thus does not have a standard set of beliefs, outside of regulation by the 39 articles, which is limited at defining Anglican theology. Chuck leaves out many details of the church that I would have loved to hear about. I’ll list just several. He didn’t really talk much about the issue of separatism, like the Methodist movement and the Puritans. He didn’t talk at all about the Westminster Confession, which was the product of mostly Anglican Divines. Why? He didn’t address the issue of the Anglican Church in non-English speaking communities. This is a concern, since the Anglican Church revolves around the book of Common Prayer and the beautiful writings, prayers, and encouragements of Thomas Cranmer, which would lose some of their beauty when translated.

The theology is weak, in that Collins doesn’t try to draw an hard-line theological stances. For example, he has a hard time in discussing the tension between law and grace. He fails in the Reformed (and stance of Aquinas) in noting that salvation has always been the same from the Old Testament to the New. The terms of the Covenant are stated differently, and the obscure is revealed in the New Testament, but the faithful will always live the same, and salvation was always by faith alone, even in the Old Testament. His theology on the communion host is weak but acceptable to me.

For the most part, this was a nice review of the Anglican Church. I can agree with most of theology that Collins presents, as well as his love for the beauty of Cranmer (Lancelot Andrews, which he never mentions) JC Ryle. I studied under JI Packer, an Anglican who is now deceased, whose theology I define as my own. I love attending an Anglican Church. I adore the language of Cranmer. I love the thought that they treat all of Scripture, Old and New Testaments, as valuable, and not to be avoided. I love the ACNA church where I currently attend, and especially love that it is not formed by mostly rich, comfortable people content with their status; our church is a lighthouse, a harbor for the “dregs” of society. It is excellent at preaching the whole counsel of God in a wasteland. The ACNA shines in its ability to present the real gospel to sinners, of which I am chief. I realize that I come from a church that is theologically so rigid that variations of theological stances are greeted with the cry of “heresy”. Heresy had come to mean anything that they disagree with, without discussion or referral back to Scripture. I’m glad that I don’t have to endure that!

NPNF1-6

Version 1.0.0

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers Series 1, Volume 6, general editor Philip Schaff ★★★★★

Volume 6 of this series continues the writing of Augustine of Hippo, the great saint of the end of the 4th century and into the 5th century. This volume is the first of three containing the preserved homilies of Augustine. In it, there is a series of sermons Augustine preached on the sermon on the mount, a series on the harmony of the gospels, and then sermons expounding the gospels.

Throughout the set of series of fathers of the church by Schaff, an explanatory and historical exposition is often rendered. The discussion before kicking into the sermons of Augustine was an analysis of Augustine’s hermeneutical technique. Augustine, like most of his contemporaries and predecessors, engage heavily in allegorical interpretation of the Scripture. It is true that allegorical interpretations are often still utilized, especially in the Kay Arthur of Bible Study Fellowship programs, where all participants are asked to render their opinions as to what various Scripture passages mean to them. The book of Revelation lends itself primarily to an allegorical interpretation, and this perhaps is the source of the wildly divergent interpretations of this book. Allegory is perhaps too frequently shunned in today’s expository works. The danger is quite obvious, in that it would lead to a plethora of meanings and contradictory doctrines if allegory was used as strongly as a plain historical-grammatical interpretation of Scripture. Augustine discusses various forms of Scripture interpretation, and certainly considers historical grammatical exegesis to be the highest form of exposition, but sometimes (in my estimation) takes allegorical meanings to be somewhat more important than would be found in the mind of most Protestant 21st century expositors. A recent movement, in the Redemptive-Historical school of exegesis, interpretations are often forced on a passage that simply are not there, but are found only when allegorical methods are used to read a passage. Augustine is quite free to interject allegorical interpretations as he expounds on the sermon on the Mount, which is the first set of sermons found in this volume. The second set of sermons, which is actually more of a didactical study, Augustine goes through the four gospels, identifying for each story, the differences in that story as found in the four different gospels. Interestingly, the first segment of his Harmony of the Gospels is an apologetic that Augustine offers for a monotheistic religion.

In the third section of this volume, various sermons that Augustine preached based on verses in the 3 synoptic gospels were offered. I will make comments not on the content, but rather on the style of these sermons.

First, the sermons are quite variable in length, and if I were to read them, would range from 5 to 20 minute homilies. We don’t know if these are only excepts of his homilies or the full sermon. We do know that Augustine preached extemporaneously (not from notes) and that copyists wrote down his words which were later reviewed and corrected by Augustine.

Secondly, the sermons are partially expositions of the words of the text offered in a historical-grammatical style, but also that Augustine utilized a large amount of allegorical interpretation. Whenever numbers are given in the gospels, Augustine usually will try to find an allegorical meaning for those words. In the parables, almost everything is reinterpreted from an allegorical viewpoint. I have already discussed my thoughts on allegorical interpretation above.

Thirdly, sermon structure was fairly free-flowing by Augustine. I contrast that to a typical sermon found preached over the pulpit today, which has a set structure. In it, the word is read, a prayer is offered, the passage is exegeted by the preacher, and then points (usually 3) of application to an individual’s life are offered. You don’t see that in Augustine, and are often left in the lurch at the end of his sermon as to where he was taking you.

Fourthly, Augustine will frequently hit on theological issues, and those were usually the doctrines of faith that were in contention at the time. These include the doctrines of Christ and the doctrines of the trinity. Many other doctrines are not included, including soteriological issues. I must not forget that these are only a few of the enormous volume of sermons that Augustine preached, so I could not venture a guess at what other doctrines were developed by him for his homilies. Thankfully, we have Augustine’s technical writings to know what he was thinking in so many other areas of the faith.

I have two more volumes yet to read on the sermons of Augustine. The first contains expository sermons as he works through the books of John and 1 John, and also Augustine’s soliloquies. The last volume will be Augustine’s sermons through the Psalms. This volume was read with me somewhat drugged out, recovering from knee surgery. Perhaps I was not always as coherent as I should have been while reading and then writing this review. I’ll leave it at that and move swiftly on to volume 7 of Schaff’s Nicene-Post Nicene Fathers.

Yellowstone

Yellowstone: TV series 2019-2024 ★★

We watched Yellowstone on the recommendation of friends. Though Woke, Yellowstone was not suffering as badly as many other contemporary tv series in the matter of wokeness. It is the story of a large cattle ranch in south central Montana, somewhat close to Yellowstone National Park. The area is actually a fiction, though the story is cohesive so long as one does not pay to close of attention to maps. Betsy and I watched this series together. Toward the middle of the last season, we couldn’t wait for the series to end. I typically don’t do film or tv series reviews, but this series begged for a review.

The strength of this series is that it maintains a somewhat unpredictable story line. This leads to the desire to continue watching the series. It’s almost like the old Batman tv series, where at the end of one episode, Batman and Robin would be in hot trouble, but Batman and Robin would always be rescued in the following episode. It also maintains a somewhat non-woke attitude. As an example, for the first season or two, the only beer drunk was Budweiser. With the development of the woke advertisements for Budweiser, the series immediately removed Budweiser, and the only beer consumed or advertised was for Coors. The other strength was the scenery, as it presented Montana (and Utah?) at its’ most beautiful.

Why did we dislike, and often, truly hate this series? Many reasons come to mind. Some of the actors were truly despicable. Beth Dutton leads the list; her behavior led one to wish and pray that she would just be knocked off. Sadly, it never happened. Jamie Dutton was so miserably weak-kneed as to be pathetic, and defying any realistic notions about his stage part, including that of being the state attorney general. Really, one couldn’t be serious. John Dutton was acted out well by Kevin Costner, but there was never developed a sense of love or desire to see him succeed in his endeavors. The point to be made is that there was not a single character in the entire series that could be viewed as a person of virtue, and certainly the presence of virtue was non-existent throughout the series. Every role seen in the movie was self-serving. Perhaps the only character that came closest to character development was that of Jimmy. Whether it be the ranchers, who were entirely self-serving, the real estate development moguls who didn’t give a rip about environmental issues, or the Indians, who were hopelessly and cluelessly bemoaning the loss the the land that they identified as theirs. Unfortunately, the tv series was, like so many woke portrayals of Indians, the most “virtuous” of the bunch, and the Indians eventually gained control of the Yellowstone ranch.

Gone are the days where movies tended toward some form of moral development. Instead, it was repeatedly stated by characters in their rapport that morality does not exist and that actions cannot be judged based on higher law. This change in Hollywood’s attitude resembles that of entertainment in ancient Rome, which progressed over the years from virtuous to decadent, reflecting the nature of Roman society. I fear that such tv series today represent a decline in civility and virtue in society, much to our loss. There was some sexuality in the series, and nearly every episode had some lewd speech. Nudity was less common, the most seen was in one of the first episodes where Beth gets totally naked and takes a bath outdoors in front of a group of cowboys. I presume that this was included to bait teenage minds into hanging through the series, hoping for more “eye candy”. Foul language was most notable, and replete and in excess throughout every episode of the series. This is not a series for young children, and perhaps also for adults!

Christianity is still fairly prevalent in Montana. Yet, only the briefest mention of Christianity is offered in this series. There were one or two times when Dutton family members mentioned that they might have gone to church once. Instead, Indian animism and spiritism were quite frequently mentioned. Kayce Dutton performs some sort of ceremony in the outdoors to make contact with “the spirits”. Kayce moves into a new house, and their first meal is proceeded by saying “grace”, but was a prayer of thanks for their forefathers, and not to God. An animistic funeral for a newborn baby was performed. The Indians frequently mention their “sacredness”. Lost is Christianity or any resemblance of a public or private morality. Assassinations, killings, and other crimes are committed without guilt and without consequences. Crimes were considered amoral so long as the state doesn’t find out and so long as it served some sort of “good”.

Toward the end of the last (5th) season, John Dutton is assassinated. Beth then becomes the prominent star in the series, seeking vengeance on Jamie Dutton for supposedly orchestrating the murder of her father. During these final episodes, one wishes that Beth would also be assassinated, as her personality is despicable, and Jamie, not for the evil he has done, but for his lackluster, anemic personality; Jamie was assassinated by Beth, who lied to the police to hide that she did the murder. As with Jamie, justice is never properly served throughout the series, and the lesson was simply that “might makes right”.

Why the series Yellowstone had such a high rating leaves me worried. Why did people like Yellowstone? It was sewage morality, the only great actors were John Dutton and Lloyd, a hired cowhand. Though Beth was touted as a great actor, I thought that she was quite lackluster, and her oral deformity (cleft lip) was particularly annoying. We were more than grateful at the end of the series to have finished it. What’s left now is two prequels, 1883 and 1923, which I’ll probably tag to the end of this review at a later date. For now, Betsy and I need a break from this series.

Version 1.0.0

1883: A Yellowstone Origin Story ★★

This series goes back to 1883 with the Duttons departing from Fort Worth Texas. The entire 1883 series is nothing but the chronicle of their wagon train journey. Their intention was to go to Oregon. Along with the Duttons were a motley gang of German immigrants seeking guidance to get to Oregon, but completely unprepared for the journey. Also were several guides, Shea and Thomas (in real life Sam Elliott and Lamonica Garrett). The entire wagon train also rounds up about 20 stray steer to take along as food, along with some wranglers to help manage the cows. They encounter multiple difficulties, including internal dissension, Indian attacks, fatal river crossings, and challenging decisions owing to health, absence of water, and absence of horses/wagons.

Eventually, most of the German travelers had died. By the time the wagon train reached Wyoming, there were only two wagons left, no cows, and Elsa dead. Indians directed the reduced Dutton family to Paradise Valley, which is where we find them in the Yellowstone series. Sam Elliott and Lamonica Garrett make it the next year to Oregon. The plight of everybody else was left in question.

Good things about the series – The filmography was stunning, with beautiful prairie scenes, and the grandeur of the mountains of Wyoming and Montana. The acting of Sam Elliott set the standard for the series—without Sam, the series would have failed. Compared to the main Yellowstone series, there was MUCH less obscenity, and only one word (the “f” word) was used occasionally. There was no formal nudity, and the sex scenes were more subdued.

Bad things about the series – Much of the series had running editorials for Elsa Dutton, and the entirety of the series was mostly focused on her love lives and foibles. Elsa was an immature 18 yo promiscuous brat, whose character greatly diminished the series. It was torture to repetitively see her, very similar to the immature torture of watching Beth in the Yellowstone series. The world view and thinking were very much 21st century and NOT thinking what one might expect in the year 1883—this was a grave mistake. Unlike Yellowstone where there were no characters that one really felt strongly towards, Shea (Sam Elliott) and James Dutton (Tim McGraw, acting as the father of the Dutton family) were the only two characters that one gained a feeling for. The character development of everybody else left me feeling indifferent as to their ultimate fate.

The high rating of this series is a mystery to me. True, there were a few suspenseful episodes but one was left knowing that the Duttons would ultimately make it to Paradise Valley, Montana. The series could have been stronger if one saw the Duttons settling in. Perhaps that is the role for the second prequel, 1923, which will be reviewed in a few weeks.

Version 1.0.0

1923: A Yellowstone Origin Story ★

This final (I hope) series of Yellowstone chronicles the years after WW1 and the encounter with mass migrations to the west. The top stars, Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren were in good form. The remainder of the acting went from good to awful. The script writer went crazy, having 3 or 4 intertwined stories, that of Harrison and Helen at home, dealing with sheep herder rustlers, that of Indians being unjustly punished in their personal life by Catholic missionaries, and that of Spencer Dutton, the heir to be, coming back from Africa at the behest of the homestead to help solve issues with sheepherders and developers.

I’m not going to tell the plot of the story, only because it is fairly slow paced. There’s lot of unnecessary abuse of the Indians, and the narrative unjustly attributes the abuse to wicked nuns as school teachers. None of it made sense, and was devoid of historicity. It is true that the Indians were abused by the white settlers, but also true of lots of unnecessary Indian raids and abuse by the Indians. Hollywood is a terrible place to learn what actually happened in the wild west. Spenser is living his post-war years in Zanzibar, but gets a letter from mom to come home and help with the farm stresses. He seeks to return, including return with a new wife that he acquired. The boat travel was highly problematic, and by the end of season one, he is left stranded in England. He does return to Montana, but only in season 2.

Problems on the farm are predictable, with people wanting to buy his land for development, sheepherders laying claim to the land for their sheep, and Indians again stressing how the land was “stolen” from them. It became wearisome. As expected, people died, blatant criminals get away with nothing at court trials, and business remains as usual from the main Yellowstone series.

We purchased a bundle that stated that it contained all of the series, but indeed, did NOT include the second season of 1923. This is an unpardonable deception. It will cost $20 to get the last two discs, something that I have zero interest in watching. So, I will let it go. I honestly do NOT recommend this series for anybody. It is the new Hollywood at its best, trying to sell fictitious, woke party lines while refusing to acknowledge the lies and deceptions that Hollywood would love to market on the general public. I don’t buy it!

NPNF1-5


Nicene and Post-NIcene Fathers Series 1, Volume 5, edited by Philip Schaff ★★★★★

I have already worked through the first four volumes of the NPNF series 1, all of which were the writings of Augustine, volume 1 and 2 being his early works, letters, and some of his lengthier books (like the Confessions, City of God, and Enchiridion), volume 3 his anti-Manichean writings, volume 4 his anti-Donatist writings, and this now being his anti-Pelagian writings. Following this volume will be 3 volumes of the published sermons of Augustine.

The anti-Pelagian writings were written later in Augustine’s life. At the end of Augustine’s life, he wrote his Retractions, detailing where he thought he was in error earlier in life, or describing how he would have worded his position differently. The anti-Pelagian writings matured Augustine’s thought on human free will, and thus led to a retraction of a number of statements he made in his anti-Manichean writings.

The anti-Pelagian writings form the basis for the Reformation. Indeed, most of the thoughts of Luther and Calvin reflect the writings of Augustine. In regard to his anti-Pelagian writings, one will find all of the theology of the Reformation in very clear terms. Augustine often excels over Luther, Calvin, and other Reformers and laying out the doctrines of grace. Even the later synod of Dordt, which laid out the five principles of TULIP, was already described clearly by Augustine, though the doctrine of particular redemption (limited atonement) is only hinted at. Augustine hammers hard and repeatedly that grace is non-meritorious. Predestination was not first dependent on God’s foreknowledge that we would make correct choices towards God, since the ability to choose rightly is also a manifestation of grace, i.e., of God’s unmerited favor, and the ability to choose rightly in life would be impossible without grace. Faith is an unmerited gift, and perseverance is an unmerited gift. Augustine would have gone into a rage had he known of the concept later developed in Roman Catholicism of supererogatory merit. It is very clear to Augustine that we acquire no merit of any sort which earns us Brownie points in heaven (or purgatory).

Yet, Augustine is wiser than many contemporary Reformed scholars who have a trouble identifying the necessity of godly living. He emphasizes that preaching must emphasize not only doctrine but also moral instruction. There is no way that Augustine could even remotely be confused as an antinomian, as so many Reformed preachers in today’s world might be confused, as modern preachers shy away from preaching moral instruction, fearing that to do so would be be preaching law and not grace.

Modern writers will find Augustine to be overly prolix. Even Augustine will occasionally mention that he is being excessively verbose. Unfortunately, the art of systematic theology had not been developed yet for Augustine to lay out his theology in a systematic manner. Augustine is methodological in his discussions, but hammers hard from multiple approaches his arguments. This might be viewed by the modern reader as a touch tedious. If one is able to overlook Augustine’s prolixity, one will find this volume to be a sheer delight to read. If offers the best explanation possible as to what drove Luther and Calvin to their beliefs. It will also lead one to be perplexed as to how the Roman Catholic church, which in Augustine’s time was in agreement with Augustine’s teachings, could reject his theology so soundly. It was even in the last few years of Augustine’s life that a form of semi-Pelagianism was developed, that eventually degenerated by the Roman church into full blown Pelagianism, or semi-Pelagianism with a highly sophisticated scholastic gloss given to it. Thank God to Martin Luther for returning us to the real Augustine!

I enjoyed this volume of Augustine’s writing more than any of the others that I’ve read so far. For the most part, his discussions were not obscure or veiled by thinking contemporary to Augustine. Most readers in the 21st century will grasp quite easily the writings in this volume. Thus, I can highly recommend this volume to any Christian wishing to learn about how the Reformers developed their ideas; they come straight out of the writings of Augustine!

To Be A Christian

To Be A Christian: An Anglican Catechism: Approved Edition ★★★★

This is the catechism text used by the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA), and covers the basic doctrines of the faith, as you would expect both the young and old members of the church to be familiar with. Beginning with an introduction by JI Packer, the catechism discusses first that of becoming a Christian. It uses the Apostle’s Creed to explore very basic aspects of the nature of God, the nature of the Father, Christ, and the Holy Spirit. It briefly touches on the theology of the sacraments. Using the Lord’s prayer as a framework, the catechism discusses what it means to live as a Christian. The catechism then uses the 10 commandments as a framework for discussing how we are to model our lives like Christ.

The strength of this book is three-fold. First, it is theologically sound, according to both ancient Christian tradition as well as Reformed tradition. Secondly, it is a highly devotional book. It does not render a theology that is dry, but rather, theology that is living, vibrant, always conversant with God, always praising and thanking God, and always committed to love for our fellow human beings. Thirdly, the catechism is inclusive of the whole span of the Christian church, even quoting arguments from the Didache and other ancient Christian writings.

The book ends with a discussion of the ACNA process of catechizing the young in faith, and then confirming them in the faith. I wished this section to be a bit longer, but it instead provides internet links for continued study.

The catechism discussed here is very basic. Hopefully, the ACNA eventually writes a lengthier catechism, not necessarily in competition with the Westminster Confession, and not necessarily as long as the Westminster Confession, but including more doctrinal precision. One looks at the Anglican catechism side by side with the Westminster shorter catechism and Heidelberg catechism, all being elegant descriptions of our Christian beliefs. The Anglican catechism leans much stronger to the style of the Heidelberg catechism, being a more thoroughly pastoral catechism, as compared to the drier style of the shorter and longer Westminster catechisms. Although Anglicans were a major aspect of the writing of the Westminster confession and catechisms, I remain puzzled as to why the Westminster works are not more thoroughly used in the ACNA. Certainly, the 39 articles are the foundation of the Anglican faith, and to that end the 39 articles should perhaps have been discussed more thoroughly in this catechism. My presumption is that the Anglican Catechism is focused on a raw, living Christian faith, and not necessarily marketing a particular denomination or belief system. Thus, this catechism could be used by the Presbyterians, Roman Catholics, many Baptists, the Orthodox Church, and well as many other sects of Christendom without a problem. Perhaps that is its greatest strength.

NPNF1-4

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series 1, Volume 4, compiled by Philip Schaff ★★★★★

This is a continuation of my reading through the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers. In series 1 of the NPNF, volumes 1-8 are the writings of St. Augustine, with 6-8 being the sermons of Augustine. This volume (4) contains Augustine’s Anti-Manichean and Anti-Donatist writings. The next volume will be Augustine’s Anti-Pelagian writings. I’ve now spent over a year dedicated to reading Augustine, and have found it most rewarding. Specifically, Augustine provides a literary style which formed the standard style for writing through the middle ages up until today. Secondly, Augustine demonstrates skills in thinking unprecedented until now, and later utilized heavily by not only Aquinas but also Luther and Calvin. There are issues that Augustine brings up, such as the efficacy of baptism in removing original sin, which would nowadays might be labeled a heresy. Yet, it would be only the most ignorant and unthinking person that would choose to label any of Augustine’s writings and beliefs as heretical.

The Anti-Manichean writings were the subject of Augustine’s early anti-heretical writings, and for a good reason; Augustine was held in the Manichean belief system for about 9 years before he became a Christian. Thus is was very personal to him. Schaff introduces the anti-Manichean writings with a historical review of Manicheism. Mani developed his beliefs as an amalgam of Christian writings with that of old Babylon beliefs such as Zoroastrianism, as well as Gnostic beliefs. Augustine delves into the nature of virtue, the nature of “the good”, the nature of who God is and His characteristics, and the nature of Christ being both fully human and fully God. Augustine also wanders into the areas of the importance of both the Old and New Testaments, the nature of sin, as well as the issue of theodicy, why did God permit evil. One of his books on the Manichean heresy is a point by point rebuttal of the Manichean devotee Faustus, where Augustine will quote Faustus, and then offer a refutation, showing the error of the Manichean system. It is a wonderful lesson in the art of argumentation. What amazed me most about the Manichaeans is their extensive knowledge and use (actually, abuse) of Scripture. It is most akin to those of the Moroni (Mormon) or JW tradition, where Scripture is heavily quoted but in deviation to a legitimate hermeneutic of Scripture.

Interestingly, the anti-Manichean writings also received a large portion of the comments that Augustine wrote at the end of his life in his retractions. Specifically, Augustine had to temper his comments of the freedom of the will with his later anti-Pelagian writings where he countered the loss of freedom of the will. As I read into the anti-Pelagian writings (coming up next!), I might make further comment on this.

The anti-Donatist writings follow a different direction. There are two important subjects that Augustine focused on, that of the schismatic actions of the Donatists, and that related to baptism. The schismatic topic might seem to be at contention with the Protestant reformation a millennium later, but isn’t. The issue of the Reformation was the issue of a church gone bad to the core in theology and practice as well as in morals. The issue with the Donatists had nothing to do with theology, but related to the idea that one could actually forgive a tratidore (a person that was a traitor to the faith and turned over sacred Scriptures to be burned to the state) and worship in church with him. Excess zeal with purity in the church is, as Augustine argued, anti-Scriptural as well as dangerous. The issue of baptism seems to be a lengthier issue, and at first I was left in the lurch as to what Augustine actually believed, in that he argued both for and against the legitimacy of baptism in a schismatic church. The issue was that the Catholic church accepted the legitimacy of the baptism of the Donatists as well as the legitimacy of the ordination of their deacons and elders, while the Donatists demanded re-baptism of those coming out of the Catholic church. In Augustine’s final analysis, he discusses the notion of ex opera operato, that is, the action of baptism depends not so much on the faith of the baptizer as much as the baptisee, as it is essentially God performing the baptism. This seems consistent with some Protestant practices today, as well as the practice of the Roman division of the Catholic church.

As I get more into the mind of Augustine, the more I am able to appreciate him for his solid thinking, his irenic, conciliatory nature, as well as his style of argumentation. There is much prolixity in his writing, and there is much where Augustine loses me, especially with historical details. Still, the value of reading Augustine is enormous. He is us! The Reformation started through Luther and Calvin becoming familiar with the writings of Augustine, seeing that Augustine directly opposed the thinking of the Roman church at the time of the Reformation. To view Augustine as a Roman Catholic and NOT a Protestant Catholic is a grave mistake, made too often by Christians. To that, my encouragement is for Christians to become more familiar with this giant of a saint.

NPNF 1-3

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers Series 1, Volume 3, by Philip Schaff ★★★★★

This volume continues with the writings of Augustine of Hippo, as it will be through volume 8 of this series. Volume 3 includes many of Augustine’s shorter works. Specifically, it includes On the Holy Trinity, The Enchiridion, On the Catechising of the Uninstructed, Concerning the Faith of Things not Seen, On the Profit of Believing, On the Creed: A Sermon to Catechumens. Following these works, which were primarily theological and oriented toward catechumens, are the moral treatises, Including On Continence, On the Good of Marriage, Of Holy Virginity, Of the Good of Widowhood, On Lying, Against Lying, Of the Work of Monks, On Patience, and On Care to be Had for the Dead.

It would be boring to go through each work and summarize its contents, as the titles best describe what each individual book is about. Reading Augustine is always a pleasure; he is scholarly and thinks methodically. Though Augustine lived in a much different world than our own, the issues that he had to contend with remain contemporary. Thus, there is great value in reading an early church scholar. I’ll use a simple example. In his two dissertations on lying, he addresses an issue that modern evangelical scholars take to task. I call it the Corrie Ten Boom controversy. When asked whether Ten Boom’s house contained Jews, the Ten Booms lied and said there were none when there actually were. Modern evangelical moral theory notes that the Ten Booms were correct in that they performed a “lesser” sin in order to avoid a greater sin, that of the Nazi soldiers apprehending and killing the Jews. Augustine takes serious issue with this, claiming in his prolix argumentation that no lie is ever justifiable. I have always argued the position of Augustine, not realizing that he took a strong stance against lying, even to save a life. Read Augustine for his advice as to how to handle such a situation.

Sometimes Augustine gets bogged down in issues that seem to be irrelevant or unheard of in today’s world. Some segments demanded skimming through, and others demanded going quite slow to think out Augustine’s line of thought. Every treatise of his was rewarding. So, while foregoing boring details of each book, I encourage the reader to pick up Augustine and start tackling him. You will be all the richer for that.

Stockholm Syndrome Christianity

Stockholm Syndrome Christianity—Why Christian Leaders Are Failing — and What We Can Do About It, by John G. West ★★★★★

Stockholm Syndrome Christianity (SSC) addresses the issue as to why so many churches, church leaders, and church members are failing to maintain true Biblical teachings. John West is currently the vice president of the Discovery Institute in Seattle, WA. John writes in a very personal style, as though he was in a conversation with you. The book is about the 10th-grade level, so nearly any high schooler or college student should have no problem reading the book. It is not a book on the order of tackling Immanuel Kant’s Kritik der reinen Vernunft. The style of this (SSC) text is indeed similar to a previously published (and must-read book) Darwin Day in America (DDA). DDA addresses how society and its particular structures (like politics, law, education, medicine, etc) have failed us. This book (SSC) is complementary to DDA in addressing how and why the church, its leaders, and its members have failed its higher Biblical calling. The book is an encyclopedic tour de force of examples of how Christian leaders and Christian schools have failed their members.

John West draws heavily throughout the book on the writings and life of Francis Schaeffer, which also touches near and dear to my heart. I attended indubitably the most liberal college in America, Portland State University. In Paul Johnson’s words, it was a veritable hothouse of extremism (see full quote below). This was in the mid-1970s when Schaeffer was well known and debated even on far-left liberal campuses, and my liberal secular professors were quite familiar with him. In my many liberal arts papers I would often quote in my arguments words from Schaeffer. I got “A’s” on my papers back then, something that would never happen in today’s University world. Schaeffer kept me grounded in the Christian faith in the cesspool of anti-Christianity. And this is perhaps why I strongly connect with the current author. Back to the book…

SSC is written in three parts, the symptoms, the causes, and the cures for SSC. A short introduction to the book details John West’s personal account of how he saw SSC force itself onto the campus of the school where he was a professor, Seattle Pacific University. It sets the stage for why this book was written.

The symptoms section is the longest, taking up over half the book. Chapter 1 is a lament as to how traditionally orthodox churches have discarded the whole counsel of God, mostly by making irrelevant the entirety of the Old Testament, save for fuzzy, feel-good chapters like Psalm 23. Many pericopes and narratives of the Old Testament were considered outdated or worse, not true. Chapter 2 extends this wholesale trashing of the OT with the trashing of the creation narratives. The “pious” alternative to discarding Genesis 1-3 is theistic evolution (TE). TE, when formally examined, is much less of a science than is purportedly the case with intelligent design, yet snobs itself off as the intellectual stance of the elite Christian. It’s not just bad science, it’s dung science (I won’t use the more offensive word), since it lends an air of holiness to atheistic thinking, and is syncretism on par with merging Christianity with Hinduism or Satanism. Chapter 3 discusses Christians caving in on issues of sexuality. Whether it be the heterosexual promiscuity or the gay agenda, Christians have been given a counterfeit gold piece when they are told that the loving action is to love the person with the action, rather than (the Schaefferian approach) to love the person but hate the action. In the long run, it is most loving to condemn sexual perversion, yet to do that in a manner that shows genuine empathy towards the person. Chapter 4 addresses the issue of race and ethnicity in the church. To me, this seems like a simple problem to solve, yet, the modern Christian cure has become worse than the original disease. Scripture is quite plain that there is no racial division in God’s kingdom. Yet, church leaders somehow find it holier to accentuate the differences rather than the unity among various races. Chapter 5 speaks of Christians standing up for their Christian liberties; examples include the manner in which churches responded to the Covid “crisis”, or to bakers refusing to produce a gay-lesbian-themed cake when asked. West goes into detail about how Christians have insidiously lost their religious freedoms through the anti-Christian biases of the government, the courts, and the public square. Chapter 6 references the many churches and individuals who have hopped on the greased slippery slide to hell, one example being Francis Schaeffer’s son Frank who started as a militant evangelistic Christian and ended up as a functional atheist. Thankfully, West gives the story of Günter Bechly and Eta Linneman who both started at the bottom of the slippery slide and returned to the orthodox faith. The tacit lesson is that there is always hope!!!!

Section 2 addresses the causes of SSC. Chapter 7 speaks of listening to the wrong voices. Whether it be corrupt (or deluded) national media, social media, web search engines, entertainment media, or authorities (scientists, university professors, etc), you will probably need to use extreme discretion. I’ll quote an example of the use of entertainment media that is badly used. I remember being on a medical mission with my wife to a Muslim country in Africa. We had a chance to watch a movie that just came out regarding the Crusades. The movie was “The Kingdom of Heaven”, and while correctly identifying graft and corruption in the Crusaders, it painted a totally righteous image of Saladin and the Muslim invaders. The grotesque twisting of history was desperately unnerving to me, and yet sopped up by the missionaries as a warning about how evil Christians really are. They were duped!!!!! Chapter 8 discusses the desperate desire to please people, and those people are often the wrong people. Generally, you want to make your boss, your priest or minister, your advisor, or your friends happy. Sadly, this leads to a series of compromises in one’s beliefs that ultimately lead to a non-Christian Weltanschauung. Two words suffice: STRENG VERBOTEN!!!!! Chapter 9 discusses tolerating the wrong rulers. Whether it be a wrong person(s) on the board of directors of a college, or elders in a church, or government officials, a bad apple or two on a board will eventually rot out the entire system. West’s warning is most appropriately heeded, as he speaks from numerous real-life experiences both in the ecclesiastical as well as the educational system.

Finally, section 3 addresses solutions and cures. In the last three chapters of the book, Dr. West gives very sagacious, wise, perspicacious, and sound advice for students, academics, clergy, laity, and just plain old farts like myself as to how to respond. Maintaining the intent and desire to let Scripture control your hour-by-hour thinking, your Weltanschauung, and your meditative life, living true to that Scripture, and being willing to sacrifice everything including one’s life are relevant. The call to engage the culture and fight the evil… no, Satanic, secular beast that confronts us, are words we approve of but always find a challenge to do. May we pray for ourselves and our culture that we could be the olive branches that bring sanity to devils that seek not only our minds but also our souls.

So far, amazon.com has one written review, and the complaint was that West should have moved beyond social issues and just addressed Christianity. But, he totally misses West’s point! It is impossible to divorce the social from spiritual aspects of the Christian life. The reviewer’s mindset is exactly why we are in the morass we are in.

I need to mention two individuals that West brought up throughout this book as examples of SSC. They are Francis Collins and Tim Keller. I met Francis Collins once, as he was the keynote speaker at the Society of Surgical Oncology annual meeting (for which I’m now an emeritus member), which occurred somewhere around the year 2002. During his speech, he emphatically claimed that progress was going so well in cancer research that by the year 2012, we would no longer be seeing anybody dying of breast cancer. Yet, in 2022, 42,211 women in the USA died of breast cancer. The incidence of death from breast cancer has dropped somewhat, but mostly owing to earlier detection, and not from “miracle” cures. The form of dishonesty displayed by Collins breeds huge donations for research but also breeds false hopes and severe disappointments, including lawsuits against treating physicians; “If we are winning the war on cancer, then why am I dying of the disease” is asked by many patients. Collins’ less-than impeccable reputation has generated wanton ruin through his leadership at the NIH and with his involvement with groups such as the Christian Medical and Dental Associations, who held him in great acclaim. Tim Keller has also been mentioned frequently. A pastor of a past church of mine held Tim Keller in the highest esteem as a model of how Christianity should be presented and Sunday worship executed. It was Christianity lite, a Christianity stripped of everything except for empty grace grace grace. I regarded Keller as a heretic many moons ago, even before other groups began to become very uncomfortable with Keller’s stances on theological and public issues. I’m glad that West was able to provide greater substance to that. Keller’s defection was a great loss. He is now dead and cannot correct his sins, which, if he had corrected them, could have made a serious impact on global Christianity. Keller will now accompany Harry Emerson Fosdick, another New York liberal Presbyterian preacher of a century ago, into the waste bin of history, an insignificant failure who did more harm than good to the whole of Christianity.

A slight bit of humor must be added to West’s book. The patron saint of Stockholm Syndrome Christians is none other than St. Peter himself. Like SSCs today, Peter in a moment of pride and self-preservation denied the real Christ at a critical moment. Unlike SSCs today, St. Peter soon saw the error of his ways and wept bitter tears, never to ever deny his Lord and Savior again. It is not ok to have screwed up, but it is redeemable; St. Peter showed us how to do that. Soli Deo Gloria!

SUMMARY: If you are a conservative Christian with a belief in scripture being the infallible word of God, don’t even ask the question! Buy this book from Amazon and read it! It is not a Streams in the Desert devotional book. You won’t feel warm and fuzzy. The book will convict you, direct you, inspire you, inform you, and motivate you to stand firm; it will open your eyes all the wider to see the wolf in the sheep’s flock, the devil in the pulpit or pews; it will put your fight to where the battle is being fought. Mainstream conservative Christianity needs a reboot and reset and this book will do it. God bless you and God bless John West for his labors in writing this book.

Universities are the most overrated institutions of our age. Of all the calamities which have befallen the 20th century, apart from the two world wars, the expansion of higher education, in the 1950s and 1960s, was the most enduring. It is a myth that universities are nurseries of reason. They are hothouses for every kind of extremism, irrationality, intolerance and prejudice, where intellectual and social snobbery is almost purposefully instilled and where dons attempt to pass on to their students their own sins of pride. The wonder is that so many people emerge from these dens still employable, though a significant minority, as we have learned to our cost, go forth well equipped for a lifetime of public mischief-making.
Paul Johnson, To Hell with Picasso, 07SEPT1991

The Eclipse of God

The Eclipse of God: Our Nation’s Disastrous Search for a More Inclusive Deity (And What We Must Do About It) by Erwin Lutzer ★★★★★

My wife and I sat under the pulpit of Dr. Lutzer for 7 years, and appreciated his ministry at Moody Church. Now that he is retired, the books continue to flow. His writing style is very similar to his preaching style, which is always informative and interesting, and always touching on subjects most relevant to the church. This book is a perfect example of that.

I won’t summarize every chapter. The book is well-written and hits squarely on relevant topics facing Christians in the church today. Lutzer wisely notes that the current eclipse of God in the public square owes to a philosophical shift from a Christian basis to a pagan/secular basis. He chooses three philosophers as Karl Marx, Charles Darwin, and Sigmund Freud. Those are reasonable choices, though mine would have been a bit different, but the idea is correct that a change in thinking in the public square first started in the ivory towers of Academia and later drifted down to the man on the street.

Luzter spends much time talking about what I call the religion of the self. Whether it be a non-judgmental God who loves everybody and asks you to come as you are, or whether you wish to define your own ethic, it is still the glorification of the self as god. Even Christian circles have this problem. How often have churches thrown out the Old Testament as irrelevant to New Covenant morality! My only contention with Luzter is his dispensational approach to the Old Testament. I don’t find civil law irrelevant; it simply describes what God would do if he wrote a civil law for a country. Clearly, all law needs to be appended to the specific circumstances, yet the principles are still applicable.

Lutzer offers solutions, and the approach is to return to the God of the Bible. Personal lives make a difference, and the need to view the world through the lens of Scripture is made quite clear. We need to see God in all of His dimensions; He is a God of love but also a God of wrath. He is a moral God, whose morality doesn’t change. He has prescribed laws that He expects man to live by, and those laws don’t fluctuate with the winds of change in secular society.

Like all of Lutzer’s books, this one is very easy to read. It can be completed in 2-3 sessions. It strikes the heart, not just the mind. That’s why I recommend it to you.

NPNF2-14

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers Series II, Volume 14, Editor Philip Schaff, author Henry Percival ★★★★

This volume of the NPNF is essentially a republication of a book written in 1899 by Henry Percival titled “The Seven Ecumenical Councils of the Undivided Church”. The relevance of the seven “ecumenical” councils still remains debated, some people excluding the 7th council, others the 5th through 7th, and others pick through the councils for a mix of truth and error. Church history students first become acquainted with the councils through the development of doctrine, including the orthodox expression of the Trinity, the basic creeds of Christendom, the nature of Christ, etc. Yet, much of the council business was writing canons of law for the church. This canon law focused on rules for the clergy, such as, in prohibiting them to move from location to location without the permission of the bishop, or in permitting and forbidding marriage to the clergy. It also focused on disciplinary measures for various sins committed by church members. Mixed with laying out the various written documents of the councils was commentary by church scholars on the meaning and implications of the various decisions that were made by the councils. Also included were the proceedings and canon law produced by intervening synods and councils, such as the council of Trullo in AD692. At the end of the book were other canons written by Basil the Great and other significant saints of the early church.

One may wonder as to why such documents would be relevant information for the contemporary church. It should not be forgotten that this is our church, regardless of whether one in Protestant, Roman Catholic, or Orthodox. Luther certainly was correct in pointing out the church councils were NOT infallible. Much of the canon law was suited for the culture of ancient Rome and the presence of monasteries/nunneries, and do not seem to apply to today’s culture. The fundamental goal of these councils was to keep the purity of the church, which included not only holiness of living but correctness of doctrine. The contemporary church scene seems to ignore one or the other of these goals, usually with prolific explanations that fail. Antinomianism and legalism both disguise themselves handily to wreak havoc on the contemporary church, and it is refreshing to see how church fathers managed doctrinal, ethical and political decisions in the church. We have much to learn from their correct decisions as well as their mistakes. Thus, there is great value in reading the proceedings of the church councils and being aware of the fundamental nature of their proceedings. The book is not challenging to read, but greatly informative to the reader who is inquisitive about the nature of the Christian church.