
Anglicanism: A Reformed Catholic Tradition, by Gerald Bray ★★★★★
My wife and I grew up in an Amish/Mennonite community, attended a dispensational church (Moody Bible Church) while living in Chicago, and then became Presbyterian (PCA) in Washington State. Upon moving to Las Vegas, we attended the PCA church in town for a little over one year, but to our amazement and shock, the Las Vegas PCA church shared little resemblance either liturgically or theologically to our church in Tacoma. Our disappointment caused us to check out alternatives, and this resulted in us moving on to an Anglican church (ACNA) in North Las Vegas close to where we live. We’ve been there more than a year now, and I am now asking the questions as to how the church functions, since it is quite different from the Presbyterian structure of the PCA. The liturgy is distinctly different and far more regulated, as they follow the Book of Common Prayer (BCP) as their guide to worship, with variation only with the actual homily delivered early on it the worship service. They do not use the Westminster Confession (which they wrote!), but instead hold to an Americanized version of the 39 articles. This book offers a scholarly and erudite but simple review of the distinctives of the Anglican communion of churches. I found it extremely valuable at giving me a better feel as to the nature and personality of the Anglican communion. The book also corrected a number of misconceptions that I had of the “denomination” and pointing out the diversity that one would find within the entire community of Anglicans.
Bray begins by discussing the history and origins of the church of England starting before the Reformation, and then the role of Henry VIII in withdrawing from Rome, reconciling with the teachings of Luther, and instituting a separate entity with himself as head of the church in political aspects and the archbishop of Canterbury as the head of the church. Archbishop Cranmer wrote the BCP (in its original version) as well as a number of homilies that offer a framework for Anglican theology. In the 1600s, the Anglicans were mostly responsible for the writing of the Westminster Confession, which they quickly abandoned soon after Charles II came into power. It seems as though the church leaders felt that liturgical practice held a higher priority than church theology? Anglicanism since Charles II has formed into a number of factions, as follows…
- Puritanism: an effort to complete the Reformation within the Anglican church
- Anti-Puritanism: an amorphous reaction to the extremes of Puritanism
- Low church: Puritan sympathies but wishing to remain in the church
- High church: Anti-Puritan but wishing to separate the church from the state
- Latitudarianism: Anti-dogmatic theologians wishing more freedom of thought within the doctrinal confines of the church
- Evangelicalism: Dates from the 1740 revivals and affected by German pietism, represented by the Wesleys and and George Whitfield, and later by Charles Ryle and recently by John Scott and JI Packer
- Anglo-Catholicism: originally called the Oxford Movement or Tractarians, who rejected the Reformation and blamed society ills on Protestantism.
- Liberalism: A move to correct and update Christianity to modern times
- Broad church: a movement open to liberal ideas but attempting to restrain the extreme results of liberalism. CS Lewis and Rowan Williams would fit in this category.
The Anglican communion has grown worldwide, lacking only a strong presence in Continental Europe itself. In Africa and elsewhere, strong Anglican movements have occurred. Bray mentions that the four cohesive properties of the church include 1) an episcopal church polity, 2) Liturgy restricted to the vernacular, 3) Involvement of the laity in church government, and 4) A hierarchy of beliefs rooted in the 39 articles. Anglican theology has thus attempted to allow for broader variations in belief than you would find in other denominations, specifically, the Presbyterians, who sought for a more rigid defined theological system, and acting as a bridge between the Roman Catholics and the Protestants, but centered around a loose interpretation of the 39 articles. Bray mentions pseudo-theological issues, such as the definition of which vestments should be worn by the clergy.
Subsequent chapters then work through the 39 articles as seen from a modern conservative viewpoint. I won’t belabor these chapters in order to prevent this book from becoming a book in itself. The main points Bray makes is that 1) Anglicanism belongs to the Western and not Eastern tradition, 2) Anglicanism is definitely a Protestant and NOT Roman Catholic, and 3) Anglicanism is Reformed, and not Lutheran, Anabaptist, or Pentecostal/Charismatic. In practice, I have seen that point 3 is perhaps not true, and a true Reformed soteriology is lacking, while elements of Pentecostalism seem to have a strong root in certain Anglican circles. Interestingly, Anglicans still hold to the Apocrypha though admitting that it should not be used for issues of church doctrine. In its soteriological statements, the 39 articles goes only so far as to denying free-will, as well as rejecting the notion of supererogatory merit. Its definition of predestination has a very Augustinian and not Calvinistic tone to it. Regarding the sacraments, it allows great variation in the mode and application of baptism, though strongly rejecting baptismal regeneration (in contrast to Augustine’s stance). The 39 articles rejects the idea of transubstantiation in the Lord’s supper, suggesting a more Zwinglian approach of the bread and wine taken in a heavenly and spiritual fashion and leaving it at that. Article 35 refers to a set of Homilies, some written by Cranmer, and others following him. Oddly, these Homilies do not seem to be readily available, and thus I wonder as to their applicability in modern times.
Bray ends with a description of the current status of the modern Anglican church worldwide. The recent ordination of a female liberal archbishop happened well after this book was printed, and I would wonder as to his thoughts on that. Clearly, the worldwide Anglican communion has shown great heterogeneity similar to the Roman Catholic church, though with the “glue” that holds everything together being not a common pope, but rather a common liturgy and BCP. The 39 articles do not have a strong common interpretation or application within the broader Anglican communion, and thus is not included in the Anglican glue.
Being new to the Anglican church, I have a few mixed feelings. Foremost, the Anglicans have a wonderful liturgy, and tend to have worship as a strong priority in their exercise of communal religion. They tend to be much more tolerant of theological variants than the Presbyterian heritage that I came out of, who tend to fight over minuscule points of theology, each side accusing the other of being heretics. It is almost reminiscent of the battle between Nestorius and Cyril of Alexandria, both of whom were both right and wrong, but their inability to resolve their differences in a civil manner led to harm within the church. The Anglicans (in my humble opinion) tend towards the opposite extreme, and perhaps allow a bit too much latitude in their theological development. A happy medium is as rare as hen’s teeth.
This book is wonderful to read. Bray provides a beautiful description of the Anglican Communion, and has helped me to appreciate the denomination that I am currently attending. For a person new to the Anglican tradition, it is very much worth reading. Bray is easy to read, and holds the reader’s attention well. Thus, I highly recommend it.

