
Aristotle for Everybody: Difficult Thought Mad Easy, by Mortimer Adler ★★★★★
This book was given to me by a dear friend AD Waterman, with whom I was engaged in conversation about why Thomas Aquinas referred so often to the thinking of a pagan philosopher Aristotle. I had studied Aristotle extensively while in college, and this book provided a delightful refresher course. It is hard for me to review philosophy books. When I read philosophy, the value of the book is its ability to generate further thought, and my mind was constantly taken off onto wild tangents.
Outside of the introductory chapter, the book is broken up into four sections. The first relates to man the maker, i.e., that man tends to make things. That doesn’t sound terribly philosophical, until you start thinking about the material cause, efficient cause, formal cause, and final cause of things, related to what are you using to make something, who is doing the making, what exactly are you making, and finally why are you making it. Aristotle sometimes muddies matters by combining formal and final causes. The second section deals with man the doer. This section is man the doer, and primarily focuses on ethics, as found in his Nicomachean Ethics. Aristotle answers from a totally “logical” perspective as to what is the good, how should we behave in society, and how should society behave towards us. The third section is man the knower, and relates to how do we think properly. This section focuses on Aristotelian logic. Issues such as the law on non-contradiction (something cannot be either A and non-A simultaneously and in the same fashion). The last section deals with more “difficult” subjects, that of infinity, eternity, the nature of the mind, and God. Within this section, Aristotle mostly bares his weaknesses and inconsistencies. His god is definitely not the God of the Bible, as Aristotle does not comprehend an infinite-personal timeless creator God as found in Scripture.
So, does Aristotle have value in today’s world? Absolutely yes? I would add further that I would say the same of Plato; the school of Athens so perfectly depicts the contrast between the two, with Plato looking up and Aristotle looking down. Aristotle helps us to understand how we go about thinking about things. Everything (except for God) needs a prime mover. Everything has a final (teleological) cause (or ending). We tend to think in a muddied fashion, because we don’t follow the simple rules of logic, which we might assume to be common knowledge, and yet they aren’t. As proof, just watch any discussion on tv, or in the halls of congress. Aristotle frequently uses the phrase “uncommon common knowledge”, phrase that might be confusing until the “common” in “uncommon” does not mean the same thing as the “common” in “common knowledge”. I’ll leave it to the reader to figure out that one. I dearly wish that more people would think with an Aristotelean logic.
I started this review by mentioning my query as to why Thomas Aquinas would rely so heavily on Aristotelean thought. In terms of a logical structure for thinking, I have no problems. With ethics, I argue that it is impossible to form a consistent ethics starting from the self. True, there seems to be endowed on all man by our creator a sense of right and wrong, which we might call natural ethics. Yet, for fallen man, fallen both in will as well as intellect and body, we will never achieve on our own logic an ethics as found in Scripture. God has spoken to man, and has conveyed an ethic to fallen man. All of ethics, and dare I say, all of philosophy, must be evaluated in light of Scripture, which is the only thing that is truly infallible. Our logic and thought processes are fallible, but Scripture is not. At this point, I haven’t read enough of Aquinas to render an opinion about his writings, though my preliminary thought is to have no problems with Aquinas’ use of Aristotle. And to that, I will let this book review rest. I won’t discuss the plethora of other thoughts that streamed through my philosophical mind but invite the reader of this review to pick up a copy of this very well written book and take your mind on a delightful journey.
“Within this section, Aristotle mostly bares his weaknesses and inconsistencies. His god is definitely not the God of the Bible, as Aristotle does not comprehend an infinite-personal timeless creator God as found in Scripture.”
The Hebrew mind is not the Greek foolosophical mind. The infinity-words that translators put into their Bible translations come from their Greek, not Hebrew, conditioning. For instance, superlatives such as “all” to the Greek mind mean “without exception” whereas in Biblical text it means “the preponderance of”. Hebrew thought is concrete and finite, staying within the limits of human comprehension, within space and time. Greek infinity-thinking attempts to achieve the mind of God beyond this – the one that YHWH told the Israelites during the Exodus that “it is none of your business”.
Are you saying that the concept of the infinite is NOT found in OT/Hebrew writings? You can’t be serious! Have you never ever read credible Hebrew scholarship on this issue?
Hebrew scholarship or credible Hebrew scholarship? George Eldon Ladd is one author who makes the case about speculative language beyond space and time as absent from Hebrew thinking. Please try to take on Ladd!
Infinity-words simply do not occur within the Bible, yet translators routinely put them in and Bible commentators (theologians) just assume them from their Western Greek conditioning. It’s not scholarship; it’s conditioning.
The 23rd Psalm illustrates the point. The last sentence as translated is: “And I shall live in the house of the Lord forever.” The infinity-word is “forever” – an unending, hence infinite, amount of time. But the actual Hebrew wording is “for all the days”. Which days? And how many of them? It doesn’t say, but the connotation is that it is a finite number of them, and not unbounded time. Numerous other examples could be given.
Keep in mind that Greek (and Hebrew) scholars also bring worldview or cultural assumptions to their work. Some of these assumptions do not reflect how the ancient Hebrews thought, but do reflect how the Greeks (the Hellenistic-Platonic strain) thought.