Art of Public Speaking

May 21st, 2012

The Art of Public Speaking, by John Hale ★★

The Art of Public Speaking is a 12 – 1/2 hour series produced by the Teaching Company, using one of their regular lecturers, an archeologist John Hale. Hale’s style is to call up  noteworthy public speeches throughout history, showing how they were effective as public speeches. Hale selects a specific theme for each lecture, and will use a historical example followed by other historical examples reflective of the same theme to drive his point home. Much of his advice is sound and worth considering when speaking in public. My only gripe with the lecture series is that he tends to use choice speeches as soap boxes. Thus, there was the lectures on speaking in public, plus the under current of socio-philosophical ideology. I suppose Hale didn’t intend that, but it still comes out strong.

The Brothers Karamazov

May 14th, 2012

The Brothers Karamazov, ★★★★★

Having just read the Brothers Karamazov, I found this film to be quite rewarding. This is 12 – 45 minute episodes, I presume made for television. Spectacular is an understatement. The acting, the filming, and the script writing were all superb. For the script writer, reducing a lengthy novel and yet retaining the substance of the book would have been challenging and yet done flawlessly in this series. The filming is most outstanding, with the beauty of old Russia coming out with each scene. There was no hint of soap opera or cheap acting in this film, and all the actors were very convincing in their roles. Too bad they couldn’t be included in the choice for the countless Hollywood screen awards, since this film would definitely win. The subtitles often had misspellings, and grammatical errors were rampant, yet it was still easy to figure out what was being said. If one loves Dostoevski, then this movie (series) is an absolute must.

The Broadway Musical

May 6th, 2012

Great American Art: The Broadway Musical, by Bill Messenger (Teaching Company) ★★★

Bill Messenger did another Teaching Company series on the history of jazz, which I liked considerably. Though I was not terribly interested in the broadway musical (far preferring “classical” music), I thought this would be an interesting series to hear out. Messenger starts with the minstrel format, showing how it was a parody of a parody of whites imitating negroes imitating whites. This evolved eventually into ragtime, vaudeville and tin pan alley, now considered to define American music. Eventually, through the work of various greats as Irving Berlin, Jerome Kern, George Gershwin, Cole Porter, Richard Rogers and Oscar Hammerstein, the full-blown American musical emerged. Messenger follows the broadway musical all the way up to the turn of the century, showing how the genre has changed over time. He offers many musical examples, often performing himself on the piano. This is a fun and informative series, even for a person not terribly interested in Broadway.

Classics of Russian Literature

April 23rd, 2012

Classics of Russian Literature, by Irwin Weill (Teaching Company) ★★★★

I originally started to listen to this series several years ago, and found it to be somewhat boring. I made it through about 4 lectures. Recently, I devoted myself to reading Dostoevsky, and returned to this series. Having read some Russian literature, Weill began to make sense, and I found the series to be considerably more enjoyable. Weill’s attention is definitely directed toward Pushkin, Dostoevsky, and Tolstoy. He spends several lectures apiece on 20th century writers, though Solzhenitzen is given only one lecture. Many of the 20th century authors were quite appealing after Weill’s discussion, but the particular book or play was either unavailable on Amazon.com or moderately expensive, and not available for Kindle. This was a touch frustrating. In all, Weill presents an appealing presentation for delving in the Russian Literature, and an excellent summary for the person versed in the Russian author.

Crime and Punishment

April 21st, 2012

Crime and Punishment (Film) ★★★★★

This is a Russian adaption of the Dostoevsky novel by the same name, made for television, and in 8 episodes. Having just read the novel, I was quite curious about seeing how a Russian filmmaker would render the novel. This series stuck very close to the book, and minimal artistic license seemed to have been exercised. The sets and acting were for the most part superbly accomplished. There were only a few rare scenes where the acting was slightly “soap opera-ish”. Raskalnikov was totally superb in his acting. The filming was superb. On Amazon.com the only real complaints were about the subtitle translation. True, there were frequent misspelled words and grammatical errors but these were never so egregious that one could not immediately figure out what was said. For those who love Dostoevsky, this is a MUST have. Do NOT get Hollywood versions of the Dostoevsky novels, as they have been best performed in the mother land. If you must have the movie in English and don’t know how to read subtitles, then you shouldn’t be watching movies at all but going to English school. Betsy and I are now working through Brothers Karamozov and soon the Idiot, both also made for television, the Brothers Karamozov (soon to be reviewed) is equally superlative in its production and accuracy to the novel. Nothing is better than reading the novels themselves, as Dostoevsky’s writing style and the minor nuances of his text could never completely put on film. I would highly recommend reading these Dostoevsky novels before ever watching the films.

 

Sermons on Romans

April 21st, 2012

Sermons on Romans, DM Lloyd-Jones ★★★★

Lloyd Jones would spend Friday evenings at church slowly working through the book of Romans in an expository fashion. This took him a number of years to accomplish, preaching a total of 353 sermons in the series. This makes for a total of 290 hours and 20 minutes of sermon. Lloyd Jones numbers among the great preachers of all time, preaching in a conservative fashion from the Reformed perspective. In most cases he is fairly conventional, though at times he does bring objections to the most eminent Reformed theologians. In particular, his perspective on Romans 7 is unique, in that he holds this chapter as speaking of the non-converted sinner under conviction of sin. So, it is neither the non-converted person you would find on the street, nor the converted. His perspective on what Paul meant by “Israel” and the “Jew” are also somewhat at odds with convention, though he is quite firmly not a British-Israelite. Altogether, it is solid teaching and very informative. These sermons were listened to by me over the last several years while I was riding the bicycle on the trainer in the garage. As you might detect, I worked out a lot.

The Emerald Forest

April 15th, 2012

The Emerald Forest ★

This movie is supposedly based on a true story and is presented by various eco-environmental groups as a moving and compelling argument to save the rain forests. Because of its high reviews on Amazon.com, I decided it demanded a re-watch, having seen it many years ago. The story is quite simple. A young engineer in charge of building a dam in the Amazon basin is out with his family near the construction site, when the young (about 7 year old) son is taken captive by a tribe which was isolated from civilization. This boy grows up in that tribe and becomes a leader. Ten years later, the father eventually finds his son, but is caught in the cross-fire of inter-tribal warfare. The raiding tribe has made contact with civilization and has procured machine guns, and thus have hauled off the young ladies of the tribe to be prostitutes. Meanwhile, son  weds a young tribal lady, only to find her as a captive of the warring tribe. Using his now alienated father for assistance, the girls are rescued and son decides to stay primitive rather than go back to his roots. Upset with the dam that father has built, son calls on the frogs to make it rain, and a heavy rain coupled with new sympathies of father, father dynamites the dam and the progress of man is halted.

While this movie is reportedly based on a true story, it is quite clear that much of the events are fictitious. Hollywood needed to make a statement, and didn’t seem to be concerned about truth. Thus, when they made statements at the end lamenting the loss of the primitive savage and rain forest, they give numbers that any credible thinker would question. The filmography of the movie was okay, but not great. It is clear that the film crew had three or four locations at most. But, what about the movie? Why would it get such a low rating from me? This movie would be best thought of as a merger of Al Gore in Inconvenient Truth and Brooke Shields in The Blue Lagoon, with a story line written by Margaret Mead. The script writer had tried to develop the innocent savage theme of Margaret Mead, perhaps not realizing that most of what Margaret Mead wrote about her adventures to the South Pacific were a total fiction, and should have been condemned to the genre of the Harlequin Romances rather than credible science. Unfortunately, Mead was devoured by the non-critical ideologues of academia and was sold as an argument against civilization and for the peace-loving, amoral primitive man, not driven by money, greed or passions. This movie makes light of the alternate belief structure of the primitive Amazonian. They are able to call on the frogs to make rain, without explanation as to how they might have the power to do this.This leads to a beautiful non-sequitor, in which we should not destroy rain forest because if we were sensitive to “Mother Earth”, we could pray to frogs who would help us destroy the advance of modern technology. The movie leaves out that these primitives live in constant fear of the spirit world, which is an ugly taskmaster, and not the benevolent loving God of the Judeo-Christian faith. A favorite scene of the movie was the swimming hole, where the naked young Amazonian men would meet the equally naked young Amazonian women. It was a mixture of the opening scenes from Margaret Mead’s “Coming of Age in Samoa” and various scenes from the Blue Lagoon–entirely fictitious and entirely wishful for free-love without bounds or constraints or defined morality. If only the scriptwriters could actually live in one of these communities for a while to see that the female always takes a seriously subservient mode to the man. But, academic fictions contribute to even more fictions, and the most gullible among us, the Academics, sell this trash to us without any thought as to its truth content.

The movie poorly asks the question as to which culture or civilization is best. Is it the primitive native of the rainforest, or is it the so-called civilized man? The referential framework for making this judgement in the movie is the question of who treats the earth the best, and clearly, the primitive native wins out. But, that is not really a fair question, since it is not the primitive native making this assertion, but rather, it is the civilized man using the technology and knowledge that is despised to fight technology and “knowledge”. It suggests that there is a primitive knowledge that is lost (note the very last statement of the movie!), but the movie makes clear that what is lost is a “knowledge” of the spirit world, a world that most modern man choses to believe does not exist, but those that are of a Christian heritage would ascribe to the demonic world whose torments are best to be delivered from.

Regarding the concern that anthropologists have to preserve primitive cultures, that is a total hypocrisy, since they wish to have access to these cultures, but nobody else. After all, if a primitive culture exists that you don’t know exists, it doesn’t matter whether or not they exist. Yet, the obsession with preserving primitive culture as a reference point for where modern culture has gone wrong fails. Margaret Mead used several isolated cultures in Samoa and New Guineas to build an argument for feminism and sexual liberation, an argument that is specious at best by denying what we see in man every day as a depraved person. We build utopian or mythical worlds to escape what we see is evil in our own culture, yet fail to grasp that we are chasing nothing but a fantastical creation of our mind devoid of reality.

In conclusion, the movie is inconsistent and ambiguous enough to make any decisions regarding either cultural judgments or environmental concerns. The movie offers no greater reference point for making any further judgements, either regarding morality or culture. Thus, one must turn elsewhere for these decisions. It is no wonder that The Emerald Forest has not had a lasting impact, and no wonder that the environmental movement and anthropology comes across as a touch insincere.

The World’s Greatest Structures

April 14th, 2012

Understanding the World’s Greatest Structures: Science and Innovation from Antiquity to Modernity, by Stephen Ressler (Teaching Company) ★★★★

This is a fascinating tour of structures mostly built within the last 100-200 years throughout the world, with an orientation around first bridges, and then buildings. Ressler is a civil engineer, and so the orientation of the course was entirely around the design and mechanical features of bridges and buildings that have allowed for their great length or height. It is a most fascinating story of design failures, learning curves, and serendipitous success.  Ressler is reasonably non-technical, though I wish he would have included at least one lecture on the real mathematics of design–not all of us are science dummies. Ressler has an interesting style of teaching, but most effective. His personality struck both Betsy and myself as a cross between a close friend R.B. and Mr. Know-it-All Bullwinkle Moose. Both Betsy and I enjoyed this lecture set tremendously both because of the topic and the teacher, and recommend it to our friends.

Schubert Complete Songs

April 13th, 2012

Schubert: The Complete Songs, with Graham Johnson ★★★★★

This is a fairly lengthy work of 40 CDs representing the complete songs of Franz Schubert. The common aspect of the Hyperion production is the pianist, Graham Johnson. The vocalists are a broad assortment, many quite well known names, but all being superb in their delivery. The recordings are also completely top-notch. The length makes this a little challenging to listen to all at once, and this is my second time straight through. The brilliance of Schubert as a song writer is reflected strongly in this production. The song cycles, especially Schwanengesang, are superlative. The entire cost of this set is a royal bargain, worth any classical collection.

Zemlinsky Choral Works

April 13th, 2012

Zemlinsky: Complete Choral Works and Orchestral Songs, conducted by James Conlon with the Kölner Philharmoniker ★★★★

Zemlinksy was an Viennese contemporary with Mahler, Strauss, and Schoenberg, and acquainted with all of those. Being mixed Jewish, Muslim and Catholic, he eventually emigrated to NY City in 1938. Unfortunately, his life was always spent in the shadow of his better known contemporaries. His music resembles a merger of Mahler and Strauss. The EMI performance here is apparently a reissue, as EMI seems to be the only record company that has produced Zemlinsky’s works in depth. He is a worthy composer and most of his works do not deserve the obscurity that they have received. This album will definitely be enjoyed by those who enjoy choral works from the turn of the 20th century Viennese genre.

Trumpet Concertos – Eklund

April 2nd, 2012

Trumpet Concertos by Haydn, Hummel, Neruda, and Weber, by Niklas Eklund ★★★★★

These are four  baroque and classical trumpet concertos, with only the piece by Dedrich Weber being written for a valved trumpet. These are played by Eklun on a modern valved trumpet. Eklund has a few legendary trumpeters to compete with, the most recent being the masterful performances of Wynton Marsalis. Yet, Eklund holds his own, have a fluid, very non-brassy tone to his instrument that is most pleasurable to listen to. To put it bluntly, Eklund’s performance is quite stupendous. Naxos offers very affordable recordings, and these are most worthy of a classical collection.

 

The Cathedral

April 2nd, 2012

The Cathedral, by Dr. William Cook (Teaching Company Series) ★★★★

This is a series of 24 1/2 hour lectures offered by the Teaching Company in the video format only. Cook provides an informative 24 sessions, progressing from the Roman to Romanesque to Gothic to modern architecture of the cathedral. Cook’s main focus was on the superficial architectural design, and on the artwork, consisting of the design work, statues, and stained glass seen throughout European cathedrals. Him greatest emphasis was on the Gothic cathedrals of France, and he chooses to elaborate on the greatest of the French cathedrals, leaving the cathedrals of England, Germany, Spain, and eastern Europe only superficial touches. Though I find that he spends too much time elaborating on cathedral art, he is quite effective at generating an interest in paying more attention to portals and stain glass. I wish he would have spoken more about the general structure of the cathedral,  rather than limiting the interest solely to the main chapel. He also spent very little time elaborating the means of cathedral design and construction. The Teaching Company series on Understanding the World’s Greatest Structures seems to complement well this course, and Betsy and I are currently watching that series.

The 30 Greatest Orchestral Works

March 25th, 2012

The 30 Greatest Orchestral Works, by Robert Greenberg (The Teaching Company Audio) ★★★★

Greeenberg reviews thirty of the greatest pieces in the orchestral repertoire from Bach to Shostakovich. Each piece includes a biographical review of the composer, the nature of the composition, the compositional style, and then what makes it great. It is a whirlwind tour that covers the most relevant pieces. The last lecture on the ones that got away leaves one feeling that probably far more than thirty pieces still could have been included. Greenberg ends with a statement about how we need to support modern composers by listening to their music, noting that the very odd compositional years of the 80′s are long gone, and that composers are again writing quite sensible pieces. Perhaps the best thing Greenberg  could do is to do a series on contemporary classical music, giving us an argument as to why we should listen to modern pieces,  showing us what’s out there, and showing us why those pieces make them worthy of our attention.

Experiencing Hubble

March 19th, 2012

Experiencing Hubble: Understanding the Greatest Images of the Universe, by David Meyer ★★★★

This brief Teaching Company series of 12 lectures takes one on a tour some of the most impressive images taken by the Hubble Space Telescope. In this series, David Meyer, one of the managing astronomers for the telescope, provides the scientific insights and explanations as to the significance of the Hubble images. Thus, they are far more than just beautiful photographs. Meyer explains first the politics of the Hubble Telescope, and how one gets a chance as an astronomer to use this telescope. He explains how the Hubble has shown certain things such as the formation of stars, the colliding of galaxies, and even the most distant reaches of the universe. Meyers maintains a teaching level that is not too complicated, such that most could follow what he has to say, and yet maintain ones interest. In conjunction with other astronomy courses, this course serves as a fitting introduction into a small category of astronomy, that of the advances which the Hubble telescope has provided to us.

 

Junction Boys

March 13th, 2012

 

The Junction Boys, starring Tom Berenger ★★★★

This movie was recommended to me by a doctor friend of mine, who was one of the star players for one of the winning seasons of the LSU football team. This movie presents a brief episode in the life of coach Bear Bryant, one of the winningest coaches of all time. Bear already had many successful seasons with Kentucky, and was recruited to coach the Texas A&M team. He started by forming a 10 day boot camp for the players at a place just outside of Junction, Texas. During the next 10 days, he thoughtlessly drove many players to total despair, having 2/3 of the team walk out on him. He did some exceedingly foolish things, such as deprive the players of any fluid replacement in spite of 114 degree Texas heat, causing some star players to collapse of heat stroke and exhaustion. Players remained in practice with acute lumbar fractures and other serious injuries. The final toll was his only loosing season of 1-9 wins-losses. The redemption of the movie was a brief 5 minute scene of the Junction Boy reunion at the practice camp, where he apologized for his total stupidity. The players who stuck with Bear had some sense that they benefited from this hell-hole experience and appreciated their time with coach Bryant. This is akin to kidnapped captives or abused children having a psychological affinity to their oppressor — in some ways it is a sick sort of devotion to an equally sick person. Sadly, even in the year that the Junction Boys camp took place, it was quite well known that fluid replacement was imperative for best performance in heat, and that over-practice can be as harmful as no practice at all. For coach Bryant to learn that at the cost of many young aspiring football players is nothing but a shame. There was a beautiful quote in the movie, when coach Bryant was explaining to a parent whose son was thrown off the team because he had a heat stroke that football was “war”, the parent, who was missing his left arm and spent two years with bilateral hip fractures and recently lost arm in a Japanese prison camp, responded “You don’t need to tell me what war is like, as I know it all too well. Football is not war, football is a sport” (rough quote as I remember it). This quote summarizes the theme that makes the movie worth watching. It is a good movie, very well done, but also a reminder for sports players to never forget that their sport is nothing but a sport.

Espionage and Covert Operations

March 8th, 2012

Espionage and Covert Operations (Teaching Company), by Vejas Liulevicius ★★★★

This is an enjoyable set of 14 – 1/2 hour lectures on the history of spying from earliest records until the year 2011. There is much to like about these lectures. Liulevicius is quite entertaining as a speaker, and covers the topic of spying fairly broadly, from episodes of international intrigue, to states spying on their own citizens, and ending the series offers a solemn warning about care with the state spying on you. What I find intriguing is how often spy craft gets it wrong, often leading to worse consequences than if there were no spies, a recent example being intelligence evidence for weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. The few spying successes were found in WWII with the code-breaking of the German and Japanese communication signals. Our eagerness to maintain an international spy network has been troubled by numerous moles, leading to probably more deaths from spy activity than lives saved. Interestingly, misinformation given to spies has been quite effective at creating international pandemonium, and when international news alleges certain things, a strong aura of disbelief is healthy. I had wished that Liulevicius had spent more time talking about actual spy craft, perhaps even just a lecture on the nature of actually being a spy. One lecture did delve into spies in the literature and movies, and interestingly, many of these books, such as the books by Ian Fleming and LeCarre, were written by ex-spies. So, enjoy these at your own risk.

Bach: h-moll Messe

February 27th, 2012

This review covers four different video recorded performances of Bach’s b-minor mass. The first is from the Thomaskirche in Leipzig with Blomstedt conducting, then second from Neubuern with Guttenberg conducting, the third from München with Karl Richter conducting and the fourth from the Thomaskirche again with cantor Billing and a Jungenchor. Each performance is quite different and it would do an injustice to Bach’s h-moll messe to only see one performance. But first, I must say a summary about the mass itself. It was written by Johann Sebastian Bach during his Leipzig years when he was Cantor of the Thomaskirche. This was during the most mature phase of Bach’s composing years, and this piece was written by Bach without much expectation that it would ever be performed in his lifetime. Indeed, this piece also represents the pinnacle of all music of all times, written by the greatest composer to ever have lived. I look forward to the days in glory when Bach is again writing music, this time in a glorified state, and possibly with King David, the sweet musician, at his right hand providing words and suggestions for the melody.  The h-moll Messe is a demonstration of how perfectly words and music could go together — nobody did it better than Bach. The music of Bach always fits the words, and fits them perfectly. Though the church I attend emphasizes the importance of having the tune match the words, I think of how often they fail. Two examples follow. The first is O The Deep, Deep Love of Jesus, sung in a minor key to a Jewish dance rhythm. Bach would have been horrified. The second is Rock of Ages, sung to the New City tune. The New City tune itself is catchy, but absolutely terrible in its compositional development, in that the first phrase is repeated with slight variations all the way to the end without progression or true development, and it simply doesn’t fit the words of Rock of Ages, wording that needs a solid tune, not a fancy flighty tune. The words that Bach uses are words that are so correct and true that they will again be sung in heaven. The music has a level of complexity and genius that no composer to date has even come close to matching, but bringing shear terror to the performer. It is sad that so many church musicians have a culturally closed their ear to the music of Bach since his compositions were all in either German or Latin, and never in English. The modern English and American church composers have no contest when placed against the least known or performed works of Bach. It’s a pity that we have to put up with the contemporary rubbish of Rutter, Townend, Getty, and others. Truly, I find it impossible to maintain a dry eye once a well-done Bach performance begins, as it is just too beautiful to contain the emotion. There are few other composers that can so overwhelmingly move a person. I pray that other church musicians will catch the Mendelssohn discovery that Bach can be imitated but never surpassed.

Bach’s B-minor Mass, Herbert Blomstedt conducting Gewandhausorchester und Gewandhauskammerchor ★★★★★

This is an all-adult performance (no child-musicians) on modern instruments. It is held in the choir loft of the Thomaskirche, facing the altar and grave of JS Bach. Having been in that church a number of times, I’m not sure how they fit everybody in. The acoustics were superb, and performance was most delightful. Blomstedt is a very engaging conductor. He tends to manifest a very friendly face to the musicians, frequently smiling and interacting with the musicians with his eyes and hands, while singing along with the music. The musicians seem to respond in kind to him, maintaining a dynamic spirit that promotes the spirit of the piece. As an example, when the credo speaks of the crucifixion and burial of Christ, the music is quite solemn and hushed. This immediately transforms into a most joyous explosion of the trumpets, orchestra and musicians when singing of Christ rising from the grave, and Blomstedt makes it happen perfectly. This performance is not with a large choir and orchestra, but reflects perfectly the spirit of Bach in Bach’s home. I’m sure that Bach gave a smile in the grave.

B minor mass, performed by the Neubeuern Choral Society, Enoch zu Guttenberg conducting ★★★★

This is a difficult piece to critic. There is so much good and bad about it. The performance itself was very good. The singers were very well organized. The orchestra and soloists performed flawlessly. Guttenberg conducted with intense spirit. I was surprised at how young many of the singers and musicians were. Though there were a few older people in the performance, it was mostly younger people. The choir itself was much larger than the orchestra and placed behind the orchestra, which was an average size for a Bach performance. The entire production occurred in a small narrow church, so that it seemed that the distance between the conductor and last row of the choir was quite great.

Things that bothered me were several. The recording itself did not do justice to the performance, coming across as a bit flat. You really didn’t have the feel like you were recording in a church. The conductor recently appeared to have left upper extremity surgery, and his arm was in a sling and cast, making it very distractive. The biggest flaw of the recording was the camerawork, which was constantly straying to painting and fixtures on the wall of the church. It was quite annoying. The camerawork and audio recording gets a 1 star for failing to make you feel present at a performance. Other than that, it is a worthy recording to have in ones collection.

Bach Messe in H-moll with Janowitz, Topper, Laubenthal and Prey, Conducted by Karl Richter, Münchener Bach Chor ★★★★

I have always liked Karl Richter, and his renditions of many of the Bach cantatas are absolutely first class. Interestingly, this performance, held in a large baroque styled church in 1969, seemed to be a bit flat. Except for Hermann Prey, none of the soloists seemed really moved by what they were singing, and the entire performance limped. The quality of performance was exemplary, and the performance occurred without a flaw. Even the cameraman seemed to be bored, with him rarely holding onto the performers, but focusing on the ceiling or drifting around the walls and lattice ornaments of the church. It would have been more enjoyable to simply listen to the performance, and not watch it on the DVD.

Bach h-moll Messe with Thomanerchor Leipzig, Cantor George Biller and Gewandhousorchester Leipzig ★★★

This performance had a number of distinct differences from the performances above. The choir was a boy’s choir. The alto solo was a male alto. There were added pieces in latin, some of which were sung by the cantor. The performance was quite decent, and stupendous for the boys. My problems with this production were several. First, I really don’t like boy’s choirs, except as a curiosity. Second, I find male altos to be especially harsh on the ear, even though this alto was not bad at all. Thirdly, the camera seemed to find particular fascination with the newly remodeled roof of the Thomaskirche. A nice touch was the camera panning in on Bach’s grave at the very beginning and very end of the performance.  All things considered, it was a rather impressive performance for the Knabenchor. This was a nice change from the typical performance of the B-Minor mass.

 

Keeping Score – Shostakovich

February 19th, 2012

Keeping Score – Shostakovich Symphony #5 with Michael Tilson Thomas and the San Francisco Symphony ★★★★

Besides Bach, Shostakovich is one of the truly great composers to ever have lived. His was a life like Bach’s that was filled with tormentors and critics that had no appreciation for the greatness of the person. This film is one of the “Keeping Score” series where the director of the San Francisco Symphony engages in an educational forum that briefly describes the life of Shostakovich, while doing a quick analysis of the 5th symphony. It is quite educational, and even if one doesn’t like Shostakovich, they would find this film to be  informative. The DVD actually consists of two parts, the first being an analysis of the piece, and the second  being a live performance in London of the 5th symphony. Together they help to give a person a starting understanding of person of Shostakovich and the style of his compositions. The film is definitely intended for musical beginners, though anybody will get value out of seeing Thomas’ interpretation one of the great symphonies of all time, Shostakovich’s fifth.

Conagher

February 18th, 2012

Conagher, starring Sam Elliott, based on a book by Louis L’Amour ★★★★★

Betsy and I have watched a number of westerns recently, including True Grit (3 stars), High Noon (4 stars), Once Upon a Time in the West (1 star), Magnificent Seven (2 stars), and the Wild Bunch (1 star).  These films will not be reviewed by me. Several (the 1 star films) were so bad we could barely endure the entire films. Even True Grit had terrible acting, and no real moral punch to it. Sorry, but John Wayne is not the best cowboy. Conagher was completely different. Sam Elliott was a soft spoken, but very well acted cowboy who minds his own business, and keeps his promises even at the risk of his life. This gets him in jeopardy with a band of cattle rustlers after the cattle Conagher is guarding. Meanwhile, a young family moves into a lone house not far removed from Conagher, but the husband perishes in an attempt to get cattle for starting a ranch. Eventually Conagher endears himself to the husbandless/fatherless family, and …, well, watch the movie. This movie was likable because it did not create a fictional west. There were bad guys and good guys. The indians were not painted as tree hugging earth loving pacifists, but for the feared savages that settlers in real life knew them to be. Conagher did not have the miraculous art of killing 12 people with 8 bullets while shooting from the hip. He mostly behaved like a normal person would and should behave. The filming was nice with superb scenes. No “in your face” shots, or prolonged emotional drama. The action was a bit slow, but that helped paint the realism of the film. All together, this made a true-to-life but suspenseful drama, well worth watching.

History of the United States

February 12th, 2012

History of the United States (Teaching Company Series), by Allen Guelzo, Gary Gallagher, and Patrick Allitt ★★★★

It is impossible in the course of 84 – 1/2 hour lectures to give a detailed history of the United States. Yet, Guelzo, Gallagher and Allitt do a fine job of reviewing the high points of the American experience. Starting from its discovery by the Europeans and settlement, all the way to early George W. Bush, these three lectures provide a delightful summary of the last few hundred years of the United States. It is entertaining, and gives their perspective, typically respectfully, of their view of the American experiment. I don’t always agree with their analysis and conclusions, but that doesn’t distract from their ability to give a fairly balanced discussion of America throughout the years. The most contemporary discussions on matters such as the new world order, environmentalism, women’s rights movements, etc. did not deserve full 1/2 hour lectures, but are too charged of topics to glance over briefly. All in all, the lecture series works well as all the instructors are masters at the art of teaching.

 

Clint Eastwood Movie Reviews #1

January 31st, 2012

You may wonder what films we’ve been watching the last month. I got the Clint Eastwood collection for Christmas, and with some added additional Eastwood films (such as the No Name Spaghetti Westerns), worked through most of the filmography of Clint Eastwood. Clint primarily portrayed two characters, the first being the silent cowboy who shows up from nowhere and disappears into the sunset. In the meantime, he could shoot a handgun with precise accuracy and immense speed, thus terminating all opponents. His western films would be labeled revisionist, in that the good guys were the indians and the outlaws, and the bad guys were the government officials. Older westerns would have a moral theme, but revisionist westerns remain morally ambiguous. Thus, John Wayne would typically refuse to star in Eastwood’s films as an objection to the revisionist genre (although John Wayne rarely portrayed a morally pure character himself).

The other character of Clint is the quiet cop or detective who bucks authority, somehow seems to have the criminal figured out beforehand, usually has incompetent bosses and political figures telling him what to do, and Clint eventually solving the issue by working around the authority, usually terminating the criminals.

A lesser character of Clint seen is later years is the cranky old man, who knows better, but has to put up with the younger crowd. Such movies as Million Dollar Man and Gran Torino fit this category. Clint often has religious scenes, usually Catholic, many of them with him contending with the priest, or going against the advice of the priest. In a very strong way, Eastwood suggests that being mister tough guy and standing up for yourself is the most important thing in life. All of his movies, regardless of his role, portray this character and theme. Sadly, as good as many of Clint’s films are, they all fail to offer any suggestion of a higher morality or virtue. It is just another form of Nietzsche’s Übermensch. Hitler would have loved Clint’s films.

I find that except for the spaghetti westerns and Dirty Harry series, Clint’s early films are generally quite bad. There is a significant improvement in the quality of his later films, though even then a moderate number are not worth watching a second time.

These films are reviewed mostly in the order in which they were watched, which was in alphabetical order. The chronological order would have been a more natural way to watch his films, but the alphabetical order allowed for a better mix-up of Clint’s films. Because of the length of this post, it is given in three sections.

 

Absolute Power ★★★★★

This is one of Eastwood’s later films, and is a mishmash of the Nixon scandal mixed with the scandals of the Clinton administration.  The president is observed by a break-in artist (Clint Eastwood) in a rape/murder, which is covered up by the secret service. Realizing that he (Clint) cannot go to the police to report the crime, he then devises the means of bringing down the president. The action is fast and suspenseful, and the plot is unpredictable but a touch realistic.

 

Any Which Way You Can ★

Clint Eastwood is a retired prize fighter, now pursued by the syndicate to do one last fight, against his own personal will. He, his orangutan, and girl friend eventually resolve matters. This is supposed to be a comedy, but we didn’t find it to be very funny, and really didn’t have any significant plot or objective.

 

Bird ★

Clint Eastwood does not star in this film. It is supposed to be a biographical sketch of Charlie Parker, one of the great Jazz saxophonists of the past. The action is very slow moving, and is constantly taking chronological jumps as Charlie relives his past before committing suicide. Betsy and I were unable to endure more than 40 minutes of this film.

 

Blood Work ★★★★

Clint Eastwood as aging FBI officer has a massive heart attack while chasing a man and requires a heart transplant. He eventually learns that the heart came from a murder victim, whose sister is now asking Clint to solve the case. The plot is great with multiple unexpected turns until the case is solved.

 

Bridges of Madison County ★★

The Red Green Show once commented that the Bridges of Madison County failed as a movie since nobody was killed, and none of the bridges were blown up. There is truth to that statement. The only reason this movie received two stars is that the acting by both Clint Eastwood and Meryl Streep was superb. Two middle aged people are going through the remains of their just-deceased mother, and discover that many years ago she had an affair. This affair is the main body of film, which occurred when a photographer (Clint) stops at a farmhouse asking directions to a bridge. The remainder of the family is off to the Illinois State Fair, and so she then spends the next four days in an increasing relation with him and they separate for good. Many parts of the film go so slow that we had to fast forward them. It was torture to watch this film. The message of the film unavoidably states that anything is okay as long as nobody finds out. The higher values of truth and purity are forgotten.  This is not a film worth watching.

 

Bronco Billy ★★

Clint Eastwood stars in Bronco Billy, the ex-convict who is now head of a roving circus cowboy show. It’s a rather lame film, with various characters getting in trouble with themselves and the law, mixed in with a somewhat spastic rich lady whose husband runs off on her, and she is left to live with the low lives of the circus until she realizes that they have something she doesn’t have with her wealth.

 

Changeling ★★★★★

This is the last film Clint Eastwood produced, and he does not star in the film. Supposedly, this film is based off of a true event. Angela Jolie is a single mother with a 9 yo son in 1928 Los Angeles. The son is kidnapped, leading Angela to seek for the child using the LAPD. A child is produced, which is very clearly not the son, even though the LAPD insists that it is. When Angela pushes the issue, she is committed to an insane asylum. Through the work of a Presbyterian pastor who was fighting corruption in the police system, she is released, and eventually a reasonable clue is found as to what happened to her son. This movie is unusual for Clint Eastwood, in that Eastwood’s characters are usually police that take the law in their own hands since the city and courts are incapable of that function. The roles are here reversed, where the police are found to be too aggressive. The common theme in Clint’s movies is the ultimate corruption in government, and this point is well made in this movie. It is only wishful thinking to imagine that matters aren’t any better nowadays – just different.

 

City Heat ★★

Burt Reynolds is a private detective, and Clint a police lieutenant, Clint rescuing Burt from various entanglements of the syndicate, in a film set within big city gangster town of the prohibition 20’s. Clint definitely proves a better actor than Burt in this otherwise very mediocre film.

 

Coogan’s Bluff ★★

Clint Eastwood is an Arizona cop sent to NY to return a criminal that he caught (how he got to NY wasn’t explained) to bring back to Arizona for trial. In the process, the NY police give him great grief, the criminal gets away, and Clint goes on a lengthy manhunt process independent of the NY detective agency. Clint tends to sexually attack every female that comes into his presence, which I guess makes him cool.

 

Beguiled ★★

Clint Eastwood is now a wounded union soldier, who ends up in a private girls school at the end of the civil war. The head mistress ends up keeping him and nursing him back to health, all the while preparing him to be picked up by confederate soldiers to be hauled off to prison to die. Meanwhile, he falls in love with a number of the girls in the school, and is caught making love to one of the older students. This leads to a series of tragedies since he was caught, ultimately leading to his demise. Poor Clint.

 

Dead Pool ★★★★★

Clint stars in the last of the Dirty Harry series, and this film is at his mature best. Lists of celebrities were published with wagers as to the greatest number of people who would be dead in a given span of time. Started as an innocent game, it turned bad when it was realized that somebody was individually picking off characters on the list. Dirty Harry happens to be on the list, and proceeds to eventually find the killer and terminate him. A second story line is Clint having to contend with the press, including an obnoxious female.

 

Dirty Harry ★★★★★

This is the first Dirty Harry film with Clint Eastwood. A sniper if knocking off people in the city of San Francisco, with a monetary ransom to have the killing stopped.  The killer and Clint interact, and then is released on legal technicalities. The killer then frames Clint for police brutality. Eventually the killer hijacks a school bus with children, only to be rescued by the ever-resourceful Dirty Harry.

Clint Eastwood #2

January 31st, 2012

Eiger Sanction ★★★★

Eiger Sanction could have done better on the plot, with Clint acting as a retired hitman, called back into duty to the service of his country to knock off several killers involved in an international spy ring. Strangely, Clint needs to perform this action while climbing the north face of the Eiger. Clint eventually discovers that he was deceived but comes out in the best. The most spectacular part of this film with the video of the Eiger climb, which unfortunately led to the death of a climber assisting in the filming.

 

Enforcer ★★★★

This is the third Dirty film. Dirty Harry is teamed up with a female that he considers incompetent in an effort by the city to make the police force more diverse. This episode, they have to fight a militant revolutionary gang, that leads them all over the city and even out to Alcatraz, Clint also having to do battle with the SF mayor, until he is required to rescue him from the gang.

 

Escape from Alcatraz ★★★★★

One of Clint’s better films, illustrating a breakout from Alcatraz. The head jailor is in best form, as Patrick McGoohan (Secret Agent/The Prisoner). The acting is superb, the story line is superb, the description of the very inhuman life in prison is notable, and you end up cheering for the prisoners that got away.

 

Every Which Way But Loose ★

This film was absolutely awful. It is a prequel/sequel to Any Which Way You Can, with Clint acting as a prize street fighter. The entire film was nothing but casual sex (not seen visually), bad language, beer drinking, indiscriminate violence, but worse of all, country-western music. Clint falls in love with a country western singer who doesn’t let on that she has no interest in him, until he’s chased her all over the country. A sick motorcycle gang, renegade policeman, and others are after Clint. Ho-hum.

 

Few Dollars More ★★★★

Clint Eastwood starred in a number of spaghetti westerns in the late 1960’s, this being one of them, and also included in the “Man with No Name” trilogy, which includes “The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly”, and “Fist full of Dollars”. Here he teams up with Van Cleef as bounty hunters after the big nasty gang located along the border of the US and Mexico. Van Cleef has some awesome acting very much the equal of Clint, and a young Klaus Kinski shows up in this movie. The biggest winner in the Trilogy is the music of Ennio Morricone, who deserves an Oscar of his own for the genius of the accompanying music.

 

Firefox ★★★

Clint is a retired fighter pilot jock, called back from retirement to assist in the theft of a highly secretive high-tech stealth airplane of the Soviets (pre-1990). The graphics are good, the plot is suspenseful, the action is quite exciting, the acting is somewhat mediocre, and the reality of the plot is marginal, making the film a three-star. Though Clint does a better “top-gun” than Tom Cruise, between playing secret agent man, top-gun, and himself, he fails.

 

Fistful of Dollars ★★★★

Another of the spaghetti westerns, and the first of the No Name trilogy with music by Morricone.   Clint is a Whitey that rides into town along the Mexican border to find a feud between two clans is leading to the death of the town. By pitting the clans against each other, he manages to eliminate both clans. There is a wonderful mix of suspense and humor in this movie that makes up for an otherwise short story line.

 

Gauntlet ★★★★

Clint is a policeman in Phoenix sent to go up to Las Vegas in order to pick up a criminal to be delivered for testimony in court back in Phoenix. It ends up that both the police chief in Phoenix and the mob set him and his prisoner (Sondra Locke) up to be eliminated. There is much shooting and tough guy action as Clint and Sondra work their way back to Phoenix to establish real justice with the police chief. Much of the story line is not terribly believable, such as a bus driving through many streets of firearm, and Clint on a motorcycle escaping by bare centimeters firing from a sharpshooter in a helicoptor. But, things get blown up, so the movie is worth watching.

 

Good, Bad, and the Ugly ★★★★★

This is one of Eastwood’s best films, a spaghetti western and last of the “Man with no Name” trilogy, staged during the time of the civil war, where three gents, one being Clint, and another Van Cleef, are in search of buried gold. The tales of finding the clues to the location of the gold, the interactions of “the good, the bad, and the ugly” characters create suspense in a film that is entertaining even after watching a number of times.

 

Gran Torino ★★★★★

Betsy and I had low hopes at the start of this movie, thinking it was going to be just another Clint Eastwood “adoration of the fictitious self” movies. It looked like he was going to racing cars, or something of that sort. It instead turned out to be something quite other. Clint is a just widowed old man who had a heroic war past, but now sits on his porch drinking beer and smoking cigarettes and watching the neighborhood being taken over by foreigners. The next door neighbors are Hmong people. Slowly, he gets to know them, and eventually comes to their rescue by offering himself up totally for them. There are Catholic religious references throughout the film which suggests that Clint has no idea about true faith, but that doesn’t denegrate from this film, which actually suggests a moral lesson. I particularly liked the Clint character, a gnarly old man, similar to a few that I know.

 

Hang Em High ★★★★

Clint is a ex-lawman now rancher that was lynched and hung, only to rescued by a lawman in the Oklahoma territory. He is now out to get the nine men that lynched him, after he is re-made a lawman. Seeing much injustice in the system, including a couple of kids caught cattle rustling and hung, he finds it hard to adjust to his role in the system. He eventually gets most of the lynchers, but only after they shoot him up. The action line is very irregular, and incomplete, in that he doesn’t get all nine players. Also, there is a lengthy hanging scene where hymns were sung and the preacher active, all of which seemed to make mockery of religion, without realizing that that religion is what instilled a sense of justice to begin with.

 

Heartbreak Ridge ★★

Clint is an non-cooperative drill sergeant with war experience now assigned to a young group of Marines in boot camp. He establishes his presence going against authority, and eventually proves himself in the Grenada invasion. If Clint is supposed to be the Marine role model of the tough – guy, he fails miserably.

 

High Plains Drifter ★★★

Clint is now a no-name cowboy, that rides into a lonely town in the early west where the people refuse to defend themselves from roving gangs. An old gang is supposed to return to town, and they pay Clint to defend the town. For inexplicable reasons, he has flashbacks of a previous episode when the town allowed their sheriff to be whipped to death without lifting a finger. Clint gets even by knocking off the gang, but also by knocking off the town. Ho-hum.

 

Joe Kidd ★★

Just another Clint western, with him as a good-bad guy Joe Kidd, who is supposed to help a dishonest wealthy man knock off a renegade Mexican who seems to be doing nothing more than trying to honestly defend his land. Eventually Clint takes the side of the Mexican and helps knock off the rich dude and his henchmen.

 

Honkytonk Man ★

This is probably the worst Clint Eastwood movie of the bunch, with nothing good to say about it. Clint is a country singer in the depression 1930’s of Oklahoma. He wants to go to Nashville to sing in the grand ole Opry and takes along his nephew and uncle. On the way, he teaches his 11 yo nephew to drive, since he is too drunk to get behind the wheel. He then teaches his nephew to drink, steal, and visit whore houses. The movie has no redeeming moral lessons, and worst of all, the viewer has to be tortured with country music, even worse from Clint himself. Don’t waste your time on this film.

 

In the Line of Fire ★★★★

One of the late films of Clint, he is a secret service agent protecting the president. He is being tracked by an ex-CIA agent who plans on assassinating the president. In his typical role, Clint is the outsider who figures out eventually who the killer is and manages to stop the assassination by jumping in the line of fire. Though many of the elements of the movie are predictable, it does make suspense and is well filmed and acted.

 

Invictus ★★★★★

Clint directed but did not star in this film. The stars were Morgan Freeman and Matt Damon, both of whom had superb acting. This movie was based on a real historical event, though the details I’m sure were Hollywood fictions. It is the story of Morgan Freeman as Nelson Mandela, being released from prison and becoming president of the country, but being able to set aside the long-standing grievances of the past, using Rugby to spirit the nation into breaking down the racial divide. The movie is quite moving, and wonderfully enacted by Eastwood’s direction.

 

Kelly’s Heroes ★★★

This is a WWII not to be taken seriously, with many anachronistic elements, like Don Sutherland playing a 1960’s hippy. Actually, Don Sutherland was probably the funniest actor in the movie. A small group of GI’s discover that the Germans have a load of gold in a bank 30 miles across the front line. They work out an effort to retrieve this gold without their commanders knowing what was happening. The film had too many unreal aspects, such as an unorganized group simply breaking through the German offensive line, and a pile of gold sitting around practically unguarded. How they got a number of well known actors to participate in the movie is a mystery to me. It was pretty bad, but at times, funny.

 

Letters from Iwo Jima ★★★★

This is a story of the Iwo Jima from the viewpoint of the Japanese, and mostly from the eyes of a young kid who was a baker in Japan, but pulled away against his will to fight in the war. He remained one of the few survivors of the bloodbath. The movie was mostly in Japanese with under-titles. The filming was excellent. Clint directs but has no acting in this film. One wishes he would have cameoed himself like Alfred Hitchcock used to do.

 

Magnum Force ★★★★

Clint stars in the second Dirty Harry film in Magnum force. Clint is out to solve the mystery of a rash of assassinations of prime crime suspects that defy conviction. He eventually resolves that it is a group of four rookie cops led by in boss the lieutenant. There is lots of fast action and stunts making it enjoyable to watch, but is typical Dirty Harry.

Clint Eastwood #3

January 31st, 2012

Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil ★★★

Apparently this movie is based on a book relating a true story of a murder in Savannah, Georgia. Clint directs but does not show in the film – his daughter does some acting in the film. A upcoming extremely wealthy young man is convicted of murdering his employee. Much of the film takes place in the trial, where truths about the wealthy person are exploited, but eventually exonerating the man of murder save for self-defense. Many other themes are woven through the book includes a voodoo practitioner, a transvestite, wealthy society women and haute society life in Savannah. It gave one a good feel for the superficiality of life in the South, where appearances were more important than reality. I presume that unless one has read the book, the movie tends to drag a bit. The directing is superb, but many scenes did not contribute to the flow of the movie, though probably made sense in the book itself, such as the graveyard scenes. Many of Clint’s later movies are better than this one.

 

Million Dollar Baby ★★★

Clint runs a boxing center, and trains the pro boxers. He has a girl pestering him to have him become her trainer, which he initially refuses to do. She goes on to great success, only to have an attack from the rear by her opponent long after the bell rings, rendering her quadraplegic. She eventually gets Clint to pull the plug on her since she doesn’t wish to live. The movie has lots of slow action, and unnecessary scenes, making it drag, and a terrible moral ending that suggests that killing (euthanasia) is occasionally ok. Otherwise, it wasn’t a bad movie. The acting is superb, including that of Clint, Hilary Swank and Morgan Freeman. The movie does an excellent job of portraying the agony of one who makes decisions against his better judgment and then has to live with the consequences of those decisions.

 

Mystic River ★★

Three childhood friends eventually grow up and go their separate ways. One of them has a child that was murdered, another was the suspected murderer, and the last is the detective trying to solve the case. The movie begins in a very slow and confusing fashion, and we almost turned it off out of boredom. The movie does a good job of psychoanalyzing the effects of child abuse and broken relationships, yet never offers ultimate redemption for any of the characters.

 

Outlaw Josey Wales ★★★★★

This was a western starring Clint that is truly a decent film. Clint is a farmer in Missouri whose farm is overrun and family slain by renegade union men just after the civil war. Clint seeks justice, but finds that the Union remains deceptive and corrupt. Plus, the union now has a price on his head. Running from bounty hunters and ex-outlaw partner, he is continually placed into tight situations where he narrowly escapes, but befriended by indians and settlers who also are fighting for existence in a land without justice.

Paint Your Wagon ★★★

This is a fairly lame musical, even having to bear with Clint singing. He doesn’t do too bad. The cinematography and scene setups are awesome, but then, beaucoup bucks were spent to make this film. The scene is the Sacramento area during the gold-rush, when Clint and Lee Marvin stake out a profitable region yielding much gold. They also end up with the same wife, purchased off of some Mormons. The story leaves much to be desired. Worth watching once.

 

Pale Rider ★★★★

The scene is in the gold rush basin of central California, and a downstream mining company is harassing the upstream settlers to leave. Clint comes into town as a preacher man, and eventually settles matters, when the mining company decides to hire a gang of renegade sheriffs to remove Clint from the scene. All are exterminated, and Clint goes riding into the sunset. Actually, this is a rather well done film, with good acting, and a good flow of action.

 

Perfect World ★★★

A couple of jail breakers kidnap a young boy, Philip. Kevin Costner, one of the jail breakers, kills his partner, and then runs off with the kid. A massive police search is done, with Costner adequately evading capture while creating havoc and murders along their path. Costner is the main star, engaging in conversation with the kid, learning that he had a “deprived” childhood, since his mom was a JW and would not let the kid celebrate halloween or Christmas, etc. So, Costner endears himself to the child, painting a fantasy world to him.  Eventually, Costner is wounded by Philip, and then is cornered by the police, with Clint in charge. Costner is again shot against Clint’s instructions, and the child goes home with mommy. The worst part of this film is that it painted fantasies that children should experience or else they would be “deprived”. The kid was a good actor.

 

Pink Cadillac ★★★

Clint fills the bounty hunter role in the 1960‘s of seeking out a lady who skipped out on paying her bail bonds. This leads him into getting entangled with a gang of outlaw soldier of fortune dudes hiding out in the Sierras with the kidnapped child of the lady. They eventually get the baby back. The movie had much humor giving it 3 stars, but the typical worn-out Clint dodging bullets, driving recklessly, and managing an uncontrollable female all at the same time.

 

Play Misty for Me ★★★★★

This movie is “Fatal Attraction” before that movie ever came out. It is a suspenseful psycho-thriller of a lady who falls in love with a disc jockey, and then pursues him relentlessly to her ultimate demise. Clint is quite young at the time, and I’m told this is his first movie that he directed. He definitely ran a low budget but brilliant directing and acting created a masterpiece.

 

Rookie ★★★★★

While not within the Dirty Harry series, this film fits the Dirty Harry tradition, with Clint playing an aging cop, and Charlie Sheen as the rookie. In a break with Dirty Harry tradition, the rookie doesn’t get knocked off, but becomes a Clint Eastwood clone. The action is great, and Charlie does a superb job of acting his role. Clint and Charlie are cops in LA snaking out auto thieves, and stumble across a ring of thieves. At first, Charlie makes a series of rookie mistakes, but learns quickly in order to get the bad guy.

 

Space Cowboys ★★★

Clint becomes a space shuttle pilot in this episode. He happens to be the sole designer of a guidance system for satellites, that is now long outdated. It just happens that the Soviets stole his guidance system plans and used them in a supposed communications satellite of their own. This guidance system has gone haywire and the satellite in orbiting on a crash course with earth. For some unknown reason, the Soviets call on the US to repair their satellite. And, it happens that Clint and his three pilot buddies have a grudge with NASA being “dissed” 40 years previously. So, they train, struggle through bureaucratic baloney and finally make the flight. In space, they discover that the satellite is not a communications satellite but loaded with six nuclear rockets aimed at the US, which explains why the soviets wished to have it fixed. They finally send it to the moon, but, people die and Clint flies the space shuttle home to Florida without a scratch. The graphics were nice in this film, the the story was just to hokey to be reasonable.

 

Sudden Impact ★★★★★

This is the fourth Dirty Harry film. It seems like the later Dirty Harry films are better than the first. Clint is trying to solve the mystery of a series of killings, which are occurring from a lady (Sondra Locke) who was gang-raped. She is out to do justice. Eventually the killers are knocked off, and Sondra not identified as the killer except by Dirty Harry, who lets it all slide.

 

Thunderbolt and Lightfoot ★

Clint Eastwood and Jeff Bridges play Thunderbolt and Lightfoot, two criminals seeking for their next heist, when old ex-partners of Clint’s enter the scene and complicate matters. They eventually stage a heist of a bank vault, find previous heist money, and only Clint ends of getting away and surviving. Not exactly a thrilling film, with even a worse message.

 

Tightrope ★★★★

Tightrope has Clint has a detective on the murder squad in New Orleans. He is tracking down serial rape-murders, where the murderer has a past history with Clint and thus is trying to pursue the females that come into Clint’s life. The film starts with a lot of inappropriate nudity from the rape-murder scenes, but evolves into a very intense psycho-thriller. Good acting from both Clint and Clint’s daughter Alison.

 

True Crime ★★★★

Clint is an aging reporter working for the newspaper in Oakland. He’s troubled by a past of heavy alcohol use, and a present life of cheating on his wife through liaisons with a coworker’s wife. Then he smells out that a black man is wrongly convicted of a murder that he didn’t do, but the execution is scheduled for 12 hours from now. In the course of 12 hours, he proceeds to solve the mystery of the killer, and save the man from execution. It is a good story line, which isn’t helped by painting the main hero (Clint) as a drunken, philandering godless man.

 

Two Mules for Sara ★★★

Clint is wandering through Mexico, when he runs across a nun named Sara (Shirley McClaine) who is being raped by three gringos. He frees her, then they begin a collaboration to help throw out the Mexican resistance throw the French out of Mexico. This they accomplish though with the inclusion of a number of side events, such as Clint being shot in the chest with an arrow or when Clint discovers that the nun is actually a prostitute. The movie makes for light entertainment but is not your best western.

 

Unforgiven ★★★★★

Outside of his No Name Trilogy, this is Clint’s best western. He is a “retired” gunman and reformed by his now dead wife. A young kid comes to his place seeking bounty money paid by a group of whores in town to seek revenge on two cowboys who cut up one of the girls. Clint, the boy, and his “partner” head off to find the two cowboys. A secondary theme is a renegade sheriff in town who tends to do more harm to innocent people than to criminals, and making law only to protect himself. Clint and the kid eventually get the two cowboys, but return to town to find that the sheriff killed the “partner” for no good reason. Clint eventually gets revenge on the sheriff, and then moves himself and kids out to San Francisco.

 

Where Eagles Dare ★★★★★

Clint Eastwood and Richard Burton are the two main stars in this film. They are a part of a covert operation to bring back a General held captive in Schloss Adler (supposedly Kehlsteinhaus – Hilter’s hideout in the Bavarian Alps). Between incredible cinematography, stunts, superb acting, a fast paced story line, and a highly unpredictable outcome, the film deserves five stars. It’s most serious problem is that it has an unbelievable story line, with Richard and Clint singlehandedly resisting and knocking off squadrons of German soldiers without getting hardly a scratch. If that can be forgiven, the film becomes quite awesome to watch – one of Eastwood’s better films.

 

White Hunter, Black Heart ★★★

Clint Eastwood plays a rough, eccentric Hollywood director working on a film in Africa. He arrives before the producer, and decides to go on an elephant hunt. He can’t get the elephant hunt out of his head until the black guide is killed by the elephant Clint was trying to hunt. The movie portrays Clint as a worst possible movie director, irresponsible, inattentive to the producer, and irresponsible for other people’s lives. The movie left you hating the Clint character. Not a bad film.

The Joy of Bach

January 21st, 2012

The Joy of Bach, featuring Brian Blessed ★★★

This short movie is a wonderful tribute to the greatest musician of all time, our own Johann Sebastian Bach. The movie is an amalgam of Blessed reenacting fictitious though highly possibly true scenes from the life of JS Bach, and modern day performances of Bach. The modern day performances were both done in standard orchestral classical style, though the emphasis was on how musicians have incorporated Bach into the most unique circumstances, such as performances on steel drums, guitars, Moog synthesizers, and you name it. Blessed effectively communicates that the music of Bach is so great, that it continues to live today regardless of how it is played. Perhaps there is no other composer that has ever or will ever achieve this distinction to the extent that has happened with Bach. This movie can inspire even those who dislike the music of Bach.

Ives: The Symphonies

January 21st, 2012

Ives: The Symphonies, performed by Dohnanyi, Marriner and Mehta ★★★

These are reasonable performances of Charles Ives, a early 20th century American composer (1874-1954). Ives uses much American folk tune and American hymn motifs in his writing. Together, he makes for very poorly convincing symphonies. His are symphonies that I would never use for my “Desert Island Collection” or attend in formal concert. I’ll settle on listening to these symphonies from time to time simply to stay knowledgeable in American music. They are not enjoyable. Better classical music in the 20th century is Russian and German.  The English speaking world flunks in the classical music realm.

Oceanography

January 5th, 2012

Oceanography, Teaching Company Course, by Harold Tobin ★★★★

Tobin is a superb teacher, and except for his habit of excessively rolling and waving his hands, has a wonderful skill of conveying his knowledge and interest in oceanography. I appreciated the way he made oceanography quite personal, explaining how he developed an interest in the subject, and how the study of the ocean still drives him. I certainly learned more in this course than in many of the other science courses from the Teaching Company. My major complaint with the course material is the occasional excess preoccupation in some topics that were only peripheral to oceanography. It was not necessary to spend a whole lecture on plate tectonics, or on cosmology, as it didn’t contribute to the understanding of the ocean beyond what a brief mention would have accomplished and referral to other Teaching Company series. I appreciated the lecture on ocean ecology and pollution, but there was excess time spent on global warming and its effect on the ocean in several other lectures. Save for the criticisms, this was a valuable series and spurred increased interest in being more observant at the ocean, and considering our human impact on the sea.

Note by Note

December 26th, 2011

Note by Note: The making of Steinway L1037 ★★★★

I’ve always wondered how a piano was built. I didn’t realize that Steinway concert grand pianos were entirely built by hand, and are probably one of the only concert pianos still made by hand. This movie walks one through the year long endeavor to build a piano. One starts in the lumber mill, where wood is specifically selected for the piano case and sounding board. Slow and meticulous processes eventually lead to the developed project. Many scenes are also shot of profession musicians in the NY Steinway piano store  trying out pianos. I guess that even with Steinway pianos, the action can vary enough that a concert musician may need to try 10-15 pianos before finding the instrument of his liking. There are a lot of extras with this movie, but the feature attraction was itself a fascinating journal behind the walls of the Steinway piano factory in New York, with interviews of many of the piano building craftsmen. Steinways have many hand carved features, constructed to precise millimeter tolerances. The tuning is all by hand, and not electronic like most other piano builders. The keys and their actions are all meticulously adjusted by hand to properly strike the strings with appropriate action on the key. One was left realizing that there may be a day where much of the art and skills of hand piano construction may be lost, and then we will be stuck with cheap Japanese imitations. Oh well!!!!

 

How the Earth Works

December 23rd, 2011

How the Earth Works, by Michael Wysession (Teaching Company Series) ★★★

This teaching company series, taught by a Geophysicist, discusses the mechanisms and processes that make the earth the way it is. Wysession is able to interlay the various processes, whether they be geologic, biologic, or astronomic, in discussing what gives us our world. The lecture series can be divided into three parts, with a grading on each part…

I. Plate Tectonics – 5 stars – the longest part of the course, it also is the best part of the course, taught where Wysession is most expert. Details of how the continents were created, how plate tectonic theory was developed, how earthquakes and volcanoes occur, are all discussed in popular lay terms that can be understood by anybody.

II. The Weather – 3 stars – though the weather is an important process in molding the earth, another Teaching Company course on Meteorology has done a far superior job of detailing how weather is formed, and the processes that lead to our climate and living conditions.

III. Biology and “My Soapbox” – 1 star – Wysession adequately discusses the role of biological organisms in helping to form the earth. He does a far worse job of playing biologist. Much of the last lectures of the course are more a soapbox on various subjects such as climate change, humans elsewhere in the universe, and the destiny of man, which would have best been left out of the course. Many of the last lectures have no relation to discussing how the earth works, but rather create a dummy pulpit for Wysession. I do credit Wysession for maintaining a sense of scientific uncertainty about matters such as climate change, and he doesn’t become preachy like Algore.

The course could be improved in many ways. Most importantly, I wish Wysession would have spent a few lectures discussing in depth the mechanisms for studying earth. He could have better discussed the various instrumentation for “sounding” the depths of earth. He could have given us more detailed explanations of land formations that help us understand the world we see, to allow us to engage in the process of being junior geologists. I would have been interested in having a rough feel as to how a geophysicist mathematically models things like earthquakes.

Wysession is an excellent teacher and adequately uses props and visuals to get his point across. This is a series worth watching, though the final lectures would be best deleted or changed as mentioned above to get the discussion back to the intended topic for the course.

Blood, Sweat and Gears

November 28th, 2011

Blood Sweat + Gears, Racing Clean to the Tour de France ★★★★

This film is yet another bicycle documentary, looking at the origin of the Team Garmin Slipstream and their rise from humble origins to competition in the Tour de France, with Christian Vande Velde placing 4th in total standing. The prevailing theme was a determination to do bicycle racing clean without the use of performance enhancing drugs. It is a moving and well done story, inspiring one to hop on the bicycle and take off.

 

 

Bicycle Dreams

November 28th, 2011

Bicycle Dreams ★★★★

This movie is a documentary on the Race Across America, the longest and cruelest ride in bicycle racing. The ride goes over 3000 miles, and is often done in 9-12 days, with an average of 350+ miles/day. The competitors rarely sleep more than two hours a night, and often spend the entire night and day riding. During this documentary, which was made during the 2005 ride, one of the competitors, a surgeon from Minnesota, was killed by a semi truck. This was his sixth time to ride the RAAM. There was one lawyer attempting the ride, who didn’t last more than two days. The agony of the riders is well documented. It assured me that this is a race I would never ride, even if I could. The film won numerous awards, fitting for the quality of this documentary.

 

 

Concert Masterpieces

November 28th, 2011

 

Concert Masterpieces, by Robert Greenberg ★★★★★

Greenberg does it again, producing a delightful review of eight concert pieces of value from the classical repertoire. In this set of 32 45-minute lectures, each four lectures covers a given piece of music. Included are the Mozart 25th Piano concerto, Beethoven 5th piano concerto, Dvorak 9th symphony, R. Strauss Death and Transfiguration, Beethoven Violin Concerto, Brahms violin concerto, Mendelssohn Mid-summer night’s dream, and Liszt Totentanz. Each set of four lectures covers in the first lecture a broad survey of the musical scene. The second lecture then focuses on the particular piece in its setting with other similar pieces of music, and then the last two lectures delve into the details of the piece of music itself. The entire lecture set remains very easy to listen to because of Greenberg’s humor mixed with a steady stream of fascinating information. He is never too technical, and spends much time filling in the listener  to the music theory and technical details of the piece. This set is a wonderful way to familiarize yourself to these eight pieces of music. It also helps build one’s ear for listening to any piece of classical music.

 

 

Höllentour

November 26th, 2011

Hell on Wheels (Höllentour), starring Team T-mobile ★★★★ Hell on Wheels is a documentary of the 2003 Tour de France from the viewpoint of the riders on the T-Mobile team, with special focus on Eric Zabel. It was an intimate account that documented the frustrations, exhaustions, and rare joy that occurs when competing in the Tour. The film is in German, with a moderate amount of French, and occasional English, but with subtitles to make it all work. This movie did not show what would be seen on television. It showed rather what one would see and sense as a rider or intimate spectator of the tour, including the set-up of cameras, conversations with the T-mobile riders between days, and expression of the moods of the moment when riding the Tour. Between scenes, clips of historic Tour de France scenes were shown. The Tour has come a long way! For Tour de France aficionados, this film will be a delight.

Harry Potter

November 26th, 2011
Harry Potter Complete 8-film collection ★★★
If one were to read the Amazon.com reviews, you would find to sets of reviews, those that are 4-5 stars and those that are 1 star. The 1-star ratings are offered simply because sufficient extras were not included in the set, and that certain director’s cuts were not included with the films. I have read the Harry Potter series, and it was a “cute” children’s story, which became darker and more foreboding with each episode. The movie seems to follow reasonably closely the book story line. On a second time through the Harry Potter story, a number of thoughts come to my mind.
1. I don’t think that this story glorifies witchcraft and evil too much more than the CS Lewis stories. Contrary, the greatest failure is for the series to fail to offer a true distinction between good and evil, and the source of both, other than that Harry and his closest friends were good, and that Voldemort was bad. Sure.
2. Character development left shallow personalities in all, including Harry Potter. The characters were flat, and never showed evidence of advancing or truly growing up. This is especially true of the students, who were either just good, or just bad. The kids are smarter than the adults, but just not as powerful as the adults.
3. Filmography on dvd was oftentimes way too dark, leaving much clipping when presented on a large screen tv. Otherwise, the graphics of the film were fairly stupendous.
4. Each book had its own separate story line or challenge that Harry Potter had to face, but there was a prevailing theme of the return of Voldemort, and his eventual defeat through the “chosen” one, Harry Potter. Who chose Harry is never mentioned. Which leaves a larger question mark with the entire series. Each story of itself had a strong sense of unbelievability, with Harry and his friends getting into trouble, and just somehow coming across the solution in the nick of time. Some of the plot was very poor, such as having Severus Snape swear allegiance to Voldemort in order to infiltrate his attack on Harry. It’s not exactly what you want to teach kids, of true heroes standing up to their word, especially when their word is sworn.
5. In the long term, the Harry Potter craze will wear off, and the series will be confined to the dustbins of countless other chronologically failed novels. There is no reflection of higher virtues. There is no basis for good and evil. Harry Potter is a flawed savior who passes into ignominy with time. The book/movie series has no compelling reason to be considered great other than the phenomenal graphics.

Deutsche Volkslieder

November 26th, 2011
Brahm’s Deutsche Volkslieder, with Schwarzkopf, Fischer-Dieskau, and Moore ★★★★★
This is a delightful set of songs written by Johannes Brahms for soloist with accompanying piano. Brahms uses both a soprano and a baritone voice, and often they sing in the same piece, but never at the same time. It is a delightful set of songs that can be enjoyed though one may not understand the words. The performance could not have found a better set of two voices to represent Brahms. I had listened to this set a few times before but have never reviewed it, and felt that it was high enough quality to deserve a place in my blog site.

Seabiscuit

November 26th, 2011

Seabiscuit ★★★★

This movie is supposed to be based on a true story of a smallish race horse, destined to be rejected, but purchased by a person willing to give the horse a try. The horse was run at the Santa Anita Racetrack in the 1930′s depression years, going on to become a winning horse in spite of various tragedies to both horse and jockey. It is a spirited film that gives one a good feel to the world of horse racing.

 

Baader Meinhof Complex

November 18th, 2011

The Baader Meinhof Complex (2008) ★★★★

This film is in German with English subtitles and attempts to re-create the story of the Red Army Faction, a militant group in the ’70′s through 1990′s. They had engaged in the bombing of a number of buildings, most notably the newspaper Bild building, as well as the assasination of a number of prominent political figures and police. The film is fairly well done, with fast action, considerable amount of violence, some exposed flesh, and some obscene language (though in German), making it perhaps not good to view with small children. The film presents many questions in the mind of the viewer, including the proper balance of freedom (anarchy) and law (police state). It also questions the treatment of criminals. In this situation, many of the RAF were able to continue their reign of terror even when behind bars. Politicians were nervous about being harsh on the violent criminals because of the presence of an odd, small, highly vocal, mostly consisting of students and lawyers, group holding a sentiment in support of the RAF. Throughout the film, it was difficult to hold pity for the RAF members, especially with their immature and extremist behavior. Yet, it was public support for them that maintained their criminal activity for so long. The film is very thought provoking and well worth watching. It should provoke some good discussions with my German friends.

 

 

Breach

November 16th, 2011

Breach, Starring Chris Cooper and Ryan Phillippe ★★★★★

This is supposed to be a film version of the uncovering of one of the worse security breaches in US history. It is the story of Robert Hansson, who had been selling secrets to the Soviets, resulting in the death of several Soviet agents that were working with the US. There are questions in Amazon.com reviews about the accuracy of historical details in the film, though it seems to follow the Wickipedia storyline quite well. The movie starts slow and you wonder at first where it is going. The action never speeds up, but it remains spellbinding to the end, when Hansson is finally caught in the act. The acting is superb, especially with Chris Cooper as Robert Hansson. The storyline slowly intensifies, as Phillippe acting as the young FBI operative who uncovered Hansson slowly realizes what he is doing. My appreciation to Dr. JL who introduced me and Betsy to this film.

 

Planet of the Apes Series

November 16th, 2011

Planet of the Apes ★★★, Beneath the Planet of the Apes ★★★, Escape from the Planet of the Apes ★★, Conquest of the Planet of the Apes ★★, Battle for the Planet of the Apes ★

This is a series that started poorly, and should have ended after the second episode. The plots are as follows, Planet of the Apes – Charleton Heston is stranded on a strange planet after traveling into the distant future from his rocket ship sent from earth, only discover that the planet is now ruled by apes. He is taken captive, and eventually escapes with the help of two chimpanzees, only to discover that the strange planet is planet earth. Beneath the Planet of the Apes, a second rocket ship crashes, and the sole survivor meets up with Heston in underground caverns, which are clearly the ruins of NY City. The human inhabitants here are invaded by the apes, who decide on mutual destruction of all by setting off an atomic bomb which destroys the world. Escape… two the chimpanzees who helped Heston land in a rocket ship on the shores of Los Angeles, going back in time, and are discovered as talking apes. They reveal the scenario of the future so it is decided to kill the apes and save the future. A sole newborn chimpanzee survives. Conquest… it is now 1991 and all pets have been killed by man, so monkeys are now the predominant other species, used as pets, slaves, etc. The talking chimpanzee baby leads an ape revolt which takes over mankind. Battle… it is now many years later, and the first chimpanzee baby (Caesar) is now old, and there are battles between chimpanzees and gorillas and humans for control of civilization.

The films are rather benign, though there is much unnecessary obscenities and language used. There is a lot of ridicule of organized religion, and evolution is considered a given. The story plot is quite lame. It’s hard to criticize acting, when most of the actors are wearing monkey suits and acting like apes. My only wonder is how they made so many sequels until somebody got the idea that it was a stupid series.

 

Journey into Buddhism

November 13th, 2011

Journey into Buddhism: Vajra Sky over Tibet ★

This film was given to me by a very good friend who had converted from Anglicanism to Buddhism. It was his desire to demonstrate the virtues of Buddhist thinking. So, I watched it with as open of a mind as possible. The film was made in Tibet at the main centers of Buddhism. It showed the principle sites of worship, temple artwork, adherents coming to worship, and various outdoor scenes, some with religious events occurring. The commentary throughout the film was heavily oriented toward anti-Chinese sentiment regarding their purported destruction of a culture.

This film failed  to evoke sympathy for the Tibetan Buddhist tradition. Countless cultures have come and gone throughout history, without any argument for their preservation. In Tibetan Buddhism, there was presented no argument that the culture offered anything worth preserving. True, the artwork was nice. True, a small subset of Tibetan devotees have the “right” to worship as they please. Yet, the film fails to suggest that Buddhism offers anything superior to the Christian faith, or any other religion or ideology. Even in Buddhism, they have the good and evil spirits, yet there is nothing to argue why the evil spirits are evil and the good spirits are good. All are one, and none should be given preference. In real life, Buddhists seem to be as violent as anybody else when given the opportunity. Similarly, I don’t see the same “Free Tibet” group arguing that Israel needs to be set free for the Israelite/Jew, since that is their legitimate homeland. I don’t see a war-cry that Temple worship should return to Judaism as restoration of a culture that should not have been destroyed by the nasty Romans. There seems to be a great degree of hypocrisy in the Free Tibet movement.

Oddly, the film reminded me much of our recent visit to Rome. In Rome, we saw devotees spending hours praying to artifacts, doing ritual climbs on “sacred stairs”, lighting of candles, holy water, endless repetitions of the Rosary. Is this no different than prayer wheels. If only we could automate our spirituality, or make it so that all one needs to do is to perform certain perfunctory functions. It is odd how Christ stated so plainly that God doesn’t listen to mindless repetition, yet this is how universal public religion has evolved. It is no wonder that the Roman Catholic church has often had the greatest problem in defending that Christianity is the only way to God as written in the Bible. The RC faith doesn’t offer anything much different from the Buddhists.

So, the film did not suggest that Buddhism is worth exploring. It only made me appreciate my Christian faith all the more. I am glad that I am able to have a personal relationship with the God of the universe. I am content with an Absolute in morality, truth, and existence, by whom I gain my own existence. I am comforted that I don’t have to seek to attain to god-hood, yet never be sure if I could be good enough to do that. What could be more assuring than to have the God of the Universe provide forgiveness solely through true faith in Him, and trust in Him. Christianity gives a God who truly loves, truly feels, and encourages love for ones’ brother while seeking to attain progress in life through secular work and sacred worship together, as neither are better than the other, yet neither can do without the other. Life does not end up as an endless circle, but as a linear progress, so that I can view the future as a non-repetition of the present. It is a pity that too often Christianity degenerates into a mechanism, to which it offers no advantage over any other world religion.

I would love to take a trip to Tibet since I’ve read much about it. Yet, I’ll probably do it with my Chinese friend, and probably not feel bad that Tibet is now mostly Chinese.

 

Star Trek-Original Series and Feature Films

November 12th, 2011


  Star Trek-The Original Series, Seasons 1-3 ★★★★

This series is a set of three boxes that take one through the original Star Trek series. Since then, multiple spin-offs have occurred, but the original series endures. The films are well preserved, and for those who enjoyed Star Trek, it is a delight to once again view many of the episodes again. I have several complaints about this series as it is offered. The packaging is worthless, and was immediately discarded. The episodes were not presented in order, I’m not sure how they decided on the order of presentation of episodes. I remember episodes that did not seem to be included in any of these three seasons, and wonder if they were intentionally left out. Finally, in regard to the film content itself, the series seemed to diminish in quality over time. By the second and third season, many ideas were repeated, such as placing several of the Enterprise crew member into a historical earth scene. The series transformed from being a simple science fiction film to being a socio-political statement. I became nauseous every time I heard Captain Kirk comment “We come in peace!”. I’ll never be a trekkie, but these films are quite enjoyable to watch, especially if never seen before.

Star Trek Feature Films including

The Motion Picture ★★★ This film is very slow moving, playing on mostly special effects. The plot is simple. A massive energy cloud approaches earth, and Kirk/Spock eventually discover that this is a massively advanced configuration of the original Voyager 6 “V-ger” space probe.

The Wrath of Khan ★★★★ This was the most suspenseful film. Khan returns from a tv episode in an attempt to pay retribution on Captain Kirk. Spock dies.

The Search for Spock ★★★ Spock just sort of died, and the intention of this film is to get Spock’s thoughts, which were transferred to McCoy, back to Spock, wherever in the universe he might be. Kirk steals his Enterprise spaceship to accomplish that and Spock is rescued, though the Enterprise is destroyed.

The Voyage Home ★★★ Kirk and Spock are now federation bad boys, but a space probe has approached earth and trying to destroy it. Spock and Kirk figure out that it is calling out for extinct whales, and they must journey back two centuries to earth to pick up several whales and save the earth. In the process, Kirk and crew are redeemed.

The Final Frontier ★★ The Enterprise is called on to rescue several ambassadors from a remote planet, only to have the space ship taken over by a bunch of hippies. The resolution of the conflict involves Kirk proving to the hippies that there is no Nirvana or Heaven to go to.

The Undiscovered Country ★★★ The Klingons have gone bankrupt and sue for peace. Kirk must escort the Klingon ambassador to the peace meeting, when things are sabotaged and the ambassador is murdered in a strange fashion. Eventually, it is discovered that junior officers working in conjunction with Klingons sought to dismantle the peace process, but only after many unusual adventures and last moment rescues.

 

War and World History

October 23rd, 2011

 

War and World History (The Teaching Company Series), by Jonathan Roth ★★★

This series looks at world history from the perspective of how war affected that history. Roth shows possibly by this lecture series that multiple other factors, such as religion, politics, and chance seem to affect the occurrence of war as much as vice versa. Thus, Roth delves at length how economy, culture and nationalism has affected the occurrence of war in the last several hundred years. Though he spent some time speaking of the development of war technology, it was rather minimal considering the topic. Also, I had hoped for more discussion on the style of conducting war, strategies, and how geography affected the nature of war, and the development of war in world history.

 

Review of three economic documentary films with commentary

September 9th, 2011

I am currently reading a book by Niall Ferguson on the history of money which will soon be reviewed, but have diverted to three films, all highly recommended by a broad spectrum of people on Amazon.com, and thus I felt reasonable to watch. In particular, I wished to learn more, after the fact, about the nature of the economic collapses of the last decade. In the end, I feel that I could have simply sat down and read a text from Ron Paul or Pat Buchanan and had a better feel as to the nature of the problems with the system of economics in this nation. I will review each film in order in which I watched them.

Collapse, starring Michael Ruppert ?

This film was absolutely awful.  The majority of the shots were various angles on Michael sitting on a single chair in the middle of an otherwise empty warehouse. We had to endure his continual preoccupation with cigarettes. Michael’s only message was that the entire system is going to break because the world is going to run out of oil. This will be followed by mass chaos and mass starvation, war, and disruption of all the social aspects of life.  He seems to fix most of his blame on George Bush. Michael’s brand of alarmism is disingenuous, in that he has essentially given up on the system. The final views are him in his home which has past due taxes and bills that he cannot pay. Poor Michael! While there is truth in his thesis of the purported coming system collapse, he lacks not only credibility, but also the ability to develop his claims in a convincing fashion. This film is a total waste of even the time it takes to watch it.

 

 

Enron, The Smartest Guys in the Room, editor Allison Ellwood ???

This film is a documentary of the rise and fall of Enron. It is a sad story in many ways, in that it reflects what is happening throughout the financial structures of corporate America. Unfortunately, the editor identifies what I believe to be false or superficial causes for the collapse of Enron, including government giving in to demands for increased deregulation. The prevailing undercurrent in this film was a statement against deregulation. In fact, the documentary failed dismally to identify where deregulation was the great evil, outside of holding people responsible for their actions and maintaining transparency in issues that involve the public concern. There is a sense of anger left at the end of the film, as to why so many of the top executives could make out with hundreds of millions of dollars, middle managers and traders with millions of dollars, and yet leave many pension plans (such as with PGE) destitute. The films fails to identify a greater evil lurking in the very heart of corporate America that may lead to such corporate collapses many more times over in our short lifetime.  This film is worth watching if one has not stayed on top of the issues that led to the fall of Enron.

 

Inside Job, directed by Charles Ferguson, narrated by Matt Damon ??

This film is a documentary of the 2008 financial collapse. It attempts to offer an in-depth analysis of what went wrong with the financial system, placing most of the blame on none other than George W. Bush (surprise?).  No mention is made of the fact that it was a very socialistic democratic congress that essentially controlled governmental financial dealings. Oddly, the film uses two faux-pundits to help sort out was went wrong with the housing bubble and collapse of AIG and Lehman Brothers. The first was Barney Frank, who waxed eloquent about how proper regulations were not put in place on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Oddly, it was Frank and the democratic party that refused to listen to warnings. Barney is more to blame than anybody is the collapse of Fannie and Freddie. The second faux-pundit was George Soros, the consummate hypocrite who has made more billions off of shady dealings on Wall Street than anybody alive. The only benefit that I received from the film is that I was left with the impression that it is the fox that guards the financial hen-house.  The film shows adequately that even the academic institutions are now besot with corruption with very lucrative advisory roles given to many economics professors.  It has enough fairness to admit that even St. Obama has failed the faithful by continuing Wall Street personnel such as Larry Sommers, Timothy Geithner and many others who have failed the public trust through corrupt actions.

Conservatives tend to defend Wall Street as the model of free-market economics. The argument is against limits on top executives since free-markets determine what a person earns. Such an argument is certainly true for the prior builders of industries that have made America, such as with Andrew Carnegie, The Rockefellers, etc., and is also true of modern industry builders such as Dell, Gates, and Jobs. They deserve what they have earned. I have much more trouble with the astronomical profits earned by the financial gamblers of Wall Street who run the banks. They produce nothing, their risks are not great since the Feds will bail them out, and they will be able to make catastrophic decisions and still take home at least 100 times what I will earn in a lifetime.  Ferguson argues that these banking systems create the “wealth” that powers modern society to drive itself forward. Yet, I disagree to some extent. America grew quite fine before the Federal Reserve was created on Jekyll Island in 1913. There was never an issue of phantom monies coming and going, of corruption and dishonesty controlling and regulating itself. Why are normal politicians not allowed to see into the workings of the Federal Reserve? Because we just can’t understand? If banking is truly that complex, then we have a serious problem. Strangely, many evil people such as Sommers and Geithner were given positions by George Bush, only to held on to and adored by St. Obama.

As brother Dennis rightly states, there is minimal difference between the Republican and Democratic Party in many things, and economics seems to be one of them. Few besides Ron Paul have the wisdom to identify that the Federal Reserve is built in a fashion to protect corruption, promote parasitic high-rollers in the banking world, but in whom we are supposed to trust our money. Is it no wonder that the world economic status has become unglued?

The Liszt Collection

August 14th, 2011

The Liszt Collection, produced by Deutsche Grammophon, multiple performers ????

This is a hodge-podge 34 CD collection from the Deutsche Grammophon archives, presumably reflecting the best of Liszt. It was probably produced for the bicentennial year of Liszt’s birth. Sony has also produced a 25 CD collection, as well as the recently reviewed Leslie Howard complete piano works of Liszt. Sadly, nobody has ever compiled the entire production of Liszt like has been done for Mozart, Beethoven, Bach and other composers. This collection has all superb performances, as well as superb recordings. It is a very worthwhile introduction to Liszt for the classical lover who would like to get into Liszt.

The Adjustment Bureau

August 14th, 2011

The Adjustment Bureau, starring Matt Damon ???

A recent conversation with Jeff Banker during a hike/climb of Flattop Peak in Anchorage, AK led to the issue of free will and providence. This movie came up in the discussion. It is suggested that there is a bureau of people who have enough insight in the makeup of all people in order to ultimately have plans for their fates, as well as the fate of the world. It is as though they are god, yet, unlike the Christian God of the Bible, is constantly changing his plans, not totally aware of the future, has no actual control over anything, can be worked around, has no prevailing moral code of operation, and is limited in his insights, judgement, and power to actually determine the fate of events. Damon is not his best in acting, and was much better in the Bourne series. I am quite sure this movie reflects a sense of providence/predestination equivalent with most people’s thinking, including Christians of the Arminian persuasion. This movie is an excellent argument that such a god is no god at all, but rather just a little more powerful version of the human being.

German Military Marches WWII

August 14th, 2011

Großdeutschland. Stormtrooper Marches. ??

Both of these albums were taken from historical archives. Thus, their quality is ok to quite poor. The recordings could have been cleaned up a little better, but were not. Many of these marches and songs are quite difficult to obtain. Of note, the Horst Wessel Lied is not available in Germany. It is illegal to have the tune, or to play it. It was hard enough to procure here in the US. For my German friends…

Bitte zur Beachtung! Passen Sie auf! Dieses Lied ist nicht erlaubt auf Deutschland. Hör es nur mit Kopfhörer. Wenn der Staat wisst, das du dieses Lied gehören hast, kannst du bestraft sein. Du werdest in Gefängnis geworfen sein, und der Schlüssel weg geworfen. Hör auf eigene Gefahr!

01 Horst Wessel Lied (Nazi Party Anthem – choral) 1

First, a clarification. I wish to compare this song with the French and American National anthems.

German original English translation
Die Fahne hoch! Die Reihen fest geschlossen!
SA marschiert mit ruhig, festem Schritt.
Kam’raden, die Rotfront und Reaktion erschossen,
Marschier’n im Geist in unser’n Reihen mit.
Die Straße frei den braunen Batallionen.
Die Straße frei dem Sturmabteilungsmann!
Es schau’n aufs Hakenkreuz voll Hoffnung schon Millionen.
Der Tag für Freiheit und für Brot bricht an!
Zum letzten Mal wird Sturmalarm geblasen!
Zum Kampfe steh’n wir alle schon bereit!
Bald flattern Hitlerfahnen über alle Straßen.
Die Knechtschaft dauert nur noch kurze Zeit!
Die Fahne hoch! Die Reihen fest geschlossen!
SA marschiert mit ruhig-festem Schritt.
Kameraden, die Rotfront und Reaktion erschossen,
Marschieren im Geist in unseren Reihen mit.
The flag on high! The ranks closed tightly!
SA marches with calm, firm steps.
Comrades shot by Red Front and reactionaries
March in spirit within our ranks.
Clear the streets for the brownshirts,
Clear the streets for the stormtroopers!
Millions are filled with hope, when they see the swastika,
The day of freedom and bread is dawning!
The storm warning is sounded for the last time!
We all stand ready for the fight!
Soon Hitler’s flags will fly over all streets.
Our bondage will only last a short time more!
The flag on high! The ranks close tightly!
SA marches with calm, firm steps.
Comrades shot by Red Front and reactionaries
March in spirit within our ranks.

French National Anthem

Allons enfants de la Patrie, Arise, children of the Fatherland,
Le jour de gloire est arrivé ! The day of glory has arrived!
Contre nous de la tyrannie, Against us of tyranny
L’étendard sanglant est levé, (bis) The bloody banner is raised, (repeat)
Entendez-vous dans les campagnes Do you hear, in the countryside,
Mugir ces féroces soldats ? The roar of those ferocious soldiers?
Ils viennent jusque dans nos bras They’re coming right into our arms
Égorger nos fils et nos compagnes ! To cut the throats of our sons and women!
Aux armes, citoyens, To arms, citizens,
Formez vos bataillons, Form your battalions,
Marchons, marchons ! Let’s march, let’s march!
Qu’un sang impur That an impure blood
Abreuve nos sillons ! Waters our furrows!
Que veut cette horde d’esclaves, What does this horde of slaves,
De traîtres, de rois conjurés ? Of traitors and conjured kings want?
Pour qui ces ignobles entraves, For whom are these vile chains,
Ces fers dès longtemps préparés ? (bis) These long-prepared irons? (repeat)
Français, pour nous, ah ! quel outrage Frenchmen, for us, ah! What outrage
Quels transports il doit exciter ! What fury it must arouse!
C’est nous qu’on ose méditer It is us they dare plan
De rendre à l’antique esclavage ! To return to the old slavery!
Aux armes, citoyens… To arms, citizens…
Quoi ! des cohortes étrangères What! Foreign cohorts
Feraient la loi dans nos foyers ! Would make the law in our homes!
Quoi ! Ces phalanges mercenaires What! These mercenary phalanxes
Terrasseraient nos fiers guerriers ! (bis) Would strike down our proud warriors! (repeat)
Grand Dieu ! Par des mains enchaînées Great God ! By chained hands
Nos fronts sous le joug se ploieraient Our brows would yield under the yoke
De vils despotes deviendraient Vile despots would have themselves
Les maîtres de nos destinées ! The masters of our destinies!
Aux armes, citoyens… To arms, citizens…
Tremblez, tyrans et vous perfides Tremble, tyrants and you traitors
L’opprobre de tous les partis, The shame of all parties,
Tremblez ! vos projets parricides Tremble! Your parricidal schemes
Vont enfin recevoir leurs prix ! (bis) Will finally receive their reward! (repeat)
Tout est soldat pour vous combattre, Everyone is a soldier to combat you
S’ils tombent, nos jeunes héros, If they fall, our young heroes,
La terre en produit de nouveaux, The earth will produce new ones,
Contre vous tout prêts à se battre ! Ready to fight against you!
Aux armes, citoyens… To arms, citizens…
Français, en guerriers magnanimes, Frenchmen, as magnanimous warriors,
Portez ou retenez vos coups ! You bear or hold back your blows!
Épargnez ces tristes victimes, You spare those sorry victims,
À regret s’armant contre nous. (bis) Who arm against us with regret. (repeat)
Mais ces despotes sanguinaires, But not these bloodthirsty despots,
Mais ces complices de Bouillé, These accomplices of Bouillé,
Tous ces tigres qui, sans pitié, All these tigers who, mercilessly,
Déchirent le sein de leur mère ! Rip their mother’s breast!
Aux armes, citoyens… To arms, citizens…
Amour sacré de la Patrie, Sacred love of the Fatherland,
Conduis, soutiens nos bras vengeurs Lead, support our avenging arms
Liberté, Liberté chérie, Liberty, cherished Liberty,
Combats avec tes défenseurs ! (bis) Fight with thy defenders! (repeat)
Sous nos drapeaux que la victoire Under our flags, shall victory
Accoure à tes mâles accents, Hurry to thy manly accents,
Que tes ennemis expirants That thy expiring enemies,
Voient ton triomphe et notre gloire ! See thy triumph and our glory!
Aux armes, citoyens… To arms, citizens…
(Couplet des enfants) (Children’s Verse)
Nous entrerons dans la carrière[3] We shall enter the (military) career
Quand nos aînés n’y seront plus, When our elders are no longer there,
Nous y trouverons leur poussière There we shall find their dust
Et la trace de leurs vertus (bis) And the trace of their virtues (repeat)
Bien moins jaloux de leur survivre Much less keen to survive them
Que de partager leur cercueil, Than to share their coffins,
Nous aurons le sublime orgueil We shall have the sublime pride
De les venger ou de les suivre Of avenging or following them

Finally, the US National Anthem (I hope you know it already!)

O! say can you see by the dawn’s early light,
What so proudly we hailed at the twilight’s last gleaming,
Whose broad stripes and bright stars through the perilous fight,
O’er the ramparts we watched, were so gallantly streaming?
And the rockets’ red glare, the bombs bursting in air,
Gave proof through the night that our flag was still there;
O! say does that star-spangled banner yet wave,
O’er the land of the free and the home of the brave?

On the shore dimly seen through the mists of the deep,
Where the foe’s haughty host in dread silence reposes,
What is that which the breeze, o’er the towering steep,
As it fitfully blows, half conceals, half discloses?
Now it catches the gleam of the morning’s first beam,
In full glory reflected now shines in the stream:
’Tis the star-spangled banner, O! long may it wave
O’er the land of the free and the home of the brave.

And where is that band who so vauntingly swore
That the havoc of war and the battle’s confusion,
A home and a country, should leave us no more?
Their blood has washed out their foul footsteps’ pollution.
No refuge could save the hireling and slave
From the terror of flight, or the gloom of the grave:
And the star-spangled banner in triumph doth wave,
O’er the land of the free and the home of the brave.

O! thus be it ever, when freemen shall stand
Between their loved home and the war’s desolation.
Blest with vict’ry and peace, may the Heav’n rescued land
Praise the Power that hath made and preserved us a nation!
Then conquer we must, when our cause it is just,
And this be our motto: “In God is our trust;”
And the star-spangled banner in triumph shall wave
O’er the land of the free and the home of the brave!

Notice that the anthems all tend toward violence, and the Nazi anthem is no worse than the French or American. The only redeeming value of the American anthem is the last stanza, which is unfortunately rarely ever sung. Francis Scott Key wrote other hymns, one which is still in the church hymn repertoire, “Lord with glowing heart I’ll praise thee”, but unfortunately is not found in many hymnals any more.

Shostakovich Complete Symphonies

July 25th, 2011

Shostakovich Complete Symphonies, performed by Kiril Kondrashin and Moscow Symphony Orchestra ?????

As you can tell, I’ve been reviewing mostly Russian music, including Borodin, Rachmaninoff, and Shostakovich. Shostakovich is my favorite of all Russian composers. This 11-CD set includes all 15 of Shostakovich’s symphonies, as well as his violin concerto. Though recorded a few years ago by Melodia, the sound is quite excellent. Kondrashin provides very convincing performances, that rank among the best. His tempo and dynamics often differ a bit from western conductors, but is done in a way that is quite pleasing. The 5th symphony is comparatively slower than Bernstein’s, yet maintains all the vim and fire worthy of the symphony. This is a set of Shostakovich’s symphonies that is worth having, and is probably the best Russian performances available. I have complete sets by Barshai, Haitink, Maxim Shostakovich, and Jansons, as well as this set by Kondrashin, and tend to prefer the Kondrashin and Jansons sets above the others. Each conductor provides a much different interpretation of these symphonies, and all of the sets are worth having. Kondrashin would be a reasonable starting set for the beginner.

Rachmaninoff Edition

July 25th, 2011

Rachmaninoff Edition (Complete Works), various performers ?????

This is one of the sets produced by Brilliant Classics as a budget series, though none of the recordings in this set would fit the “budget” category as being highest quality performances. Especially delightful were the piano concertos with Earl Wild at the piano. This is reportedly a comprehensive set of Rachmaninoff’s works, including his operas, solo piano and solo voice works and other works. As a special treat, various historic performances of Rachmaninoff were also included. This set doesn’t seem to be available any longer from Amazon.com, but for the price when it was available, was a true bargain.

Borodin Chamber Music

July 25th, 2011

Borodin Chamber Music, performed by the Moscow Trio and Moscow String Quartet ?????

Alexander Borodin was a Russian chemist associated with “The Five”, a group of amateur musicians that sought to reform Russian music. The others in “the Five” were Balakirev, Cui, Rimsky-Korsakov,  and Mussorgsky. Though the musical output of the Five was not massive, it did have a profound influence on composers to follow, including Tchaikovsky and the 20th century Russian composers. Borodin has a sweet style to his music that is neither harsh on the ears or lacking in luster. Borodin’s chamber music is not commonly heard, and that’s a shame, since it is both tuneful and creative. The recording is flawless with a strong sense of presence, and the performances by the Moscow Trio/Quartet manifest charm in their interpretation. This is a worthy set to have in either small or large collections.

Fünf Stimmen für ein Halleluja

July 24th, 2011

Fünf Stimmen für ein Halleluja, by Die Beinahe Sechs ?????

Die Beinahe Sechs (The nearly six) vocal ensemble  from Germany has composed and revised various Christian themed songs. They offer a mix of songs sung in German and English in a truly remarkable performance. Dr. Kretschmar (from Leipzig) first introduced me to this album. Rather than offer a ponderous description of their music, I thought it best to include two excerpts, both in highly reduced format to hopefully render these as not violating copyright laws. My only regret is that this group is not producing more albums, as they beat most of the Christian music being produced in the English-speaking world.

Jesu, meine Freude

What A Friend We Have In Jesus

 

The Three Stooges

July 24th, 2011

The Three Stooges (8 volumes) ????

This series of the Three Stooges as presented on television goes from the earliest episodes in 1934 up to the final episodes with Joe Besser in 1959. The Three Stooges offer their own commentary of wit and humor. Many people who watch the Stooges in action feel that they are too violent, and I’m sure Leonard Maltin or Woopie Goldberg would not approve for the violence, but as they also tend to make fun of racial and ethnic stereotypes. The greatest disappointment with this series is that the last few years offered mostly remakes of previous episodes, often with only minor alterations in order to make it a new episode. In addition, Joe Besser simply cannot compete with Curly or Shemp. I remember watching the Three Stooges on television when I was 5 or 6 years old, and they were transfixing then. When I let the grandchildren watch them, they find them still amusing. Much of the wordplay is missed by kids, but makes the Three Stooges equally humorous for children and adults alike.

The Stoning of Soraya

July 3rd, 2011

The Stoning of Soraya, directed by Cyrus Nowrosteh ?????

This is a bad movie to watch late at night, as it will haunt you. It is the story of a young wife in a small village in Iran, as told through the voice of a journalist who was passing through the village. Apparently, it was based on a true story, as this story mirrors what happens many times throughout strict Muslim countries. Soraya is mother of two young boys and two young girls, but whose husband has found her to be less than satisfactory, in spite of her hard work and virtue. He decides to get rid of her and marry another girl in a neighbor village. She takes up the job of helping to care for the children of a neighbor widower, encouraged by the town officials and holy man. Through this, the town officials and holy man assist in devising a false trumped charge of adultery. The widower is threatened with his life if he fails to assist in this plot, and so contributes to the deception of the charge of adultery, attesting that she was found lying on his bed. The final verdict was the death penalty, and all men in the village, including Soraya’s sons throw stones. Justice is finally served when Soraya’s husband discovers that the other girl is not available to him and he is left without a wife, and that the journalist brings the story to the rest of the world.

The intention of this movie is to alert the western world as to the mistreatment of women in Muslim countries. The film inadvertently portrays a much deeper evil that lurks throughout the Muslim mindset, which is unfortunately turned into a virtue by the Muslim faith. In the Judeo-Christian ethic, a person that leads to the death of another in a trial by bearing false witness is also condemned to death (Deut. 19:15-20). Integrity and truth are considered integral to religion and worship of God. In the Muslim faith, the worship of Allah is divorced from the ethical environment. A hierarchy of values are generated whereby one evil may justify the performance of another evil.Thus, suicidal terrorist acts, the organized mistreatment of women, the debauchery that occurs in all Muslim countries are all condoned since the ends justify the means. My experience of having spent time in several Muslim countries (Bangladesh and Northern Africa) confirm this through observations of women essentially having the same social status as animals. This is not superficially observable as many Muslim men treated their wives with respect, even though they still remain second class citizens in the society. Attempts have been made to accuse Western society for demeaning women, yet, the difference is such that females are considered equal but different, contrary to feminist ideology that considers females not only equal but not different. Either is a far cry from the Muslim world, where a female might be imprisoned for driving a car, or speaking out in public.

The director of this movie did a brilliant job of character development, scene portrayal, and plot flow. It will hold you by the seat of your pants, in spite of the fact that I have just given away the plot of the movie. I highly encourage you to watch this film at your first chance.

Bartók Complete Solo Piano Works

July 2nd, 2011

Bartók Complete Solo Piano Works, performed by Zoltán Kocsis ????

Bartók has a unique style of composition and Kocsis a delightful ability to render those compositions in a pleasant and enjoyable manner. Bartók was born in Hungary, eventually emigrating to the United States in the early 1940′s to escape the war, though many of his works were produced prior to his emigration. He delved into a range of styles, including atonality of the Schönberg style, polymodal chromaticism, and various modifications of early 20th techniques. Bartók focused on the utilization of Hungarian folk song themes in his compositions. Kocsis manages to take these various forms of composition, and make them flow with reasonable emotive expression. These performances would never be in my “desert island” top 10, but they have great value in most music lovers’ collections, and much to commend to them.

Tchaikovsky String Quartets

June 18th, 2011

Tchaikovsky String Quartets, by the Borodin String Quartet ?????

I don’t often review music that’s sat in my library for many years, but this is an exception owing to its excellence. Tchaikovsky isn’t too well known for his chamber music, yet this set of 3 string quartets is gripping, addicting, moving, and most enjoyable to listen to. The melodies are catching but never “jingo-istic”. The Borodin Quartet is flawless in their performance, but not mechanical, adept at extracting the soul of the piece. The absence of popularity of these pieces should not prevent one from giving these pieces one’s full attention for many an evening.

Fall and Rise of China

June 8th, 2011

Fall and Rise of China, taught by Richard Baum (Teaching Company) ?????

This is one of the best Teaching Company series that I’ve heard in a long time. Prof. Baum was quite compelling in his presentation, and maintained a competent discussion mixed with a large volume of personal experience to be not only informative but also enjoyable to listen to. I personally appreciate Baum’s teaching style, though he does demand full attention, since he typically does NOT repeat what he’s said. I especially appreciated how Dr. Baum maintained neutral political stances in his discussions–he did not use his lecture stand as a bully pulpit to push down his personal ideology. Yet, few professors in my recent memory (from the Teaching Company) has sparked such interest in the topic at hand. A day did not go by when I was seeking further information from the internet, and even better, from close friends who grew up in mainland China and could not only confirm but expand on the professor’s statements. Prof. Baum offers several introductory lectures to provide a background history of the West’s involvement with China in the 1800′s, leading to the rise of anti-western sentiment and the emergence of Mao Zedong. Baum follows through the life of Mao to his death, with China emerging from its backwater status to be a leading economic and social force in the world. These lectures are a beautiful complement to another excellent Teaching Company series “From Yao to Mao: 5000 years of Chinese History”. Regardless of one’s view of China, it remains a people that are rising on the world scene, and there is no better way to mentally fit China into the grand scheme of things than through this set of lectures.

Rienzi, der letzte der Tribunen

May 30th, 2011

Rienzi, der letzte der Tribunen, by Richard Wagner, performed by the Deutsche Oper Berlin ??

Wagner wrote three early operas that are relatively unknown since they are rarely performed, including die Feen, das Liebesverbot, and Rienzi. They are operas that are not typical of  Wagner’s mature style, but do show development toward the final Wagnerian style. Rienzi is the opera that launched Wagner’s career as a musician, and several of the pieces including the overture are still occasionally performed. There were no available movie versions of this opera until this performance came out, so I decided to buy it, especially with the reasonable reviews given to it by Amazon.com reviewers. This performance has its merit. The singers were faultless, acting and singing well. The recording was high quality, though there were often problems with mixing of the sound of the singers and the orchestra, in that the orchestra tended to drown out the voices on stage.

My problem with this performance is the staging. I don’t object to modern versions of operas, so long as they don’t distract from the story and theme of the original opera. If the staging is such that it creates another theme or story than the original opera, or if it restricts itself to being solely a commentary on either the opera or the composer, then it should not be considered as a legitimate version of the opera. I recall the Peter Sellars versions of various operas that attempted contemporary contextualization of 18th and 19th century operas, yet they were never sold as straight opera renditions. Creative license with modern European staging tends to destroy the composers intent, and this should be overtly stated. It would be like re-writing a Beethoven symphony for a Jazz band but calling it the original symphony. Liszt did not have the audacity to do that, but was willing to call his transcriptions something else, and bizarre creative staging should be called something other than the original opera.

The staging used in this performance is indeed bizarre. The citizens of Rome come out masked at first, eventually removing their masks and donning suits that looked more like Soviet peasant outfits. Rienzi and his daughter appeared more like Adolf Hitler and Eva Braun than a noble Roman tribune. The themes of Stalin, Hitler and Mussolini prevailed, forcing the entire opera into an entirely other interpretation. Adriano, the traitor, is made into the hero, and Rienzi is reduced to totalitarian scum. The final scene, with Rienzi in Hitler’s bunker and Speer’s model of the new Berlin before him was exceptionally distractive to the aria “Allmächtiger Gott…” and completely out of place. The videos of Rienzi as a totalitarian propagandist before microphones appearing on television were seriously distracting. Wagner’s character development in the opera was completely re-written. The behind the scenes slaughter of the assassins at the end of act 1 altered the story of the opera. This is not the way Wagner intended the opera to be, and the staging was too divergent from the actual opera story to be legitimate. I’d rather just listen to a recording than to watch what Stölzl has given us.

Whatever one may think of Wagner, I suggest that performances should leave Wagner alone. It is true that Wagner was a truly despicable  egotistical, racist person, yet his composing is sublime. It is quite easy to see his anti-Jewish sentiments throughout his operas, which must be overlooked. Thankfully, many Jewish Wagner conductors and performers have been able to do that, producing some of the best performances of Wagner in existence (eg., James Levine’s Ring, Leonard Bernstein’s Tristan und Isolde). To be obsessed with mid-twentieth century totalitarianism when performing a Wagner opera deprives the opera of its legitimate interpretation and reduces the performance to just another case of Euro Trash.

The Complete Liszt Piano Music

May 27th, 2011


The Complete Liszt Piano Music, by Leslie Howard ?????
This set consists of all the known piano music of Franz Liszt, including his solo works, transcriptions of other composers’ works, and orchestral pieces. In the section on rare works, even short 12 second snippets were included. The entire set consisted of 99 CDs, all but the last CD packed with music. The recordings themselves are very forward and realistic, sounding much like the piano is next to you in the room. Liszt has been known for the complexity of his compositions, thus limiting the number of performers willing to tackle his pieces. Yet, Howard does this with aplomb. Before hearing this set, I was familiar with the volume by George Bolet, and the short pieces by Earl Wild and Cziffra. These recordings place Leslie Howard with the best of all possible performers of Liszt. There is not a single piece in this set that lacks luster, or has been performed better by somebody else. In the nearly 122 hours that it took to listen to this entire set, the only tedium was in listening to the rare snippets – perhaps Howard didn’t need to be so complete in his complete compendium! Liszt’s music lends itself to showmanship. Yet, Howard gives one more than showmanship, and his interpretations are neither extreme nor flamboyant, but very creative with a touch that draws out the soul of the composition. This is highly recommended by me as a “must have” for classic music lovers.

Le Nozze di Figaro

April 16th, 2011



Le Nozze di Figaro, by Wolfgang A. Mozart, conducted by Karajan ???? and Böhm ?????
Both of these performances are awesome, the first with Herbert von Karajan, performed in 1949 with Elizabeth Schwarzkopf, Irmgard Seefried, and George London, and the second by Karl Böhm, performed in 1969 with a star-studded cast of Hermann Prey, Gundula Janowitz, Edith Mathis, Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau, and Tatiana Troyanos. The sound of the Karajan recording was definitely inferior to Böhm’s later recording, providing the greatest distraction. Yet, for a post-war production, it has a stunning and awesome quality to it. Böhm maintains technical excellence while producing a piece that overwhelms with charm. Both recordings are fitting for the Mozart lover.

Modern Intellectual History

April 16th, 2011


Modern Intellectual History: From Descartes to Derrida, by Lawrence Cahoone (Teaching Company) ????
I’ve been a bit disappointed recently at the quality of Teaching Company lectures and have backed off on purchase of some of the latest productions from that company. My feeling was that the lecturers were too biased in their discussions without giving credence to opposing views. In this lecture series, Cahoone maintains a very compelling discussion of the major philosophers from Descartes to those still alive today, holding ones’ interest while giving an in depth review of the main philosophical contributions of the person under discussion. He ends a touch weak, with a discussion arguing against the death of philosophy. It seems as though philosophy has gone full circle, with philosophy realizing that a crisis created by Derrida and other post-modernists have left no discussion since the claim is that all truth is either un-knowable or un-communicateable. Cahoone shows how modern philosophers have tended to return to the classics to resolve this muddle, creating a spiral (not a circle). Thankfully, he doesn’t discuss whether philosophy is spiraling downwards or upwards, as I tend to feel that it’s taking a downward spiral. After all, without an infinite reference frame, there should be no way of knowing whether one is spiraling up or down! This is a lecture series worth listening to, and will probably be heard again by me.

Touching the Void

April 16th, 2011


Touching the Void, starring MacKey and Aaron ?????
I love to watch climbing films, but often they are miserably done in a manner that considers the viewer completely naive to climbing technique and possibilities. I was fairly nervous that this film would repeat the horrid sensationalism of other recently reviewed films, like the Vertical Limit. This movie was everything but that. It is based on the true but unbelievable story of two British climbers Joe Simpson and Simon Yates who set out to scale an unnamed peak in Patagonia. In the process, they succeed to make the summit, but descent is greeted by disaster when white-out conditions, and a fall by one of the partners, leaves the two completely out of communication, and presuming that the fallen climber is dead. The struggle to get off the mountain and eventual survival of both climbers is well beyond belief. The movie does a beautiful job with superb acting to portray as accurately as possible with what is thought to be the events that led to both climbers getting out alive. About the only other story this incredible is Doug Scott escaping from an unnamed peak in the Himalayas with both femurs fractured, while living out a 2 week storm. This is a movie very much worth watching, even if you aren’t into climbing.

Cherubini Masses & Choral Works

April 5th, 2011


Cherubini Masses, Overtures, Motets, Conducted (mostly by) Riccardo Muti ?????
Cherubini is an under-heard and under-appreciated composer from the era of Beethoven. Writing in an Italian style, these masses and other choral works are a delight to hear. Cherubini is quite accessible to both classical neophyte as well as long-standing classical listener. Muti does a masterful job of conducting these performances, which have a very crisp and clean recording presence. This set is a true bargain from Amazon.com, and worthwhile in any classical collection.

The Dead Sea Scrolls

March 26th, 2011


The Dead Sea Scrolls, by Gary Rendsburg (The Teaching Company) ????
This lecture series was a fairly comprehensive introduction to the history of the discovery and research on the Dead Sea scrolls, but also lengthy discussion of the various factions in Jewish society around the 200BC to 100AD time period in Palestine. Rendsburg was delightful to listen to, and remained fairly even in his discussion, always being willing to admit, and to discuss alternative interpretations and division in the field of Dead Sea scroll research. It is believed that the scrolls were the product of the Qumram community, who lived in a small community (about 200-300 people) on the northwest side of the Dead Sea. Rendsburg removes much of the mystery as to why it took so long for many of the scrolls to be published, as well as the actual contents of the scrolls. Besides numerous copies of the OT scriptures, many scrolls details the rules of life within the (presumed) Qumram community and various other writings of the community. Interestingly, one scroll was even a so-called treasure map, describing the various location of vast amounts of gold and silver, none of which has been found. Unlike many of the religious lecture series from the Teaching Company where the lecturer presents a single opinion on any subject, Rendsburg was quite engaging in discussing the Dead Sea scroll subject with true academic humility, often admitting that many questions remained unanswered.

Religion in the Ancient Mediterranean World

March 6th, 2011


Religion in the Ancient Mediterranean World, taught by Glenn Holland ?
This is an audio lecture offered by the Teaching Company. It’s focus is the ancient religions of the Mediterranean basin, including the ancient religions of Sumer, Babylon, Assyria, Canaan, Egypt, Greece and Rome, as well as Israel. The entire set is not what I had hoped it to be. I doesn’t give a very good feel for the development and structure of religions outside of the Judeo-Christian realm. Coverage of important texts, like the Gilgamesh epic, leaves much to be desired. Holland offers very little analysis of these non-Israelite religions until the very end of the series, when he offers the pathetic statement of how they all have a unifying notion of our search for the divine. I don’t need to suffer through a 48 lecture course for that conclusion. There is no serious comparison and contrast of the various religions, and typically minimal insight into how these religions and their differences affected the various cultures. There were many religions that Holland mostly glosses over, such as the religions of the Ammonites and Edomites, which have substantial source material to work with. Meanwhile, he is quite ready to offer inane criticisms of the Bible, falling into the confusion of the higher school redaction criticism of the texts. Even here, Holland is not up to date on his facts or critical of his assessments, as I would expect of a university professor. As an example, his disagreement with the dating of Abraham simply shows misguided and uninformed criticism. He seems to be most critical of the Judeo-Christian texts since they are endowed with a certain reverence in the Western world. I don’t expect him to manifest a similar enthusiastic reverence, but I do hold him accountable for providing a critical review free of personal bias and as eager to prove as well as to disprove the veracity of a the sacred texts at hand. It was difficult to endure to the end this series because of the absence of true scholarship.

Shostakovich Symphonies – Jansons

February 23rd, 2011

Shostakovich Symphonies, conducted by Mariss Jansons, multiple orchestras ????
My first complete Shostakovich Symphony set was that conducted by Haitink, and also have complete sets by Barshai, Maxim Shostakovich, as well as multiple renditions of symphonies that do not have complete sets, such as symphonies conducted by Bernstein and von Karajan. Jansons seems to be the most novel of all the sets. Some symphonies did not sound entirely like what I heard out of the other performances. In many instances, such as his performance of the Fourth Symphony, it has a very accessible nature, probably the best 4th I’ve heard so far. Some of the recordings had annoying background noise and were not of highest quality. I still prefer Haitink as the all-round best performance of the Shostakovich symphonies, but consider Jansons in very rightful competition for the interpretation of these symphonies, and very much worth having in a music collection.

Living Stereo Collection

February 16th, 2011

Living Stereo Collection of Classical Music, RCA ????

This is a collection of 60 CDs, representing more than 60 albums of music published on vinyl under the Living stereo label. I remember having a number of these recordings as a teenager. They are now reproduced in CD format. For all of the CDs, the transfer was impeccable, with a brilliant and clean sound. Many of the performances are historically notable, such as the VanCliburn Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto. Also featured were many of the recordings of Fritz Reiner and the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, Charles Münch and the Boston Symphony Orchestra, as well as Jascha Heifetz. This set represents a super value, running at less than $2/disc when purchased on Amazon.com.

Music of Gregory Kufchak

February 16th, 2011

Homeland in Heaven, and Better than Light, by the MidOhio Chamber Players with the Apostolic Christian Church Choir, conducted by Gregory Kufchak ???

I have long sought for performances of the Zion’s Harp songs, the hymnal used by the Apostolic Christian Church. Kufchak has done a memorable service to this music by providing well-performed and orchestrated renditions of many Zion’s Harp songs, as well as a few of his own compositions and other music. Many of the songs had a ACCA translation (?), not the translation that  I was used to with the ACCN hymnal. Orchestration tended to be one-dimensional, in that the orchestra essentially paralleled the 4 part harmonies, with only an occasional embellishment. Kufchak tended to limit the amount of brass used in these pieces, and probably for good reason since the trumpets were seriously marginal in their performance.  I would wish that Kufchak continue his work, as he is to lauded for a great start in making public many Zion’s Harp songs. I hope that as he ages, his orchestrations develop a sophistication that complements rather than simply parallels the choir.

January 28th, 2011

Jesus of Nazareth, directed by Zino Zefferelli ? ? ? ? ?

Of all the films on the life of Jesus Christ, this has to be not only the longest, running a good 6 hours, but also the best done, with superb acting and very expensive props. It is clear tha an attempt for historical accuracy from a Biblical perspective was attempted, een though there is a moderate amount of directing freedom that has occurred. The film does have a touch of a Catholic “ring” to it, with Jesus running around as though he were a mythical character, but this film paints more humanity into Jesus than any of the other films available. Also, compared to the Jesus film, it is not so occupied with “in the face” emotionalism, but attempts a review of Christ’s life more akin to what you might see on tv with investigational reporting. Thus, it ranks in my estimate as much better than the Jesus film. This is a must see, long and demanding several nights to make it through the whole series, but is well worth it.

 

An Inconvenient Truth

January 16th, 2011

An Inconvenient Truth, by Rev. Algore ?

This film is labeled a documentary, but its entire format is really that of a sermon by Rev. Algore. There is very little documentary here. Included are also occasional testimonials by supposedly notable figures. There is much political jabbing, some of which is justified, but most of which is not. Approximately 95% of the entire film has at least 40% of the screen filled with Rev. Algore’s face. There are multiple clips that just don’t relate to the thesis of global warming, such as a complaint about how the votes were tallied in Florida, with the subsequent Supreme Court ruling, and no explanation as to what this had to do with the “inconvenient truth” of this film. The film is entirely about global warming, but unknowingly shows how Rev. Algore is particularly skilled at depleting carbon units, although he is exempt since he alone is allowed to consume mass quantities of energy. I can’t imagine the energy required to run Rev. Algore under the North Pole in a nuclear submarine and surface through the ice, just to add a 2 minute episode to the sermon. I could go on and on. Rev. Algore sanctimoniously suggests that the family farm quit growing tobacco because of the concern over lung cancer, yet it almost certainly was a result of declining reimbursements from tobacco. Rev. Algore’s tone of voice, inflections, and speaking style were much more like a sermon than a documentary. The fools who gave this film an Academy Award fail to offer how this film stood out in quality and credible research. The entire thesis of the film is based on supposed rising atmospheric levels of carbon dioxide, while Rev. Algore maintains a schoolboy belief in the accuracy and significance of the data and its extrapolations, without any questioning of the data. It shows the absurd fallacy of having a lawyer/politician pretend to be doing credible science. There is no doubt that there is some truth to what Rev. Algore is saying. There is a retreat of glaciers in the last few decades. There are certain interesting climate changes. Yet, Rev. Algore fails to substantiate the exact causal nature of these events, and chooses instead to promote emotionalism and extreme reactions, exactly what he accuses the Republican party of doing, though on other issues. If Rev. Algore didn’t make so many hard jabs at his political opponents, he might have gained a few more sympathetic ears. Making the weather a political rather than a pure environmental issue makes Rev. Algore ineffective and suspect as to his true intentions for making this film. It is thus hard for me to give this film even one star. It is not worth purchasing, though a single viewing is of value only to see the many gorgous faces of Rev. Algore. Global warming supporters may have a credible argument, but it certainly is not given in this film.

Hitchcock Presents

January 9th, 2011

Alfred Hitchcock Presents, Seasons 1-4 ?????

This is a television series which ran for four seasons. Each season contained 4 DVDs, each DVD lasting about 3 hours and each episode about 25 minutes. Hitchcock would come on at the beginning an ending, to discuss some aspect of the film about to be seen. Each episode would use first-class actors, and most plots were quite delightful. Towards the end of the fourth season, Betsy and I could usually guess approximately what the ending might be, as they are not what one would suspect. Interestingly, Hitchcock in this series is frequently imitated. After all, there is no greater director of suspense films than him. All the episodes are in black and white, and nothing objectionable as is usually found on television nowadays is seen in this series, with minimal violence and certainly no sex or smut. Hitchcock shows that one doesn’t have to resort to filth in order to entertain. There are no Hitchcock cameos that I could find in any of the episodes. In all, this is an enjoyable and suspenseful series that is most highly recommended for all viewers.

John Field concerti

January 9th, 2011

John Field Piano Concertos (sic), performed by Benjamin Frith, Northern Sinfonia ?????

First a brief comment about the English language. The pleural of concerto is NOT concertos but concerti. Unfortunately, we must live with this unbearable abuse of the common language. John Field is a little known contemporary of Ludwig v. Beethoven. That he is little known is a terrible travesty, since his concerti are so delightful. These 6 concerti on 3 CDs belong in the regular repertoire, as they are most compelling, and fascinating to hear. Field maintains a style that is distinctly classical, but distinctly different from Beethoven and more in line with Mozart or perhaps Schubert. These performances are crisply recorded, and though offered on a budget set, are definitely not budget recordings. They are most highly recommended by me. Though Field does not have much music that is offered in recorded form, he is worth seeking out for what little he may have out there. I have commented previously on the fact that British Isle music is generally lacking, with significant decent composers from those parts being able to be counted on one hand with most of the fingers amputated. Field is Irish, and would have to be added as one of the few that gets counted as a truly great British Isles (though NOT British!) composer.

Greenberg-The Music of Wagner

December 27th, 2010

Robert Greenberg- The Music of Wagner ????

It is hard to dislike anything that Greenberg does, and this Teaching Company series is no exception. Many of us waited for years for Greenberg to produce this set of lectures, as I’m sure it did not come easy to him. Throughout the lecture set, you sense a very strong love-hate relationship with Wagner and Greenberg. This feeling is reflected in the cynicism found throughout each and every lecture, though usually presented quite humorously, like suggesting, when the sword was named Notung, that perhaps Wagner even had a name for his pillow. In his animosity against the person of Wagner, Greenberg has forgotten his comments on the operas of other composers. Almost every opera has a silly if not ridiculous plot. Almost every opera is inconsistent with real life. No opera is believable. One could crack insults at Verdi for writing an opera where a larger-than-life character becomes fatally obsessed over a lost handkerchief, or a Puccini opera where ladies die of consumption at precise moments and heroes magically appear at the right moment to save tragedy, or Mozart operas where heads of state are made to look like bumbling idiots, Queens of the night appear out of no-where, etc., etc. Greenberg seems to love the music of Wagner, but writhes in agony at the consummate anti-semitism of the composer. Greenberg certainly is correct when he spends lengthy hours describing Wagner as inconsistent, arrogant, self-adoring, egotistical, impetuous, racist, mean-spirited, and any other possible negative epithet. All of these are correct, and would Wagner be alive today, he would be regarded as a despicable Arschloch. Greenberg is quite informative in showing how the thinking of Schöpenauer and virile anti-semitism is reflected in all of the music of Wagner, and this was most informative.

Greenberg does a marvelous job of following the chronological history of Wagner. Of interest is his almost certain Jewish father, which Wagner probably was aware of in forming many opera characters with lost identity. Greenberg probably added too much comment regarding Wagner’s desire for German unification. Most German intellectuals were desirous of unification, just as France had accomplished earlier, and Italy was in the process of accomplishing. It is wrong to presume that what was right for France, England, the United States and Italy was wrong for Germany, and perhaps the world wars came partially as a result of this prejudiced exceptionalism of the rest of the world to German unification. Wagner reflected a German ethos rather than a personal arrogance in desiring to see a unified country.

Greenberg is correct when he repeats often that one cannot separate the man from his music. He is incorrect in not stating that perhaps the greatest insult to Wagner the man is for his music to performed by Jewish conductors (such as Levine) with absolute disregard for the “deeper” meaning in his writings. Such disregard is not only possible but necessary, so that even in an unforgivably flawed person like Wagner, there remains genius to be appreciated. I await the day when a Jewish conductor with an all-Jewish orchestra from Israel performs Parsifal at Bayreuth in a comic fashion.

Felsenstein Edition

December 27th, 2010

Walter Felsenstein Edition ????

This set consists of  Beethoven: Fidelio ????, Janacek: The Cunning Little Vixen ???, Mozart: Don Giovanni ????, Verdi: Othello ?????, Offenbach: Les Contes d’Hoffman ?????, Offenbach: Barbe-Bleu ??, Mozart: Le Nozze de Figaro ????.

Felsenstein was the manager of the Comic Opera in east Berlin, and also the producer of these operas. There distinction with this set, is that the operas were all performed in German, though only Fidelio was actually written in German. They are also produced as movies for film. Oftentimes, the opera script was heavily edited, such as Fidelio, with a number of inessential sections removed. In the Tales of Hoffman, additional spoken material is added and acts 2 and 3 are reversed. The operas work unbelievably well in German, and the modifications mostly improve rather than diminish the operas. These recordings have as much a historical value as well as entertainment value. The first three operas above were in black and white and thus somewhat lacking in the best of quality. The latter operas were very impressive, and the Tales of Hoffman and Othello were competitive with the best productions of those operas. The singing and acting were superlative in all the operas. The only opera that I didn’t like so much was Offenbachs’ Barbe-Bleu, but that had nothing to do with Felsenstein or the production, as it was not an appealing opera compositionally.

Widor Complete Organ Works

December 27th, 2010

Widor Complete Organ Works, performed by Ben van Oosten ?????

Charles Marie Widor, principal organist at Saint Sulpice in Paris and the most distinguished organ position in all of France, commanded the international scene from the late 19th century up to his death in 1933. He had multiple distinguished students, including Louis Viernce, Dupre, Varese, as well as Albert Schweizer. Widor had a strong interest in the organ works of Bach, and these organ works definitely have the distinct imprint of Bach on them. These are very attractive works, and while his most memorable organ symphony is his 5th, it would be a disservice to one’s self to limit listening to only his 5th symphony, as the grand total of his ouvre is remarkable and worth listening to. This set consists of 7 CD’s, and Ben van Oosten does a marvelous and flawless job of performance. I have not heard other sets of Widor and so can’t offer comparison, though this set seems to have a high rating on most public forums.

Vierne Organ Works

December 27th, 2010

24 Pieces en style libre, 24 Pieces de Fantasie, Complete Organ Symphonies, by Ben van Oosten ????

Louis Vierne was an assistant to Charles-Marie Widor in Paris, and during the first third of the 20th century was a formidable organist at Saint Sulpice in Paris. He was legally blind, and had a fairly unfortunate life, being involved in an accident which injured his left leg, having an unfortunate marriage and social life, but otherwise commanding a great presence in the organ scene. His improvisations often became the subject of many of the compositions above. While he is distinctly different from Widor, there are many similarities in their compositional style, including a Debussy-style compositional trait of painting moods rather than distinctive tunes. The result is organ music that is very easy to listen to, yet compelling enough to never venture towards being boring. Vierne is unfortunately not well enough known, and his works are definite masterpieces worth belonging in a good classical collection. There are a grand total of 9 CD’s in this 3 set collection, and the performance by Ben van Oosten is most compelling.

Rocky and Bullwinkle

December 27th, 2010

Rocky and Bullwinkle, seasons 1-4 ?????

It’s a cartoon, but it’s intended for adults as much as for children, so that both will appreciate and laugh at the jokes and antics. Bullwinkle is a moose without too much of a brain, and Rocky is his partner the flying squirrel, with only slightly more intelligence. Together, they fight the arch-criminals Boris Badenov and Natasha from Pottsylvania. Between the Rocky and Bullwinkle story is multiple other features, such as the fractured fairy tales, Aesop’s fables, Dudley Do-right, Mr. Know-it-all, and other small fragments, mostly featuring Bullwinkle. If you remember any of the Bullwinkle series, this is very much worth sitting through. Eventually, the last (5th) season will be made available. Until then, we’ll continue to enjoy most of the antics of the dynamic duo fighting crime and evil.

Shostakovich Piano Trios

December 17th, 2010

Shostakovich Piano Trios #1 & 2, Seven Romances on verses by Alexander Blok ?????

I’ve been listening to the works of the Beaux Arts Trio, who perform a number of classical as well as modern composers, but have selected a few that are my favorites. Of the modern composers, Shostakovich has written the best piano trios. They are tuneful, easy to listen to, and conducive to many repeat listening sessions. There aren’t many piano trios that are wearisome to listen to, whether they are from Beethoven, Mozart, Chausson, Faure, Brahms, or whoever. Yet, the Shostakovich trios stand out as the best of the best. These are NOT Schubert quartets. They are far more soulful, heart-wrenching, agonizing. The trios are accompanied by seven romances that consist of the piano trio plus a solo soprano, also well done, but doesn’t totally fit with the two trios on this disc. For the 20th century classic music aficionado, these are piano trios of that genre at their best, and a must-have.

Schubert Piano Trios

December 17th, 2010

Schubert Piano Trios, performed by the Beaux Arts Trio ?????

This is a most compelling set of piano trios and flawlessly performed by the Beaux Arts Trio. Schubert’s best knack is that of coming up with highly memorable tunes, developing them in complex fashions, and then delivering them in a most enjoyable fashion. These discs are very easy listening, and yet would not be identified as “elevator music” as creative genius exudes from each measure that is performed. Of all my music (of which there is much), this is one of my favorite sets for a relaxed encounter with the sublime.

Haydn Piano Trios

December 17th, 2010

Haydn Piano Trios, performed by the Beaux Arts Trio ?????

I’ll be reviewing the Haydn piano trios here, and the following two reviews will go over the Schubert and Shostakovich trios by the same group. All of the performances are superbly done,with a delicacy and interpretive style that conveys a richness to the pieces that are hard to not notice. The Haydn piano trios are a “must hear” set. This is a lengthy set as one would expect with Haydn, but gives an opportunity to see the progression of composition style of Haydn. The first trios of a young Haydn are attractive but slightly pedantic, with a sense of predictability, but the later trios truly reflect the genius of Haydn. It is possible that the interaction with Mozart, especially with the novel compositional style of the Mozart Haydn quartets, triggered the most delightful and mature Haydn to compose as he did. With the superlative performances of the Beaux Arts trio, this is a set that should be in every classical collection.

Kenneth Fuchs

December 5th, 2010

Fuchs: An American Place, etc., performed by London Symphony Orchestra ???

Kenneth Fuchs is a contemporary composer who teaches music at a college in the mid-west. Having a name roughly similar to my own, it piqued my curiosity. It was quite easy to listen to him, much against my expectations for a contemporary composer. Actually, it sounds like a merger between modern music and elevator music. This is not intended to be an insult but a compliment. There is nothing in these pieces that stood out as either bad or superlative. Fuchs has potential as a composer, and will keep an eye out for subsequent works from him.

Glass Violin Concerto

December 5th, 2010

Glass: Violin Concerto, etc., performed by Adele Anthony and Ulster Orchestra ????

Philip Glass creates a violin concerto and other works that do not seem to press the virtuosic abilities of the performer so much provide a minimalistic but not monotonous array of tones that enchant the hearer. I’m not a huge fan of minimalistic music, and would probably die at a Glass opera. This music lacks the intensity of a Wagner or Beethoven, or the cacophony of a late Schönberg. It is easy on the listener. The performance is very well done, and recording made with highest standards. This is a good buy for the budget price that one would find with most Naxos discs. It is to be commended to those who appreciate minimalistic music.

Rubinstein – Chopin

November 26th, 2010

The Chopin Collection, performed by Artur Rubinstein, on the RCA Victor Gold Seal label ???

This is a historic collection, and thus contains much disturbing recording noise to it, though in many of the tracks, it tends to be less apparent. There are now a number of Chopin collections, including the Biret and Ashkenazy collection, both of which are superb. I also have  other Chopin recordings by a potpourri of other performers, and the historic performer that is my favorite is Vladimir Horowitz. Artur Rubinstein (not related to Anton Rubinstein) was a Polish-America Jewish child prodigy, making his greatest claim in the interpretation of Chopin. His was a somewhat wanton life, living as a hedonist, though occasionally expressing moral approbation when his personal value system was affronted. While fighting “racism”, he arrogantly manifested himself as the greatest racist and intolerant to others not of his own thinking. Like Richard Wagner, his own personal life and character tends to distract from the personal genius of the man. This is an inexpensive set worth having for historical reasons, though better recordings are now available.

Ancient Empires Before Alexander

November 26th, 2010

Ancient Empires Before Alexander, by Robert Dise, from the Teaching Company ????

Many of my recent Teaching Company reviews have been less than favorable, but this series is an exception. Covering in this series is a discussion of the rise of the concept of empires, first noted historically by Sargon in Mesopotamia. Dise proceeds to then discuss the Ur kingdom, the Kassites, Hatti (the Hittites), Egypt, Minoan and Mycenaean empires, Israel, Assyria, neo-Babylon, Persia, and finally Carthage. Throughout, Dise remains informative as well as interesting. His discussions do not err as many in extrapolations of data, but instead gives a good review of our current knowledge of the various empires above. My most serious complaint is his treatment of Israel and use of the Biblical data. It is so often the case that while trying to maintain an air of objectivism and critical review of the sources of ancient literature, one fails to appreciate the differences in stylistic writing that would clue one into the credibility of the literature in question. Such is the case with the Biblical script, which should not come under doubt simply because it is also considered a religious genre. Other than that, it is nice to see that moderns did not invent the concept of empire, which existed from earliest written history. It is not a question of whether or not empires will exist, but rather, who will lead and control those empires. All empires have had the tendency to be expansionistic. Some empires desired expansion for economic reasons (Carthage), many for defense of borders, and some simply for the joy of lording over others. Power seems to remain throughout history a stronger driving force than wealth or any other characteristic in motivating empire. This series does a masterful job of helping one explore the concept of empire, and understanding those driving factors throughout mankind that drives for empire.

Saint-Saëns Choral Works

November 13th, 2010


Saint-Saëns; Oratorio de Noël performed by the Bachchor and Bachorchester Mainz ?????; Requiem and Psaume XVIII, by the L’Orchestre National D’Ile France ????

Both of these works are excellent, that oddly have not made it into the standard repertoire . The first piece, a Christmas oratorio, is superbly performed with sensitivity to the script. Neither piece has catchy tunes to titillate the senses or become the object of Hollywood movie moguls. Both have a sweetness to them that make listening easy. Saint-Saëns varies from simplicity to complexity in the pieces while avoiding the bombastic attacks of orchestra and choir as Händel and others might do. Both are high recommendations.

Liszt-Various Choral Works

November 6th, 2010

Liszt: Graner Messe, performed by Orchestra and Chorus-Paris/Sorbonne ?????
St. Stanislaw, Cincinnati May Festival ????
Missa Choralis and Via Crucis, by Corydon Singers ????
Requiem, performed by the Hungarian Army Male Chorus ???
Sacred Choral Music, Chorus of Radio Svizzera Lugano ????

Franz Liszt is mostly known for his piano music. During his lifetime, he underwent various phases. Starting first as a virtuoso performer of the piano, Liszt set new standards throughout the music world of what was expected of a solo music performer. Eventually, he would write more complex pieces for the piano than what was then existent in order to showcase his performance technique. Later in his life, he retreated to a monastery. Living most of his life as a European playboy and “rockstar”, it is a little bit unusual to get a large proliferation of sacred music from him. Yet, the quality of this music is variable but quite good. Of all the CDs reviewed briefly here, the Graner Messe was the best in both composition and performance, and St. Stanislaw close behind. The Corydon Singers do an orchestrated version of the Via Crucis, and quite capably performed. The other Via Crucis found on the last CD was quite anemic, and was the piano and male chorus version of the work. This Via Crucis was a bit anemic, the piano version being performed much better by the Netherlands Chamber Choir and found on the Philips label. The last piece, Liszt’s Requiem, was also performed somewhat marginally, and could have been more convincing in its presentation. Though I appreciate the choral works of Liszt, I find that his piano compositions are far more enjoyable and best demonstrate Liszt’s creativity.

More Shostakovich

November 4th, 2010

Shostakovich: Girlfriends, performed by the Polish National Radio Symphony Orchestra, the Tale of the Priest and His Worker, Balda, Songs and Waltzes, performed by the Russian Philharmonic Orchestra with Thomas Sanderling ?????

As with my previous post, the review of these CDs reflect my horrid infatuation with the music of Shostakovich. All three of these CDs were budget, yet absolute marvelous specimens of music, impeccably and creatively performed, charming, enjoyable, and compelling. The Songs and Waltzes were particularly attractive, in definite competition with the best of the Johann Strauss waltzes. Shostakovich is not known well enough for his greatness. Much of the music on these CDs is totally accessible. They are not atonal pieces of cacophony so typical of much modern music, but reflect a creativity distinctive of 20th century music while not straining the ear of the listener, and very tuneful. Thus, my highest recommendations.

Shostakovich Film Music

November 3rd, 2010

Shostakovich: Odna, Hamlet, The Fall of Berlin, Suite from the Unforgettable Year 1919, performed by the Moscow Symphony Orchestra ?????

Those of you who know me well know that I am crazy about Shostakovich. He is, in my opinion, the greatest composer of the 20th century. These works are “pop” works of his, totally accessible, catchy, tonal, entirely tonic-dominant music. Yet, it is creative and possessing a clear brilliance. These are more collector pieces rather than something one would like to time and again. Some pieces, like the Fall of Red Hill in the Unforgettable Year 1919 suite, are absolute masterpieces of all time. The only regrets that I have while listening to these CDs is that the films are not themselves available with English subtitles (0f course). These CDs were purchased separately but were sold by Amazon.com as budget CDs, yet they are NOT budget music presentations.

Mendelssohn Chorwerke

November 3rd, 2010

Mendelssohn Chorwerke, performed by the Chamber Choir of Europe with Nicol Matt ?????

These choral works are entirely religious, and encompass the breadth of Mendelssohn’s career. Purchased from Amazon.com, they are a steal at less than $3/disc. Some are works that are quite popular, such as Hör mein Bitten, but performed better than more expensive recordings that I have purchased in the past. There was no piece in this set that was inferior, and the soloists were always in top form, not weak as is often heard with Mendelssohn performances. It is a pity that Mendelssohn is so seriously overlooked, especially among church choirs. It is also a pity that Nicol Matt is not better known, as he is a first-rate conductor. Perhaps works like this will draw more attention to Mendelssohn, and we will see more high quality performances of his work.

Cherubini String Quartets

November 3rd, 2010

Cherubini: The String Quartets, performed by the Melos Quartet ?????

Five stars should not suggest that these are my favorite quartets. For contemporaries, I certainly prefer the quartets of Beethoven or Schubert. Yet, these quartets have a delightful charm of their own, and worthy of highest recommendation. The Melos Quartet offers a very spirited interpretation, making it a joy to listen to each one of these six quartets. Cherubini is often forgotten, though one must remember that both Hayden and Beethoven praised with works. Anybody who listens attentively to these quartets will understand why Cherubini should stand among the great classical composers. Both the quartets as well as his religious choral works are charming, creative and enjoyable to listen to.

Schumann Secular Choral Works

October 29th, 2010

Schumann: The Secular Choral Works performed by Studio Vocale Karlsruhe ?????

A one time I never found much of interest in Schumann. Now that I’m re-listening to a number of his works, they are gaining a fascination. This album is no exception. The performances are charming and impeccable, very masterfully done. Each piece has its own delights, and provides for differing styles and types of works. This set is a budget set that consists of four CDs, and is a true bargain that will delight.

Vaughn Williams Sacred Choral Music

October 29th, 2010

Vaughn Williams Sacred Choral Music, performed by the Choir of Clare College, Cambridge ??

These set of songs were adequately performed, but lacked brilliance and charm. It is typical of Vaughn Williams to have very predictable music, so that if one has heard one Vaughn Williams piece, you’ve heard them all. There is nothing about these choral pieces to excite the soul or transcend the realm of the ennui. I purchased this CD hoping to find in VW and British music some charm—but, British music, like British food, tends to be bland and uninteresting. The Brits have failed to produced good composers, outside of Purcell and the Beatles. The more I listen to VW, I realize that it is not a matter of missing something in the music that is subtle or complex, such as learning to appreciate the music of Wagner. The music of VW is just plain boring and uncreative.

Glass String Quartets

October 20th, 2010

Glass String Quartets, performed by the Carducci Quartet ????

I am not a big fan of Philip Glass, but these quartets were quite appealing to me. True, they possessed a minimalist aspect to them, with much repetitive structures. In opera, minimalism creates boredom. It does just the opposite in the string quartets, creating a relaxed, meditative atmosphere. Yet, Glass maintains enough character to the overall flow of the pieces to lend character and distinction to each movement and each quartet. This made listening a joy rather than a matter of endurance. These quartets are a “must hear” for anybody who enjoys the whole panoply of classic music.

Barber Piano Concerto

October 20th, 2010

Samuel Barber Piano Concerto, Prutsman, Royal Scottish National Orchestra ???

This and the next review focus on contemporary American composers. Samuel Barber is best known for Barber’s Adagio, popularized by Bernstein. This disc contains not only the Piano Concerto, but several other short works by Barber. The performance was technically adequate, but the pieces lacked an overall luster to them. Perhaps the performers didn’t have a chance? Barber seems to have a sense of non-direction to his music, being occasionally bombastic, occasionally quiet, but never leading anywhere. Fortunately, it was reasonably tonal and thus endured listening to. This is not exactly a disc that I’d encourage you to rush out and purchase.

La Fille du Regiment

October 19th, 2010

La Fille du Regiment, by Donizetti, starring Natalie Dessay ???

Donizetti was an extremely productive early 19th century Italian opera composer, though most of his works go unperformed at this time. His greatest works include this opera, as well as Lucia de Lammermoor, L’elixir d’Amore, Anna Bolena, and a few others. This is probably the poorest conceived of his better known operas, and best known with Joan Sutherland as the star daughter of the regiment. In this opera, Natalie Dessay is the star. Her vocal qualities do not compete with the excellence of Dame Joan, though her acting and overall operatic skills make her one of the better daughters to ever have filled this role. Thus, it was a delight and joy to watch. The staging was a cross between traditional and minimalist, and served as much as a distraction as a help to the overall flow of the opera. This is not one of my favorite operas. The music is not memorable, and the plot contrived. A baby girl (Marie) is picked up and raised by a French army regiment, but recovered by a rich Tyrolean couple who think that she is their long-lost daughter, and arrange a marriage for her though she is love with a Tyrolean Toni who she met in the regiment and who joined the French regiment in order to marry her. Eventually Tonio and Marie resolve the issues that hold them apart. Yawn! Ho-hum.

Ormandy

October 19th, 2010

Ormandy Collection ???

This is the last of the budget series that I’ll be reviewing, with the conducting of Eugene Ormandy. Eugene Ormandy was born in Hungary as Jeno Blau, being a prodigy that received a masters degree in music at age 14 before coming to the US. After a short stay as director of the Minnesota symphony, he moved and stayed for 40 years at the Philadelphia Philharmonic. Though his major mentor was Toscanini, his style and form are much different from this conductor. Ormandy excelled at modern works, and his renditions of Shönberg works were notable. Many of his works in this set were straight forward, though the recordings left something to be desired. His performance of Mahler’s second symphony was quite poor and left something to be desired. At least Ormandy never felt the urge to speed through a piece like Toscanini. It is without a doubt that Ormandy is one of the great US conductors of the 20th century, though this set would tend to betray Ormandy at his best. My advice would be to seek out Ormandy recordings, but not this set of recordings. There are better out there.

Furtwängler

October 15th, 2010

Wilhelm Furtwängler Collection ????

This is the second of three composer collections that I will be reviewing, the first being that of Arturo Toscanini. Furtwängler possesses far greater sensitivity in his conducting that Toscanini. Furtwängler was the director of the Berlin Symphony Orchestra during the second world war years, and was eventually replaced by Herbert von Karajan. It is without hesitation that I could remark on the greatness of Furtwängler as a conductor, in spite of his associations with Hitler and the Nazis. These recordings are quite variable, many of them having much record noise, but many being quite clean. For $17 it is hard to beat as a sampling of Furtwängler. The collection includes mostly classical and romantic composers, with a few non-German composers included.

The Clay Bird

October 12th, 2010

The Clay Bird, directed by Tarique Masud ??

This film is a quasi-historic depiction of life in Bangladesh just before the 1971 independence. It selects out a family whose father turns hard-line Muslim, sending his child off to Madrasa (Muslim education school), and depending on Allah during a child’s illness, leading to the death of his daughter and alienation from his wife. There wasn’t much of a plot– this is more a depiction of daily life and the struggles for faith and country that a typical Muslim household might have experienced in the pre-war years.The movie attempts a gentle and supportive rendering of the Islam faith, but instead shows it as a cruel uncaring religion before a merciless god. Sadly, most reviewers of this film on Amazon didn’t see it as such. The film has its strengths in showing regular life in Bangladesh, which is little changed since independence. Being a strict Muslim country, it still possesses much of the religious behavior that is shown in this film, though the intellectuals of the films were wiped out during the war with west Pakistan which I feel has led to an even more oppressive and depressive public ethos. The film ends in tragedy, which is exactly what a combination of hardline Muslim faith and war among Muslims will do. I enjoyed the film as being one of the first that was spoken mainly in Bengali, and I even was able to understand a few words.

Nordwand

October 10th, 2010

Nordwand (North Face) ?????

This movie is based on the true story of the attempt of the north face of the Eiger in 1936 by Toni Kurz and Andi Hinterstoisser. As of 1936, the north face of the Eiger had not yet been climbed, and pressure from the German regime to climb it before the Olympic games for Nazi propaganda was high. Two climbers from Bavaria were enticed, and this is their story. It is told mostly from the vantage point of Toni’s ex-girlfriend Luise, who is a photojournalist for the Berliner Zeitungen. The climb starts out marvelously, but disasters with an Austrian team pursuing close behind eventually lead to the death of all four members of the Bavarian and Austrian teams. Naturally, because they all perished, the exact story had to be surmised and fabricated in a good Hollywood fashion. Yet, it is presented in a compelling drama that keeps one on their seats for the entire movie. The attempted route of Kurz and Hinterstoisser becomes the route used by German climbers two years later to be the first to conquer the Nordwand. I love climbing films, and this film was exceptionally well done, with cinematography that was truly impressive. This is a wonderful, clean film that anybody could enjoy. It is in German with English subtitles.

Toscanini

October 9th, 2010

Toscanini, A collection of his works ??

It is typical that the first performance of any classical work that one hears, if well performed, tends to stick in ones mind, and defines for hearings of other performances a standard to measure up to. I grew up on Toscanini, and was told repeatedly that he was one of the greatest conductors of the twentieth century. I remember sitting for hours, listening to nothing but Toscanini. In the case of Toscanini, the rule introduced at the beginning has not held true, and I have found much better recordings and performances of just about everything that Toscanini has to offer. This compendium of 10 CDs of his works confirms that statement. Toscanini tends to always be very sharp, bombastic, and unfeeling in his performances. Somehow, he seems to think that if a work is flawlessly performed in double the meter of any other conductor, it is better performed. Toscanini just has no feel as to the soul of any piece of classical music. There is nothing on this CD that I have not heard better performed by other conductors. Toscanini does a reasonable job with the American composers like Gershwin and Grofe, but destroys Wagner. I will be comparing two other conductor sets in this series, one with Furtwängler and the other with Ormandy. Furtwängler is not my favorite composer but is total delight to listen to, after having one’s ears abused with Toscanini. In addition, the recordings in this set are poorly cleaned up, and much of the record noise and tinny sound remains. They could have done better, though this set was only $17 for 10 CDs so it’s hard to complain too bitterly. The  good grace of this set is that it is very inexpensive, and does give one a proper feel for Toscanini.

Edition Bachakadamie Hänssler

October 9th, 2010

Edition Bachakademie Hänssler, mostly featuring Helmut Rilling ?????

This is now my second hearing of this set of 172 CDs, consisting of all the known works of Johann Sebastian Bach. There exist two other collections of his works, one put out by Brilliant Records, and the other by Teldec. I do not have the Teldec set, but will probably purchase it when it becomes available again. This set, costing about $1600 (I paid much less for it), is now being offered for $300 on Amazon.com, which should be a total steal. The Hänssler edition is the only collection that utilizes adults and modern instrumentation for the productions of all the cantatas and other choral works. The only exception, of course, is the boys choir in the Mätthaus Passion. There are better performances many of Bach’s cantatas. I feel that Karl Richter’s cantatas are superior in terms of feeling and expressive content, though Richter offers less than half of all of Bach’s cantatas. Rilling is a most capable conductor, offering the complete cantatas and other vocal works of Bach, with more compelling performances than any of the other complete collections. The Brilliant and Teldec sets oftentimes uses boy performers, which can easily become quite wearisome to the ears. Rilling, like Richter, avoids period instruments, thus giving a brilliance and charm to the works that other performances do not possess. Regarding using modern vs. original instrumentation, the keyboard works for harpsichord are variously performed in this set, occasionally with a piano, occasionally with a clavecin, and usually with a harpsichord. I appreciate harpsichord music, but, much dynamics of performance appear to be missing with a harpsichord. Even when a piano is used instead of a harpsichord, the performer usually tends to plays the piano in a fashion like I was taught, to make it sound like a harpsichord. This ends up in a rather mechanical sound, that might be imitated by a piano roll. Perhaps, this is why I really appreciate the Bach performances of Glen Gould, who breaks out of the mold of original instrument thinking, and allows Bach to speak in a new and fresh fashion. Sometimes, an unusual array of instruments are used, such as in the Wohltemperte Klavier, where the harpsichord, organ and Clavicin are all variously utilized. The keyboard works were quite variable, though most with quite convincing and compelling performances, even though a number were more routinely and mechanically driven. In total, this set is an amazing compendium of mostly top notch, well performed Bach. The cantatas are the selling point of this set, though that should not diminish the attractiveness of the rest of the works on the set, whether they be keyboard, violin or cello sonatas, or any of the other plenteous compositions of the greatest of all composers of all time. Any lover of Bach must have this set: it will be treasured for many hearings.

Les Contes d’Hoffman

October 1st, 2010

Les Contes d’Hoffman (The Tales of Hoffman), by Jacques Offenbach, performed by Covent Garden, starring Placido Domingo ?????

Les Contes d’Hoffman is opera at its best, and this is a superlative performance of that opera. Domingo makes a perfect Hoffman. This performance utilized different opera stars for each of the women in Hoffman’s life, as well as a different “evil man” for each act. The story starts and ends in a tavern adjacent to an opera house, and Hoffman is led to tell the story of the lost loves in his life, all of which are based on short stories by ETA Hoffman. The first is Olympia, a young girl that Hoffman falls deeply in love with, only to discover that she is a mechanical doll. The next act, Hoffman falls in love with a courtesan in a harem, only to end up losing his shadow. The third is a young musician, told not to sing by her father, but encouraged to her death by Dr. Miracle. The music in each act of this opera, as well as the prologue and epilogue are unforgettable and often copied by later composers. This is one of the desert island operas that one would wish to watch many times over, and this is a wonderful performance of that wonderful opera.

Schumann Masterworks

September 29th, 2010

Schumann Masterworks: Multiple performers, produced by Deutsche Grammophon ?????

This is a wonderful mix of Schumann’s compositions, including his symphonies and other orchestral works, concertos, large choral works, songs, chamber music, and a rather comprehensive mix of his solo piano works. There are multiple performers, so that even in the piano works, you’ll hear a number of different pianists, including Pollini, Ashkenazy and others. Not all the works are the best of Schumann. As an example, Karajan does a much better job of the symphonies than does Gardner included in this set. The Lieder (songs) are very compelling, and offer a superb portrayal of Schumann at his best. Before my listening of Karajan’s rendering of the Schumann symphonies, I have never paid much attention to the works of Schumann as they have tended to be bland. Between Karajan, Kempff, and this set of Schumann Masterworks, life is brought into the Schumann compositions that has stirred my interest in this composer. This set contains 35 CDs and is well worth the price that one can find on the internet.

Schumann Piano Works

September 29th, 2010

Schumann Piano Works, by Wilhelm Kempff ?????

This is not a comprehensive collection of Schumann’s piano works, but rather an assembly of his most popular romantic works. Kempff performs flawlessly and with spirit, making them appealing. As with his Schubert performances, Kempff is one of the best interpreters of the early Romantic composers, and deserves a careful listening. This set consists of 4 CDs, and is usually sold quite reasonably through Amazon.com.

Avatar

September 29th, 2010

Avatar ??

This has to be one of worst films that I’ve seen in recent times. The only reason for two stars is that the graphics are incredibly well done.  The story is how a group of earthmen (mostly Marines and scientists) have need for a certain ore on a distant planet Pandora occupied by tall blue people called Navi. The earthmen have no regard for the environment of the planet, and run ripshod to tear up “sacred” landscape in order to obtain their ore. Eventually, the natives win out and are able to drive out the earthlings. So, what’s wrong with the film? 1. Character development: acting was poor. None of the characters in the film could be called admirable. Most were sullen, angry people (or Navi) bent on idolization of themselves. Sig. Weaver was a worn out hag. The Navi were angry, never happy, quite war-like and certainly not at peace even with themselves. The military marines and scientists were painted at thoughtless, brain-dead, clueless. The earth “traitors” that went over to the Navi side lacked any sort of insightful virtue. 2. Plot. This film has often been criticized for portraying developers and industrialists against environmentalists. That is too simple of an analysis. It one looks at the  Navi, they are essentially dressed with African animistic paraphernalia, and the thematic structure of their “religion” is essentially animistic and pantheistic, with the world “force” emanating out though every living being that is connected to the “mother”. Animism didn’t get the Africans and other primitive tribes too far, and fantasy films are now necessary to promote such religion of animism that is taking over America by storm. In total, this film make it for its graphics arts effects and not for its story, and so barely deserves two stars.

Claude Chabrol Collection

September 26th, 2010

Claude Chabrol Collection ????

Each of the films will be reviewed separately. Chabrol has a very distinctive style in his movies, and oftentimes uses his wife as the main female character. Many of his actors are repeat players, and it’s fun to meet different people playing differing roles.  All in all, the collection deserves four stars, though with its criticisms. These are very unlike American films! All the films are in French, with English subtitles optional. The speaking is usually not too difficult to follow in French, though the subtitles definitely help.

Juste avant la nuit ????

This is the story evolves around a central character Charles Masson secretly murdering his best friend’s wife after having an affair with her. Charles is riddled with guilt, initially telling his wife, and then his best friend, both offering acceptance and forgiveness. Regardless, Charles is unable to psychologically cope with this guilt, which ultimately leads to his ruin. The gist of the movie is the absence of an absolute morality, and that psychological internal factors are our judge. Chabrol is masterful at exploring the psychology of guilt in this movie, similar to that seen in Woody Allen’s Crimes and Misdemeanors. Though the movie starts with a brief episode of female nudity, the remainder is clean enough for general viewing, and would be a shame to refuse a good film thinking that the film was going to mostly be off-color.

La femme infidele  ????

This is a suspenseful story of a lawyer from Paris living in the countryside close to Versaille, who discovers that his wife is having an affair with somebody in town. He learns of his identify and then murders him. The police remain on the track of the murderer, who never solve the murder mystery. His wife does discover that he is probably the murderer but remains silent. Chabrol is skillful at holding suspense but never in an on-the-edge-of-your-seat fashion. Thus, the art of a slowly unfolding plot that never is obvious as to direction.

Le Boucher ????

The film starts at a wedding, at which the young but well-known butcher in town Popaul encounters the town head school mistress Helene and falls in love with her. Simultaneously, a series of brutal murders takes place. Slowly, Helene sorts out that it is Popaul who is committing the killings. Eventually, Popaul commits suicide. Though a simple plot, the story unveils in a Hitchcock style that holds suspense while typically leaving one unsure as to who-done-it. This is considered one of Chabrol’s best films.

Les Biches ???

This is an odd film, entertaining the mixing of complex though maladjusted characters. A rich woman Frederique encounters a street artist (Why) in Paris and falls in love. They go live in a villa in St. Tropez where a third person, a male architect is encountered, first falling in love with Why, and then soon after with Frederique. When the architect and Frederique decide to return to Paris without Why, Why murders Frederique. Chabrol artfully develops this dark drama, bringing in other characters, such as a gay male couple living at Frederique’s estate in St. Tropez. I rated this movie a 3-star, since Chabrol attempts profundity through what are essentially shallow characters. This is not one of his better films.

Les noces rouges ???

This film is a very strange story, though in many ways similar to the other Chabrol movies. Here, the wife of the mayor of a town is having an affair with the mayor’s chief assistant Pierre, who is having a terrible marriage of his own. Pierre eventually murders his wife, and then the mayor in order to allow their relationship to go unhindered. Yet, the mayor’s daughter detects what is happening, and turns mom into the police, causing both to be arrested. The movie is most interesting simply for the way Chabrol weaves the flow of the story line in a most unpredictable fashion.

Madame Bovary ???

Chabrol’s version of Madame Bovary, well acted, though Madame Bovary not exactly the seductive vixen that she is supposed to be. Otherwise, this is well acted and holds reasonably well to the story line of the novel.

Nada ????

Nada is the name of a revolutionary organization in France, which has just kidnapped the ambassador to the USA. Eventually the police discover the whereabouts of the group in a distant farmhouse, though use heavy handed means to corner the group, leading to the death of the principals of both the police and the terrorist group. As typical of Chabrol, the outcomes are not predictable, except that one can be assured that his films will never end with a happy end, this film included. Nada does hold ones attention for the unveiling of the plot as a police detective film.

Que la bête meure ?????

Known in English as “This Man Must Die”, this is probably my favorite film of the collection. It is a suspenseful thriller that starts with a young boy being killed in a hit-and-run accident. The boy’s father Charles slowly weaves out clues that lead to the killer, who is an influential businessman in Northern France. The killer has a most repugnant character, and all who know him wish for him to be dead. Thus, the complexity of sorting out the murderer in the end, when the killer is found dead by poisoning. Chabrol does excellent character development and flow of action in this film, with the usual French characteristic of most films of leaving the films’ conclusion not entirely certain and thus to the imagination, but definitely not a happy end.

The Secret Labyrinth

September 24th, 2010

A Secret Labyrinth, with the Huelgas Ensemble conducted by Paul Van Nevel ????

This compendium of early music (medieval and renaissance) was a pleasant surprise. Carrying a quite inexpensive price tag, the performances are flawlessly executed, yet with enough spirit to make them quite enjoyable. This is a mixture of sacred and secular pieces, and a broad spectrum of composers.  It is distinctly early music, being polyphonic yet without the compositional characteristics of music for the modern ear. This album is a delight, and medieval music at its best.

Peter Grimes

September 12th, 2010

Peter Grimes, by Benjamin Britten, starring Peter Pears, conducted by Britten, made for t.v. ?

This is an opera that has been recorded for DVD at least 5-6 times, and usually gets a 5-star rating. This performance by the composer himself has the highest reviews of all. Yet, both Betsy and I sat entirely bewildered for at least 2 hrs. and 15 minutes. This piece did not appear to have any remarkable creativity at all. It is exactly the sing-songy type speech one would make if one chose to satirize an opera. The story line also was entirely incoherent. It was quite obvious that Britten wished to make strong anti-Christian statements, but did so quite poorly, the story line showing hypocritical Christian leaders condemning Peter Grimes, and not showing sympathy for him. Yet, it was Peter Grimes that was money-grubbing, resulting in driving a child to death at the beginning of the opera and then the end of the opera again. No wonder the “Christian” folk were upset! Britten was a flagrant homosexual, and his lover was Peter Pears, thus, he wrote many pieces supposedly for Peter Pears. Perhaps his utilization of a boy-servant for Peter Grimes was not quite appropriate in such a setting. All in all, this work had no consistency for music, there were no musical episodes that one could call great composed music, the plot was horrible, and if a statement was attempted to be made, it was made quite poorly. This is an opera that I would never waste my time watching again. Don’t waste your time.

Der Fliegende Holländer

September 9th, 2010

Der Fliegende Holländer, by Richard Wagner, conducted by Wolfgang Sawallisch, starring Donald McIntyre as der fliegende Holländer, and Catarina Ligendza as Senta ?????

This opera production has received mixed reviews with Amazon.com, being that it was a filmed version and not a staged version of the opera, and that there were short deletions in the full performance of the opera. I can appreciate criticisms regarding deletions, but not on objection to the opera being filmed in life-like circumstances. I consider the opposite of film versions, to be minimalist opera, which seems to be exactly fly in the face as to why composers wrote operas rather than oratorios–because they expected the staging/scenery to contribute to the statement of the opera. To change the scene from what the composer wrote is (in my not so humble) opinion similar to changing the musical script itself. Meanwhile, back to this opera. First, the musical performance was superb. Both McIntyre and Ligendza have superb voices, and the supporting vocalists were all first class. The live scenery was more effective at conveying the opera story than a staged version would have ever done. Of the two things that have made opera accessible to modern populaces, undertitles (supratitles at the opera) and filmed versions have been the most effective at spreading the appeal of opera to normal folk. I would certainly like to see more productions like this, especially with the Wagner operas, such as Tannhäuser or der Meistersinger. While playing this opera, I asked Betsy to guess the composer, and she was quite surprised to learn that it was Wagner. She had thought that Wagner did not write melodious opera that could appeal to all. This opera, and this production in particular, is a wonderful way to begin entry into the world of Wagner, before tackling his more mature works.

The Fugitive

September 9th, 2010

The Fugitive, starring Harrison Ford, Tommy Lee Jones  ?????

This is Harrison Ford at his best, filmed mostly in Chicago. It is a suspenseful thriller, Harrison Ford playing the role of a vascular surgeon, Dr. Richard Kimble, falsely sentenced to death for murdering his wife. He manages to escape while being hauled to prison, and then weaves a tale of running from the detectives, while sorting out the identity of the actual killer of his wife. There were a few unbelievable sections, such as when he survives a leap into the spill-out of a dam, and the solitary persistence of the detectives on pursuing Dr. Kimble, with Dr. Kimble remaining only a few steps ahead of them, both parties seeming to know exactly where the other party was going. Even so, it makes a great story and thrilling plot. Mostly, I enjoyed seeing Chicago again. I left Cook County Hospital in 1990, and this was filmed in 1993. Clearly, the insides were not completely Cook County Hospital, but there were recognizable characters, such as Dr. Roxanne (Rocky) Roberts, who was several years ahead of me in residency and stayed on staff in the trauma unit. As an aside, I was glad to hear that they are NOT going to tear down the old County Hospital, but leave it standing for other purposes.

Beethoven Violin Concerto

September 9th, 2010

Beethoven Violin Concerto; with von Karajan and Anne-Sophie Mutter ???

It is uncharacteristic of me to give Karajan only three stars since he is my favorite conductor of the twentieth century. Even this piece was impeccably conducted and beats other performances for its interpretation. I found several things annoying about the recording. Camera work was often bizarre and not typical for filmed orchestral performances. The recording often left the solo violinist too quiet to adequately hear. Since this was recorded close to the end of Karajan’s career, there is a sense of the absence of his prior dynamism.Oddly, he had his eyes open more than is typical for him conducting orchestras. Mutter’s only expression of enjoyment was the last two seconds of the recording on completion of the piece. Regardless, she performed the virtuoso sections of the concerto without flaw and expressively. This is a performance perhaps best listened to and not watched.

Sadko

September 7th, 2010

Sadko, by Rimsky-Korsakov, performed by Kirov Opera, Valery Gergiev – Dirigent  ????

Sadko used to be quite strong in the Russian repertoire of opera pieces, and one of the most recognized of RK. This production by Gergiev is very well done, with superb conducting, and awesome and expensive staging sets. No expense was spared on the number of performers/singers, ballet dancers, costumes, visual effects, etc. Unfortunately, the opera story is just plain boring, with a ridiculous plot. The music is delightful, but no pieces stand out as extraordinarily remarkable. It is superb R-K with a bad plot. There are other Russian works far more worth watching. This opera is best for those who have exhausted the standard repertoire and wish to explore the lesser known Russian works.

Sacred Music

September 7th, 2010

Sacred Music-Cornerstone Works of Sacred Music – a Harmonia Mundi Compilation  ????

This set represents 29 CDs of sacred music from the time of the Gregorian chants through the 20th century. It is a broad mix, including selections of oratorios (Messiah, Paulus, Weihnachtsoratorium), masses, requiems, and singular pieces of church music. The quality of the production is quite variable. Various groups, such as Le Chapelle Royale with Philippe Herrweghe, or Les Arts Flourrisants with William Christie (the Messiah) were quite mediocre. Other works, such as Leonard Bernsteins’ Mass was performed well, though very mediocre as a compositional piece. I could have thought of many other late 20th century works of better quality and more representative of modern sacred music. Harmonia Mundi excels in productions of early music, and that is where this collection shines. The cost of this complete set is quite cheap, and thus a worthy addition to many collectors’ libraries.

Doctor Zhivago

September 5th, 2010

Doctor Zhivago, starring Omar Sharif ????

Doctor Zhivago, loosely based on a novel by Boris Pasternak, is now produced as an epic soap opera occurring at the time of the Revolution in the Soviet Union. Through a complex mix of many characters, including Dr. Zhivago, Tonya (Zhivago’s wife), Larissa (Lara), and others, a complex tale is weaved, from a novel mostly commenting on the nature of the Bolshevik revolution, but turned into a soap of Dr. Zhivago, who, through many encounters with an unusual woman Larissa, eventually develops a love affair with her, but then separated by the vicissitudes  of the Revolution. The film can be rightly praised for the awesome filming, even though most of it was filmed in either Italy or the United States. There were many in-the-face shots, characteristic of either soap operas or director David Lean. The music tended toward mono-thematic, with nothing other than Lara’s theme being repeated again and again, in a Wagnerian Leitmotiv fashion, though with only one Leitmotiv. The acting is superb. Oddly, the filming gives poor reason why Zhivago would betray his wife; most odd, because the film character for Tonya was far more attractive and a nicer personality than Larissa. So it goes with movies. It was noted that Klaus Kinski played a small role in the film-I missed him completely. This is a long movie–over three hours–with an intermission after the style of movies in the 1960s.

Meteorology-Teaching Company

September 4th, 2010

Meteorology: An Introduction to the Wonders of the Weather, by Robert Fovell ???

This Teaching Company series was a set of 24 half-hour lectures on the science of meteorology. Fovell covers most introductory aspects of meteorology, including the basics of how weather occurs, clouds form, atmospheric circulation, global weather events, hurricanes and tornados, etc. Fovell ends with two lectures explaining in quite simple terms how models are being developed to try to forecast the weather, focusing especially on predicting the path of hurricanes. Fovell’s teaching style is very dry. He does not have the enthusiastic bounce of Filippenko, another Teaching Company lecturer. Fovell’s explanations as to how various weather events occur, such as the development of tornados, just did not seem entirely plausible. This is probably the state of the science of meteorology rather than Fovell explaining poorly. Fovell made abundantly clear how poorly forecasters are at predicting weather events. He used the example of the path of the hurricane Rita, which various models gave a 100 mile spread as to where the hurricane would hit land one day before the event. Such wide spreads limit the usefulness of predicting, since most models showed Rita going straight to Houston, and it went instead to the Texas/Louisiana border, quite a significant way away. This is a series worth watching to learn the basics of what the weatherman needs to know. It is not a series to get you excited about Meteorology.

Zulu Dawn, Zulu

September 4th, 2010

Zulu Dawn ??

Zulu ??

Both of these films were very well rated on Amazon.com, a mystery to me, since they were both horrible films. Some Amazon reviewers comment on the historical accuracy and others on the remarkable historical inaccuracy of the films. Knowing Hollywood, they probably got the facts slightly right. Both films were done by the same director, and so they shared a very similar style, and both were filmed in Natal, where the action historically occurred, using Zulu actors. One cannot criticize the cinematography. Both films have a long and arduous lead-up to the final battle, in Zulu Dawn, the British regimen was annihilated, and in Zulu, a small remnant survived. The historical commentary suggests that the British were invaders into the Zulu lands, and invaded the large Zulu kingdom in an unprovoked attack. The historical facts of British dealings with the Zulu are one of many black stains on the Victorian rule in building a world-wide empire. These films attempt a minor commentary on British actions in Natal, though done in rather poor style. Too much of both films included overly silly scenes, such as the preacher scenes in Zulu, or the hospital scenes. There was too much lengthy filming of army movements, or clumsy falls. The officers are painted as inept and rank and file troops as undisciplined. Only the first (inept officers) is probably partially true. Don’t waste your time on either of these films–they are not worth the 90 plus minutes each that you will have to endure on each film.

Strauss Operettas

September 4th, 2010

Eine Nacht in Venedig by Johann Strauss, made for tv ???

Johann Strauss, Wiener Blut, made for tv ???

I am reviewing both operettas together, as I watched them together, and they share similarities. I would have given them only one star each, except that the music was truly wonderful, and well sung and performed. The problem with the operettas is their plots, which are almost the same, the main personality being a prince-philanderer who flirts with multiple women, three of whom through disguise or mistaken identity carry on the operetta to its conclusion when the ladies true identity is revealed and the prince gives in. Obviously, one operetta takes place in Venice, and the other in Vienna. I appreciated the film style of the operetta, which is so much better than watching a stage, though one could occasionally tell that the singers are lip-synching. The plots of both operettas tended to identify the sumptuous though trifling lives of aristocratic persons in Wien. Perhaps this is an unintended statement of Strauss in satirizing the ruling class. Whereas Strauss’ Fledermaus is a must-see, these two operettas are worth watching only if you are either an avid fan of opera or if you are intensely bored with absolutely nothing else to watch.

Requiem – Verdi

August 14th, 2010

Messa da Requiem, by Verdi, conducted by von Karajan ?????

This is a staged piece with an empty audience, performed by the Teatro alla Scala in Milan in 1967. This was a time when Karajan, and many of the performers, such as Leontyne Price, and Nicholai Ghiaurov were truly in their prime. Luciano Pavarotti is very young in this production and appears a touch insecure, though Verdi gave the tenor a minor solo part in this work. The work itself is a compositional masterpiece, stylistically being very operatic. Karajan’s conducting is also demonstrative of the best that this piece could possibly be performed. Interestingly, he is usually found with his eyes opened during the conducting, a characteristic I find peculiar to Karajan conducting choral works. The filming is a little problematic at times, since the camera seems to stray off of the performers, and the view is often obstructed by microphone poles. All in all, this is one of the best performances of Verdi’s Requiem, and a must have by any music lover.

Der Kuhhandel

August 8th, 2010

Der Kuhhandel, by Kurt Weill ??

This opera is about the country of Santa Maria that started as a peaceful, happy country, until corruption encouraged the leaders into an arms race with a neighboring country, resulting in oppressive taxation and brutality to its citizens. The staging was not totally minimalistic, and so was endurable for a European produced production, and the singing/acting was well done. The opera was interesting in that if one simply closed their eyes and listened to the music, they would imagine that they were listening to a modern American move-musical, such as a Rogers & Hammerstein musical or the Wizard of Oz, etc. I am sure that Kurt Weill had a major influence on later composition of musicals.

So, why the poor rating? Weill was a Jewish composer that had to flee Germany during the Nazi years, eventually dying at age 50 in NYC. His political leanings tended toward Communism, and this opera represents a very strong leaning toward the same. Yet, it represents highly confused thinking, possible attributing to why the opera never really became popular. The corrupt government is the source of evil. Simple, primitive life is good. The government is hell-bent on destroying your life, while living themselves a life of luxury. Unfortunately, all of these traits were present in virtually all of the socialistic or communistic regimes of the 20th century. When Weill protests capitalism, he also glorifies capitalism by extolling the virtues of owning private property (a cow, which is the peasants means of producing a living). Such muddled thinking is so true of most liberals today, shooting a “capitalist” straw man. Weill seems to protest moral decadence by having the fat government officials relishing in a brothel, yet, had the brothel maidens dancing in the forefront at the end of the opera. Perhaps Weill needs better direction as to a real (I actually mean, only) system of morality.

Napola-Elite für den Führer

August 5th, 2010

Napola, Elite für den Führer ???

This film has been produced in English, but I unfortunately have only the German version. I was able to follow most of the speaking, though there were critical sections where I was totally unable to understand what was going on. Thus, my review may not be entirely accurate. It is a quasi-historical film (historical fiction) detailing a young boy, good at boxing, who is asked to enroll in a special school system that Hitler had set up to establish an elite system of education. This boy goes against the wishes of his parents to attend the school, and does well at first, until questions start arising. There is an unusually high attrition rate at the school, and certain classmates are treated in a very embarrassing fashion, such as the kid who occasionally has a problem with bedwetting. The turning point was when the students were asked to hunt down and shoot some young escaped Russian POWs. This led the star character to give up, and in the end get thrown out of the school.

Reading the reviews of this movie, many comment on how this film represents a resurrection of rethinking some of the crimes of the past Nazi regime. I’m not sure such an episode is worth re-thinking. The mistake made in this film is that they do NOT engage in a re-thinking, but rather, a re-creation or a re-invention of what actually happened. They imply that young Germans actually knew better, that they had hearts and souls that defied the evil of their elders and wished to correct those evils. One wishes that were true, but such is not the case in any epoch, in any time, in any place. Such is human nature to defy the elders, but in such a fashion as to generate an even worse ethic or morality. So, Napola doesn’t satisfy the wish for a therapeutic re-think of past sins. It excuses the past by claiming that the youth really knew better, and often did act in defiance of Nazi policy. A few did, such as Sophie Scholl, but most did not.

Quantum Mechanics

July 31st, 2010

Quantum Mechanics: The Physics of the Microscopic World, by Benjamin Schumacher ????

This was a hard series to rate, in that, while holding my interest, I fell asleep at the end of about all 24 of the lectures. Schumacher was not boring, so I couldn’t fault him. He also generated enough interest on my part to pull out some light reading books by Richard Feynman on Physics, and enquire about more substantial quantum mechanics textbooks. He brought back memories of Physical Chemistry which I took for one year in college, in which we used the essentials of quantum mechanics quite heavily for our calculations, but of which the third term was spent doing simple solutions of the Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom. It seemed a little strange trying to teach quantum mechanics without mathematics. So, it ended up being more a “Quantum Mechanics for Psychology Majors” class, something which nobody could really take seriously. Dr. Schumacher covered the history of quantum mechanics, some of the basic ideas, and discussion of how quantum mechanics differs from how we see and experience the macroscopic world. I found the discussion of his work in quantum informatics to be most interesting. Should he edit this course for a new edition, I would like to see him a) include more mathematics, even if it is not totally understood, b) speak more about the history of quantum mechanics, especially in the most recent several decades, and c) include more discussion of sub-atomic work, such as quarks, muons, etc. and discuss how they tie into the quantum mechanics discussion, and d) discuss more fully how relativity and quantum mechanics conflicts and interacts in understanding the universe.

Bach Organ Works

July 27th, 2010

Bach Organ Works, performed by Simon Preston ?????

I was a little leery of getting yet another set of Bach Organ works, since both the Peter Herford and Helmut Walcha sets are superb. Preston offers a change of venue, with many of the Bach pieces not performed in a perfectly traditional manner. Yet, the performances were entirely compelling, and most interesting to listen to. Oftentimes, syncopation or variations in volume or tonal presentation made a completely different piece than is traditionally heard. This is a very worthy purchase for the Bach lover. Quite honestly, I think that Bach would approve entirely of this performance. Remember that Bach quite often re-worked the pieces of other composers in order to hear them in a fresh manner. These works are definitely fresh, and bring an intense amount of life and vitality to what might otherwise be considered fairly boring works.

Black Holes Explained

July 11th, 2010

Black Holes Explained, by Alex Filippenko ?????

This is a series of 12 one half hour lectures on black holes. Betsy and I had watched Filippenko’s Astronomy series previously and thoroughly enjoyed it. This short series was no exception. One cannot help but notice the enthusiasm that Filippenko has with the study of Astronomy. This series was a set of lectures as much on physics as on astronomy. The first few episodes detail the original idea of a black hole by a German physicist Schwartzschild made while he was on the eastern front during WWI, and follows it with the original descriptions of black holes and evidence for their existence. Since they are black holes, they cannot be directly seen, but only inferred. Filippenko keeps the amount of physics equations to a minimum, yet later discussions on competing descriptions of black holes by the theory of relativity vs. quantum mechanics, the evaporation of black holes as described by Stephen Hawking, the possibility of mini-black holes, gravitational waves, and worm hole theory, all left one wondering as to the veracity of these claims. Since the Hadron collider at CERN and new space probes are intended to answer some of the questions of the nature of black holes, we have much to anticipate in the news as physics and astronomy works hand in hand to discover some of the “darker” secrets of the universe. Filippenko must have given us every possible joke about black holes ever written, and even demonstrated how he dressed up as a black hole every Halloween. Between his humor and compelling teaching style, this was a wonderful series to watch.

Aguirre, the Wrath of God

July 9th, 2010

Aguirre, der Zorn Gottes, starring Klaus Kinski, directed by Werner Herzog ?????

Herzog and Kinski made many films together, though the reportedly did not get along too well with each other. Most of their films will leave an overwhelming impression on you, and this film is no exception. Amazon reviewers either left it 5 stars or one star. I could argue both ways with this film. Kinski has to be one of the ugliest, brutish actors to ever hit the stage. It is amazing that he had such a beautiful daughter. His acting included almost no speech, and much of the movie is passed with silent imagery of soldiers marching through the Andes, or sailing down a tributary of the Amazon. Yet, the film tends to be very effective. It is quite a depressing film, where a expeditionary team of one of Pizarro’s army, attempting to find El Dorado, the city of Gold, ends up with mixed intentions and internal rivalry, ultimately leading to the destruction of the entire expedition. This is reportedly based on a true story, though I’m not certain as to it’s faithfulness to the historical narratives. The film was in German, though it is available in dubbed English, and could be enjoyed by American audiences. Don’t watch it as a film to lift your spirits. It won’t.

The Outer Limits

July 6th, 2010

The Outer Limits TV series ????

The Outer Limits, like the Twilight Zone, were the two serials that I remember as a child. Both of them tended to give me nightmares. They don’t seem to be too spooky anymore. Comparing the two series, I would say that the Outer Limits tended to be “scarier”, in that there were more scary monsters and creepy scenes. But after reviewing both series, I would say that the Twilight Zone had better episodes, tended to offer a clearer message with each episode, and had more compelling plots. Both series tended to repeat similar stories or themes, such as a travel back in time, or a monster appearing that either was actually benign, or that required uncanny skills to control or eliminate, or adventures of space travelers on another planet. Each episode of the Outer Limits was an hour long, compared to the Twilight Zone where the episodes were 1/2 hour, with the exception of one years worth of episodes that ran for an hour. All in all, I enjoyed the Twilight Zone more, but found both as interesting displays of quality television from years past.

Vivaldi Edition

May 22nd, 2010

Vivaldi Edition by Philips, featuring I Musici and Vittoria Negri ?????

I’m a Vivaldi fan, but he is not in my top 5 composers of all time. Our friend J.S. Bach was far better endowed from our creator with the gift of music, and Bach remains the greatest musician that ever tread on terra firma. Ever. Yet, the fact that Bach listened to the music of Vivaldi, and often wrote modifications of Vivaldi, suggesting that even Bach held Vivaldi’s music in highest regard. This 29 CD set is no longer available, and that is a great shame, since this is the best performances one will ever get of Vivaldi. Between such performers as I Musici and the artistic direction of Vittoria Negri, you will never hear Vivaldi in a better light. It is a pity that the only piece that is usually performed by Vivaldi is his Four Seasons, as so much of his instrumental pieces have deep charm and compositional brilliance. It is even a more serious pity that virtually none of his choral music is widely known, as Vivaldi’s choral (sacred) music excels his instrumental pieces. How could one not be deeply moved by the brilliance of his Dixit Dominus, Nisi Dominus, his Glorias, etc. Vivaldi via Vittoria Negri is a absolute must for the discriminating listener. Make every effort possible to get copies of these performances and you will be greatly blessed through listening to them.

Aufstieg und Fall der Stadt Mahagonny

May 18th, 2010

Aufstieg und Fall der Stadt Mahagonny, by Kurt Weill from text of Bertoldt Brecht, performed at Salzburg Festival 1998 ?

Known in English as “The Rise and Fall of the City of Mahagonny”, this opera by Kurt Weill rates among the worst of the Euro-trash operas. Though Weill has had occasional lapses of reasonable music that he has written, his ideologic drive for communism has clouded his thinking and produced a piece of trash that would not survive the kindest of the Soviet years. To be fair to this opera, I will critique separately 1) the musical performance, 2) the stage performance, and 3) the opera itself. First, the musical performance was not too badly performed. The only problem is that there was little the was overtly demanding, including no demands on the singer, save to sing weird, no lengthy segments, no  music that could even be thought of as likable. The stage performance represented a complete lapse of ingenuity. Isn’t one tired of the suitcase on stage carried by a Zoot-suited individual, as is now seen in just about every European opera production? I could wax eloquent about how virtually every scene lacks in creative imagination. The minimalist staging suggested that the producer really didn’t care enough for the opera to put much into it. And, that is quite understandable, because it was not an opera to enjoy or appreciate as a work of art. Brecht (via Weill) at the end of the opera spewed out a vindictive against capitalism, the stage designers and Brecht not-so-subtly implying that the greatest sinners of their communistic ideology are the Americans. A leading character named Jimmy is sentenced to death for a lack of money. I presume that Weill was attempting to make some sort of profound statement against greed and monetary avarice, but he fails dismally. Any thinking person finds the philosophical statements of this opera to be poorly developed non-sequitors with a forced conclusion, believed only by Brecht and Weill, and perhaps a few of the performers and audience. Such go the warm and fuzzy statements of the new art, promoting the warm and fuzzy sentiments of the new philosophy and the new politic. It’s one thing to have wasted one’s money on this opera, but even a worse crime to have wasted one’s time watching it.

Trois Colours

May 16th, 2010

Les Trois Colours (Three Colors) Trilogy (Blue/White/Red) by Kiezlowski ????

These three films receive a uniformly 5-star rating by Amazon reviewers, and there is much to commend for this series, superbly well performed and directed. They are separate tales, but tied together by the French themes of liberty, equality, and fraternity, which is actually demonstrated very weakly in the series. The first film (Bleu) is about the wife of famous composer, whose family, including her composer-husband and young daughter are killed in a tragic automobile accident. She goes on to try to free her life from her past, but eventually discovers more to the life of her late husband than she expected. The second film (Blanc) is about a polish hairdresser involved in a messy divorce, with his wife mercilessly dumping him while living in Paris, he being unable to capably defend himself owing to language problems. The remainder of the film takes him from destitution to ultimate revenge on his ex-wife. The third film (Rouge) depicts a young model who chances across a retired judge who now spends his life eavesdropping on his neighbors. Ultimately, a deeper relationship is developed between the two, as they interact with the past of the judge and future of the young model. Kieslowski nicely incorporates the thematic colors in his films in an interesting sort of way. In Bleu, there are blue rooms and blue chandeliers and many blue objects, in Blanc, emotional episodes show a screen white-out, and in Rouge, there is an equal profusion of red, such as a large red banner announcing a fashion show with the star character imaged. I reduced the rating by one-star because of the overwhelming morose mood throughout the entire series. Only Blanc showed any humor at all. All were moderately dark, deeply-foreboding films, quasi-tragedies of ruined lives desperate for significance and meaning, and the films never offering a way out. Ultimate liberty, equality or fraternity are never achieved, but a cheap imitation. These are not films to soar with, but will put you in the gutter and leave you there. They would be nice films for conversations on philosophy, but not for conversations on a life of higher aspirations.

Camille Claudel

May 14th, 2010

Camille Claudel, starring Adjani and Depardeau ?????

I’ve always liked the acting talent of Gerard Depardeau, and he is at his best in this film, playing the role of Auguste Rodin. With Adjani capably serving as the title role of Camille Claudel, this film follows the historical fate of Claudel in the late 1800′s to her death in the mid-twentieth century. Camille was an aspiring artist, dropping out of school, and eventually working/studying in the workshop of Rodin. Becoming his lover, and then breaking up, she develops a paranoid delusion of Rodin constantly plotting to ruin her. In return, this paranoia leads to her institutionalization for most of her life. It is a sad but true tale, all too true because it actually happened, but also because it represents life’s drama in so many of us who look for false sources of significance. Acting in this movie was superb, the cinephotography excellent, the French was not too difficult to follow, especially with the help of sous-titles, it was R-rated for some sexual depictions-but never in an obscene way, and the “fill-in” on the known historical facts of Camille C. to make a movie version seemed fairly reasonably as to what one would expect. Thus, a highly recommended film, though not for children.

The Twilight Zone

May 6th, 2010

The Twilight Zone-The Complete Definitive Collection ?????

This collection represents essentially five seasons. Each episode is 1/2 hour, except for the fourth season, where the episodes lasted an hour. Narrated by the familiar face of Rod Serling, and with over half of the episodes written by him, you cannot help but appreciate a distinct style throughout the collection. The seasons seem to evolve over time, with the productions being done a bit more professionally, with fancier props as time goes on. The first few seasons have a very distinct moral twist to each and every episode, something that partially lost as time goes on. In comparison to today’s television shows, many of these episodes would be considered too moralistic or “prejudiced” or “religious” to permit broadcast. Pity. Compared to the Outer Limits t.v. series, the Twilight Zone is not nearly as frightening, though some classic episodes exist that could be considered downright spooky.  Who cannot forget the episode where bandages are taken off the face of a young lady, only to be greeted with horror as she appears completely normal — until you finally see the faces of the physicians and nurses, who have completely disfigured, ugly faces. Even then, Serling presents it as a strong lesson that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The Twilight Zone should be considered a must-see if you haven’t seen the series before. If your only viewing was in the early 60′s when they were first broadcast, it is quite worth another viewing to realize how trashy prime-time television has become.

Complete Brahms Series

May 1st, 2010

Brahms Complete Works, by Brilliant Classics ????

Brahms Complete Edition, by Deutsche Grammophon ?????

I realized that I did not have collections of the complete works of Brahms, and so when these two editions came out on sale, decided that they needed to be in my collection. Both are very worthy editions to have in one’s collection, and are distinctly different. Brilliant Classics, though sold as a “budget” production, had notable quality that would be worthy of the sole Brahms of a less ardent classic music collector. Yet, the Deutsche Grammophon recordings were generally better. The symphonies had a livelier sound and better production, partially attributable to the conducting of von Karajan. The DG edition also had far better vocal works, making the vocal pieces far less of a drudgery, and actually enjoyable, to listen to over the Brilliant collection. The chamber works with the Brilliant Classics were quite nice, and quite on par with the DG productions. All in all, I’d vote for the DG edition, but enjoyed hearing both sets of Brahms works.

The Origin of Civilization

April 19th, 2010

The Origin of Civilization, by Scott McEachern ??

This series by the Teaching Company is about archeology, and the discoveries of archeology in various parts of the world, including Africa (esp. Northern Africa/Cameroon and the great Zimbabwe), Egypt (though formally a part of Africa), the mid-east, India, China, and Central/South America (Mayan and Incan civilizations). Scott first spends six lectures detailing his philosophy for doing archeology. During this time, you get a delightful flavor of his biases, and intentions for doing archeology. Dr. McEachern spends most of his time working in Northern Cameroon, digging up ancient garbage.

You are not given a historical perspective in this study. Compared to an excellent Teaching Company series on the origins of civilization by Kenneth Harl, this series leaves you swimming a bit. You are told considerable amounts about what kinds of food are thought to have been eaten by ancient civilizations, and perhaps what sort of structures for housing they may have built for themselves, but that is it. The remainder of what we are left with is pure guesswork. Much of this guesswork presupposes that ancient civilizations might have been similar to the various cultures and civilizations you see today. Unfortunately, that gives you no information at all, except the obvious, that is, that mankind has remained similar over the course of its short history. I really don’t find it fascinating to imagine that people ate similar foods in ancient times as today, and that famines might have happened. Scott lacks better stories to tell, and though he is careful not to extrapolate to wildly, extrapolate he still does, and refuses to remain silent where the evidence is only foggy or unclear. He seems to suggest social structures based on remnant housing and graveyard goods, yet this could be utterly deceiving. In the end, I’ve learned very little about what we are to think about ancient civilizations, other than that they had analogous social systems and political constructs as we have today. It was very challenging actually making it through 48 1/2 hour lectures in order to glean this truth. This course has also persuaded me to stay far away from archeology.

Is there any benefit that I see for archeology? Yes. When we have purported historical narratives from the past, archeology might help substantiate the legitimacy of these stories. This is particularly true of the fall of Troy, the stories of Greece, historical narratives from China, etc. Most importantly, archeology could assist is further substantiating the veracity of Scripture. Yet, McEachern dares not tread on such a subject, even when it would have been entirely admissible. As an example, he is overwhelmingly astonished at how early urbanization occurred in civilization, yet Genesis suggests specialization (and thus urbanization) from very early times. He is amazed at the amount of trade occurring in ancient times, yet much Scripture speaks of international trade and commerce from quite early on. It is chronological arrogance that overwhelms some of the thinking of Scott that does not allow him to constructively best put together the data at hand.

I could not recommend this series to anybody, except for those who are deeply interested in archeology and the various schools of thought. Scott is not difficult to listen to, but his content would have a hard time grasping most people’s interest.

Alice in Wonderland (1966 BBC)

March 20th, 2010


Alice in Wonderland 1966 BBC production ??

This movie is NOT a faithful reproduction of the Lewis Carroll narrative, but rather is a fanciful political statement based roughly on the Alice in Wonderland story. It is definitely British, and definitely 1960′ish, even with the background music of Ravi Shankar. The movie is in black and white, and very choppy in its movement from scene to scene. Apparently, it was made by the BBC as a low-budget Christmas film. The Alice actor is rather bland, though most of the other characters are quite humorous in their bizarreness. The film holds a surrealistic vision of upper-class England, yet treats the Queen as quite tawdry. Perhaps the producer caught the spirit of Lewis Carroll in this rendering, yet it is a little too bizarre for modern viewing.

Galaxy Quest

March 11th, 2010

Galaxy Quest, starring Tim Allen and Sigourney Weaver ????

This film was watched at brother Dennis’ request. It was a film that Betsy actually enjoyed watching, and laughed most of the way through. It is a tremendous spoof on sci-fi films and movies, especially the  Star Trek series.It starts at a Star Trek groupie-like convention, where the main actors did not get along with each other, nor take serious their roles. That is, until real space aliens, the Thermians, take them away, to help save them from the enemy, General Sarris. The subsequent adventures are hilarious as they save themselves and their alien friends. I won’t give the movie away, as you need to watch it and enjoy it.

Batman Series

March 11th, 2010

Batman ??, Batman Returns ??, Batman Forever ?, Batman and Robin ?, (all with Michael Keaton as Batman), Batman Begins ???, The Dark Knight ??? (both with Christian Bale as Batman).

These are two series which illustrate that too much of a good thing usually goes bad. Unfortunately, in this case, it was a lot of a mediocre theme. Both series can be criticized for very poor character development, characters being more trivial and immature than super-heroes or super-villians. The first Batman film is excellent only in that the Joker with Jack Nicholson was superb. Nothing else about the film was praise-worthy. The remaining Michael Keaton series attempted to wow the audience with high tech graphics while forgetting about story lines that are meaningful or consistent. Unfortunately, the films often made the worst of good actors, like Arnold Schwarznegger playing Mr. Freeze. It was especially unnerving when the immature and irresponsible characters of Robin, and then Batwoman come on the scene. There were more than a few ipecac moments. The second series lapsed into its own problems, the first film attempting to offer a realistic start for Batman, where he goes off to the East to learn the disciplines of the Buddhist Kung-fu experts, only to discover that they were the ultimate enemies of Gotham City. All in all, the story line was simply stupid and inane, not really worth watching. Again, both films of this second series show an inability to maintain a quasi-realistic story line, or develop real characters. The second series did flow better, especially the Dark Knight, which is why it received three rather than two stars.

Albert Einstein: Physicist, Philosopher, Humanitarian

February 27th, 2010

Albert Einstein: Physicist, Philosopher, Humanitarian, by Don Howard (Teaching Company Lecture Series) ?

I ordered this set from the Teaching Company, hoping to receive a non-biased, educated assessment of the life, thinking, and times of Albert Einstein. The series started as a modestly historical narrative of the early Einstein, and included discussion of his thinking in physics, but also in philosophy and politics. Einstein apparently felt modestly prejudiced against, owing to the fact that he was a Jew, surviving in a primarily non-Jewish culture. His success in physics came with shaky fits, having problems with the higher institutes of learning in Switzerland, but eventually ending in the pinnacle of his career while in Berlin, before moving to America in 1933 at the time of the rise of Hitler. Howard is willing to admit that the social life of Einstein left much to be desired, mistreating several wives, and essentially abandoning his children. Howard excuses Einstein, noting that he was a great socialist and humanitarian, thus making up for his otherwise despicable lifestyle. Though a number of the early lectures discusses the innovations of physics by Einstein, you are also left with the notion that Einstein burned out early, vacillating frequently when theories didn’t fit his personal philosophy. His greatest despair was his development of the science of quantum mechanics, only to later disown it as it didn’t fit his personal world view. He is like Napoleon-a brilliant youth followed by a not so brilliant middle and older age. By the 10th lecture, this series became quite worrisome, in that the lectures became a dummy pulpit for Howard to expound his own socialist belief system. Howard fails miserably to discuss the various ramifications of Einstein’s political and philosophic stances, arguing both the pro’s and con’s of the various social solutions Einstein offers. Thus, Howard betrays his own calling as an academician, forfeiting his claim as an intellectual, in order to push a social agenda that Einstein supposedly espoused. By the end of the lecture series, you are left wondering how accurate Howard remained to the true thinking of Einstein. You are left with multiple holes. I would have loved more discussion of Einstein at Princeton, yet you hear nothing save for his involvement with socialist issues, anti-war issues, and government interactions during the second world war. Oddly, Howard barely takes Einstein to task for his horrid inconsistency for advocating the development of the atom bomb, only since he presumed it would be used against the German state that mistreated him. Howard unnecessarily idolizes Einstein to the point of losing an objective focus for discussion of the man, making the entire series very wearisome to listen to. I simply could not recommend this series to anybody for a serious discussion of the thought and life of Albert E.

Roger Ramjet TV Series

February 24th, 2010

Roger Ramjet ????

Roger Ramjet ran as a short series many years ago, and remembered well by me, as actually being an adult cartoon, with many insinuations that only could be understood by an adult. Unfortunately there are only 120 of the 156 episodes here in this collection, but, that’s better than nothing. It is a bit challenging, having to tolerate the lengthy initial theme song and ending song, which occupied nearly 1/2 of each 5-10 minute episode. Yet, it’s worth watching. Roger is the hero who saves America from the bad guys, like Noodles Romanoff. In the meantime, multiple jokes are made about American culture and ideology, making it a most enjoyable series to watch. If only somebody would edit out all the intro and ending pieces. This is a wonderful piece of nostalgia from the 1960′s, but still understood with jokes that would stand today.

Kalman – Die Csardasfurstin

February 21st, 2010

Die Csardasfurstin – by Kalman, with Moffo & Kollo, Deutsche Grammophon ????

Emmerich Kalman wrote this light operetta in 1915, a precursor to the current day musical that we all know of. This is a filmed version, staged in Budapest, and well done, with first class acting and singing as well as filming. The plot was very trivial, but then, what do you expect out of an operetta? It is the story of class identification for the nobility in marriage, and how that was overcome with a prince desiring to marry a Vaudeville chorus girl. It is a light operetta, not one that would become one’s favorite, though certainly of more demanding singing than the current musical scene as we know it.  Two stars for the operetta and 4 for the performance gives a three star average.

Bach Cello Suites

February 18th, 2010

Bach (Johann Sebastian) Cello Suites, by Pablo Casals ????, Pierre Fournier ?????, Yo Ma-Ma ?????, Lynn Harrell ?????, Boris Pergamenshikow ????, Jap Ter Linden ????, Mstislav Rostropovich ???.

The Bach Cello suites were brought to light by Pablo Casals, who essentially defined the modern interpretation of these suites. Prior to Casals, the cello suites were viewed as nothing but petty exercises for students. Then, why would anybody imagine that. Even the student pieces of Bach are charming. When we think of student pieces, we imagine Schaum piano graded pieces, or the Czerny finger exercises (more like torture) for the budding pianist, and certainly NOT melodic. So, even if Bach did write these originally as student exercises (which I doubt), they have enough charm to be worthy of repeated listenings and performances. The interpretations tended to vary. First, Casals was given a star off, since the recording was poor, with multiple record scratch marks coming through. The sound was phonographic, but also a bit distant. Fournier, Ma-Ma, and Harrell all had superb recordings that reflected the joy that these pieces seem to exude. Pergamenshikow gave a surprisingly excellent recording, very light and joyous, dancelike, and with a very crisp, clean recording. He is a cellist to keep ones eye on. Ter Linden also was a superb interpreter, a little slower and somber in presentation, and the recordings were made a touch softer. Unfortunately, I had to give Rostropovich only three stars. The recording was okay, but the performance made these pieces sound like funeral dirges. Bach labeled them all with dance names, like Allemande, Courante, Bouree, Sarabond, Minuet, and Gigue, all of which were lively dances and whom most people would have been familiar in Bach’s time. Rostropovich is a most capable performer, and other recorded works definitely tend to shine. I’m not sure what he was thinking in these performances.  I will soon be reviewing a book on the cello suites, recommended by Dr. Leitz. These are must listen to pieces that are worth one obtaining a bit of familiarity with.

Rigoletto – 2 DVD versions

February 15th, 2010

Rigoletto – with Placido Domingo, Ileana Cotrubus, Cornell McNeil, James Levine conducting Metropolitan Opera ?????

Rigoletto – with Luciano Pavarotti, Edita Gruberova, Ingard Wixell, Riccardo Chailly conducting the Wiener Philharmoniker ?????

This is my favorite Verdi opera, so it is hard for me to be easy in criticism of a production of this opera, yet, both of these productions receive 5 stars, though they are much different operas. The first was filmed in 1977 with Domingo, Cotrubus, and Levine in the early years of their career. Domingo is magnificent. Cornell McNeil wins the day though, as a first-class Rigoletto, with excellent acting, and a superb voice, blending perfectly with Cotrubus.  The second film was recorded in 1983, though is presented as a film, that is, it is filmed in Mantua, the actual site of the opera, with the opera singers lip-synching. Some Amazon reviewers can’t get past that, yet, I think that is what 19th century opera composers would have had if the technology had existed back then. This technique does produce a clearer sound track, since the sound is recorded in a studio, and the audience applause is eliminated. After having seen the Domingo version first, Betsy and I both thought that Domingo would be a tough act to follow, yet, Pavarotti actually was in many ways the better actor and the better voice. La Donna Mobile was meant for the voice of Pavarotti. Wixell was a very convincing Rigoletto, and Gruberova had the voice of an angel, absolutely in control, and clear. Either opera would be quite appealing to the novice to operas, though the Pavarotti version could persuade some to take up opera-watching as a life’s secondary passion.

Regarding the opera itself, this is one of Verdi’s middle operas, which include some of his greatest operas, such as la Traviata and il Travatore. His early operas are to me a touch tedious, and his late operas, including Othello and Falstaff, while masterpieces, are not the lovable gems of his middle-years.  If you are deeply interested in the life of Verdi and his music, I recommend the Greenberg series on Verdi by the Teaching Company .This opera is similar to many Italian operas, especially the newer Puccini works, manifesting verismo, or realism, rather than the German tradition in opera of depending on myth and the miraculous. This opera has a tragic ending for several reasons, in that the innocent or deformed people suffer the curse, and the rich, wealthy and wise person escapes the curse though manifesting the most flagrant violations of moral behavior. Unlike German opera, nobody is ever saved in Italian opera. Tannhäuser experiences redemption in the last few moments of the opera and dies together with his lover in her arms. Rigoletto is not so lucky, and dies of tragic heartbreak in a boat with his slain daughter.  Such are the Italians, always mushy, gushy and brutal to the end. I only regret that nobody has done a filmed version of Tannhäuser. In summary, either of these operas is a must-see, and should be in every music aficionado’s collection.

Tannhäuser – Levine

February 12th, 2010

Tannhäuser, by Richard Wagner, performed by Levine, Metropolitan Opera ?????

This is a traditionally staged and performed opera. I’m not sure if it’s the Dresden or the Paris version of the opera. Sometimes, the staging leaves something to be desired, such as the re-use of the scene from the second part of the first act for the third act. The Venusberg scene was not terribly convincing in the first act. Having been in Thüringia and the Wartburg, the scenes were not terribly reminiscent of the places Wagner was attempting to represent. Even still, few dvd performances nowadays are available with traditional staging, and most are offered as minimally staged, which, I think, does Tannhäuser an injustice.  The entire production is very well staged, the video operation well done, and audio comes through always well with excellent voice to orchestra balance. Thus, in spite of its problems, this is probably the best dvd Tannhäuser available today.

People often ask me why I like Wagner, especially in terms of his anti-semitism. Such anti-semitism doesn’t seem to cause Levine too much of a problem, as well as many other Jewish conductors, who are quite masterful at the works of Wagner. It is like many composers. I see nobody protesting Tchaikovsky because he was a child molester, or Britten, because he was fond of little boys. We overlook Shostakovich’s anti-capitalism, Beethoven’s anti-social behavior, and Schumann’s psychosis, and Bach’s penchant for perfection, frequent anger fits, and probable addiction to alcohol. He also had a criminal record. Most composers, in spite of their life, produced a transcendental music, and Wagner is no exception. Certainly the prudishness of many anti-Wagnerites competes with Wagner’s own arrogance. Nobody competes as well as the Brits with the ability to be racist. so, we appreciate Wagner’s music for what it is. Wagner does an excellent job of representing various human emotions and traits, though this portrayal of Christianity is that of a very medieval Roman Catholic sort, the Pope being the sole source for salvation from certain sins. This is probably how many, even Christians, view the faith, and that is sad. This opera is early Wagner, and, over time, we see improvement in both his musical expression as well as his thematic choices. The Tannhäuser music is quite addicting, most of it very catchy, and makes for a first Wagner opera to listen to if you are unfamiliar with his works.

Rise and Fall of the British Empire

February 6th, 2010

Rise and Fall of the British Empire, by Prof. Patrick Allitt, Teaching Company Series ????

Patrick Allitt is a worthy lecturer of this series, having been born in Darby, England, and having grown up in England until college years brought him to the USA. He is able to offer personal vignettes from his family history regarding recent events in the last days of the Empire. The British Empire once held land in every part of the globe, from multiple holdings in Africa, all of India/Pakistan/Bangladesh, Egypt and the middle East, Ireland, Australia, Hong Kong, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, the United States, multiple Caribbean Islands, and multiple islands elsewhere in the world. Indeed, when The Empire was the largest, it was also the most unstable and weakest, which was immediately following the 1st world war, both the 1st and 2nd world wars being pyrrhic victories to England. Allitt spares no punches at elaborating the multiple abuses of the empire that the Brits exercised, including deception and brutality with the Irish, the multiple exercises of brute force in India and unjust reign in that country, the absolutely embarrassing and horrid inconsistencies with their treatment of the Chinese in the Opium wars, and the wretched and unjust treatment of the Boers in South Africa, provoking war not for the sake of justice or virtue, but solely for wealth. We would not elaborate the horrid treatment of the Zulu kings of Africa, and plays of force in achieving domination of the peoples of those countries. We would also not mention Britain’s aggressiveness at assuring that no other country in the world would exercise the right of ability to also conquer lands and develop colonies, taking greedily colonies from the Dutch and Germans, and assuring weakness with the French and Spanish in their overseas holdings. Allitt spends much time discussing the racism that prevailed in a fairly extreme form, sometimes as extreme as Hitler, in developing the concept of the superior race of the Anglo-saxon, which prevented them from interacting justly with the Indian, the Negroes of Africa, or the  Aborigines of Australia/Maori of New Zealand. Though Great Britain is often thought of being virtuous in bringing Western law and Christianity to all parts of the world, they most often brutally oppressed missionary activity, and rarely lived by the laws which they purported to be holding in high esteem. In summary, the British have exercised an extreme form of arrogance, racism, and domination of “might makes right” that is an embarrassment for the West. Much of this is seen in the recently reviewed series of “The Jewel in the Crown”.

In terms of Allitt’s teaching style, he is very easy to listen to, sometimes lapses into irrelevancies (such as his 35th lecture on British literature), and does repeat considerable amounts of his lecture series on Victorian Britain. Even still, this series is thought provoking, especially in consideration of American attempts to repeat the worst of Great Britain’s mistakes. Ron Paul is right in his foreign policy as a corrective to British mistakes, though most Americans seem to arrogantly accept that we must maintain a police presence throughout the world. Someday (probably soon), we will be seeing a lecture series on the rise and fall of the United States of America, if we don’t wake up to our pompous policies in the world at large.

The Jewel in the Crown

February 4th, 2010

The Jewel in the Crown, television series ????

This is a 14 part series based on a historical novel about the last days of the British rule in India. It is really three interwoven stories in one, first, the story of Indian independence, second, the story of the British in India at the same time, and third, the complex interweavings of a few British folk living in India at the time. The story starts with a Indian Hari Kumar who grew up and schooled in England returning to India, and finding himself a misfit, rejected by the British for the color of his skin, and by the Indians for not being Indian enough. He falls in love with an English girl, the girl who is eventually killed, and the blame placed by an incompetent overbearing police person Ronald Merrick on Hari. Hari is imprisoned, not to make a showing until the very last two minutes of the entire series. In the meantime, you follow the friends and acquaintances of R. Merrick and the deceased girl through the years 1942 to 1947. One gets a feel of the caring, yet also the pompous arrogance and racism of the British living in India at the time, and the Indian public response to that. Unlike the film Ghandi, which is mostly from the Indian perspective, this film offers primarily the British perspective, yet is fair enough to paint the the British not only for all their virtues, but also for all their faults. The story line sometimes drags, thus giving the series a 4 rather than 5 star rating. Otherwise, it will keep you interested up to the end, especially as to the person you most hate in the story (Ronald Merrick), finally offering due justice to him. This film is supposed to offer a fair perspective of India in the era of independence. Not having been there, I could only assume that those Indians that recommended the film were accurate in that assessment.

Hindemith-Cardillac

January 28th, 2010

Cardillac, by Paul Hindemith, performed by Das Bayrische Staatsorchester, dir. Sawallisch ????

This is definitely a fin-de-siecle opera, with modernistic approaches to staging, music, and story line. It tells of a goldsmith who would murder all people who purchased products from him, being unable to part with his creations. It supposedly is symbolism for the artist and rejection while still alive. The staging was a trifle worn from other operas, with moving leaning buildings on stage, and suitcases and trench coats, but also with some innovation, such as the Parisian populace presenting with unusual masks and black lipstick. The music was distinctly 20th century, with the absence of classical tonal progression, yet it all seemed to work okay in this opera. Hindemith avoids much of the monotonous repetitiveness of other 20th century composers, such as Britten, which I recently reviewed. I tend to appreciate Hindemith’s chamber works more than his opera, yet this was not an opera like MSND of Britten,where I couldn’t wait until the end to arrive.

Britten: Midsummer Night’s Dream

January 28th, 2010


Midsummer Night's Dream by Benjamin Britten

Midsummer Night’s Dream, By Benjamin Britten ??

I am growing weary of reviewing trashy operas published by elitist opera houses of Europe. This opera, produced by the Barcelona Opera in Aix-en-Provence, stunk of Euro-trash. The scenes were minimalistic of a bed motif. Many of the performers/singers were also flagrantly gay, not fitting to the story line of this opera, but fitting only for the composer himself, who was a homosexual. Boy-children in the opera were perhaps a reflection of Britten’s infatuation, like Tchaikovsky?  The orchestral scores were quite nice, though usually drowned out by highly non-creative singing, a mixture of song and Sprachstimme. A child missing a few pertinent chromosomes and of lower mental strength could have written an equally compelling piece of music. This is not an opera to cherish or delight in. Britten follows the Shakespeare story line okay, but the opera looses the charm of the old Bard.

Händel – Serse

January 26th, 2010

Händel SersesHändel- Serse, performed by the Dresden Opera ??

Reviewers on Amazon.com gave the opera performance 4-1/2 stars, with the lowest rating a 3-star. Much was commented on the brilliant performance and sumptuous arias.  I found none of this to be true. First, Händel is a very monotonous composer, and there is minimal brilliance in his operatic style. Why the English loved Händel eludes me, save that their taste is food is equally dismal. Secondly, I am continually annoyed by his staging of males with females, but to stage Serse as a female with a soprano role really seemed to go a bit too far. In fact, there were only two male roles in the entire opera. I agree that the performance itself was rather faultless, and soloists quite talented, but even their skills could not make up for an otherwise dreadful opera.

The Exorcist

January 16th, 2010

ExorcistThe Exorcist, starring Linda Blair ?????

I will occasionally watch and report on somewhat more controversial films, and certainly this is one of them. I realize that there are films that might be considered simply not suitable for viewing at any age. I saw the Exorcist when it first came out with a group of friends from church. It stimulated thought back then, but now brings other thoughts into reflection. This is not a movie for everybody. The first time I saw it, there were certainly nightmares that followed. The production is well done, though at times, one could easily see the errors in make-up of Regan, or other faux-pas. The first half of the film portrays physicians. Interestingly, much of the medical tests which were performed were on radiological instruments or with tests, like cerebral angiograms, which simply are not performed any longer. The movie at least had a somewhat kindly view of physicians, though their bedside interactions were somewhat sterile. Well, this is not a movie about doctors, but devils, though some people may consider them to be one and the same. C.S. Lewis’ quote on devils is quite apropos here, inexactly restated by me, that the problem with our belief in devils is either to not believe they exist, when they actually do, or to believe and think too much about them. Using the devil for entertainment purposes runs a precarious risk of exercising both extremes of C.S. Lewis. It would be easy to dismiss the devil as an invention of Hollywood or the Catholic church, and thus offer him the regard most improper of him. The movie story entails a 12 year old girl, who dabbles in Ouiji boards and a few things, and eventually becomes possessed. Her mom, who is a movie star, seeks first medical, then psychiatric help for her daughter to no prevail, as she becomes progressively worse. Finally, it is recommended that she seek a priest for an exorcism. Two priests come to the aide of the mother, and eventually are able to cast out the demon, but at the cost of their own lives. So, two thoughts on this movie. First is its’ portrayal of demon possession. Possession turns a person into a raving maniac, with bouncing beds, heads that rotate 360 degrees, and projectile bilious vomit, not the thing that actually does happen to a demon possessed person, at least, as is portrayed in Scripture. This extreme portrayal may cause one to loose sight that demon possession may be manifest in many other ways, such as, in the kindness of a person like Barak Hussain O., who is evil to the core, but presents as sweet as pudding. The other thought was how various inanimate objects were treated as possessive of special “charm”, such as the consecrated water, the crucifix and rosary, the words of incantation for exorcism, and the statue of Jesus. Protestants fall into error of “charming” other objects, though for the bad, such as trinkets or amulets, which they hold might be possessive of evil or harm. In reality, nowhere in Scripture are we told of an inanimate object possessing Spiritual qualities, and indeed are instructed that they absolutely do not and cannot have an ability to convey a curse of carry a demon with it. Yet, many Christians continue to believe such a thing. Pity. I would recommend this film, though not as a piece to amuse ones self, but rather, as a jumping off point in contemplating the roles of demons and the devil in this current world.

RoboCop Trilogy

January 16th, 2010

RoboCop, RoboCop II, RoboCop III ???

At the end of Robocop III, it was easy to see that the movie was terminated with the possibility of a sequel. Not making the mistake of the Alien series, we were spared that torture, and the movie studios let a good thing end gracefully. This is not really a “tough guy” film, like Rambo or Die Hard. It is more appealing to the Marxist-Socialist types in America, in that it suggests that corporate America generates the evil that oppresses the freedom loving poor of this world, and that this corporate entity either lives in bed or pressures the government to do wrong. Robocop was a cyborg, invented by a corporate firm, contracted to defend the streets of Detroit. Already, the film becomes a no-brainer. Detroit, even in the 1980′s, was not a city worth defending. All the same, the creators of Robocop attempt to use this half-policeman half-robot to their advantage. Robocop II and III show the development of more sophisticated Robocops, yet our hero, Robocop I, continues to find a way to gain ultimate victory. The action is good and the story line is reasonably well written to allow an absence of predictability and hold ones’ interest; thus the three stars. All in all, not the worst film, and moderately entertaining, though the prevailing message is usually confused.

Zar und Zimmerman

January 8th, 2010

Czar and CarpenterZar und Zimmerman, by Albert Lortzing, performed by Hamburg State Opera, starring Hans Sotin, Lucia Popp ????

I’ve never seen nor heard this opera before, but apparently it is quite popular in Germany. The title means the Czar and the Carpenter, based very loosely on the historical Peter the Great while living in Holland. This is a playful opera, with quite simple music, used in a delightfully extraordinary manner. The performance of Lucia Popp is absolutely extraordinary, with superb acting complementing a most beautiful gentle voice. The plot of the opera is comic, with confused identities, resolving in an expectable sort of way. The opera is sung in German, but the under-titles are fairly accurate in translation. I’m told that Wagner was heavily influenced by this piece written in 1837, and I’m not surprised. Recommended for viewing.

Alien Quadrilogy

January 7th, 2010

Alien???, Alien2???, Alien3??,Alien Resurrection?? starring Sigourney Weaver

Actually, I’m being a touch kind about my rating, but the graphics were fairly decent, so an extra star is given. It seems like this series should have stopped with the first, as each episode was increasingly poor quality. In particular, the plots were very contrived, if not disjointed or just plain silly. The acting was particularly horrid, and I got rather tired of highly masculinized females running around like paramilitary militia with oversized weapons that were larger than they were. Character development was shoddy, including with Sigourney herself, so that when she “sacrificed” herself at the end of the third episode, there really wasn’t a feeling of regret. When she returns in the fourth installment, it’s almost a let-down. Each episode shows increasingly bad language, unnecessarily so, and increasing sexual innuendoes, which don’t contribute to the plot. From the first episode, people rarely ever spoke to each other, but usually yelled at each other. Most of the men were portrayed as either idiots or evil, while the women were caring or lesbian, as seen in the past episode. I saw parts I and II about 30 years ago when they first came out, and was quite disappointed to imagine that I actually liked those films at that time. I guess a touch of maturity also gives discernment. These films are not worth renting nor watching—don’t waste your time on them.

The Conservative Tradition-Teaching Co. Series

January 2nd, 2010

The Conservative Tradition, by Patrick Allitt ????

This is a Teaching Company lecture series, including a total of 36 1/2 hr lectures on the history of conservatism in the United States and Great Britain. Patrick Allitt is a professor at Emory University, though he came from England, but studied at UC Berkeley. He covers the tradition of conservatism from the mid-1700′s until the present day, providing a fairly even-handed summary of the nature and character of conservatism during that time period in the two respective countries. It is particularly interesting how problematic it is to define somebody as a conservative vs. a liberal, in that radical conservatives and radical liberals often live in the same camp, and neither a conservative nor a liberal can be clearly defined, with a multiplicity of camps between the two of them, as well as gradations. Certainly, conservatives tend toward adherence to the past traditions, which at one time was the royalists who adhered to the King. At one time, Adam Smith style economists were the liberals-they are now the conservatives. It was helpful to see that controversy raged throughout America’s history, so that certain belief systems that we hold were at one time fixed in the American ethos, such as constitutionalism, definitely never were, and the issue of the constitution of the US has always been controversial. One might define conservatives as tending toward elitism, or the upper class, and liberalism toward the common man, yet in practice, both liberals and conservatives love elitism if you are the “ruling class”, and hate elitism if your are the “common class”. By this, we see that liberals have an extreme arrogance about conservatives being “stupid”, as witnessed by their recent treatment of Sarah Palin, and their orientation toward the academic setting, and desire for secret meetings in government, contesting that the common man does not understand the intricacies of government. They are inclined to regulation and paternalism, since the “ruling class” knows better than anybody what is good for you. Contrary, the conservatives tend to argue for Republicanism rather than Democracy as the form of government of the US, which in actuality is another form of elitism, the elected official knowing better than the public at large what is good for you. All in all, the lecture series has generated a number of thoughts and questions regarding ones’ personal stance, as well as realization of the diverse nature of conservatism.

You are left guessing what leaning the professor  tends toward; is he a liberal or a conservative? One of his first statements is that he will try to remain unbiased and not disclose his personal leanings. That is an immediate clue that he has liberal leanings. His remarks about a number of conservatives  sometimes discloses an absence of understanding of conservatism, such as his comments regarding the fundamental thesis and work of Francis Schaeffer. Yet, at times, he tends to labor in argument for the strengths of the conservative tradition. My guess is the Professor Allitt is a moderate though somewhat right leaning. I could recommend this series to  liberals and conservatives and moderates and libertarians, as they would all enjoy this series and find it thought provoking.

Die Fledermaus – Covent Garden

December 29th, 2009

Die Fledermaus by Johann Strauss, conducted by Placido Domingo, Royal Opera Covent Garden ????

Die Fledermaus is a fun opera that we watch most New Year’s eves, celebrating this New Years’  Eve just a bit early. This production is well done, and Hermann Prey and Kiri Te Kanawa are absolutely marvelous. Of particular note, Te Kanawa spoke mostly English but some German, Prey spoke mostly German but some English, and the other spoken parts were a mix, with some French, Italian, and Russian, as well as Hungarian thrown in. The conductor (Domingo) even was able to add some vocal to the opera. You could tell that the singers were enjoying the production, and it  works well for New Year’s Eve.

 

 

Mad Max Road Warrior Series

December 13th, 2009

Mad Max Road Warrior Series, starring Mel Gibson ???

The story of a post-apocalyptic venture in Australia, where motorcycle gangs and mad road rage dudes seek to dominate the diminishing supplies of gasoline available. These movies are best seen in a series, and are mostly bizarre episodes of war being engaged from ever more bizarre designs of road, rail, and air vehicles. Mel stars as a cop whose family was murdered by a motorcycle gang, and goes on to ever greater glory in each movie, conquering the bad guys. I’ve seen much better films of a post-apocalyptic nature, and these don’t really do it for me. Thus, three stars.

The Gods Must Be Crazy I & II

December 11th, 2009

The Gods Must be Crazy I and II ????

It was fitting to watch these films on return from Africa. The first is the story of an African bushman, seeking to get rid of a coke bottle that his tribe thinks is bringing trouble to the tribe, a renegade revolutionary and his group of bandits, a scientist studying animals of the Kalahari, and a school teacher. Their lives all collide in a most interesting fashion in this film, reflecting the conflict of cultures occurring in Africa.

The Gods Must be Crazy II is a continuation of the same theme, this time also with multiple stories threading together, one with the bushman trying to find his children, another with elephant tusk poachers, another with a New York female lawyer accidentally stuck in the brush, etc. The story similarly resolves itself.

There is supposedly a GMBC III  which reportedly is not worth watching. These two films are entertaining but not in the top 100 of best films of all time.

The Marriage of Figaro

December 11th, 2009

The Marriage of Figaro, Mozart, Hamburg Opera, (Cult Opera) ????
11DEC09 – This opera is a wonderful classic, performed in traditional style in the 1970’s by the Hamburg Opera company. The recording is not perfect in technique, yet the performance is very compelling, and well done. This is a version of Figaro worth having in any musical repertoire. The singing was actually performed in German, rather than Italian, the way Mozart originally scripted the opera. This doesn’t seem to distract from the performance. Tom Krause and Edith Mathis are the two true stars in this film, both with superb acting and voices to make the opera a true success.

Conspiracy Theory

December 9th, 2009

Conspiracy Theory, starring Mel Gibson and Julia Roberts ????

This is a film that suggests a plethora of secret activities occurring by various governmental agencies, none aware of what the next is doing. Mel Gibson plays a taxi driver caught up in such an event, involved in psychiatric mind bending by a government official seeking to terminate various lives by various accidents occurring to them. Gibson then encounters Julia as a lawyer-investigator for the police force, caught in trying to figure out Gibson’s “psychosis” or delusionary patterns from that of actual reality. The movie is fast paced, and doesn’t end as expected. A film that is highly recommended.

Help, Help the Globolinks

December 8th, 2009

Help, Help the Globolinks, by Carl Menotti ???

This is intended to be a children’s opera, written by the same person who wrote Amahl and the Night Visitors. This story is about a space invasion by aliens, who can only be destroyed by playing musical instruments. The message of the opera is quite clear. The story was somewhat akin to Mars Attacks! without Jack Nicholson. The opera is short and thus bearable, the story line a touch contrived, the music clearly 20th century though in good taste. I’ll need to try the opera on a child someday to see if it works.


The Manchurian Candidate

December 6th, 2009

The Manchurian Candidate, starring Frank Sinatra ????

This film is one of the first left-wing accuse the right-wing of manufacturing conspiracy plot films. A group of soldiers come home from the Korean war, having been unknowingly brainwashed by communists, but hailed as war heros. Over the course of the film, the loud out-spoken anti-communist Senator devises a conspiracy to use the hero of the soldiers to kill all opponents and thus achieve the candidacy for presidency. The acting is superb and plot riveting, though it fails to admit that the “sins” of conspiracy are guilty to all parties, and yes, there was communist infiltration of the government, just as there is Muslim infiltration of our government now, though not in a highly secretive masterminded manner. Recommended as a good film to watch. In B&W.


The Running Man

December 3rd, 2009

The Running Man, starring Arnold Schwarzenegger ????

Save for some harsh language and brief nudity, this film is not too bad to watch, if you don’t mind violence. Arnold is at his best in this film with the classic line “I’ll be back”. The movie is a futuristic scene of Arnold, though innocent, being held by the State, and then put on a game show to play to the death. In the end, Arnold wins, though the movie never goes beyond winning a game show to destroying an evil empire. Such sophistication is not to be expected. A good film, that keeps you on the edge of your seat for the film. The only bad aspect is the terrible acting by Maria Alonso, the hispanic girl in the film. She doesn’t contribute to the film at all and should have been differently written into the script.


Rosemary’s Baby

December 3rd, 2009

Rosemary’s Baby, starring Mia Farrow ????

This film does not have suspense or anxiety similar to other “horror” films. The stars come from the superb acting of Mia Farrow. Otherwise, the plot is a little stale. The story was most fitting to the 1980’s when Hal Lindsey’s books like “Late Great Planet Earth” was popular, and everybody was expecting an incarnate form of the antichrist. Perhaps that will yet happen, but certainly not in the manner portrayed in this movie. The amount of witchcraft talk is kept to a minimum, and witches are sold as warm, friendly people. The baby is never shown at the end of the film. This unfortunately breeds a tolerance for Satanic activity as acceptable, save for the occasional murders and ill-effects that happen in the course of the film. Not highly recommended, and directed by Roman Polanski, who should be setting behind bars, if not worse.


Bruce Lee Series

December 2nd, 2009

Bruce Lee Series, starring Bruce Lee ????

02DEC2009  Enter the Dragon, Game of Death, Game of Death II, The Big Boss, Fist of Fury, Way of the Dragon. These films do not have any particular order, even if they seem to come across as sequels. Enter the Dragon was Bruce Lee’s last film. The acting in these films is absolutely horrible. The scene set-ups were a touch amateur. The plots are repetitive and predictable. The only thing that gives these films 4 stars is Bruce Lee himself. He is totally awesome, and indubitably the greatest Kung-fu master to ever make it into film.


Weihnachtsoratorium

November 26th, 2009

Weihnachtsoratorium BWV 248, by J.S. Bach, performances with Rilling/Stuttgart Bach Collegium, Harry Christopher and the Sixteen, Richter, Münchinger, and Thomas/Thomaskirche

This Christmas season, I listened to multiple performances of both the Weihnachtsoratorium, and the Messiah, so see also my comments on the Messiah. The Weihnachtsoratorium is an under-performed piece in the United States and Britain. Oddly, both Bach, and Händel (the composer of the Messiah) were born about 30 miles from each other in the same area of Germany, about a year apart. Their individual paths were as different as imaginable, and their music also. Händel composed almost entirely opera, and as mentioned, the Messiah is as close to an operatic piece as possible, though without acting. Bach’s piece was more intended for church, for solemnity, for pastoral reflection, for teaching of the Christmas story. Yet, omitting the flamboyancy of Händel, it is the work of an absolute genius, dare I say, a far greater genius than even Händel. The piece begins with a Pauken (kettledrum) solo. Unglaublich (unbelievable)!!! I had to listen to the opening 5-10 times and review the score the first time I heard that. Drums were not used as a solo instrument of melody until the 20th century, and to think that Bach invented that. Regarding tradition, it is sad that in English speaking countries, the far more worthy Weihnachtsoratorium goes essentially unheard, and we have to endure the Messiah year in and year out. True, the Messiah was Händel’s greatest piece, and it truly is worthy of greatness, but is still surpassed by the majesty and genius of this humble piece by Bach.

Regarding the individual performances, I preferred the Richter performance above all for its interpretation of a piece fitting the accompanying words. Münchinger is very close in conducting style to Richter, and also is a worthy listening. Rilling is typically a superb Bach conductor, but tends here to focus more of style than substance in the piece, though I’d still rate his performance highly. The Christophers have a more intimate performance, but well done. The Thomas performance is at the church where the Weihnachtsoratorium was first performed, and used children for the soprano parts, which I tend to dislike even though the original performances probably used children. I believe that Bach would have used adults if allowed by the school. All of the performances are worthy to listen to.

The Messiah

November 26th, 2009

The Messiah, by Georg Fredrick Händel, Conducted/Performed by Vienna Boys Choir  ??, Solti/CSO?????, Richter ????, Marriner????, Klemperer?????, Higginbottom???, Davis????, Bonynge???, Bernstein????, Alldis????. OK, that’s one lot of Messiah’s to be listening to in the season. I omitted the “doctored” version of the Messiah by Mozart, who translated the Messiah into German. It doesn’t sound bad. The Messiah is a theatrical piece written by a person whose claim to fame was the writing of opera. Thus, rather than a church-type feel, this piece has an auditorium type feel to it. The low rating of the Vienna Boys Choir has nothing to do with their technical skills, but only with their boyish voices, which doesn’t suit me well. The Higginbottom piece was on original instruments, and did not sound bad at all, with a more chamber-sound to the piece. In general, most of the pieces had minimal qualitative differences, though there were differences in the version of the Messiah that they chose to perform. My two favorites remain the Solti and Klemperer performances, which excel.

Note my comments on the Weihnachtsoratorium, which is also used as a Christmas concert piece, though rarely in the US. It is a pity since, though the Messiah is a work of genius, the Weihnachtsoratorium even excels the Messiah. Perhaps someday it will measure more prominently in American church performances.

Death on the Nile

November 21st, 2009

Death on the Nile, starring Peter Ustinov, David Niven, etc. ???

This movie was watched while int he guest house at N’Djemena, waiting for our flight out of Chad, and most of the original review when the movie was fresh on my mind was lost in the iWeb crash. The stars were certainly quite select, though my impression was that of watching a soap opera more than that of seeing a serious movie. It was no fault of the acting, but probably more of that of the director. I was also somewhat taken back by the very contrived plot, especially with the end solution to the murder mystery. It was truly not a believable ending, leaving the entire story in question. I have not read any of Agatha Christie, but if her other stories are similar to this, I will find them all not worth reading. She might have called down little green Martians to be the murders, and the story would have been just as believable as her ending. A movie not worth watching.

Die Schöpfung – Karajan

October 31st, 2009

Die Schöpfung, Conducted by von Karajan ?????

This review is in conjunction with the review of the same piece conducted by Bernstein. While Bernstein offers a rather operatic approach to this Oratorio, Karajan offers a gentler, more pastoral rendering. The performance and recording is impeccable, the sound coming across with clarity and vibrancy in both pieces. Karajan manages to arrive at the soul of this piece in a better manner than Bernstein. This is a strange comment, since Karajan is usually accused as performing too much to the camera. Yet, I see Bernstein as the more flamboyant conductor, when viewed on video. This flamboyancy comes through in the sound of the performance. This is my preferred performance of Die Schöpfung, even though I would give both pieces 5 stars. This piece is a perfect example as to why it is important to listen to the same piece by differing conductors, as the performance is distinctly different in each case.

Die Schöpfung – Bernstein

October 31st, 2009

Die Schöpfung, by Franz Haydn, performed by Leonard Bernstein and Bayerischen Rundfunks ?????

I review this recording in conjunction with Herbert von Karajan,s version of the same oratorio. Both are excellent, though both are completeley different. Both command the best of the best soloists, this version using Judith Blegen, Thomas Moser, Kurt Moll, Lucia Pop, etc. In both, the sound is superb. Bernstein’s performance has a more aggressive, forward feel to it. It is conducted as though he were conducting an opera. It is always lively, with a sense of sprint to the pieces including the various solists pieces. This is a performance of Haydn’s oratorio that is much worth having. See critic above…

Luther

October 31st, 2009

Luther, starring Joseph Fiennes ?????

This is the third or fourth time that I have seen this film, but have not yet reviewed it. There are several video histories of Martin Luther that have been made, but I feel this to be the best. I have only seen the film in German. J. Fiennes makes a perfect Luther, and the script seems to not deviate too wildly from the history that we have of Luther in order to sensationalize matters. Luther does not need “Hollywood-ization”, yet they still did a moderate amount of this, such as with the mother of a crippled child, and the adulating crowds. Also, they tended to make Luther appear like a dolt in the Augustiner Kloster, yet most history reports him to be quite brilliant even at that time. So, the historical data was reasonable, but not perfect. This is a good film to watch, but hopefully, you also take the time to read books about the Reformation to find out what really happened, and the real theological underpinnings of the Reformation.

Les Miserables

October 29th, 2009

Les Miserables, Starring Liam Neeson ????

I’ve never read the book before. The other versions of Les Miserables that I have seen include the version starring Gerard Depardieu, and the take-off of John-Paul Belmondo, as well as the play by the name, which I saw in London. The London play would receive only one star. Gerard Depardieu was a better lead man Jean Valjean, though this production had superb filmography, and acting that truly could not be criticized. The John-Paul Belmondo is a 5-star worthy film, though is a take-off of the story set in WWII Paris. This version has some problems. 1. It reportedly does not follow the Victor Hugo text closely at all. 2. It turns Cosette into a spoiled brat. 3. The boy revolutionary leader is a girly-man– why does Hollywood love girly-men so much nowdays? 4. There is an abnormal sense of a love affair with Cosettes’ mother, which I doubt the book really portrays. 6. The movie never explores the rationale behind the Inspector finally turning Jean Valjean free and committing suicide. The version here is a version worth watching, if you are a Les Miserables fan, with the criticisms noted, it’s still worth 4 stars.


Shostakovich String Quartets

October 27th, 2009

Shostakovich String Quartets, Borodin String Quartets ?????

I have four versions of the Shostakovich String Quartets, including those by the Borodin, Fitzwilliam, Shostakovich, and Emerson Quartets. The Borodin was my first purchase, and still my favorite, though I would be reluctant to give any of the renditions anything less than 5 stars, as they are all well done. This recording is slightly more recessive than the others, as though it was recorded in a large hall, giving it a sense of the mysterious depth than seems to be written into this music. The performers seem to have a feel for the great angst and depression that Shostakovich was experiencing as he wrote his most intimate and private works, many of these quartets not being performed or published until after his death. They are creative, soulful, brilliant in their composition, and reflective of the greatest of the greatest composer of the 20th century. Included in this set is the most delightful piano quintet. I will offer special mention to the 15th string quartet, Shostakovich’s last. It begins with an elegy, immediately followed by the screech quartet, a funeral march, and finally a very active ending. It is the composer at his greatest, and in this quartet, Shostakovich says more than most 20th century composers in their lifetime of compositional output. This is truly a set of string quartets worth owning.

Sweet Land

October 17th, 2009

Sweet Land, starring Elizabeth Reaser ??

This is the story of a German (????Norwegian) bride to be moving to Northern Minnesota to be married in the early 1920’s farmland. The bride Inge encounters grave community vitriol, and marriage is refused until her husband to be saves the day, so to speak, at one spot. The story is based on a Will Weaver novel, and produced by Ali Salim. Unfortunately, having a father that grew up as a German immigrant in that area and time, things were not well depicted as representative of America. In effect, it was just another effort by Hollywood and Muslim producers to make American faith and religion appear unloving and cruel, when in actuality, though harsh, it was everything but was depicted in this film. The thought processes were a late 20th century projection of early twentieth century religious and community farm life. Indeed, one Amazon reviewer has is correct that the book author has only a superficial sense of what it was like to live back at that time. The movie never develops true depth to its characters, and even the attempt at foreign language fails, with gibberish being muttered for either German or Norwegian. The farming was ridiculous-they were harvesting corn but delivering wheat to the market. They used no horses, and two people hand picked 160 acres. Farm communities always tended to be closer than what was portrayed. I watched this film with an Englander in the group, who asked if this truly what America was like back then. Unfortunately, this sort of rubbish in filming only creates images of moral judgmentalism at a time when America held moral values but also strong hospitality and deep community spirit.   Truly Hollywood could have done better than that. Many Amazon reviewers suggested that this was a touching love story demanding Kleenex. I’m not sure about the Kleenex, but there were enough errors in the film to ruin a story that could have made a good film.

The Kingdom of Heaven

October 10th, 2009

The Kingdom of Heaven, starring Orlando Bloom ??

This film was rated R for violence. I saw the film in Cameroon, and some of the editorial was lost in the iWeb crash. I’ll do my best. There was a moderate amount of violence in the film, most of which did not contribute to the general flow of the theme, and placed mostly for entertainment purposes. It is a very quasi-historical depiction of some crusaders going to Jerusalem to retain the city following the first crusade. The main character was the illegitimate son of one of the princes in the Holy Land. The main character notes the depth of corruption of both the ruling class and clergy in Jerusalem, particularly the desire to continue to militarily rule the area. In the end, the movie makes the invading Arabs out to be the morally more righteous, and the Christians as the cheats, naves, dishonest fools. All renditions of Christian clergy were shown to be steeped in dishonor, greed, and corruption. While this is certainly partially true, it is hard for me to imagine the Muslim invaders as any more righteous in their behavior or deeds. Thus, the movie degenerates into a politically correct statement of love for Islam, but historically lacking.

Fidelio

September 25th, 2009

Fidelio, Hamburg Opera, Cult Opera Series ?????

Though the music is absolutely spectacular and fitting of Beethoven at his best, the opera also shows the problems that Beethoven had at writing opera, in that the staging is quite awkward, making it challenging for any opera company to produce. This opera is a “reality” opera filmed in a real Spanish prison rather than on the stage. The singing is absolutely spectacular, with an awesome cast, including a very young Lucia Popp as Marcelline. The recording has a slightly tin-ny ring to it, as though you were listening to an old RCA recording from the 1950’s. This opera was produced in 1968. In spite of all the faults, it was so well done, that it deserves 5 stars.

The Blues Brothers

September 16th, 2009

The Blues Brothers, starring John Belushi and Dan Aykroyd ????

I give this movie four stars a touch reluctantly, since it is really gutter cinema-photography, about which I have ranted in the past. There are no real sexual smut, just bad language, and antics of very bad behavior. The film is quite dated, and most the jokes are worn out. In spite of all that, it is a funny film, leaving you in suspense as to the outcome, if you don’t remember it from the last time you watched it. John Belushi gets out of prison, and immediately gets in trouble from the law again, spending his time with his brother running from the law, while simultaneously trying to re-start their band and raise money for the convent-school in which they were raised. Special effects are quite plentiful, such as when they drive their car through a mall, destroying everything, followed by multiple police cars, all of which were destroyed. Having lived in Chicago, it was nice to see the town again.

 

Orpheus in der Unterwelt

September 9th, 2009

Orpheus in der Unterwelt, by Jacques Offenbach, Hamburg Opera ????

This opera is part of a set, whose review you will be seeing in completion in the next six months, titled Cult Opera. These are operas filmed at the Hamburg Opera, in color, and meant for television. Regardless, they are very well done, with modest but adequate staging, and superb performers. The opera is a comic opera spoof by Offenbach on the Orpheus motif, and a touch raucous, thus, not suited for young children, who wouldn’t be watching this opera anyway. It is a fun opera to watch, and gives the viewer the lighter side of opera, though laced with much speaking. This production ranks with the other Orpheus opera productions that I have. This opera does not have many available productions on DVD, and so it’s difficult to compare with other Aufführungen. That’s too bad. I still prefer Les Contes d’Hoffman as my favorite Offenbach opera, but this ranks high.

 

As Far as my Feet will Carry Me

August 16th, 2009

As Far as my Feet will Carry Me, starring B. Bettermann ?????

This is an excellent story, apparently based on the true account (though it appears to have a few Hollywood-style changes) of a German soldier after world war II held captive in a Gulag in the far reaches of Siberia. The first half of the film chronicles the conditions of the Gulag system, and the second half of his harrowing escape to freedom. You are always left on the edge of your chair, with excellent filmography as well as superlative acting. The film was made in German with burned in English subtitles, something that should never be in the age of dvds, where subtitles should be able to be turned on or off.  When Russian is spoken (often), no translation is given.

One of the reviewers of this film on Amazon.com made note that Hollywood tends to predominate in Nazi films, yet completely overlook the Soviet gulag system. Knowing that the Soviets murdered at least 3x as many Jews as Hitler, and that their span of terror lasted 50 years, compared to the 2-3 years of Hitler, you are left to conclude that Stalin and the Soviet system was a far greater evil than Hitler, yet Stalin was an “ally” of the west. Germany felt sorry for their “mistake”, but Russia continues in their arrogance of having done nothing wrong. Why doesn’t Hollywood figure this out? Perhaps this is why I enjoy foreign films, as they don’t have the ideological base of Hollywood.

 

Hotel Rwanda

August 8th, 2009

Hotel Rwanda, starring Don Cheadle ????

This is a moving story, supposedly based on factual accounts, of a hotel manager during the Rwandan civil war and near-genocide. The movie tale symbolized the insanity of genocide in a most Hollywood fashion, portraying heros and villains and total pandemonium during the civil war. Even still, the film is well done with a low cheesiness factor, thus making it worthwhile to watch on a lonely Friday night when you have nothing else to watch.

 

Hannibal Lecter Collection

July 29th, 2009

Manhunter ???, Silence of the Lambs ?????, Hannibal ????

This series of the Hannibal Lecter story was filmed first with the highly successful Silence of the Lambs, followed by Hannibal, and then Manhunter. All are very suspenseful films. Silence of the Lambs has the best acting, and best script. Hannibal is superb for the continued  presence of Anthony Hopkins as Dr. Lecter, though Clarise Starling is much better acted by Jodie Foster than Julianne Moore, whose personality fit the part much better.  These films represent a psychopathic psychiatrist (aren’t they all????) Dr. Hannibal Lecter who has taken an enjoyment in cannibalism. He also suffers from the brilliance of understanding the nature of his own illness all too well, as well the ability to continually elude the police. This allows for the potential of many more sequels. Lecter has been able to breed a number of other psychopaths who delight in the abduction of younger girls and using their body parts for various means to gain their jollies. The graphic imagery is superbly filmed, especially such scenes as Hannibal removing someone’s calvarium with them still awake, and then feeding them their own brains sautéed in a most French fashion. These movies are fairly gory, and not for the faint-hearted, though all were fairly well done. Watch them, but not with children.

 

PeeWee Herman Collection

July 18th, 2009

Pee Wee’s Big Adventure ?????, Big Top Pee Wee ??

Pee Wee starred in a tv series, after which these two full movie productions were based. Paul Reubens eventually was removed from the children’s tv circuit for immoral behavior in public, though the films themselves are clean. The Big Adventure is with Pee Wee having his bicycle stolen, and then going off to find it. It is full of Pee Wee humor, and Pee Wee at his best. The follow-up film, Big Top Pee Wee was a total flop, with Pee Wee dumping his fiancee to join the circus. There is very little humor in the second movie as compared to the first, and the story line fails in all respects. The Big Adventure deserves a watch, as an example of classic clean humor.

 

Karajan – A film by Dornheim

July 18th, 2009

Karajan – A film by Dornheim ???

This is not exactly a music review, but rather, the review of a film about a musician. This film attempts a limited biography of Karajan, one of many, including comments of many musicians still alive that have played under his baton. The film is mildly biographical, but very limited in its scope as a biography. It certainly deals with the complex nature of this man, thought by some to be warm and friendly, others, to be cold and distant. It starts from his early career at his birthplace in Salzburg, ending in his painful last few years while suffering severe back pain and conducting the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra. Each phase in his life is given only cursory treatment, while tending to be positive as a whole. Thus, a film worth watching for Karajan fans, but not the best film biography of the man.

 

Little Miss Sunshine

July 16th, 2009

Little Miss Sunshine ??

It has recently come into vogue to show highly pathological families doing highly pathological activities, and we are supposed to consider that humorous. Such is the case with this film. Fortunately, except for the foul mouth of the grandfather, as well as his drug-using activities, most of what we see is not terribly offensive and can be watched by even young children. This is not a film to inspire one to greater things. It is cesspool cinephotography. It does not make a moral point, or suggest that the behaviors are either wrong, or that there might be a higher aspiration in life. The greatest humor is when “Little Miss Sunshine” Olive does a faux striptease venue for the beauty contest. Both the pseudo-moral reaction of the judges as well as the accepted humor of the matter actually were not funny. I found it hard except in a few spots to see the comedy in this film. Not worth watching.

 

Chuck Norris American Hero Collection

July 15th, 2009

Chuck Norris Collection, including Delta Force I & II, Missing in Action I, II, & III. ????

Having just seen the Die Hard Collection and the Lethal Weapon Series, and Rambo series, I tended to like this series the most, with the Die Hard collection a close second. The Delta Force series included two settings, the first with terrorists in a NY airport, and second with drug-dealers from South America, and the MIA series dealt with, of course, Vietnam. Norris was entertaining in that he is not only a good actor, but was able to maintain a story line without much sex and obscene language. All of these films derive their entertainment value from the special effects of things blowing up. If that isn’t your cup of tea, watch something else. Fortunately, this collection came at under $15, and I wouldn’t pay much more for it.

 

Fierrabras – Schubert

July 12th, 2009

Fierrabras, an opera by Franz Schubert, and performed at the Zürich Opera House, conducted by Franz Welser-Möst. ??

Schubert wrote 10 operas, yet they are all rarely if ever performed. This is the only opera of his that has been actually filmed. The music itself gets 5-stars, as Schubert remains the greatest song writer ever. The story and plot line gets a 3 star rating, mostly because Schubert did not excel in finding good script writers. The music performance gets a 4, and the staging gets a bare 1-star. The staging is an odd 20th century, historical, minimalist mix. The worst part was the constant distraction of “Schubert”, somebody dressed up like Schubert, who had a rare speaking role, but otherwise mostly interacted constantly with the singers. Fortunately, there were no suitcases or trench coats. There was an oversized piano and chair, that seemed to fit into every scene, and multiple doors that the stage people and singers would come and go through. All in all, it was too bizarre, and did not contribute to explaining the opera. Opera, by its nature, is both auditory and visual. It is hard to omit the visual in an opera, without destroying the intent of the composer. Liberties with staging are as much a crime to the music, as attacking the script itself. When the visual elements distract or attempt a completely different re-interpretation of the composer’s intention of the opera, then I consider the performance to have failed. And that is where this performance has failed. It would be better to get a recording of this opera, than to watch what has been presented in this performance.

 

Cyrano de Bergerac

July 11th, 2009

Cyrano de Bergerac, starring Gerard Depardieu ?????

There are many versions of Cyrano de Bergerac that have been filmed,  and I have seen none of the others. Depardieu is a favorite French actor of mine, and he truly excels in this film. I could not imagine a better Cyrano than Depardieu. This is a story of a swordsman Cyrano in love with his distant cousin Roxane, but beset with a colossally large nose. He is a truly master swordsman, but also excels with words. Under Cyrano is a younger man named Christian, with whom Roxane is in love. Cyrano finds Christian to be bumbling at the art of words for wooing a woman, and so writes his speeches to Roxane, speaks for him, and writes letters to Roxane in the name of Christian. Roxane is thus in love with Christian, but because she thinks the letters and words are his and not Cyrano’s. She eventually discovers that she actually was in love with Cyrano all along, but that is the story that you will have to watch to know. The acting and sets are all superb, it is an clean film which even kids could watch, and one of the best films of the French cinematography scene that I’ve seen. Thus, five stars.

 

Lethal Weapon Collection

July 5th, 2009

Lethal Weapon 1, 2, 3, & 4, starring Mel Gibson ??

I have appreciated other Mel Gibson films, and had hoped that this set would be equally appreciated. It was not. The plot lines are good, with frequent fast action, and impressive race scene, lots of buildings blown up, cars destroyed, ships sunk, etc., etc. The acting was good to awful, especially with the input of Joe Pesci, who is more an annoyance than a contribution to the plot of the film. The things that made the films low rated were the inappropriate graphic sex scenes, which did not contribute to the flow of the film, and to the endless barrage of horrid language. It grew a bit wearisome. There seemed that the actors had a 5-10 word vocabulary, and hadn’t gone beyond. Mel Gibson should have done better than that.

 

Moses und Aron

June 26th, 2009

Moses und Aron, by Arnold Schönberg, Wiener Oper ??

This is an unfinished opera by Arnold Schönberg, the inventor of 12-tone music, and staged at the Vienna Opera. It was not a really likable opera and I honestly could not wait until the end of the opera. The music was the most bearable part of the opera, though quite cacaphonic, seemed to fix the sets. The staging was bizarre-I weary with the use of trench coats and suitcases, as it seems like it is a worn-out idea in the minimalist operatic regimen. Can’t set designers be a little more creative? The philosophy and theology of Schönberg is a mix of Karl Barth and the Tübingen school, in Jewish clothing-a god completely incomprehensible, and completely other and thus not communicable. This is a good reference DVD to show exactly why Schönberg is not more popular on the operatic circuits.

 

l’Histore d’Adele H

June 24th, 2009

24JUN2009 l’Histore d’Adele H., by François Truffaut ????

This is actually a true story of the daughter of Victor Hugo, driven mad out of love for a soldier in the British army, and moving to Halifax, Canada, then later to the Caribbean, to be with him. The acting was superb, and the story line engaging, the filming was outstanding, as fitting for one of the greatest film directors of France, F. Truffaut. This is a rather clean film, no violence, no sex, nothing offensive for children, but better connected with real life (it was real life!) than the fictional stories of Jane Austin, thus, making it a believable love (hate?) story. Highly recommended. Not really a guy film, but good to watch when one is learning French. Oui, oui! There are English subtitles, so that even Betsy enjoyed the film.

 

Die Hard Triology

June 20th, 2009

Die Hard, Die Hard II, Die Hard with a Vengeance, starring Bruce Willis ???

This series is well done, though the style of plot remains similar with each of the three movies, so that, once you’ve seen one, you get the idea. Each movie centers around a bad guy, using terrorist tactics of mass killing, in order to steal large amounts of money, while secondarily, trying to kill John McClean (Bruce Willis), a cop from NY. Bruce gets beat up fairly badly, while ultimately getting the bad guy. The graphics are quite good as well as the action scenes. The language is quite foul, and often excessive at that. The final plot is a touch fantastic, outside of the realm of reality. Thus, three stars.

 

Vertical Limit

June 17th, 2009

Vertical Limit ?

This is a movie about climbing of K2 by a young brash group of climbers, accompanied by a film crew from National Geographic. The main characters are a brother and sister whose father and other family members perished in a family rock climb, which demanded that one of the family members cut the rope to save their life, but lead to the death of the other members of the family. All in all, the only value to this film was nice cinemaphotography. It’s deficits are plentiful. There are multiple serious climbing inaccuracies, including a) people don’t climb 5-6 people per rope on rock b) people don’t have major amounts of flesh exposed with light garments high on K2 c) people don’t breath easily for long periods of time in the death zone, d) steroids are not the magic fix for HAPE, e) nobody survives for more than an hour deep in a crevasse, as it’s just too cold, etc., etc. The film was produced mostly in New Zealand, which was also quite easy to detect. The plot of the story was quite crazy. Subplots, such as the necessity of carrying large quantities of nitroglycerine to the top of K2 in order to rescue their comrades was stupid. Historic climbing ethic was that you go down with your party, and not that you cut yourself loose in order to kill your rope members and save your own skin. I am not sure why such a quality climber like Ed Viestures would allow himself to have multiple cameos in the film with so many gross inadequacies. This film is not worth watching.

 

Intermezzo – Richard Strauss

June 17th, 2009

Intermezzo, by Richard Strauss, dir. John Cox, starring Felicity Lott ???

This is a well performed opera, and Felicity Lott is absolutely delightful, both with her voice and in her acting. It is somewhat autobiographical, reflecting an incident somewhat early on in the marriage of Richard and Pauline Strauss. This is one of Strauss’s last operas, and reflects music that is most wonderful, but the singing tends to border on Sprachstimme, (sing-song voice) rather than real singing. It’s not an opera that one would tend to watch many times over, or produce musical exerpts. But, it does reflect creative genius manifest by R. Strauss, and thus worth watching at least once.

 

The Wages of Fear

June 12th, 2009

Wages of Fear, Dir. Henri Clouzot ????

This is a fascinating story of life in a South American town, where a nearby American oil company requests the assistance of four drivers to carry high explosives into an oil field area to put out a oil well fire. The drive is extremely precarious, and the risk of jarring the explosives so extreme, that the likelihood of achieving the goal is quite low, though the pay is high if the driver succeeds. Of the four drivers, one does make it through. The film maintains a high anxiety, though it is very slow in getting going. Also, a total of three languages is regularly spoken, including Spanish, French and English.

 

Babette’s Feast

June 8th, 2009

Babette’s Feast, dir. Just Betzer ?????

This is a wonderful film that is slow moving, but very unpredictable in its outcome. Two pious sisters pass up love and the opportunity for great success on the world scene, to remain in a remote hamlet in Denmark. They are visited by an escapee from the French civil wars, who ends up being the head chef of a famous Parisian restaurant. The feast doesn’t start until well into the film, when the 12 people present to enjoy the feast are all quite doubtful about the food or the possibility of witchcraft in its preparation. Over the course of the meal, bitternesses are broken down, and people begin for the first time to speak truthfully to each other. The moral lesson is the importance not only of devout faith, but also of enjoyment of the gifts that God has given us.

 

Das Rheingold – Karajan

June 2nd, 2009

Das Rheingold, directed by Herbert von Karajan ????

This opera has its pluses and minuses. Apparently after this was filmed, there was so much distress among the cast that further operas in Der Ring were not completed. The staging is superb, the best of all the Rheingold’s that I’ve seen. It is exactly what you would expect from a traditional Ring. The acting and singing was also superb, as well as the musical conducting. The main problem that I had was more technical. The filming was quite poor, and often one could not see what was on the picture. Also, the recording was quite inadequate and balance between the orchestra and singers was terrible. Thus, only four stars for an otherwise excellent production.

 

Momo

June 1st, 2009

Momo  ???

This film is after the book of the same name by Michael Ende, and previously reviewed by me. The director takes moderate directing liberties, and does not follow the text exactly, though it seems reasonably close to the book. The film was entirely in German, but most of it could be understood by me. The acting is okay, but not superb. The sets are a touch odd at times. The book seems to provoke the imagination, and convey the message of the importance of not being too busy, far better than the movie. It is a cute, but not a great film.

 

The Color of Paradise

March 21st, 2009

The Color of Paradise  Directed Majid Majidi ? ? ? ?

We’re in Bangladesh, at the Kelley’s. We wanted to watch “What about Bob?”. We can’t get the system working. So, we put on an Iranian film, with English subtitles. At first I was a bit skeptical. What decent film could come out of Iran? This film was superb. The cinemetography was first class. The story is about a young blind child, finishing a year of school in Teheran, and going home with his widowered father to the hills outside of Teheran. I had no idea as to the beauty of Iran. It was quite nice, and quite rugged. The story discusses the dilemma of a father trying to find a life for his child, first by attempting to re-marry, later, by attempting to get his son to work with another blind wood craftsman. Ultimately the film has a tragic end. I was very tempted to give this film five-stars, but knocked it down, only because I didn’t appreciate the director trying to be too artistic with the story line, by leaving mystery such as at the end as to whether the boy met a tragic versus fortunate end. It was more a story line that you might expect from the avant-garde French directors, and while leaving a sympathy for the handicapped, failed to make a strong moral or philosophical statement, but left one hanging. One aside… if I would have seen this film several weeks ago, I would have been fairly annoyed by the dress of the women. Now that we’ve been in Bangladesh for a week, I am appreciating the (usually) colorful though fully-covered dress that is found in this part of the world.

 

Hymns of Worship & Precious Memories

February 28th, 2009

Hymns of Worship and Precious Memories, sung by Prairie Choristers ???

First of all, I love these songs. I grew  up with them.  The Zion’s Harp is the song book of the Apostolic Christian Church, a small Amish-Mennonite type church that was my church for the first 25 years of life. The hymns that are sung are absolutely beautiful and taken from mostly the German heritage of the church fathers. The ACC split in the early 20th century, and these songs are performed a mid-west group by the split side that I attended before at 13, which was when my parents then switched to the other “side”. In that side, church singing was entirely accapella, though they often used the piano in their homes. These songs are technically well performed. The recordings do not have a good balance, and the men’s voices are very difficult to hear, even when they are soloing. Another nuance that is disturbing about these performances is their overt technical accuracy, while entirely missing the emotion or spirit of what they are singing about. They rarely ever change their volume or tempo, and one could perform them to a metronome. I realize that the performers probably feel very strongly about the words of these songs, and yet these recordings show a complete absence of that warmth or love for the object of their song. So, only three stars.

 

Das Leben der Andern

February 21st, 2009

Das Leben der Andern (The Lives of Others) ? ? ? ? ?

A German made film that has English subtitles, this extremely well done movie won not only international acclaim, with the winner of the Academy Award for best foreign language film of 2006, but also considered the top conservative film of the last 25 years, according to National Review. It is the moving story of a artist being held under surveillance by the Stasi in the former DDR (East Germany). It is a witness of the realities of state control of one’s life, and even one’s thought. I fear that telling the plot would ruin the film for subsequent viewers. I must say that this is a must film, especially in the US as we have increasing state surveillance all intended on protecting us from Terrorists and the like. Though the film is rated R, there is minimal scenes that one would find even remotely offensive. Bill Buckley Jr. shows good taste in calling this one of his favorite films of all time.

 

The Ten Commandments

February 20th, 2009

The Ten Commandments, directed by Cecil DeMille ? ?

I’ve never seen this movie before, even though I’ve heard much about it, so decided that it was time. In 3.5 hours with a star studded cast, DeMille proceeds to portray the story of the Biblical Exodus. Unfortunately, he takes effort at the start of the movie to argue for the strict historicity of the movie, yet, the storyline has Hollywood written all over it, including the love affair of Moses for Nephriti and the delay in relevation to the Egyptians that Moses was actually Hebrew. The impressive visual scenes in an age before computer animation are quite notable. The rest of the movie fails. It is a movie worth watching once, but certainly not worth owning.

 

Ivan Rebroff Live in Concert

February 20th, 2009

Ivan Rebroff Live in Concert ? ? ?

A rather pathetic film done on a concert given by Ivan Rebroff in Syndney, Australia in 1984. Rebroff certainly had one of the most remarkable voices of the 20th century, with a range from deep bass to high tenor, and a fluency with both multiple languages and acting that was rather remarkable. This film does not do Rebroff a service, being a rather odd performance and not the best recording. Useful only for Rebroff fans.

 

Conan the Barbarian

December 31st, 2008

Conan the Barbarian, starring Arnold Schwarznegger ? ? ? ? ?

I’ve seen this movie probably more than 30 times, yet it continually remains funny and fresh. First inspired by Dr. Pridjian to watch this film, it nearly became a cult film for the General Surgeons at Cook County Hospital. We would get together just to watch Arnold do his thing. This film is difficult to take serious. The plot is stupid, the acting is horrid, but quotes are often from historic characters, like Gengis Khan or historica situations. The music of Prokofiev is used prolifically. It was seen again only because Andrew Flanagan had never seen Conan before, and New Years eve seemed the most fitting time to watch it, if we weren’t going to watch another version of Die Fledermaus. In spite of all its stupidity, the movie seems to work, and it’s nice to see the governor of California in one of his earlier roles. Though there is a modest amount of partial nudity, it is never presented in a vile fashion, and the biggest aspect to prevent kids from watching this film is the shear violence that occurs. Of course, this film can turn one into a violent person, as is witnessed by a generation of surgeons from Cook County Hospital.

 

Oistrakh-Concertos and Encores

December 31st, 2008

David Oistrakh-Concertos and Encores ?????

These concerti (not concertos!) were published by Deutsche Grammaphon, which means of superlative recording style. The sound is very forward, which on my system, is close to being in the concert hall. This set consists of a potpourri of Oistrakh recordings, but most importantly, the Mendelssohn, Bruch, Glazunov, Prokofiev, and  Kabalevsky concerti. There is some repetition with the EMI set, with the Bruch and Prokofiev concerti on both sets, and some concerti only on the EMI set, such as the Brahms, Khatchaturian, and Shostakovich concerti. The duplicated pieces are definitely different performances, and definitely better recorded with DG than with EMI. Both sets are worth having. Oistrakh is a consummate violinist, the best that could ever be, and these recordings reflect the various pieces performed at their very best. Oistrakh is not so strident as Haifetz, and not as smooth or mellow as Menuhin. It is a commanding sweetness that I would make it my preferred recording for the hypothetical desert island setting.

 

Great Minds of the Western Tradition

December 30th, 2008

Great Minds of the Western Tradition, various professors (Teaching Company).????

This series was a mix, with some very good and some very average professors. Starting with the Greeks, various notable philosophers were discussed, typically all by people who were expert on that person. I’ve reviewed some of the teachers in the blog site. The series is quite variable in quality, is highly repetitive of the Greeks, and leaves out many of the most important thinkers of the 19th and 20th centuries. All in all, it’s been an enjoyable series, that I will probably listen to again someday.

 

Ravi Shankar

December 30th, 2008

Ravi Shankar ????

OK, it’s not fair reviewing six albums at once. The third (West Meets East) and last (Shankar Sitar Concertos) were a touch different, in that they also included either Yehudi Menuhin or an orchestra, or both). In the first album, Ravi explains in western musical terms exactly what is happening with the music. First, it is not based exactly on the western 12-tone system, and will have many other tones included. It will not necessarily utilize conventional harmonies. The beat may be quite odd metered-such as 13 beat per measure. It is a mix of fixed format as well as improvisations, thou Ravi makes clear that it definitely is not jazz. All in all, it has a tendency toward serialism, or minimalism, which it also is not.  Shankar did cut an album with the master of minimalism, Phillip Glass, which shows a tendency to accommodate to such a musical form. I don’t like minimalism, though this music was rather enjoyable to listen to. The sitar is a fairly complex instrument to play, and is usually accompanied by a “drone” as well as a semi-pitched percussion instrument. I’m not sure there is a necessity of purchasing many albums by Ravi Shankar, since the pieces seem to lack the distinctiveness that would allow the listener to distinguish one piece from another. I’m sure more familiarity with his music might help a bit.

 

Heifetz Tchaikovsky & Mendelssohn Violin Concerti

December 28th, 2008

Jascha Heifetz Tchaikovsky & Mendelssohn Violin Concerti, with Fritz Reiner and the CSO ?????

It is difficult to imagine somebody not liking the Tchaikovsky and Mendelssohn violin concerti, and this recording is supremely done to enhance ones’ appreciation for these two pieces. Not only are the recordings of superb quality, but the performance by both Heifetz and Reiner are at the best that these two concerti could experience. Heifetz is an especially commanding and aggressive performer, while maintaining technical brilliance. While Menuhin (reviewed above) has a sweet, light and airy approach, Heifetz has no hesitation to attack. Both, as well as Oistrakh, are the best of the best. Yet, their particular performing styles create entirely different pieces. All three performers are worth having in one’s repetoire.

 

M

December 26th, 2008

M, by Fritz Lang ? ? ? ? ?

Anything by Fritz Lang is a masterpiece, and this is no exception. It is the story of a psychotic child murderer (Peter Lorre in one of his first roles), being pursued not only by the police, but by the underworld, for giving crime a bad name. The filming is wonderful, and it’s very dark story-line maintains an active pace that keeps the viewer fixed to the screen. The film is entirely in German, and there are no under-titles, so that non-German speakers may not enjoy this film.

 

Franz Kafka’s It’s A Wonderful Life

December 23rd, 2008

Franz Kafka’s It’s A Wonderful Life ? to ?? ?

This is actually a set of four shorts. The first receives a 4-star, (It’s a Wonderful Life), the story of a tormented Franz trying to write the Metamorphosis, but constantly being disturbed by neighbors and people knocking at the door. It finally ends in a “Wonderful Life” fashion, with all the playors now quite happy. The second film (Seven Gates) was a rather boring story of two brothers as they drive home after years of being away. The third film (The Deal) was awful and too obscene to even finish watching. The fourth (Mr. McAllister’s Cigarette Holder) was an entertaining story of a southern hick affixed to his cigarette holder. All in all, only the first was really funny, so wouldn’t advise anyone wasting their time to watch.

 

Menuhin Mendelssohn & Bruch Violin Concerti

December 23rd, 2008

Yehudi Menuhin Mendelssohn & Bruch Violin Concerti, Israel Philharmonic ?????

As compared to the Mozart, Beethoven, Brahms, Tchaikovsky, Mendelssohn, Khatchaturian and Shostakovich violin concerti, I am relatively unfamiliar with the Bruch violin concerto. I wouldn’t be able to compare this recording with other performances. The Mendelssohn performance is virtually stupendous, and Menuhin shows a mastery of this concerto equalled by few others. His is a sweet, melodic, flowing performance. His style reminded me of the playing of the wife of a very good friend of mine (Anita H.) in the song-like delivery of even the technically most demanding portions of a piece. Both are delightful pieces worthy of a humble collection.

 

Star Wars Prequel Trilogy

December 22nd, 2008

Star Wars Prequel Trilogy ??

This series doesn’t really deserve two stars, save that the special effects were quite awesome, as well as the sound. Following the great star wars trilogy, this set is a horrid disappointment. The acting is very poor, the story line is highly predictable and unoriginal, resulting in a rather boring set of films.  There is horrid character development and the characters have no depth, examples including JaJa and the young Anakin Skywalker, as well as the princess Amadala. The third of the series was the best, utilizing a concrete story line, rather than simply just throwing special effects at you. All in all, this set is not worth watching, even for the avid Star Wars fan. George Lucas could have done much better.

 

Rambo Trilogy

December 20th, 2008

Rambo Trilogy with Silvester Stallone       First Blood ?????, First Blood Part Two ????,   Rambo Three ???

It’s hard to believe that I have never seen any of the Rambo films, since they’ve been out for a number of years now. I’ve also not seen any of the Rocky films but have no intention of watching them. Rambo was very entertaining, though moderately violent. In the first film of the series, Rambo is a returning Viet Nam veteran who is unjustly arrested by a small-town Amerikan cop as being a vagrant, but who escapes and is pursued into the woods by the red-neck police force. Ultimately, he gives himself up, but only after extreme pain by the small-town police. If the second film, Rambo is recruited to identify whether there were Amerikan prisoners of war still being held in Viet Nam. Rambo finds a prison camp that has Amerikan prisoners and eventually proceeds to free them, learning that the government had no intention of rescuing them, but instead faking that they looked for prisoners and found none. In the third film, Rambo goes to Afganistan to help rescue the poor peace-loving Afghans from the nasty Soviets. In all the films, Stallone is an awesome actor, and the scenery and filming is stupendous. The first film is correct that the government really does give a hoot about you as an individual. In the second film, the statement is stronger, that the government is actually our enemy. Stallone makes a summary statement that he loves his country even though his country doesn’t love him. In the third film, Amerika is posed as the rescuer of Afghanistan from the terrible Soviets. I’m sure we now wish that we would have left the Soviets be. Oddly, our government never learns from its mistakes, and are now the replacement to the evil Soviets. The Rambo series makes a statement now that never was intended when filmed, and is an entertaining watch.

 

Haydn – Symphonies

December 20th, 2008

Haydn; Symphonies, conducted by Antal Dorati ?????

104 symphonies, and numerous extra excerpts later, I finished the complete Haydn symphonies. These symphonies are best heard as a whole. Papa Haydn had a genius that even showed in his first symphonies. Yet, his style improved and became more complex as one traverse from  Symphony 1 to Symphony 104. It is a similar maturity as seen in Mozart, and to some extent, Beethoven. Antal Dorati does a superb job of conducting these symphonies, never allowing a symphony to become routine or pedantic. The recording is of best quality, with a forward, resonant sound. This set is certainly the best complete Haydn set out on the market, and worthwhile for any classical music lover.

 

Christiane F

December 7th, 2008

Christiane F. ????

This is an amazing and reportedly true story, first told in the book Wir Kinder vom Bahnhof Zoo, of a 14 year girl who grows up in Berlin, and gets caught up in IV drug use culture, becoming seriously addicted herself, eventually leading to her alienation from society, and descent to a point of absolute desperation, prostitution, and violence. It is a very realistic portrayal, very graphic at times, and honest about a horrid underworld that most of us have little contact with. Allegedly, Christiane gets out of the drug culture by the end of the film, though she has since relapsed numerous times. The full story could be found at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christiane_F.  . Quite graphic, this is a very moving, and very depressing film. It should not be seen by children, but very worthwhile for parents with children.

 

Forrest Gump

December 6th, 2008

Forrest Gump, starring Tom Hanks ????

I saw this film years ago. Now that the price is down, I purchased it to watch again. I wouldn’t call this a great film. It makes no major statements, or have any distinguishing features other than being a cute story. It is the story of a kid that grows up with certain significant mental and physical deficits, and eventually overcomes them, while inspiring those around him. It’s quite funny for placing Forrest in the most interesting positions, such as meeting presidents and traveling the world over, while forever being mentally occupied with a girl that showed him respect early on in life. The acting by Tom Hanks is him at his best. The story is a bit of fantasy, but woven in a delightful fashion that owes for multiple re-watchings.

 

Thelonius Monk

December 4th, 2008

Thelonious Monk ???

Monk, though he lived mostly in New York, was probably far more appreciated overseas than at home. Monk is not a hugely regarded jazz composer/performer in the US. Though mostly regarded as the primary developer of the Boogie-Woogie style, Monks’ personal style tended to change through the years. I don’t have an overwhelming appreciation for jazz, and outside of Louis Armstrong, whom I can’t get enough of, jazz seems better as incorporated into other styles, than on it’s own. Examples of that are Rhapsody in Blue, and many of the modern works of Wynton Marsalis. This 10 CD set is a bargain, but variable quality is noted in the recordings.

 

O Brother, Where Art Thou?

December 2nd, 2008

O Brother Where Art Thou ?????

This is my second viewing of this film. I dug it out of our files. I really can’t explain it, but I love this film. It has a beautiful sense of flow, and reflective of the deep south, both in its’ charm, but also its’ hypocrisy and bigotry. The acting is superb, and the script line was flawless. It is the story of three convicts that escape from a Mississippi chain gang. It follows their flight through the Mississippi farmlands, with a story line written to suggest the travels of Odysseus. By forming a song group that becomes famous, they eventually get pardons from the governor, though with several harrowing escapes from southern justice (or absence of it).

 

Oistrakh – Complete EMI Recordings

December 2nd, 2008

David Oistrakh, The Complete EMI Recordings ?????

I realize that I’m giving a lot of classical music five stars. It’s hard not to give David Oistrakh anything but five stars. He certainly is the consummate violinist of the 20th century. This is not a complete edition of his works, and is missing certain works, such as the Mendelssohn violin concerto which he recorded with Deutsche Grammophon. There is some variability in the recording quality between pieces, and some pieces, such as some of the Beethoven violin concerto. All in all, this set is an awesome bargain for an awesome violinist.

 

Literary Modernism; The Struggle for Modern History

November 28th, 2008

Literary Modernism; The Struggle for Modern History, by Jeffery Perl ????

Typically, I detest literature courses. I started out wondering what possessed me to listen to this series. The first lecture didn’t fare so well. Then, the professor started to connect with issues dear to my heart. I don’t know exactly where Prof. Perl is coming from, but he does a masterful job of concealing his own personal orientation. The discussion evolves are a set of poets in the twentieth century, including D.H. Lawrence,  Ezra Pound, T. S. Eliot, James Joyce, Willam Carlos Williams and Gertrude Stein. Perl spends a lengthy period discussing the movement in the 1920s and 1930s to abandon the concept of language being capable to act as a means of communication. He discusses the various camps of classic vs. neoclassic modernism, but how these poets all moved as a group in certain areas. They all were communist supporters in the 1930’s, and supported either the movement of Hitler or Mussolini, followed by a post-war despair in their writings. While these poets remain the ideal of intellectualism of the twentieth century, it seems to me that they are self-contradictory. They deny that words could convey meaning, yet they use words to convey those meanings. Their intellectual arrogance refuses them a mirror on their own folly. I certainly won’t run out to buy any James Joyce or T.S. Eliot, but there is a high probability that I will re-listen to this series, approaching it from a slightly better attitude toward some types of literature discussion. Perl is a compelling teacher, and quite knowledgeable, thus is worthy of a hearing or two.

 

Paganini – Complete Chamber Music

November 26th, 2008

Paganini: Complete Chamber Works, Misc. Performers ?????

This was a budget set of the works of Paganini, but the performances were definitely not budget. It did not seem to be “complete”, since the 24 Caprices and other works were missing. Most of Paganini’s chamber music represented here also included the guitar as one of the intruments, which seemed to be quite effective. The sound was forward and crisp, giving you a sense of presence. All in all, this was quite delightful to listen to, and deserving of 4-5 stars.

 

Manon – Massenet

November 15th, 2008

15NOV2008 Manon, Jules Massenet, starting Natalie Dessay and Rolando Villazon  ?????

Manon is the story of the slow destruction of the life of a young lady. It is a story that also has been done for the opera by Puccini as Manon Lescaut, though Massenet definitely has a more convincing storyline, and more delightful music in this opera. The staging for this production is somewhat austere, though a similar recent production utilized an off stage-1950’s Los Angeles theme structure. Dessay commanded this opera with superb vocal control as well as near-perfect acting. This opera is a definite must for the opera-lover, and this version would certainly fit among the top performances to date.

 

Die Fälscher

November 14th, 2008

Die Fälscher, (The Counterfeiters) ?????

This movie is reportedly based on a true story, of the life of a man who was caught making counterfeit Deutschmarks in the pre-WWII era. Being a Jew, he ended up in a concentration camp, at first forced to do menial labor, until his talents were noted. Toward the end of the war, the Germans attempted to flood the British and American currency with counterfeit bills, produced by an operation in one of the concentration camp using a large contingent of highly skilled Jewish craftsmen. Various sabotage techniques kept the production of American dollar bills delayed to nearly the end of the war. This is a tale of extreme wit to accomplish one’s survival with death close at hand, and yet not being an accomplice to the Nazi war effort. A suspenseful thriller, it is quite engaging from start to finish-definitely worth seeing. The sound track is in German, but there are English subtitles. Even Betsy enjoyed the film but was depressed all day after seeing it!

 

Bluebeard’s Castle

October 19th, 2008

Bluebeard’s Castle, Bela Bartok, conducted by Georg Solti ????

Bluebeard’s Castle is another piece whose music is not approachable when listened to without the visual. The music works very well with the added visuals. The visuals in this case are on the opera stage, but reality scenes. This is Bartok’s only opera, based on a early 17th century Hungarian tale, unknown whether it was based on any historical event. The opera consists of only two singers, Bluebeard and Judith. Bluebeard introduces his new bride to his castle, a dark foreboding place. There are seven doors that Judith are forbidden to enter, though in the course of the opera, Judith has Bluebeard open each of the doors, as she learns of Bluebeard’s tyrannical past. She finally learns about Bluebeard’s other wives. I find Bartok to be a tad bit challenging to get to know, yet becomes with time a very likeable composer. This piece runs about 56 minutes but is very accessible when heard with the accompanied video.

 

From the House of the Dead

October 17th, 2008

From the House of the Dead, Leos Janacek, Pierre Boulez conducting???

An opera based on Dostoyevski’s “Memoirs from the House of the Dead”, is a storyline of men within a prison camp. I’ve heard the music before without the video, and it really doesn’t work — you must have the visual to see what’s happening. There are no arias or linear music such as one might be accustomed to with classic opera, but the music definitely fits the part. The staging is quite nicely done to form a very effective story line of life in a Russian prison. This is not a “fun” opera, and you would not watch it, as though you were watching “The Marriage of Figaro”. Janacek’s other operas that I have on video, “The Cunning Little Vixen” and “Jenufa”, tend to not be so morbid, with CLV being a fun little comedy. This DVD had in addition an account of the making of the opera. I found it most interesting that they would spontaneously transform from German, to English, to French, and then back to German, as though it were all one language.

 

Works of Igor Stravinsky

September 30th, 2008

Works of Igor Stravinsky, Conducted by Igor Stravinsky, mostly with the Columbia Symphony?????

I purchased this set with trepidation, since I really didn’t like the works of Stravinsky. I didn’t feel that they connected in the same way that Prokofiev or Shostakovich did, that it was just bombastic noise. I couldn’t resist the price of under $50 for 22 CDs all conducted by Igor himself, so, I felt it worth having in the collection. The recordings themselves are old but quite excellent. I did not hear any hiss or record scratch, the stereophonic components came through quite clear, and the sound was very forward. I turned out that I was able to connect with these performances unlike any other that I’ve heard of Mr. Stravinsky. True, some of his pieces were quite odd or wierd. The Wedding  is a very unique piece which tends to grow on you the more you listen to it. It sounds a bit like oriental music, which is somewhat characteristic of a lot of Stravinsky works. His chamber music was completely delightful. The sacred music was mostly enjoyable, though some of it included spoken narrative, not exactly designed for casual listening. The Opera Rakes’ Progress had a very strong “Gilbert & Sullivan” touch to it; it happens that I really can’t stand Gilbert & Sullivan, so I didn’t like that piece. The Lamentations of Jeremiah were quite ingenious though different from anything I’ve heard before. Stravinsky creates some sonorities that tend to work well in that piece. All in all, this is a very affordable set for someone looking beyond Mozart and Tchaikovsky.

 

Reich – Different Trains

September 25th, 2008

Different Trains, by Steve Reich, performed by the Kronos Quartet ???

Reich is an interesting composer, in that he provides minimalist music while maintaining a tonal system. There are several works on this album, the first being a set of three pieces, before, during, and after the war, which has electronic music and speech combined. It has a fascinating approach that doesn’t lead to the tediousness or monotony of a Philip Glass or other minimalists. This is not exactly an album to rush out and buy, unless you wish to dazzle your friends with the bizarre. For twentieth century exploration, it could be a quite enjoyable album to hear.

 

Abba – Gold

September 21st, 2008

ABBA, Greatest Hits ?

This was purchased for Diane on return from Deutschland, and I finally got around to listening to it. Abba was popular in the 1980’s, being a Swedish group that made it well in the West. They were re-popularized with the musical Mamma-Mia. I’m not sure why they were popular. Their music is quite boring. It manifests a total lack of creativity. It was un-edurable to hear the whole album, as every song sounded the same. Now, maybe the mistake was that I listened to Abba in the midst of hearing a Stravinsky compendium, and it is not right to combine street music with the music of genius. All the same, I don’t think I’ll hear the album out again, or buy any more Abba albums—one’s enough.

 

Die Zauberflöte – Karajan

September 11th, 2008

Die Zauberflöte, WA Mozart, 1980 Berlin Performance with H. von Karajan?????

Heavens to Mergetroyd! I’ve just reviewed a Zauberflöte by Karajan, so why another? Well, they are two totally different performances. The Zauberflöte reported below was produced soon after the war, one of Karajan’s first recordings. It is very emotional, sung with greater contemplation and emotion. Conversely, the recording itself is not of today’s standards, and sounds like a recording in a box. This recording, now performed by the Berliner Philharmoniker, has brilliance, as though you were sitting in the room with the orchestra and singers. It is performed to perfection, a flawless representation of Mozart at his best. The signers are the best of the best, and every solo or ensemble is impeccable, brilliant, and delightful to listen to. I once owned this performance years ago and got rid of it, giving it to Alan Segall, the kids’ piano teacher. There was something about the performance that somehow didn’t click with me. I’m not sure what I didn’t like about the piece, except that I was searching for a particular performance, one that was the first recording of the Magic Flute that I had ever heard and this one wasn’t it. Well, I have it back now as a cherished member of my record collection. Die Zauberflöte holds a special corner in my heart, since it was the first opera that I had ever heard. I was living in Portland, going to college, and two girls from the mid-west, Deb and Amy, suggested we go to an outdoor performance of this opera, held up in Washington Park in Portland, Oregon. It was a beautiful setting, overlooking the city and Mt. Hood. Male hormones may have been a small factor in me enjoying the opera, but it was an unforgettable experience, and I’ve been into opera ever since. If you had to get just one recording of Die Zauberflöte, this would be it. Turn it up and let it rip. One little issue about this recording—I’m not sure why they needed to put it on 3 CD’s. It doesn’t matter when you immediately rip it to mp3 like I do, and then listen to it on iTunes. True, they included all of the spoken dialogue, nice (for me) since I can understand the German.

 

Honegger – Symphonies

September 11th, 2008

Honegger Symphonies, with Charles Dutoit, Bavarian Radio Symphony??

This was a reasonable performance of the Honegger symphonies. I can’t say that I’ve really acquired an appreciation to his works. I realize that I used to have a problem with many other composers, like Mahler, who I thought were just making noise. Eventually, Mahler sounded organized and likeable, then very likeable. Honegger doesn’t do that for me. After multiple hearings, his music remains noise. Maybe someday I’ll get it? At least I tried…

 

Stalingrad

September 2nd, 2008

Stalingrad, directed by Joseph Vilsmaier  ?????

A number of 6th army offensives in the east – films have been produced, including this film, another named “Stalingrad”, and a German film “Hunde, wollt ihr ewig leben”. This is definitely the best, the most convincing, the most moving of all the films, and indeed, one of the best war films of all time. Like “Im Westen nichts Neues” (All Quiet on the Western Front), this film does not glorify war, and glories neither a victor, nor the act of war itself. It portrays the immense horrors of armies unable to either retreat or advance, and eventually defeated not so much by the enemy as by nature itself, in the freezing winter of the the Ukraine. Though many reviewers attest to the realism of this film, having not been there, I’m sure that nothing could portray the sheer terror and despondence that both the Russians and Germans experienced in this battle. Seen in the film are the epitomes not only of human altruism and love for fellow man, but also the depths of evil. This was best portrayed when a lead character was ordered by the commanding General to execute a Russian child and then refused to do so. This film is certainly much better when watched with the audio in German, but regardless of the language, in one of the must-watch films of all time.

 

Die Zauberflöte – Karajan 1950

August 29th, 2008

Die Zauberflöte WA Mozart by H. von Karajan and Wiener Philharmoniker

The performance was made in 1950, soon after the war, and at the support of Walter Legge from EMI.

The recording was technically the best possible for 1950, and still has a warmth that is appropriate. This recording omits the dialogue, thus shortening the work, but certainly not diminuting the piece. It is a young Karajan, with a touch an warmth that few Magic Flutes’s since have experienced, including Karajan’s later production of the same piece. This is a valuable piece to all Zauberflöte collectors.

 

Berg – Lulu

August 29th, 2008

Lulu, by Alban Berg, with Glyndebourne Festival Opera, Andrew Davis????

This opera, written by the Viennese composer Alban Berg, represents the life of a society hostess, in her rise and fall to eventual murder. A tragic tale, the music was most fitting to the piece, though often in a serial or atonal style. The opera was by Mozartian standards a bit strange, yet was completely fitting for expectations of 20th century works. If you are not familiar with 20th century opera and expect standard solos, duets, ensembles, etc., this piece will not fare well with you. Certainly the lead role of Lulu, performed by Christine Schäfer, was impeccably done, with a very demanding and challenging part performed  to perfection and with greatest finesse. Christine herself gets 5 stars. The opera itself gets only 4 stars from me, not because of any performance problems, but only because 20th century serialism is not exactly my favorite cup of tea, while the plot and story line itself focused on the gutter elements in society, not exactly transcending the soul to greater thoughts and loftier ambitions.

 

Rubinstein – Chopin Collection

August 28th, 2008

The Chopin Collection, by Artur Rubinstein ???

This is not a bad collection, and certainly worth the price. Some of the recordings have not been well cleaned up, and still have very prominent record scratch, serving as a major distraction. I suppose that those noises were left in the delight the ever persisting insistence of vinyl-philiacs that records indeed are a better media for storing musical sound than CDs. Bless their hearts. I have complete sets of Idel Biret (a female Turkish pianist), and Ashkenazy. Ashkenazy is definitely the best of all the sets, with Biret coming in second and Rubinstein third. I also have single CDs of Horowitz on Chopin, which are absolutely superb, and Perahia, also superlative. Rubinstein is mechanically a master of the art of Chopin keyboarding. Though Wikipedia introduces him as “widely considered as one of the greatest piano virtuosi of the 20th century”, I don’t think so, and it was a label afixed more out of his Hollywood popularity rather than his interpretative abilities, and others in the 20th century, such as Horowitz, Brendel, and Ashkenazy had a much greater sensitivity to interpretive qualities of a piece than I ever find in Artur R. For Chopin, I would recommend the Ashkenazy set, or better yet, pick up individual pieces, such as Horowitz’s “My Favorite Chopin”.

 

Karl May Orient Box

August 22nd, 2008

Karl May series Orient Box (Der Schut, Durchs Wilde Kurdistan, Im Reiche Des Silbernen Löwen) ?????

Karl May was a popular author of adventure stories for older children, very well known in Germany. Many of his stories were made into movies in the 1960’s, with Lex Barker starring as the main character. This box is 3 films from stories in the mid-east. These were actually filmed in (Yugoslavia??) but very well done in the Spaghetti-Western style. The stories are great, the acting is good, and for an English speaker, the German is not hard to understand. I especially appreciate the insulting jabs that the filmmaker gives to the Brits, with two British characters, and British officer and his servant, constantly bumbling their way through the desert, requiring others to rescue them, but always behaving in “proper” style, never omitting tea-time. The movie accurately characterizes various British-isms. This series is highly recommended to the German language student.

 

Complete Beethoven – Brilliant Classics

August 20th, 2008

Beethoven Complete Works, published by Brilliant Classics ?????

I now have four complete Beethoven series, including 1) The Deutsche Grammophone, 2) a series by the music publisher Amado, 3) a series put out by Sony, and now the 4) Brilliant classics series. The DG series was the most expensive and has the best recordings, by the best artists, such as von Karajan for the symphonies, Kempff for the piano sonatas, etc. This series by Brilliant was also able to maintain fairly notable performers and conductors, including Kurt Masur and the Leipzig orchestra for the symphonies, the Guinari string quartet for the quartets, etc. All of that was with 87 CDs for the price of barely more than $1 / CD. Outside of the DG recordings, I would have to put this as the best, some of the performances even excelling that of the DG series. As an example, I ran through the piano sonata #25 by five performers, including a)Alfred Brendel, who is one of my perferred performers, but felt him to be a touch distant and adynamic on this piece, b) Kempff in the DG series, the recording sounded a bit tinny, c) Daniela Rusa on Amado sounded very mechanical and rushed, d) Yokoyama on Sony, was not bad, but also recorded slightly tinny, and slightly missing in dynamism, and finally e) Gulda in this series, which was completely forward, vivacious, with a brilliant sound, definitely the best performance of the five. One other thing to mention–when one listens to a complete series, the songs are usually put at the end. Beethoven made songs in many languages including Polish, Italian, etc., etc., but also made many English songs, including arrangements of existing tunes. These are easy to skip over, but also reflect the absolute genius of Beethoven, in having intricate and most thoughtful accompaniments, which bring luster to an otherwise ordinary piece. The fact that Beethoven could make even British music sound nice is a marked salute to his genius. All in all, there is very little to complain about with this series, and for one seeking a complete Beethoven at a bargain price, this is definitely a first choice.

 

Slaughterhouse Five

August 17th, 2008

Slaughterhouse Five, based on the novel by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. ?????

Most Amazon.com readers give this film a five star rating, which I agree. I’ve not read the book, so, I can’t compare the film with the faithfulness to the book. It is a superb anti-war film, with a mixture of extreme pathos and comedy. Though now a film that has long achieved cult status, it is odd that it took until now for me to watch this film. Vonnegut makes a cogent argument for some of the most pointless points of WWII, such as the firm-bombing of Dresden. This, mixed with the piano playing of Glenn Gould and Bach in the background, one gets a surrealistic feel of the absolute vapidness of WWII, and most other wars, for that matter. Some parts of the film were a touch too bizarre, such as the journeys to a distant planet Tralfamadore where the lead character is being observed by other creatures as he lives out a quasi-sanity, and his constant relapses from his now comfortable life as a prominent optometrist in New England and his bare-survival as a prisoner of war when captured in the battle of the bulge. He was never sure whether his real enemies were the Americans, the Germans, or the Russians. The entire sense of reality is questioned, en par with other great films such as In Westen Nichts Neues (All is quiet on the western front), Catch-22, or The King of Hearts. This film is more effective than the others listed in making out the pointless-ness of (most) wars,  and one worth putting on the must-see list.

 

Wagner – Parsifal

August 17th, 2008

Parsifal, Dir. Horst Stein, Bayreuther Festspiele ????

This is actually an excellent production of Parsifal, with both an excellent recording and excellent video, as well as excellent acting and singing. It is staged in a traditional style, with conformity with probable original staging instructions. Why only four stars? This is probably one of my preferred video versions of Parsifal? Well, Parsifal has a rather stupid plot (sorry, Richard W.). The music is awesome. It is one of those few operas that is best heard and not seen. Perhaps this is an opera where bizarre staging might make for better visualization. It’s one that Peter Sellars or Doris Dorrie should attack. Other versions of Parsifal that I own include the Levine/Met Opera version, that has better staging and also using the absolutely superb Wagnerian signer Siegfried Jersusalem for Parsifal, a film with opera dubbing by Syberberg, nice and effective, but with odd staging, and a CD version with Karajan, which is indisputably the best conducted recording of this opera.

 

Schumann: 4 Symphonien

August 16th, 2008

Schumann: 4 Symphonien, with Karajan & Berliner Philharmoniker ?????

I had previously heard several other versions of Schumann’s 4 symphonies, including a budget edition by Semkow and the St. Louis Orchestra, and another by Leonard Bernstein and the NY Philharmonic, and wondered why there was such a fuss over them – they seemed rather drab without distinguishing characteristics necessary to make them a part of a standard orchestral repertoire. Then, I heard Karajan actually bring these symphonies alive. You’ve heard me adulate Karajan in the past and I will do so again. I realize that there is a lot of Karajan bashing going on nowdays, that he was a consummate showman, and not a musician, that he created an interpretation contrary to the composer’s intentions, etc. Most of these accusations are waged when one has nothing else bad to say about a person. Of course the conductor is putting his own interpretation in to the piece; it’s impossible for them not to, unless they create a meaningless drab piece that isn’t worth listening to. But, back to Schumann. The third and fourth symphonies are the most memorable, and Karajan, for the first time ever, had me whistling or humming through the various leitmotif’s in these works. Truly, they are the best of the best of any of the symphonic recordings of Schumann, not just in recording quality, but also in their interpretation. A must buy for any music lover.

 

Reich: Music for 18 Musicians

August 16th, 2008

Steve Reich: Music for 18 Musicians ???

This is the perfect purchase of a CD for the person you hate the most. It will drive them nuts, if they ever make it through the complete CD. I think that I will use it in the hospital OR. It is essentially minimalistic music with an avowed tonal construct. The tonality makes it a little less tedious to listen to. Unfortunately, there is never a progression of the piece, and, as one would expect in the sonata form that we are so accustomed to, no themes, no development, no alteration in rhythmic monotony, it would be challenging to identify whether one was at the beginning or the end of the work, if one didn’t have the electronic time coming off of the CD player. Buy this for the person in your life you despise the most, then insult them by claiming that if they didn’t enjoy the piece, they simply did not have the stuff that makes a great musician.

 

Shostokovich: Cheryomushki

August 15th, 2008

Cheryomushki (Cherry Town) Music by D. Shostakovich ????

This piece was written in 1958, and performed in Moscow in 1963. Typically, I would give anything by Shostakovich 5 stars. The music was tremendous, but the plot was fairly corny. Essentially, conditions in early ’60’s Moscow were such that one had to be desperate in order to win a cherished spot in ghetto style tenement housing. It’s a far cry from where the West was at the same time, yet they had the audacity to speak of the death of “Capitalism” since life was so much better under a socialist regime (!!!). Though Shostakovich excels at serious music, he still commands genius at lighter, comical pieces as this. I would not recommend purchasing this unless you are an inveterate Shostakovich fan as I am.

 

Matthäus Passion – Karajan

August 8th, 2008

Bach Matthäus Passion, Cond. von Karajan, Berliner Philharmoniker ?????

A well-performed and interpreted version of the Matthäus Passion, von Karajan manifests his usual ability to draw out the best of the composer. This is especially appreciated as it is performed on modern instruments, using a star-cast line-up of performers. Karajan is definitely a good first choice for this work. Unfortunately, any recording will never give the four dimensional force of how Bach originally wrote this piece, using multiple choirs and orchestras. This also makes it more difficult to find a public performance of this work, which stands among the greatest music of all time.

 

The Woody Allen Collection

August 5th, 2008

The Woody Allen Collection Sets 1-3 ???

I thought that I liked Woody Allen more than I did after watching this set. Woody has some hilarious moments, and has some nice touches on his more serious films, though Woody tends to be quite mono-thematic. This main themes or thought processes are…

  1. a)gee, there might be a god. Maybe. Maybe not.
  2. b)sex is the only justification for marriage. Without sex, move on.
  3. c)outside of personal relationships, life has no meaning.
  4. d)the family is dysfunctional.

 

So, let’s run through the films…

  1. 1)Bananas – Woody becomes a revolutionary in a third world banana republic
  2. 2)Sleeper – Woody wakes up a thousand years later, to discover that the world is slightly different. One of my favorite films
  3. 3)Interiors – Woody’s first serious film about a dysfunctional family.
  4. 4)Love and Death – a film that I never saw before, but liked tremendously, a comic serious film of Woody as a cowardly Russian during the Napoleonic Wars
  5. 5)Annie Hall – A Woody/Diane Keaton classic that is typical Woody’s angst for life
  6. 6)Manhattan – A black and white version with a different twist of Annie Hall
  7. 7)Everything you always wanted to know about sex But were afraid to ask – slightly comic film about sex.
  8. 8)Stardust Memories – Woody plays a film-maker in a dog-eat-dog world.
  9. 9)Broadway Danny Rose – Woody plays a two-bit show-biz agent in some comic antics with clients.
  10. 10) A Midsummer Night’s Sex Comedy – Somewhat humorous film that vaguely resembles Shakespeare’s Midsummer Night’s Dream, of three couples together, sorting out who belongs to who.
  11. 11)The Purple Rose of Cairo – A character from a swinging twenties film walks off of the film into the life of a now depression area small-town girl.
  12. 12)Radio Days – Life in Jewish New York in the Depression era
  13. 13) Zelig – Woody and a person trying to gain acceptance by miraculously transforming himself into his environment. Another of my favorite Woody films.
  14. 14) Hannah and Her Sisters – Life in a now grown up three sibling dysfunctional family
  15. 15) Alice – Mia Farrow plays a disenchanted high society woman who eventually discovers life in Calcutta. I never saw this before but liked it much as a film
  16. 16) Another Woman – A typical Woody film about the crisis of defining one’s spouse.
  17. 17) Crimes and Misdemeanors -  Another of my favorite Woody films that is probably the best portrayal of the harshness of guilt in a person’s life. A prominent doctor has a secret mistress threatening to expose him, and so is “terminated” by the doctor’s brother, a hit-man. Other sub-themes with Woody seemed unnecessary in the film.
  18. 18) September – Dreadfully boring, a serious film about dysfunctional family dynamics.
  19. 19) Shadows and Fog – one of Woody’s strangest films, with him and Mia Farrow as the main actors. The film is entirely in black and white, in a fog, and maintains a surrealistic atmosphere of escaping vigilantes attempting to catch a murderer, but still including all of the theses of Woody films mentioned above. Woody’s biggest problems with the films that he writes is the ending. This one is particularly true of that, in that Woody escapes life by joining the circus. Knowing Woody’s real life, this film is probably autobiographical.

 

Les Miserables

July 20th, 2008

Les Misérables ?????

Directed by Claude LeLouch and starring Jean-Paul Belmondo, this film, in French, is a passionate, moving, exceptionally well-acted film about a Jewish family escaping the Nazis in WWII France, eventually returning back together after the war, and a older illiterate man, once prized as a boxer, and now running a moving business, helping the Jewish family, including father who was a lawyer, mother who was a ballerina, and 11 yo daughter survive in the chaotic years of 1940-1946 France. This film is a must see, very loosely based on the Victor Hugo novel by the same name. I will not tell the story as it would destroy the first time impact of the film, which all, whether or not you understand French, would be deeply moved by. It is the depiction of total depravity, not only with many of the Nazis, but many of the French people, in their treatment of the Jews at the time, and yet also a depiction of people selflessly and at all possible cost of their life giving of themselves for what is noble and right. Why it has not hit the American cinema like “Life is Beautiful” or “Jacob der Lügner” is beyond me.

 

Mozart: Complete Operas

July 7th, 2008

Mozart The Complete Operas, Salzburger Festspiele ???

This is the first dvd recorded cycle of the complete Mozart operas, performed during the 2006 Mozart Festspiele in Salzburg, Austria. Heretofore, most of the Mozart operas were not available at all in VHS or DVD format, but simply as sound recordings. That makes this a valuable part of any Mozart-lovers collection. The production often used young singers, though the general quality of singing itself was absolutely superb. I am quite sure that many of these performers will be seen again in rising roles on the world opera stage. So, why only three stars? First, a number of the operas were reinterpreted, the best example being Die Entführung aus dem Serail, where rather than a story of love and escape from a Moorish harem, the entire opera was modeled, with dialogue changes, to represent a  battle of the sexes. Unfortunately, if one would play with the music, you would say that it is no longer Mozart. I say that it is no longer Mozart if you play too much with the visual aspect of the opera, since that was also written by him. The second problem is that the operas were all performed on a totally minimalist stage, the only exception being Die Zauberflöte, with a modernistic design, though properly keeping to the Mozartian story-line. The problem with minimalist operas is that the stage is designed to complement the music to clue the audience with what is happening. Without the stage, one might as well simply listen to a recording of sound only. The minimalism itself was severely lacking in creativity. There was a great predilection for handguns and butcher knives on the stage, or pieces of paper, or running paint over otherwise completely white surfaces. Sometimes very odd complements were added to the staging. An example is in Le Nozze de Figaro, where there was this 18-20 year old male with wings, constantly coming into and out of the scenery. The stage designer almost certainly was trying to make a meaningful statement by that, but in the end only created an annoying distraction. It would be like occasionally inserting trumpet calls into the music–distracting and certainly not written in by Mozart. For all their effort to produce these operas, surely they could have done better.

 

Die Verlorene Ehre der Katarina Blum

June 28th, 2008

Die Verlorene Ehre der Katarina Blum ?????

In English, the Lost Honor of Katharina Blum, this is well done film based on a book by the same name by Heinrich Böll, though written in the 70’s, has a contemporary feel to it. It was easy to sense that Böll was protesting the yellow journalism of The Bild tabloid in reporting the events of the Baader-Meinhof gang. Unfortunately, this film has had little impact in the USA, even though it has received international acclaim. The story is of a young lady that is inadvertently acquainted to somebody identified as a terrorist, and so hounded by the police and also the press in a smear campaign that served judgment on this young woman who had done nothing wrong, save to have had an acquaintance to somebody she met in normal social circles. The relevance to contemporary society becomes increasingly compelling, with, for instance, the rulings of homeland security.  I have seen such activity even in my beloved (?) hospital, where people are presumed guilty never to be granted innocence simply because of the system. This is an honest statement against the press and federal oppression that should be more familiar to American audiences.

 

Bellini: Norma

June 17th, 2008

Bellini Norma, Bayerischen Staatsoper, Gruberova as Norma ????

This is my second performance of Norma on DVD, the first staring Monseratt Caballe and the French Theater of Orange. Because of the absolutely miserable recording quality of the Caballe version, I wanted a better version. Certainly, the Gruberova version is superbly and flawlessly recorded. Gruberova also is a close contestant with Caballe for the vocal and acting qualities of a magnificent Norma. The staging is a touch odd, with the Romans staged in modern jungle guerilla outfits and machine guns at their side. Otherwise, it was well done. My main criticism is the opera itself. Though Bellini is a master of the bel canto style, much of the opera is a bit weary. Once you have heard the casta diva, it is a touch wearisome making it to the end of the opera. This is not the fault of the performer, even though the virtuoso performances continue to the end of the opera.

 

Glenn Gould Original Jacket Collection

June 12th, 2008

Glenn Gould Original Jacket Collection ?????

This is a budget offering of the complete studio recordings of Glenn Gould, offering in their original “jackets”, though reduced, of course, to represent the smaller size of the CD as compared to the original vinyl recordings. For 80 CDs, the price from Amazon.com was a true bargain. Glenn Gould tends towards idiosyncratic interpretations, often with an included vocalization of his own making. This has tended some reviewers, such as the British Penguin CD book authors, to regard Gould with disdain, and subsequent editions have mostly left Gould unmentioned. This is not appropriate, as Gould has a sense of character and liveliness that oftentimes breathes new life into a piece, whether it be by Bach, Beethoven, Scriabin, Schönberg, or Byrd, to name a few. It is a grave error to denigrate Gould to second class status. I would not consider him to the one of the greatest Bach interpreters of all time, but would certainly rank him about the great musicians of the twentieth century, whose interpretations must be considered in discussing keyboard interpretations of classical composers. I am not a purist that demands that Bach be played on original instruments. I really don’t care to know what orchestras sounded like in 1748. Bach, Beethoven, and all classical/contemporary works of the Gould repertoire deserve the best instruments that are available. Since Bach was never specific about what type of keyboard, and often what type of instrument he expected his music to played with, I really don’t think that he would object to harpsicord works being played on the vastly improved sonorities of the modern piano. Any classical music lover with an affection toward Gould would not go wrong purchasing this set.

 

Bach: Messe in H-moll

June 7th, 2008

Bach Messe in H-moll, Richter, Münchener Bach-Chor & Orchester, with Janowitz & Prey  ????

This performance in 1969 in a small church on the Amersee in Sud-Bavaria, represents Richter close to the end of his life, but in the very early careers of Janowitz and Prey. Both were already showing their talents that would lead them into lengthy careers as lead performers on the stage of the best opera houses and concert halls in the world. Richter also remains unapproachable in his art of Bach, and few today are able to match his interpretations of Bach works.  Richter is not a “showy” conducter like Bernstein, and maintains a strong sense of solemnity to his performances. So, why only 4 stars? Mostly it related to the bizarre panning of the camera, which would often fix on either some performer in the orchestra, or some edifice in the church that they were in. The recording quality was excellent. This is a must-have performance, and the DVD, because of the odd camera work, contributes little to what one would get from Richter’s CD recordings.

 

Smetana: Die Verkaufte Braut

June 7th, 2008

Smetana Die Verkaufte Braut, Wiener Staatsoper, with Popp & Jerusalem ?????

I have two DVD performances of this opera, this one and one produced in Prague by the National Opera. This is the more polished opera, an absolutely superlative performance, with the unexcelled voices of both Lucia Popp and Siegfried Jersusalem. Acting is wonderful, and the orchestra is inpeccable. Smetana manages the most magnificent flow of unforgettable melodies, with opera singing mixed with Czech folk dancing and opera. It is an addicting opera with a cute little storyline, that I won’t give away. In comparison with the Prague version, the Prague version is not as lavishly done, the singing is in German as compared to Czech in the Prague version. The Prague version does have a sense of “homi-ness” that makes it perhaps the preferred performance; it is a bit more convincing, in spite of the absence of star-studded opera divas and world class orchestra. Both versions are worthy of an opera buff like me, and both are recommended as justly portraying the genius of Smetana.

 

Beethoven Complete Masterpieces – Sony

April 15th, 2008

Beethoven Complete Masterpieces, Sony, 60 CD Limited Edition ????

This is my third complete Beethoven, and I just acquired a fourth, so thought a review would be in order. It would be difficult for me to rate the various sets, since each is superbly performed though with different styles and performers.

Deutsche Grammophone – Probably the best, though the most expensive.

Amado – Generally uses smaller orchestras, and less well know performers, but all inpeccably done

Sony- This review – see below

Brilliant – Brilliant will be reviewed later (once I listen to it), but was a total steal of $125 for 85 discs, of many superb performances, many published in the past, including the string quartets and symphonies and superb in their own right, but combined into a totally bargain basement collection.

Ok, back to the Sony set review. In all, this is not a complete Beethoven, and many lesser works were omitted. Still, it doesn’t hurt the set. I paid about $99 for this set, which is a total bargain, considering that the recordings were technically impeccable, and the performances themselves were flawless. For those who love Beethoven, I’d advise one purchase all four sets. For the less ambitious, any one of these four sets would be quite adequate, giving one many hours of delightful music.

 

Stockhausen: Helikopter Quartett

April 8th, 2008

Stockhausen: Helikopter Quartett, Arditti String Quartet 1996 ????

This quartet gets 10 stars for strangeness. Honestly, I’ve never heard anything quite like this. The quartet is performed with each string player in a separate helicopter, hovering over the audience, with the sound piped down and mixed. For all its strangeness, it seems to work. It definitely is not sonorities that we are used to hearing, yet, it is not unpleasant, and manages to comfortably integrate the sound of the beating rotors to the tones produced by the string instruments. This CD is definitely not for the neophyte or conventional classicist. It is a single track, recorded slightly longer than 31 minutes. This could be one of the most intriguing 31 minutes of listening experience that you ever experience, should you wish to venture beyond Bach and Beethoven. By the way, after playing this 4-5 times in the operating room, I’m now forbidden to play Stockhausen in the OR. We’ll see.

 

Beethoven Symphony No 9

April 5th, 2008

Beethoven Symphony No. 9 Berliner Philharmoniker, Performed 31DEC1977  ??????

Yes, I know. You can only give 5 stars total. This production was just too good to limit to five stars. As you could tell from the cover, this was the DVD version. Most DVD versions tend to have the camera drift to insignificant parts of the stage, though this DVD does a reasonable job of directing the attention to where one would be looking should you actually be in the audience.

A number of years ago, Alan Segall (a professional musician) and I blindly played to each other versions of many symphonies including segments of Beethoven’s 9th, and both of us peculiarly picked out Karajan routinely as the favorite or perferred rendering. This was especially true of Beethoven’s 9th. Toscanini was bottom of the list. I grew up on Toscanini’s 9th. Ron Bonneau recommended Toscanini’s 9th, so we assumed that it was the greatest. We were wrong. I can recall sitting in our Mill Street house basement, playing Toscanini’s 9th on vinyl, sitting around with brother Lewis and a close friend Steve Miller, adoring Beethoven and his 9th, of course, Toscanini’s version. This was our start on music appreciation. I’ve come a long way since then. Beethoven still has his magnetic attraction, but so do many other composers from Bach to Shostakovich.

Karajan’s conducting style certainly is somewhat different. Betsy thought he was very unemotional. This is simply not true. Oddly, Karajan rarely opens his eyes–I think that he is too consumed with the music. Those who accuse Karajan of showmanship fail to pay attention to other conductors like Bernstein, who make the most wild theatric gestures throughout an entire performance. Others have accused Karajan of being a Nazi and thus objected to his music. True, Karajan was a Nazi, like Furtwängler, and every other great conductor (except for Bernstein) of the twentieth century. I can think of many folk who are  worse than being Nazis, like being an arrogant Amerikan prigs. Why is it that every ethical discussion eventually likens Hitler as the penultimate evil? We forget the other  competitive evil people of the twentieth century, namely, Stalin, Churchill, Roosevelt and Tojo. Honestly, I’d have a hard time accusing any one of them as being either better or worse than the rest of the bunch. But, that’s me, and I’m going off track from the discussion. For whatever you think politically of Karajan, there is no denying of his musical genius. That genius is clearly seen in this performance, which many feel to be one of the greatest renderings of Beethoven’s 9th ever. Unless you read the Penguin guide, where the little Lilliputian Englanders set around eating their crumpets and sucking their tea with the baby finger protruding, objecting that the production was too emotional, or that original instruments were not used, or that Karajan was singing along during the choral parts. Too bad. They just don’t know good music.

 

Stockhausen: Stimmung

March 19th, 2008

Stockhausen: Stimmung, Sing Circle with Gregory Rose ????

During a recent operating room conversation with Herr Doktor Peters, an anesthesiologist and expert in classical music, he wondered whether I had any Stockhausen. I didn’t. So, now I do. Karl Heinz Stockhausen was among the Avant Garde experimental composers in the 60’s and 70’s. This is a wonderful example of that creative output. It definitely will generate many comments. Most will note that it is not music. Of course, then, we lapse into the lengthy discussion of defining music. Let’s not go there. Needless to say, this is a cohesive collection of vocal sounds that seem to have some pattern or flow to them, and not much else. I guess if I was truly into late 20th century music, I might have a better understanding of this work. But, having listened to this work about 4-5 times now, I find it quite valuable to play in the operating room as background “music”. Once you’ve listened to this recording, you’ll know why music is in quotes.  You may soon hear more in Kritik about Stockhausen.

 

Haydn String Quartets – Aeolian

March 18th, 2008

Haydn: String Quartets, Aeolian String Quartet   ?????

A set consisting of 22 CDs, it is worth every minute of listening time. These quartets are performed with great soul and vibrant feeling. Though one might expect classical era quartets to by soporific, these are everything but that, manifesting the profound genius of Haydn. I have other performances of the Haydn string quartets, which are quite enjoyable in their own right, but remain limp when compared to the performances on these discs. The recording technique itself is quite brilliant and forward, quite like you were in the room with these performers. A special treat with this series in the last CD, which is Op 51 Die Sieben Letzte Worter unser Erlöser Am Kreuz, well performed, but intermixed with poetry readings by Peter Pears. I heard this performance many years ago on plastic, wondering where it would it would ever show up again since I didn’t remember the performers. The mixture of Pears and the Op 51 quartet is especially effective… I’m not sure if Haydn actually wrote it that way, though I wouldn’t be surprised. All in all, these recordings should be in every respectable classical collection.

 

Wagner: Tristan und Isolde

March 8th, 2008

Wagner, Tristan und Isolde, Bayreuther Festspiele mit Daniel Barenboim, 1983 production, Tristan René Kollo, Isolde Johanna Meier  ?????

First of all, if you are not an inveterate Wagner fan, don’t waste your time on T&I. You will go crazy. If you bleed Wagner, then this is a must. The production was superb, with excellent props and design, and Kollo was the most stupendous Tristan I have ever seen. Having seen a more recent production of T&I using a modern staged genre and Isolde as Janet Eaglen, I longed for a more traditional approach. While Eaglen had a perfectly spendid voice, her morbid obesity did not fit the bill for an Isolde, who is supposed to be young and sexually irresistable–Janet was uncomfortable to watch because of her massive overweight. But, back to this production. I typically perfect many conductors over Barenboim.  Yet, Barenboim remains first rate, it is just that Karajan, Solti, Fürtwangler, and others do a more convincing overture and direction of general orchestration. This production gets 5 stars for its absolutely unbeatable love scene in Act 2 between Tristan and Isolde, and for the entire third act, so sublimely performed, up to the knock-out Liebestod by Meier.  All in all, this is my preferred dvd version of the opera.

 

Richter: Matthäus Passion

March 1st, 2008

Bach, J.S., Matthäus Passion, Conducted by Karl Richter in 1971. ?????

Richter used an astonishing star-studded cast, including Helen Donath and Peter Schrier, to mention a few. This is not a live recording, but recorded in studio fashion. Richter, being indubitably one of the great Bach interpreters of the last century, sets a legacy for quality of performance of major Bach works. Richter uses entirely contemporary instrumentation, in contrast to many other performances which feel that original instrumentation is more pure or true to the interpretation of the script. I disagree, and think that if J.S. were here in person, he would immediately opt for the clarity and trueness of pitch and fluidity of modern orchestral instruments. Speaking of Bach, there is no work of his that is pedantic or lacking in genius. Unlike Beethoven, Mozart, and all other composers, there is no work of Bach that lacks ingenuity, or is trite. Even his most early works show a sign of genius unparalleled in the musical world. He is the Newton and Einstein of music, all put into one.  Matthäus Passion is no exception, utilizing a total of 4 choruses, including two front, one rear, and one children’s choir. This is a magnificence that Karl Orff in his massive productions could only dream of. Richter masters Bach beauteously, not flinching at the most demanding portions of the script, and also occasionally conducting from the Harpsicord, accompanying some of the solo pieces. All in all, this is a must have recording for Bachophiles.

 

Wagner: Lohengrin

February 23rd, 2008

Wagner: Lohengrin, EuroArts,  Bayreuther Festspiele, dirigent Woldemar Nelsson, Peter Hofmann, Karan Armstrong  ?????

Issued in 2005 but actually performed in 1982, this opera follows traditional forms, with staging by Götz Friedrich. All in all, spendidly done. Hofmann is a better Lohengrin than Placido Domingo, in the other DVD copy of Lohengrin that I possess. It would be the choice of Lohengrin’s for the first time buyer of this opera. Some may question that this also was a bizaare plot, and that I unjustly attack early 19th century Italian opera. That is simply not the case, as German opera has a much different character than Italian, including the almost universal use of magic or the supernatural. This is true in Mozart’s, Beethoven’s, von Weber’s, Wagner’s, and even later Richard Strauss operas. Note that character development is quite full in the Wagner operas, compared to that of Donizetti, Bellini, or even the English light opera of Gilbert and Sullivan, where all you really learn about the person is that “He is an Englishman”. Whoopee. Lohengrin is not the greatest of the Wagner operas, but certainly shows a path to his later mature works, including Der Ring, Tristan und Isolde, and Parzifal.

 

Donizetti: Linda di Chamounix

February 21st, 2008

Donizetti: Linda di Chamounix, TDK, Opernhaus Zürich, Edita Guberova, directed by Adam Fischer

???

This production was produced in a fairly classic style, starring the wonderful Hungarian soprano Guberova as the title character. This opera is typical in musical style to most the operas of Donizetti, the bel canto style providing a formidable challenge to Guberova, who performs flawlessly. The supporting musicians remained equally capable and accomplished in their talents and performance, all in all making a delightful performance. This opera will never probably achieve the “top 10” list, owing only to the fact that it is a fairly corny plot. Linda is being pursued by the Count, who shuns his advances because she is in love with Carlo, whom she discovers is actually the Viscount of Sirval. Carlo and Linda move to Paris to escape the Count, and to pursue each other, when Carlo learns that mother wants him to marry someone else. He turns away Linda, who then goes mad. They both return to Chamounix, and Linda finally returns to sanity when Carlo declares his love for her and acts her hand in marriage in spite of mommy. Wow. OK. Whatever. A good opera if you love bel canto and music of Donizetti, but definitely not as great as Lucia di Lammermoor, L’Elixir d’amore, or Anna Bolena.

 

Der Ring des Niebelungen: Barenboim

February 19th, 2008

Der Ring des Niebelungen by Richard Wagner, Bayreuther Festspiele, Daniel Barenboim   ????

Watched the DVD version of this opera, or, rather, set of 4 operas. All in all, very well done, staged in a moderately minimalist style. Oddly, the staging manager really liked to see the singers chortling at full volume while clinging onto ladders at a very high altitude. At least half the scenes had the ladder motif. Other than that, the musicians were stellar. Really, how can you condemn a Wagnerian singer, who has to memorize 10 hours of singing, perform it in 4 consecutive days, without any audience forgiveness for even the slightest error. I don’t know how anybody can sing opera. Yet, it is done, and done quite well. Or, at least with the Ring series, it is done super-humanly well. For DVD recordings, I prefer the Met opera performance by Levine, though that is mostly for the fact that traditional staging was used. Even the Boulez recording, which is super-minimalist, is awesome as a soundtrack. Since it’s been a tradition to listen or watch the Ring each Christmas season, I’ll look forward to recommendations for next year.

 

Katerina Ismailova

February 2nd, 2008

Katerina Ismailova by Dmitri Shostakovich   ????

This opera is a revision of his previous opera Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk. The prior opera was intensely disliked by the big boss (Stalin), with the threat to Dmitri that any more such music might lead to a short vacation in the Siberian Salt Mines.  Katerina was a revision of Lady Macbeth that was more tolerated by the state, and this version was actually produced in the Soviet Union in 1966. The acting was good, the music awesome, the recording sound quite mediocre, and the film quality acceptable at best. Regardless, Shostakovich’s piece remains an absolute masterwork that is difficult to dislike. The music itself, when disjointed from the action, is quite tense, and certainly not relaxing. With the visuals, the music works perfectly. This opera should never be just listened to. I should mention that there are some productions of Lady Macbeth which are quite superlative, such as the Petr Weigl production with Rostropovich conducting. Both this Katerina production and the Weigl production are on-live-scene reality productions, and not on the opera stage, which also probably makes them much easier to follow. As an aside, Betsy would probably give this opera a 1-star rating, as she is not quite as familiar with the composing style of Shostakovich. I admit that some of his works demand repeat intense hearings in order to understand the composition, something true of any great composer. Lady Macbeth is no exception. For the Shostakovich lover, this opera is a real treat.

 

Mendelssohn: The Masterworks

January 31st, 2008

Mendelssohn: The Masterworks, produced by Brilliant Classics   ?????

This is not a comprehensive compendium of the works of Mendelssohn, though it is fairly complete, for the most popular works of this composer. This set is a budget offering, and performers are European and often less known, though never second rate. Virtually none of the performances were in any case poorly done, and the recording quality was superb (DDD) throughout. For the price, it remains an extremely good value. Besides excellent performances of his 5 symphonies and two oratorios (Elias and Paulus), you also get performances of his harder to find string symphonies, and well as a reasonably complete offering of his chamber works. I don’t see all of his solo vocal works, though a significant number of pieces are included, again, by first rate singers. All in all, it is a most worthy acquisition for those who appreciate the compositions of Mendelssohn.

 

Goethe

January 27th, 2008

Goethe    ????

Wahlverwandschaften, Der Leiden des Jungen Werthers, Lotte in Weimar, or, in English, Selective Affinities (Goethe), The Sorrows of Young Werther (Goethe), and Lotte in Weimar (Thomas Mann), or, The Beloved Returns.

This series is produced by DeFa, an Eastern German film studio, on a limited budget, yet still maintains a significant quality with good acting in the production. I will not review each film separately, but only mention that German reviewers on Amazon.de tended to be somewhat unking, espectially with Der Leiden des Jungen Werthers for not portraying the Goethe book accurately. I simply could not address that issue.  In Der Leiden, young Werther is unfulfilled in his love for Charolotte, and eventually commits suicide over this. It is reportedly based on the unrequited love that Goethe had for a young lady in Frankfurt where he grew up. Lotte in Weimar is included in the series, since it is a depiction by Thomas Mann of the hypothetical reunion of Lotte and Goethe in Weimar, after both were much older. Wahlverwandschaften is the story of love intrigue during the Napoleonic Wars, when a young noble couple are visited by a young relative of the wife, to which the husband falls in love. My wife and I engaged in conversations over these movies, comparing these films to those depicting the novels of Jane Austen. My sense is that Goethe possesses a much greater mastery of depiction of the human condition, like Shakespeare, than Austen. Jane Austen tends to paint fanciful novels, that while protraying a strong sense of early Victorian morality of love and courtship, paints that picture in a surreal, and fictitious environment of wealthy landed Gentry who spend their lives at sport, in an England that Englanders would like to believe existed but never did. Goethe (and Thomas Mann) gives one more of the true blood and guts of human existence, in a background that is more tragic, but also more closely approximating reality than one would ever find in the Austen stories. Goethe never attempts to bypass morality, and, in Wahlverwandschaften, still leaves the complexity of moral issues seeking resolution with moral implications. Goethe remains heavily neglected by American schools, a travesty that is our loss.

 

Pique Dame

January 19th, 2008

Pique Dame, Peter I. Tchaikovsky, performed at the Kirov Opera, Valery Gergiev  ?????

I’m in love with Gergiev, and so far, he can do no wrong. As an opera conductor, you will not find a bad opera under his baton. Pique Dame is no exception. Both staging and music get 5 stars. The performance showed extreme character of acting, parts sung to perfection, and music executed flawlessly. The story by Pushkin is quite creative, and representative of the genius of his pen. Interestingly, Pushkin, Tchaikovsky, and Gergiev were all from St. Petersburg, and thus a most fitting place for the opera to be performed. Pique Dame is a perfect example of Russian Opera at its best.

 

Heimat

January 9th, 2008

Heimat, Heimat II, Heimat III  ?????

The entire series is quite large, but well worth watching. It is entirely in German, but you can get English subtitles from Amazon.co.uk. Get the Tartan Video edition, which is reportedly unabridged and best quality. The version you get from Amazon.com is more expensive, and reportedly a lesser quality. This was a television series in Germany, but would never make it in the US without exceptionally heavy editing of various scenes, though it would distract from the story. Heimat starts out in a fictional village of Schabbach in the Hunsrück region of Germany in 1919, and follows a family over the years. You observe as the family grows, deals with WWII and the aftermath, and deals with the various social issues that arise in Germany over the years. In Heimat II, you follow the life of one of the children in Heimat, Hermann Simon, as he leaves to München to attend the music academy during the 1960’s and 1970’s. In Heimat III, you follow Hermann’s eventual return to the Hunsrück area, his marriage to Clarisse, and the eventual demise of most of the Simon family to the pressures of modern life. Clarisse is protrayed in an almost biographical fashion (in real life, she is the wife of director Edgar Rietz), and Hermann was also biographical of the director Edgar Rietz. The entire series has a sense of realism that is unusually well done, leaving you with a feel that you know the Simon family well. It is a must see, especially if you are interested in Europe and its people.

 

Matrix Trilogy

January 5th, 2008

The Matrix Trilogy     ??

A movie desperately trying to be profound, and failing entirely. The only reason it received two stars is the decent cinematography. Otherwise, the plot line fails entirely. It is the story of a hacker-kid who discovers that he is actually a created reality. Going from the “real world” of the matrix to the “really-real world”, all one needs is a machine that happens to be located only on spaceships that do not fly through space, but through the sewer system of the really-real world. Keanu Reeves emerges as the apotheosis, the more human than human human that will save the world. He interacts with a stereotypic black lady known as the “Oracle”, who often gets her predictions wrong, but always remains profoundly un-profound. Eventually, in Matrix II, Keanu meets #1 (Keanu would be #6), using the analogy of the old Prisoner tv series. He explains that he is on Matrix virtual reality #5 (or 6, I don’t remember exactly). How cool. What he can’t explain is to how he proceeds to screw up the design of the universe 5-6 times, and yet doesn’t just give up himself. Neither will you ever know whether the white suited, white roomed #1 is actually just another part of the Matrix. What you eventually discover is that our friendly “Man in Black” now shows up as the bad guy, and able to multiply reproduce himself. Cool. You also discover that his reproductions of himself are equally inept. The Matrix tries desperately for political correctness, making sure that the Council of Sewer World is an equal portion of male and female, and all races (except for African Pigmies and Australian Aborigines, and perhaps a few more, I didn’t see any American Indians), but also the heros were a mix of immature kids, lesbians, and who knows what. I think that the movie tried to be profound, and leave one wondering if perhaps, the dear viewer was also perhaps just a projection of the Matrix. Nice try but no cigars.

 

preload preload preload