
I’ve always pictured Reformed worship as being a solemn but joyful affair. This was true in Calvin’s time, it was true with Luther, and it was true with Thomas Cranmer, who wrote the most beautiful liturgies for the English language. All of the great denominations had their hymnals and many had prescribed orders of liturgy, with books of prayers and books for responsive worship. Much of that has since passed to the wayside as church denominations “know better” now. The trend is for a reduced liturgy, one that promotes a feeling of welcomeness and entertainment, but also of triviality. True, the short-term effect is to encourage attendance and grow the congregation, but at what expense?
I was somewhat excited recently when five of the six songs on the program for the church morning worship service were traditional hymns, with deeply meaningful words and tunes that promoted the words. After the confession of sin, the versification of Psalm 51 (God be Merciful to Me) was sung. Instead of the traditional tune which is reverential, penitential, and quite solemn, making us reflect on the horror of our sins and the deepest desire for forgiveness and freedom from those sins, it was sung to a very jazzy tune. I nearly vomited.
Perhaps the pastor can make an excuse for that. He might argue that the music is in someone else’s control. He might argue that the newer tunes to old words uplift the congregation better, and draw in more crowds. Perhaps a different tune to old words brings better reflection on the words of the tune. Whatever lame excuse could be generated, the end result reflects back on one’s personal theology. If we come to God in a lighthearted, jazzy spirit to ask forgiveness of sins, perhaps sinning isn’t so bad after all. Hey, at least we have faith!
We’ve made it to a few other churches this summer while visiting friends. Two stick out. The first was while visiting a friend who lives in Lander, WY. We attended the Catholic church that he attends, and felt truly uplifted in a spirit of worship. It was a high point for us. Later in the summer, I attended a PCA church in Columbia, South Carolina, pastored by an old friend from Tacoma days. He directed the entire worship, led the singing, gave an excellent sermon, and maintained solemn reverence throughout the worship service. His church is growing slowly, as so many Christians today wish for something more than just entertainment, and desire a true moment of coram deo, being before the face of God.
Deep in the heart of this triviality towards worship is a serious theological error. Preachers oftentimes feel the struggle between preaching how Christ works to accomplish our salvation, and that there is “nothing in our hand we bring” that would merit salvation. It is solely by grace alone through faith alone, because of a God that has chosen and elected and called us to salvation. Yet, there is the tendency to fear the diminishment of the sola gratia doctrine if one were to preach the necessity of living faithful to our calling, as though that would diminish the sola gratia doctrine.
Scripture is replete with examples that show that while God fulfills His promises, there is still an individual role to play. God promised the Israelites the land of Canaan, and it was His work entirely in offering victory after victory in battle against the enemies of the people of God. Still, the battles were certainly quite brutal, and many Israelites indubitably lost their lives fighting for God’s promises. Were those people legalists because they didn’t just let go and trust God to win the battle solus Deus?
In the book of Jeremiah, it is predicted that there will come a day when God will write his law on the hearts of His people (Jer 31:33). But, in Psalm 37:31 David notes that the law of God is in his heart. Deut. 6:6,7 notes that “And these words that I command you today shall be on your heart. You shall teach them diligently to your children and shall talk of them when you sit in your house, and when you walk by the way, and when you lie down, and when you rise.” Thus, the binding of God’s law on our hearts was true throughout the Old Testament as well as promised for the New Testament, and was a work of God, but demanded the volition of man with blood, sweat, and tears to memorize Scripture, teach it to one’s children, and constantly be in the word.
In accord with Thomas Aquinas as well as the Reformers, salvation was similar throughout history, starting with the fall of Adam. In a sense, salvation was also the same before the fall, when viewed covenantally. Salvation before the fall demanded loving faith in God and obedience to Him. Salvation after the fall also requires loving faith in God and obedience to Him. Does obedience amount to meritorious works? That is perhaps a bad question since the phrase “meritorious works” comes laden with so much peripheral meaning. Terminology is the devil here. Are works necessary for salvation? Yes! Are works the efficient cause of salvation? NO! The efficient cause is entirely the work of Christ in his life and death, his active and passive obedience.
The PCA denomination to which I belong has many who are wrangling with the tension between faith and works. It is an unnecessary tension unless you force certain definitions on faith (or grace) and works. Many of these theologians have become modern-day Torquemadas, the new style of heresy hunters. If there is a whisper of discrepancy between your beliefs and another’s, then they most certainly must be identified as heretics. Reformed Protestants spend their time haggling over the writings of John Calvin and the Westminster Confession of Faith, and each sect is insistent that their soteriological constructs more accurately fit the Calvin/WCF documents than their “heretical” opponent. I find it odd that these same people tenaciously flaunt the doctrine of sola scriptura and yet fight most vehemently in defense of their creedal profession. Our beliefs should be creedal, yet when those creeds obscure the proper reading of the Scriptures, either the creeds need to be rewritten to make their intent plain, or Scripture needs to be thrown out.
Theologians go through the most extreme contortions to make a very simple doctrine to be complex. Thinking that a vigorous separation of various concepts of the covenant(s) or dispensation(s) makes matters easier, actually complicates a very simple truth. The truth is that though there have various administrations of salvific history, the means or mode of salvation has always been the same, from Adam before the fall to the last man standing on earth. It is impossible to not see grace manifested in the garden before the fall, and grace manifested from Adam to Noah to Christ. It is also impossible to NOT see the necessity of obligatory obedience to God as an expectation for the Israelites and Jews as well as the Christians. Why obscure this truth with theological machinations? One simple example will illustrate what I mean; the doctrine of Republication is a totally unnecessary doctrine engendered by confusion regarding the covenants. Rather than rethinking the original doctrines, additional doctrines need to be generated which are totally unnecessary. But then, we don’t DARE go against the Westminster Confession of Faith and the words of Calvin, do we?
We live in a culture that tends to disparage symbolism in life and worship. Our churches are now in strip malls, and the message sent to the world is that God is now for sale. I understand that young churches cannot afford to build or purchase an actual church building. Yet, many churches nowadays have a worship sanctuary that can easily be used for any other sort of entertainment venue. The stage is large, and musicians and speakers parade their stances across the stage. The worship lacks solemnity. Praise songs without much content are the preferred music since they tend to be entirely upbeat. Kneeling to pray in church is now passé.
Sermons are intended to soothe the soul. God’s promises are a topic never to be missed. The solas are emphasized in a manner that lets us know that God has chosen us and saved us, so, there is nothing more to add to our theology. Redemptive historical preaching guides us to see what God has done for us but has left us in the lurch as to what our obligations may be to Him. We must let go and let God! Any effort on our part must be interpreted as trying to achieve salvation by works. But wait! Hell no, we are NOT antinomian; just don’t ask me to clarify exactly what I mean by that.
All in all, the modern church no longer strives for the whole counsel of God; it no longer accepts the Old Testament as equally valid for instruction and reproof in righteousness (All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, II Tim 3:16) The Old Testament is confused with law, and New Testament with grace. When you do that, you must throw out the gospels and much of the rest of the NT as well as the entirety of the Old Testament! Marcion lives on!
Reformed Christianity is undergoing subtle changes in doctrine and practice, and I fear that mainstream Reformed seminaries are no longer teaching the whole counsel of God. Theology conferences and various Reformed ministries are more popular than ever, so it is tempting to imagine that all is well in Zion. Aren’t these conferences and ministries simply maintaining what was once and for all delivered to the saints? Aren’t they defending the five solas against the heresies that challenge the basic fundamental theses of the early Reformers? Isn’t any challenge to the Westminster Confession of Faith, as John Murray has done regarding the prelapsarian covenant of works, tantamount to treason against Reformed fundamentals?
Perhaps the topic that is today most avoided is that of the human will and human volition. If God chooses us, does that negate the notion that we must also choose God? Isn’t there a duality here, described well by such Divines as JI Packer and RS Rayburn? To deny the two poles of reality creates a heresy, as is seen in modern Reformed Redemptive Historical preaching. It is so strange that nearly the entirety of Scripture is ethical in nature, moral instruction; this is especially true in the prophetic literature and Pentateuch, but it is also thick everywhere else, including in the writings of Paul. So, why is there now a move to eliminate moral instruction from preaching? When the preaching of God’s sovereignty obliterates thoughts of man’s responsibility before an almighty Sovereign, then we have perverted Scripture and created a fiction contrary to the historical faith. Seeming contradictions of Scripture need to be reconciled rather than ignored. Sadly, to even bring up the issue of human volition creates the nasty accusation of legalism, denial of the solas, and denial of the sovereignty of God.
So, I leave with a Psalm 42 moment. . .
“These things I remember,
as I pour out my soul:
how I would go with the throng
and lead them in procession to the House of God
with glad shouts and songs of praise,
a multitude keeping festival.
Why are you cast down, O my soul,
and why are you in turmoil within me?
Hope in God; for I shall again praise him,
my salvation and my God.
My soul is cast down within me;…”
For most of my life, the Sabbath entailed attending church Sunday morning for Sunday School and then a worship service, and then another worship service in the evening, followed by a mid-week prayer meeting. This was true at our Anabaptist church, Moody Church, and Faith Presbyterian Church in Tacoma, WA. It is no longer true where we attend. I’m left with a soul longing for more and not getting it. But, I also have hope that the Lord will provide something more for us. I will not despair.















































