
Golden Mouth: The Story of John Chrysostom: Ascetic, Preacher, Bishop, by J.N.D. Kelly ★★★★★
This is now my second reading of Golden Mouth, suggesting that it is a better than normal book, worth reading twice. John was surnamed Chrysostom, as Chrysostom in Greek means Golden Mouth, and John was most acclaimed as one of the greatest preachers of all time. In this biography, the author provides not only a discussion of the life of John Chrysostom, but also paints a larger picture of what was occurring throughout eastern Christendom. The many available histories of Chrysostom sometimes conflict with each other, and Kelly discusses what he thinks is the best alternative interpretation of his history.
Chrysostom was born in Antioch, which is now located in Turkey, and often mentioned in the book of Acts. He was born roughly in the year 349, making him junior to the three Cappadocian fathers. His parents were devout Christians, and so John was raised with a vigorous Christian mindset. He attended the public schools, and his teacher of rhetoric was a pagan, who had commented that John would have been his replacement in the school save that the Christians stole him away. Because John manifested very early in life a particularly excellent talent in speaking, he first strove to be a lawyer. Swayed more by religious affections, Chrysostom became an assistant to the bishop of Antioch, and then was ordained as an official reader in the church.
An increased desire for a holy life led Chrysostom to depart into a mountain close to Antioch where monks would go to live lives of solitude and prayer. Monks attempted to live with as little sleep as possible, and would always attempt to be standing erect 24 hours/day; after all, one would never lay down in the presence of a King, and we are always in the presence of the king of the universe! Meals were a scant meal a day, mostly of bread and water. During this time, John managed to memorize the entirety of the Old and New Testament. He was able to keep up the rigorous monastic asceticism for approximately four years, but became seriously ill, causing him to retreat back to Antioch. While there, the bishop of Antioch ordained John to be a presbyter (priest), so he was able to start preaching. Many of his sermons were preserved by stenographers, and demonstrated progressive improvement in his speaking style. Sermons in this age were performed with the preacher sitting, while the congregation remained standing.
Antioch underwent a serious crisis at this time. The emperor raised the taxes on the city, and riots broke out with difficult quelling the unruly mob. The emperor Theodosius was livid, and threatened to wipe the city off the map, saved only by the aggressive oratory skills of Chrysostom to persuade the emperor to forgive the city of their misdeeds. Chrysostom became known throughout the empire as one of the most impressive preachers alive. After years of preaching in Antioch, and unknown to him, he was called to be bishop of Constantinople, which was the capital of the eastern half of the Roman empire. So, off he went to Constantinople, where he would serve the remainder of his life, outside of his exiles.
Chrysostom was a stern disciplinarian. He eschewed the lavish life style of the clergy in Constantinople, and fired many bishops and presbyters and deacons who were slothful or otherwise undisciplined, or if not heretical. In other words, he cleaned up the church. By doing this, he formed many enemies. His greatest supporters were his congregation, who defended him up to his death. Even in church, John would sternly disapprove of applauding the sermon, but stated so well as to lead to even more clapping! Even in the presence of the eastern emperor and his wife, Chrysostom would maintain a very careful discipline, not engaging in the fancy meals and gala that would accompany royalty. The emperor Arcadias and his wife Eudoxia were at first very supportive of John, until John preached a sermon a bit challenging to the female sex, leading to Eudoxia’s strong and persisting disfavor. (Perhaps John Knox should have learned from Chrysostom!) Chrysostom’s battles were plentiful during his stay in Constantinople, and over time, his enemies multiplied.
The event of the Long Brothers is worthy to be repeated. The Long Brothers were a group of ascetic monks in the Egyptian desert who had some sympathies with the (orthodox) teachings of Origen. Theophilos, the bishop of Alexandria, declared Origen a heretic, and thus also deemed the Long Brothers to be heretics (which they were not). Through forceful means, Theophilos forced them out of Egypt, and so they went to Constantinople for safety. Theophilos then declared Chrysostom a heretic for harboring “Origenistic” heretics. Theophilos was ordered by the emperor to report to Constantinople in order to make a ruling on his charge that Chrysostom was harboring a heretic. Theophilos played the game as guilefully as possible, delaying his departure from Alexandria as long as possible, and the journeying by a land route rather than sailing directly to Constantinople. Along the way, he solicited the help of as many anti-Chrysostom bishops as possible, those who were fired by Chrysostom. With a large following, Theophilus held a rigged synod called synod of the Oak, which Chrysostom refused to attend, noting that Theophilus had assembled an overwhelming majority of anti-Chrysostom bishops. Chrysostom was sent into exile, but almost immediately recalled when the people of Constantinople rioted at the loss of their favorite bishop. An earthquake also happened, causing the emperor and his wife to fear that this was a message from God.
Soon afterwards, the emperor’s wife Eudoxia had a statue of herself constructed in the city, which John promptly condemned as pagan and idolatrous. Again, John was again placed into exile. His site of exile was in Cucusos in Cappadocia. This was essentially a house arrest, allowing John to engage in extensive letter writing appealing his case, especially to Pope Innocent, who agreed with Chrysostom. Three years passed, and Chrysostom was finally deposed to a remote area around the Black Sea. On the journey, in a severely weakened state, he died. His final words were “Glory be to God for all things”. Several decades after his death, his body was finally returned to Constantinople in great honor.
We have much to learn from John Chrysostom and his life. First, we learn how a consecrated, pure, devout life can sometimes not produce a happy and contented outcome. We learn that even in the face of bitter opposition, remaining steadfast in the faith and speaking the truth will lead to the best outcome, but only if eternity is kept in mind. Second, we learn how the church, even in its earliest, purest form, had petty jealousies and power struggles, all of which somebody like John Chrysostom had to fight and eventually succumb to. We are all, from top to bottom, as Martin Luther said, simultaneously saints and sinners, and often our greatest enemies are found within the church itself.
“… born in Antioch, which is now located in Turkey, and often mentioned in the book of Acts.” There is some confusion here because there were two Antiochs, the Syrian one referred to in the book of Acts and the Pisidian Antioch in Asia Minor (Turkiye). If Chrysostom was returning to an Antioch that was a major theological center, it would have been Syrian Antioch. The two are not far apart, but they are different cities.