
Abraham Lincoln: Redeemer President, by Allen Guelzo ★★★★★
Allen Guelzo offers a slightly different approach to the life and presidency of Abraham Lincoln. In this text, he focuses more on how Lincoln thought, and what he believed, rather than blow by blow details of his history. There were 3 areas of focus, including Lincoln’s opinion regarding slavery and how to deal with slaves once they’ve been emancipated, Lincoln’s politics, and Lincoln’s personal faith.
Lincoln did not hold a strong feeling regarding slavery early on in his political career. Over the course of exposure to the slave practices of the south, he slowly became more and more interested in the slavery question. His proposal was to send the slaves back to a colony in Africa. Because he was assassinated soon after the end of the war, we have no clue as to what he actually might have done. The lost-cause movement of the south emphasizes, even to this day, that the civil war was not about slavery. Such a notion betrays foolishness, and a desire to force an alternative ideology on what the civil was all about. States’ rights? Scarcely! The south wished to deprive the north of state’s rights over the issue of slavery, and nothing did more harm to the cause of resolving the slavery issue than the Dred-Scott decision, a colossal mistake, in that a fair reading of the Taney Dred-Scott decision implied that slavery must be in some way legal in all of the states.
Lincoln started as a Whig. The Whig party was noted to be a failing institution, and with the rise of the Republican party, Lincoln leaned towards a Republican membership. In spite of that, various historians have labeled Lincoln as a closet Democrat, a foremost Republican, or an Old style Whig. Guelzo tends to stick with the old-style Whig designation. Lincoln’s strength was not so much in that of having clear-cut political boundaries, but that of being a person able to hold his own party together in the face of extreme opposition, both from within and without the party. He is a man whose brilliance allowed him to not be fixated to any given ideology while remaining a strong Republican party man.
Religion was the main focus of this book. Guelzo, being a Christian of Reformed persuasion, analyzes both the writings and recorded speeches of Lincoln. Lincoln grew up as a strict Calvinist Presbyterian, but never became a member of any church throughout his life. Lincoln never ever made a profession of faith in Christ. Lincoln, throughout his life, had a deep knowledge of Scripture, and frequently quoted from the Bible. Yet, Lincoln’s main focus was on the predestination of all of history, something that he felt he had no control over. Guelzo labels Lincoln a Calvinist Deist, a term that is an oxymoron, but seems to fit Lincoln’s thought and speeches. Thus, you will frequently find Lincoln referring to Divine providence, yet never ever stated a personal faith in that Divine being, feeling Him to be aloof. Lincoln could be labeled a Christian only in that he operated under a strong Judeo-Christian mindset, and held a very strict morality informed entirely by Scripture. We have no clue as to where Lincoln ended up (heaven or hell), yet that is something that only God knows for most people. Interestingly, the only president that I can think of who professed a devout faith was John Adams, and he was not well liked, a one-term president replaced by the deist Thomas Jefferson. Thus, there is some question as to whether one could even call the USA a “Christian” country; it is Christian in mentality and ethics, but even that is rapidly vanishing.
Guelzo is a fascinating author. He grew up in Pennsylvania, but his writings show no leaning towards either the north or south in the Civil Was conflict. He has won numerous prizes for his books, and remains one of the foremost authorities on the civil war. He is not blind in his ideology, acknowledging (for instance) that when Lincoln became president, he was immediately saddled with the administration of a war, something that he was clueless about. Guelzo, in other writings, likens Lincoln to a modern day Trump, coming into power with fierce opposition, and challenged with near civil war conditions. The lessons of Lincoln are thus timely for contemporary circumstances. This is a book most worth reading, and strongly advised by me. I will next be reading another of Guelzo’s texts, a biography of Robert E. Lee. I simply cannot predict how Guelzo will frame this history, so wait with eager anticipation.
“Such a notion betrays foolishness, and a desire to force an alternative ideology on what the civil was all about. States’ rights? Scarcely!”
Nonsense. Read Jeffrey Hummel’s book Emancipating Slaves, Enslaving Free Men. It addresses the larger scope of the cause of the War, which has to do with what usually causes wars: money. The South had a cotton industry and they were selling cotton to the UK textile mills, bypassing the Northern banks and government taxation. The North (Washington) didn’t like to be left out. The rest is obvious. “It’s the economy, stupid!”
Yea, I’ve read similar books written by the Libertarians. Import taxation was an issue in the 1830’s but not much of an issue in the 1860’s. Sadly, the Libertarians cannot retain a legitimate argument against the overwhelming evidence. The passioned arguments of those like Ralph Raico cast a blind eye to the overwhelming evidence, and sulks into a postbellum pity party joined by Robert E Lee and Nathan Bedford Forrest.
What impact did the result of the War have on the cotton economy of the South? Were they able to merely resume selling cotton to Britain? Or was the effect on the cotton economy of the South substantial?
What J.P. Morgan is said to have said applies: Every [govt] has two reasons for what they do: a good reason (slavery) and the real reason ($).