The Reformation as Renewal: Retrieving the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, by Matthew Barrett ★★★★★
Matthew Barrett presents here a tour de force, a magnum opus, a major work of nearly 900 pages, densely written and thoroughly referenced, defending the notion that the Reformation was a return of the church to its original doctrinal stances, rather than a departure from the “mother” church. In the years after the Reformation, there are those scholars, such as John Henry Newman of the Oxford movement and many in our lifetime who separated from mainstream Protestantism, laying the claim that they are being led back to the true church. Barrett shows how these folk, and the Roman church at large, are contradicting their own history, and that the Papist church that they are returning to are in fact the heretics who have departed from the Christian faith.
Barrett explores the notion of when the Papist church truly went wrong. All the Reformers, from Zwingli, to Luther, to Calvin, quote heavily from the early church fathers as well as Augustine. There are doctrines in the early church to which all the Reformers felt needed improvement, but would not identify those doctrines as sufficient to label the early church as having bad doctrine. Rejecting Biblicism (which includes haughty disregard of the history of doctrine, irresponsible proof-texting and univocal predication), the author begins by exploring movements within early church monasticism. Though monasticism was rejected by all of the Reformers, the basic crisis within the Reformed movement was not ceremonial and liturgical practice, but rather, the doctrinal under-girding of the church. Many of the monastics had correct doctrine, and little dispute was found even with Francis of Assisi. Bernard of Clairvaux, or the early Dominicans. The Scholastics were heavily examined, and the early Scholastics like Anselm, Bonaventure, Peter Lombard, Thomas Aquinas and others gave no need for a Reformation. True, doctrines of transubstantiation, Mariolatry, Penance and Papal supremacy were objected to, but did not carry the force of necessitating a split from Rome. Barrett spends nearly 80 pages exploring the thinking of Thomas Aquinas. A few doctrines just mentioned find their acceptance by Aquinas, yet, Aquinas remained within the realm of acceptability, especially in the area of the doctrines of grace, which we would later call “Calvinism”, i.e, predestination, sola gratia, and sola Christus. Aquinas for the first time extensively brings Aristotle into use, though he uses the thinking of both Plato and Aristotle in his examination of Christian theology. As Barrett shows, Aquinas also criticizes areas where he thinks both Aristotle and Plato went wrong, but accepts their writings when working out the legitimacy of using logic in reading Scripture, and using the four-fold method of interpreting Scripture (literal, allegorical, moral, and analogical). Thus, it would be irresponsible to deem Luther or Calvin as being anti-Aquinas. Neither did Aquinas separate faith from reason (as accused of by the late Francis Schaeffer), a separation that occurred with later Scholastics. Indeed, Barrett shows with lucidity a major rift in thinking from the time of Aquinas to that of the later Scholastics, so that he divides the Scholastics into via antiqua and via moderna.
Scholastics of the via moderna included John Duns Scotus, William of Ockham, and Gabriel Biel. The late Scholastics misinterpret Aquinas in a number of ways. As Barrett points out, Biel, for instance, grievously distorts Aquinas’ thinking on free will (Luther here would have never disagreed with Aquinas), on the need for predisposing grace and the effects of sin on man (i.e., a Pelagian anthropology), on the teaching of merit, and the teaching on infused grace. Thus, in critical issues, the Reformers had no problem with Aquinas but serious problems with the via moderna, which unfortunately, formed the theology of the late medieval church and to which the Reformers found serious objection. Barrett goes on to show how Bucer, Luther, Calvin, and Vermigli all were quite Thomistic in much of their thinking. So, what went wrong? The via antiqua were essentially realists in their thinking, and via moderna nominalists. Barrett spends much time pointing out how the nominalism of the via moderna was at fault for the destruction of Augustinian (and Thomistic) soteriology. Thus, doctrines which the Reformers rejected, related to doctrines of merit, of prayer to the saints, of purgatory, etc., etc. were all fashioned within the Papist church after the time of Aquinas. The rise of humanism lent strength to Reformers gaining wisdom in their defense of the original faith. Humanism in the 16th century was NOT the humanism that we now think of. Humanism only later became a mentality that man is the measure of all things, which is a thinking of the enlightenment. Rather, it was a call to ad fontes, return to the sources. In the schools and universities, this meant learning Hebrew and Greek (any worthy scholar already was quite fluent in Latin). Scriptures were being re-read, and objection to the translation of the Patristics, and especially Jerome’s Vulgate translation of Scripture, were noted.
At this point, I’ve reviewed a little more than ⅓ of the book, leaving out many critical details, with the hope that those curious or objecting to my summary, would pick up the book itself and read it. Much that has been written so far had a very distinct philosophical bent to it. Barrett has built the fundamental basis for the Reformation, and now turns to a more historical account of the Reformation, and how the transition in Scholastic thinking, and thus the doctrines of the Roman church, deviated from what the Christian church had always thought. Starting with Hus, and moving on to Tyndale, and then the magisterial Reformers, the objections were never so much over liturgical practice or minor issues of doctrine. Indeed, the entire thesis of this book is that the Reformers sought to save the original theology of the church, and not the newer inventions of the via moderna. Thus, every Reformer, especially Luther and Calvin, were steeped in the writings of the Patristics and Augustine. The objection that they were creating novel thinking in the church was countered that they were indeed returning to the faith of the true Catholic church.
Barrett spends a large amount of time exploring the earlier pre-Reformation Luther, with the events and thinking that led him to such a strong reaction against the church. His intention was always to correct the errors of the church, and yet any effort of the Reformers to point out questionable theology always led to hardening of the intention of the Papists. The story of Luther is lucidly told by Barrett. He then moves on to the Swiss Reformation, notably Zwingli, but also Bullinger and other leaders in the Swiss movement, and their influence on Luther, and later on Calvin. The French phase of the Reformation was dominated first by Bucer, and then by Farel and Calvin, Calvin falling out at the most articulate and also the most brilliant among the Reformers, who ultimately became centered in Geneva. Finally, the history of the English church with Cranmer, and later Scottish church with Knox, are well laid out. Interestingly, Barrett paints Knox as a rather irascible curmudgeon, whose temper was inherited in a greatly blunted form by the founders of the Presbyterian church of Scotland. Even Calvin had problems with the temperament, though not with the theology, of Knox.
The last chapter discusses the counter-Reformation of the Papists, and especially the proceedings of the council of Trent. This council was off and on again, and frequently thwarted by wars occurring between the Holy Roman emperor (Charles, and later Phillip II), the French monarch, and the Papacy itself. Reformers were asked to show up, which they refused to do, since they would never have a vote in the outcome of the council, and they were never assured safe passage, keeping Hus foremost in mind. The Roman church showed no desire to seriously rethink their prevailing theology, or to consider it an aberration from what the church has always stood for, from Aquinas and before him. This gives Protestants the ability to say with utmost confidence that they represent the true church, and that Rome is the apostate church. The Reformers had every right to identify the Pope as the anti-Christ.
One last aside. The theme of this book is to clearly argue that the Protestants are the true Catholic church, and NOT the Papists of Rome. There were other movements in the church who identified the Roman church as hopelessly lost from the very beginning. These include many of the Anabaptists, who claimed that the church went wrong from the very beginning. Certainly, there remain many heretical movements even to this day that make that claim, including the Mormon Church, the Jehovah’s Witness church, and numerous other authors, such as Wilkinson. The Reformers made it abundantly clear that this was an abomination to their thinking, and that they stood by the church through the centuries. I just happen to feel most strongly that the Reformers were indeed correct, and that they returned the church to its orthodox past.
This book is excellent in both its content and style. Barrett writes most clearly, and it was a joy to follow through his arguments for the church, and his skillful recounting of Reformation church history. This is one of the better books that I’ve read in the last few years, and challenged my thinking, while enhancing my knowledge base of Reformation history, even though I’ve read a number of accounts already of the story of the Reformation. Thus, it is highly recommended by me. At 900 pages, many of which are quite technical or philosophical, the student who chooses to tackle this book will be surely most illumined and blest.