
Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers Series II, Volume 14, Editor Philip Schaff, author Henry Percival ★★★★
This volume of the NPNF is essentially a republication of a book written in 1899 by Henry Percival titled “The Seven Ecumenical Councils of the Undivided Church”. The relevance of the seven “ecumenical” councils still remains debated, some people excluding the 7th council, others the 5th through 7th, and others pick through the councils for a mix of truth and error. Church history students first become acquainted with the councils through the development of doctrine, including the orthodox expression of the Trinity, the basic creeds of Christendom, the nature of Christ, etc. Yet, much of the council business was writing canons of law for the church. This canon law focused on rules for the clergy, such as, in prohibiting them to move from location to location without the permission of the bishop, or in permitting and forbidding marriage to the clergy. It also focused on disciplinary measures for various sins committed by church members. Mixed with laying out the various written documents of the councils was commentary by church scholars on the meaning and implications of the various decisions that were made by the councils. Also included were the proceedings and canon law produced by intervening synods and councils, such as the council of Trullo in AD692. At the end of the book were other canons written by Basil the Great and other significant saints of the early church.
One may wonder as to why such documents would be relevant information for the contemporary church. It should not be forgotten that this is our church, regardless of whether one in Protestant, Roman Catholic, or Orthodox. Luther certainly was correct in pointing out the church councils were NOT infallible. Much of the canon law was suited for the culture of ancient Rome and the presence of monasteries/nunneries, and do not seem to apply to today’s culture. The fundamental goal of these councils was to keep the purity of the church, which included not only holiness of living but correctness of doctrine. The contemporary church scene seems to ignore one or the other of these goals, usually with prolific explanations that fail. Antinomianism and legalism both disguise themselves handily to wreak havoc on the contemporary church, and it is refreshing to see how church fathers managed doctrinal, ethical and political decisions in the church. We have much to learn from their correct decisions as well as their mistakes. Thus, there is great value in reading the proceedings of the church councils and being aware of the fundamental nature of their proceedings. The book is not challenging to read, but greatly informative to the reader who is inquisitive about the nature of the Christian church.
This book, and this genre of literature, illustrates the parochial nature of the Roman Christianity of the West in that it emphasizes Big Religion over the church in the wilderness, is preoccupied with Greek philosophical handling of Christian doctrine, and its lack of interest in pursuing certain central questions that stand like elephants in the room of the Western church of the last two or three centuries.